Could use some input on speaking out against abortion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stac4Grace
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Stac4Grace

Guest
I’m having difficulty defending my belief against abortion from a Catholic stance. Can you give me some examples of what you say to someone who thinks that people should be allowed to take a drug to prevent them from getting pregnant if they are raped or have intercourse and just want to make sure they don’t get pregnant. Your help would be greatly appreciated, thanks.
 
I’m having difficulty defending my belief against abortion from a Catholic stance. Can you give me some examples of what you say to someone who thinks that people should be allowed to take a drug to prevent them from getting pregnant if they are raped or have intercourse and just want to make sure they don’t get pregnant. Your help would be greatly appreciated, thanks.
Stac, this article from THIS ROCK magazine addresses some of the typical objections raised to the Catholic teaching:

catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0102fea2.asp
 
these pages might help -

catholicapologetics.info/morality/abortion/answers.htm

catholicapologetics.info/morality/abortion/tough.htm

and as for rape and contraceptives, well first of all, it’s not easy getting threw to someone who doesn’t have any respect for life or if they don’t believe in souls,
if you’re talking with catholics, it’s a little bit easier…but still quite difficult, and alot of people no matter what you say just won’t listen, but that’s when your supposed to just let go and let God.

well talking about rape in general is a touchy subject, i rarely get threw to people about abortion being wrong with rape, but with people who are against abortion in any other situation, you can simply ask them, what makes the baby of a rape victim any less precious?
and why is it murder when you kill a baby who was willingly conceived, but not murder when you kill a baby who was conceived against it’s will?
when you kill the child inside of you that you received against your will, you don’t just kill the rapists child, you kill your own child,

some people would counter that with “well what if the rapist was a drug user or had serious physical or mental defects that could pass on to the child?”
well what if he wasn’t? would you be so willing to kill a healthy child, just to ensure you wouldn’t have an unhealthy one? and even if the child was unhealthy, is that a good enough reason to kill* anyone*? and would you not love the child anyways? could you honestly hate a child that did nothing wrong, who’s a victim just as much as you are, in as much as it didn’t have a choice?

ok well…as for contraceptives, they’re no different from any other means of preventing birth, they’re wrong because they do not leave open the conception of a child, and it’s essentially the same as a man “spilling his seed”,
but the problem is, you can’t get these kinda things threw to people who don’t believe that sex is only aloud if your open to the conception of a child, they just won’t understand, not that they refuse to, but sometimes they just honestly don’t get it,

remember that when you are confirmed, you receive the 7 gifts of the Holy Spirit, which are-
wisdom, understanding, counsel, fortitude, knowledge, piety, and fear of the Lord.

and the 12 fruits of the Holy Spirit -
charity, joy, peace, patience, benignity, goodness, longanimity, mildness, faith, modesty, continency, and chastity.

i’m pointing this out because i know it’s so frustrating sometimes to talk with people about things like abortion, and no matter what you say they just don’t understand at all, but a big reason for that may be that they just don’t have the ability to understand,
there is nothing good we have; catholics and non-catholics, that isn’t given to us by God, everything is from God and no one should give themselves credit for what comes to them naturally or even by means of hard work and prayer, it all comes from God,
so i just wanted to say that to maybe help you handle things with more patience and less stress…or maybe you already handle things that well, i dunno, but i’m sure someone can benefit from this e,e

ok well, those are some catholic standpoints, but for anything else, that first link i gave you is very good at defending yourself with the pro-choicers.
 
Thank you so much for the links and for your reply EmeraldWings, I appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut.

I received a flyer in the mail today from Planned Parenthood that says: Support Compassionate Care For Rape Victims. Support the Ohio Prevention First Act! Attached to the flyer is a card for a petition they want you to sign supporting this act.

I have absolutely no idea how they got my name and mailing address :mad: . I will never support anything from them!! Do you think I should send it back telling them to remove me from their mailing list or just let it go? Thanks and God bless.
 
We should take medication to prevent sickness and to cure sickness… Let me ask this… When did getting pregnant and having a child become a disease?

Here is one of my previous posts… it was talking about NFP… was it contraception or not. I think you can’t have an indepth conversation about abortion without addressing the other factors that are all involved with the “death culture” of todays society.
I completely agree with you. The societal influence of the “sexual revolution” took the emphasis of a sharing sexual unity in marriage to a selfish, self centered, anything goes, “Me” mentality that has now become the accepted “norm”. I think this is a travesty. It is also very sad for our children growing up that do not know any better. They see it on TV, they are taught it in our schools and the worst part is they are not being taught the right moral things at home. Parents need to step up and be that “counter-cultural” voice of sanity. Teach our children that sex is a gift from God that unifies two fleshes to one within the bonds of sacramental marriage only. Interfering with God’s plan for life is an evil that will condemn you to hell. NFP works. And sorry guys, but if you can’t put the needs of your wife ahead of your own and go without “getting’ some” for a couple of days then you need therapy.
Wives should be honored and looked upon as a miracle themselves, for they will one day carry your miracle within her womb, God’s plan for life coming from that unity of the flesh and working through her body, continuing to form that little precious child for nine months… How could anyone see that as nothing other then a miracle. Honor you wives.
And finally, (I will step off my soapbox) we all need to change how we think of pregnancy. We need to stop thinking of it as a “disease”. Think about it. For someone who is not expecting it, it is “the end of the world” or so they are led to believe… by society… it’s just another “medical condition” that can be “cured”.
So, please… stop thinking of children as a disease.
Paul
 
Thanks Paul for that post. I have six children and just found out I am pregnant with another miracle baby. The sad part is when I start telling people I will get some of the most rude and negative comments that I have gotten before. Most people think I should be on birth control or that my husband should get a vasectomy. I really wish they understood what the whole birth control/abortion issue is all about. If only I could explain myself better to others but I’m just not good at that.

Have a blessed day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top