My girlfriend is agnostic. I entered the relationship because I was under the impression she was looking for direction. But that doesn’t seem to be the point anymore. She want’s more intimacy that I can give her. She has a hard time thinking that she will be able to sustain her desire to show her affection without becoming more passionate. How can I explain to her that physical pleasures are independent of what you can develop emotionally for another person? How can I convince her that she can we can show each other how we feel about each other without sharing intimacy? I am hoping this could be a step for her in the right direction toward god.
I agree with Monicatholic here about examining why you entered the relationship. If you thought that you could convert her, or try to give her direction, then that is problematic.
However, the situation is not without hope. What you need to do is shift paradigms. She is an “agnostic” in culture that defines “dating” as “doing it”. If the two of you are not so involved, then she wonders if your really dating. This is a tough cultural mentality. I struggled with this, and both my last girlfriend and I were both committed to chastity.
You need to look at this through the Christian mentality. You are refraining from sex to better discern if you and your potential spouse are compatible for marriage. Unfortunately, the answer may be “no”. Refraining from excessive emotional and physical intimacy makes this “no” easier. Breaking up shouldn’t be hard to do!
So what you need to do is explain that you personally need to withhold some intimacy for now, because you are discerning marriage with her. Explain that this is your need, but don’t focus to much on trying to “convince” her that it should be her need as well. Explain that If the two of you are compatible and marry, that this barrier to sexual involvement will vanish! If you and your girlfriend are truly on the “same page” then she should be perfectly happy to commit to waiting
out of respect for your beliefs!
This is a scary move, because you are sharing one of your innermost beliefs, AND exposing yourself to rejection because of it. She may balk at the idea of discerning marriage. “Agnostic” sometimes means not being sure about any major life decisions.
She may only be looking for a temporary “dating” relationship, while she bides her time, but you yourself might also be looking for only a dating relationship too, if you haven’t fully discerned your life choices either! This some to think over and discuss with her.
Talking about these kind of things is a risk, but for God’s Sake (literally

), a risk you really ought to take!