Cousin sexual relationship

  • Thread starter Thread starter fredmack2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The degrees are counted backwards.

Len to his dad James (1st degree) to his grandmother Gillette (2nd degree) to his aunt Josephine (3rd degree) to his cousin Flo (4th degree).
Can I be picky?

The calculation is Len (1), Len’s dad (2), Len’s grandmother (common ancestor, so we don’t count her), Len’s aunt Josephine (3), Len’s cousin Flo (4). Therefore, fourth degree of consanguinity in the collateral line. (The ‘easy’ way to calculate it, of course, is by counting each person (only once, never twice – Grandma’s only one person, not two!) in the situation, and then subtract one.)
 
No…not even a close call.
This isn’t accurate. Actually, consanguinity in the second degree collaterally (i.e., brother and sister) is considered a divine law impediment, and therefore, is never permitted. However, consanguinity in the fourth degree collaterally (i.e., first cousins – the children of the children of two parents) is an impediment by ecclesiastical law. Therefore, it may be dispensed. (However, if civil law prohibits a marriage, then it generally may not be considered valid by canon law. Therefore, if the couple in question may not be married by force of civil law (i.e., civil law says, “no marriage of first cousins”), then a dispensation may not be obtained.)

So, in most cases in the United States, for example, the marriage of first cousins cannot be a valid sacramental marriage under canon law.
 
Hello, i met my first cousin from my paternal side about six years ago…we didnt grow up together but ever since we met m,we have had intense sexual desires toward each other n i find her very attractive…we have kissed n had oral sex etc but no penile penetration…my question is, whats the church stance regarding cousin marriage? N what are the conditions? I know there is the 12.5% genetic make up we share…
Are there no other fish in the sea? :confused:
 
This isn’t accurate. Actually, consanguinity in the second degree collaterally (i.e., brother and sister) is considered a divine law impediment, and therefore, is never permitted. However, consanguinity in the fourth degree collaterally (i.e., first cousins – the children of the children of two parents) is an impediment by ecclesiastical law. Therefore, it may be dispensed. (However, if civil law prohibits a marriage, then it generally may not be considered valid by canon law. Therefore, if the couple in question may not be married by force of civil law (i.e., civil law says, “no marriage of first cousins”), then a dispensation may not be obtained.)

So, in most cases in the United States, for example, the marriage of first cousins cannot be a valid sacramental marriage under canon law.
The marriage impediment between sister and brother is reasonable considering heredity of genetic diseases. Also, does it conflict with the family relationship?

But literally, where is the divine law, i.e., Divine Revelation, prohibiting marriage between brother and sister?
 
But literally, where is the divine law, i.e., Divine Revelation, prohibiting marriage between brother and sister?
“The nakedness of thy sister, the daughter of thy father, or the daughter of thy mother, whether born at home, or born abroad, even their nakedness thou shalt not uncover.” (Leviticus 18:9)
 
Originally Posted by grannymh forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons_khaki/viewpost.gif
But literally, where is the divine law, i.e., Divine Revelation, prohibiting marriage between brother and sister?
“The nakedness of thy sister, the daughter of thy father, or the daughter of thy mother, whether born at home, or born abroad, even their nakedness thou shalt not uncover.” (Leviticus 18:9)
So far I have traced Leviticus 18: 6-20 to CCC 2388 and then to 1 Corinthians 5: 1-5; and to CCC 2356 & CCC 2207.

In addition, there is this very interesting statement in the introduction to the Book of Leviticus, Saint Joseph Edition, The New American Bible, “Continuing the legislation given by God to Moses at Mount Sinai, Leviticus is almost entirely legislative in character …”

Then there is the exception in Deuteronomy 25: 5.

What I am seeing is that it is the degrees of relationship which matter when it comes to laws about marriage. Now, I am wondering at what point in human history was the importance of these degrees recognized.
 
You obviously are not aware of Tay-Sachs disease. Tay-Sachs is very serious.
that’s mostly in Ashkenazi Jews and some creole people but not everywhere, and besides disease showing up, there also some good trait that can express through such breeding like good iq, longevity and so many i tell you. You might find a partner with those malicious disorders like tay sachs and they can express themselves even without you having a blood relationship!
 
“The nakedness of thy sister, the daughter of thy father, or the daughter of thy mother, whether born at home, or born abroad, even their nakedness thou shalt not uncover.” (Leviticus 18:9)
Ineteresting. When we as Catholics defend Mary’s perpetual virginity against protestant assertions that Jesus had brothers and sisters we use the argument that in biblical times and launguage there was no distinction between siblings and cousins. That the same word is used for both. Would that apply here as well?
 
As she is not your wife, I suggest that you no longer engage in sexual activities. If you have not been to confession for this sexual sin, please do so. Please ask this lady to forgive you also for engaging in sinful acts with her.

You mention nothing about her except finding her very attractive and having sexual desires towards her. This beautiful woman is a real person who deserves to have someone who respects her and enjoys the whole person that she is, not just her attractiveness and sexuality.

May God lead you to a chaste relationship with this lady.

Peace to both of you.
I agree with this post. It is fairly obvious that this relationship is not healthy and both persons should speak to a priest.
 
Ineteresting. When we as Catholics defend Mary’s perpetual virginity against protestant assertions that Jesus had brothers and sisters we use the argument that in biblical times and launguage there was no distinction between siblings and cousins. That the same word is used for both. Would that apply here as well?
Well that would be a good argument, except the old and new testament are written in different languages.
 
Well that would be a good argument, except the old and new testament are written in different languages.
So, hebrew, greek latin, aramaic are different. That I understand but what I don’t understand is which language and culture would have distinctions for that. It would seem that it would be old testament language that would not make the distinction. I’m sure the romans and greeks had distinguished familial relationships with words. And it still does not address the cultural idea of them being one and the same.

Do you know which language did not make the distinction and which did?
I don’t.
 
So, hebrew, greek latin, aramaic are different. That I understand but what I don’t understand is which language and culture would have distinctions for that. It would seem that it would be old testament language that would not make the distinction. I’m sure the romans and greeks had distinguished familial relationships with words. And it still does not address the cultural idea of them being one and the same.

Do you know which language did not make the distinction and which did?
I don’t.
So I went back and looked (some of it is who the translator is), but Hebrew and Aramaic do not have a specific word for cousin, and “brother” is often used for kinsmen. (See Lot and Abraham).
Greek however does have a specific word for cousin, and “brother” in ancient Greek is understood narrowly like it is in English.

But we must look at the context. In Leviticus, it is laying out the law, in all other instances, the law is specific and detailed, I would not think that it would lay out a law that was so ambiguous so that so did not know where the cut off was, on who was your “brother” and who wasn’t. First cousins? Second cousins? First cousins once removed? etc. (In the US this is also avoided because laws can be unconstitutional for vagueness). Also the fact that they lived in small tribal communities probably meant that everybody was related to everybody else. It is not good jurisprudence to make laws where people don’t know what is against the law and what isn’t.

On the other hand when the bible talks about Jesus’ brothers, one would assume that the people are speaking colloquially and familiarly (rather than formal law making). Not to mention the evidence against Jesus having siblings. Here is the CA tract. catholic.com/tracts/brethren-of-the-lord
 
40.png
Bezant:
“The nakedness of thy sister, the daughter of thy father, or the daughter of thy mother, whether born at home, or born abroad, even their nakedness thou shalt not uncover.” (Leviticus 18:9)
Ineteresting. When we as Catholics defend Mary’s perpetual virginity against protestant assertions that Jesus had brothers and sisters we use the argument that in biblical times and launguage there was no distinction between siblings and cousins. That the same word is used for both. Would that apply here as well?
The thing is, though, that Leviticus isn’t just saying ‘sister’ and letting it go at that. There’s a deliberate attempt to clarify what is meant: in this context, ‘sister’ means “your father’s daughter” or “your mother’s daughter”, and legalities surrounding their citizenship (vis-a-vis birthplace) don’t change the restriction: no sexual contact.

Now, this passage seems to validate the Catholic understanding of the Semitic use of ‘brother’ and ‘sister’: since there was room to misunderstand, based on conventional usage, this passage narrows it down considerably…!
 
The thing is, though, that Leviticus isn’t just saying ‘sister’ and letting it go at that. There’s a deliberate attempt to clarify what is meant: in this context, ‘sister’ means “your father’s daughter” or “your mother’s daughter”, and legalities surrounding their citizenship (vis-a-vis birthplace) don’t change the restriction: no sexual contact.

Now, this passage seems to validate the Catholic understanding of the Semitic use of ‘brother’ and ‘sister’: since there was room to misunderstand, based on conventional usage, this passage narrows it down considerably…!
Ah, now that makes more sense!
Silly me, I should have know as with most things biblical the answer is there in the context and surrounding verses not just the one being quoted!
You are correct, the clarification of leviticus actually strengthens the Catholic understanding on the subject of family.
Thanks!
Carry on with the origianl subject.
I’m glad I learned something!
 
thank you everybody who tried to share with me knowledge. I now have some insight about the church’s position on such relationships and also the bible’s stance.
The church respects various cultures and civil laws regarding this matter,i know a lot of you feel like its a gross thing to do but, the church has not really put on a hard stance on cousin marriage…it is flexible and you can actually marry one…provided a dispensation is given.
 
Now, this passage seems to validate the Catholic understanding of the Semitic use of ‘brother’ and ‘sister’: since there was room to misunderstand, based on conventional usage, this passage narrows it down considerably…!
From my understanding this appears true; there isn’t a specific word for “cousin” in Hebrew (let alone “first cousin once removed”!). On the other hand, I’m not actually sure Biblical Hebrew’s expanded definition of “brother”/“sister” is expressed the same way in Aramaic, or in New Testament Greek.
 
Was Moses the first person to recognize the errors of marrying within some kind of forbidden degrees of blood relationship?
 
As she is not your wife, I suggest that you no longer engage in sexual activities. If you have not been to confession for this sexual sin, please do so. Please ask this lady to forgive you also for engaging in sinful acts with her.

You mention nothing about her except finding her very attractive and having sexual desires towards her. This beautiful woman is a real person who deserves to have someone who respects her and enjoys the whole person that she is, not just her attractiveness and sexuality.

May God lead you to a chaste relationship with this lady.

Peace to both of you.
👍👍👍

I agree

God bless

jesus g
 
This is not a church chart … but a consanguinity chart from the city of San Antonio.

I was always a little unclear about what (say) a fourth degree of consanguinity meant.

On THIS chart first cousins would be at the fourth degree. Where a first cousin’s child would be a fifth degree. Sometime such might be of the same or “near” age. The grandparents (one set of two ) of one would be the great grandparents (one set of four) of the other.

(consanguinity) Relationships by Marriage (Affinity)


A relationship by blood is also referred to as being related by consanguinity. A relationship by marriage is sometimes referred to as being related by affinity.

A husband and wife are related in the first degree by marriage. For other relationships by marriage, the degree of relationship is the same as the degree of underlying relationship by blood Example: John and Steve are brothers and are therefore second-degree relatives by blood. John’s wife, Linda, is related to Steve in the second degree by marriage.

See Tex. Gov’t Code Section 573.025
Can’t remember if it’s beyond the fourth degree (cousins, etc) where the Church ceases to investigate or have to approve relationships (per marriage eligibility) - or if the state in many cases does. It must not be done often. I haven’t heard of such.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top