Cover songs better than the originals

  • Thread starter Thread starter John_Lazarus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Lol. She’s an Australian that is big in Aust, NZ and the UK for the last 30 years. Was originally a soap starlet in Neighbours and this song launched her pop career in the 80’s.

dailymotion.com/video/x21z9r_kylie-minogue-locomotion_music
The Linda Ronstadt version of “When Will I Be Loved” for me beats out the Everly Brothers original.

Linda Ronstadt - When Will I be Loved Live - YouTube
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GY-mTbv38Io
Artist: Linda Ronstadt
Album: Heart Like a Wheel
Released: 1974
 
Roy Orbison’s is a cover of the Everly Brother’s song. It was released on their 1960 album “A Date with the Everly Brothers” which also has “So How Come (No One Loves Me)”. I discovered it in 1972 while going through my cousin’s LP collection. I searched for it a long time after that but only found it again on Napster and then, more recently, youtube. For me their version is the definitive one. I liked Nazareth’s OK but it just made me long more for theirs.
You are right, I read it wrong. The Everlys were first.

And while I love Phil and Don’s laserbeam-tight harmonies, I still like Nazareth’s better. A bit more raw and emotional.

But that’s just me. 😃
 
I realize this borders on blasphemy, but I really, truly prefer Hall and Oates version of “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feeling” over The Righteous Brothers. I don’t know how to explain it, but the H&O version doesn’t sound as… spooky… as The Righteous Brothers’ version (seriously, it sounds almost ghostly!)
 
I realize this borders on blasphemy, but I really, truly prefer Hall and Oates version of “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feeling” over The Righteous Brothers. I don’t know how to explain it, but the H&O version doesn’t sound as… spooky… as The Righteous Brothers’ version (seriously, it sounds almost ghostly!)
Never thought of that. I think whoever was the recording engineer must have had a thing for echo chambers or something. If you listen to many songs from the late 50s or early 60s, they were really heavy on the reverb/echo, so much so that many times you couldn’t understand the words to save your life!🤷 Have you ever seen the Tom Cruise movie “Top Gun”? He came on to the leading lady in a bar singing that song backed by some of his characters’ Navy buddies.
 
Never thought of that. I think whoever was the recording engineer must have had a thing for echo chambers or something. If you listen to many songs from the late 50s or early 60s, they were really heavy on the reverb/echo, so much so that many times you couldn’t understand the words to save your life!🤷** Have you ever seen the Tom Cruise movie “Top Gun”? He came on to the leading lady in a bar singing that song backed by some of his characters’ Navy buddies**.
😊 Okay, so I lied… THAT is my favorite cover of “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feeling”! 😃
 
Lol. She’s an Australian that is big in Aust, NZ and the UK for the last 30 years. Was originally a soap starlet in Neighbours and this song launched her pop career in the 80’s.

dailymotion.com/video/x21z9r_kylie-minogue-locomotion_music
Thanks for the link! She is cute, and I’d rather look at her than the guys from Grand Funk, but I’d still rather listen to their version of the Loco-Motion.

This idea of one song rendition being better than another is very subjective, of course, and probably also depends on an emotional attachment we might have for a particular recording, depending on when we first heard it. Two examples:

Cole Porter’s* Night and Day*: Back in my days of listening to pop music, U2 came out with a version which I liked, but which my mom thought was just horrible. She was used to Ella Fitzgerald’s and Frank Sinatra’s rendition.

Irving Berlin’s* Puttin’ on the Ritz*: Again, for better or worse, I became used to Taco’s quirky version, but for my mom, Fred Astaire made the definitive recording.
 
There is a video on youtube of Carrie Underwood covering “Alone” by Heart at a fan club party performance or something.
Just looked it up. Amazing. Celine Dion does a great cover of it as well.
 
The Linda Ronstadt version of “When Will I Be Loved” for me beats out the Everly Brothers original.

Linda Ronstadt - When Will I be Loved Live - YouTube
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GY-mTbv38Io
Artist: Linda Ronstadt
Album: Heart Like a Wheel
Released: 1974
I can’t say Ronstadt’s cover of Orbison’s “Blue Bayou” is better, but it is terrific and really lets you hear her voice at its peak, especially that last note where she changes pitch or register (or whatever you call it).

Her versions of Warren Zevon’s “Carmelita” and Buddy Holly’s “It’s So Easy” weren’t too shabby, either.

Jo Stafford’s lilting cover of “You Belong to Me” (originally recorded by Sue Thompson and Patti Page) is also a thing of beauty.
 
One band I love that does covers is “Dirty Loops;” you can find them on YouTube. They play everything upbeat/jazz-fusion oriented. I doesn’t even matter what the song is they’re covering; they’re all great. 🙂

Example: La GaGa’s “Just Dance:”

youtube.com/watch?v=XQaWN5ODdVY
 
One band I love that does covers is “Dirty Loops;” you can find them on YouTube. They play everything upbeat/jazz-fusion oriented. I doesn’t even matter what the song is they’re covering; they’re all great. 🙂

Example: La GaGa’s “Just Dance:”

youtube.com/watch?v=XQaWN5ODdVY
Sounds like Herb Alpert & Tijuana Brass. They played lots of tunes upbeat jazz oriented too.
 
Thanks for the link! She is cute, and I’d rather look at her than the guys from Grand Funk, but I’d still rather listen to their version of the Loco-Motion.

This idea of one song rendition being better than another is very subjective, of course, and probably also depends on an emotional attachment we might have for a particular recording, depending on when we first heard it. Two examples:

Cole Porter’s* Night and Day*: Back in my days of listening to pop music, U2 came out with a version which I liked, but which my mom thought was just horrible. She was used to Ella Fitzgerald’s and Frank Sinatra’s rendition.

Irving Berlin’s* Puttin’ on the Ritz*: Again, for better or worse, I became used to Taco’s quirky version, but for my mom, Fred Astaire made the definitive recording.
Puttin on the Ritz – Gene Wilder and Peter Boyle from Young Frankenstein:D
 
I was stumped until your post. Johnny Cash made “Hurt” his own. I like when genres and artists crossover because I like the tension that comes from the differences. The two artists are at different places in their lives and the “hurt” comes from different places. But both artists are on the dark side.
Yes, totally agree. I like both Nine Inch Nails’ version as well as Johnny Cash because they both “felt” the words in their own unique ways.

This old 18th c. song was covered so many times by various different people from various periods. It is a rather timeless piece and still well-known by music lovers.

The original probably sounded similar like this (which I love) as we don’t have any recordings from the time:

youtube.com/watch?v=W0sfILDANJg

I grew up listening to Joan Baez through my Dad and I always enjoyed her version of it as well:
youtube.com/watch?v=dU1Gz_i5aXQ

And I also liked Nana Mouskouri’s cover:
youtube.com/watch?v=N77jIRg15U0

This cover of it with Kathleen Battle and a harp is also very lovely:
youtube.com/watch?v=g7mpEatLGks
 
I like all three of those versions. I’ve never been quite sure what the song meant, though.
It sounds like he’s singing about Francisco “Pancho” Villa, a Mexican revolutionary who raided the town of Columbus, NM in 1916 and was pursued, unsuccessfully, by Gen. John “Black Jack” Pershing for nine months before Pershing was recalled because WWI had begun. The song says “All the federales say they could have had him any day, they only let him slip away out of kindness, I suppose.” However, the writer, Townes Van Zandt claims it’s not historically accurate and that the story is only loosely based on the real Pancho Villa.

In the song, Pancho and Lefty are a couple of bandits and Lefty sells out Pancho and heads for Ohio (“where he got the bread to go, there ain’t nobody knows”). An amusing anecdote that Van Zandt tells is that he was stopped by a couple of policemen one time who asked what he did for a living and when he replied, “I’m a songwriter,” they didn’t take him seriously until he said he wrote “Pancho and Lefty” then the two cops grinned because one was Hispanic and his partner was Anglo and they were referred to as “Pancho” and “Lefty” by the other officers.
 
Duane Allman died October 29, 1971. He played with his brother Gregg in the Allman Brothers Band for only two years but they pumped out a lot of great music. About half were original and half were covers. Some of my favorite covers are:

Stormy Monday - T Bone Walker
youtube.com/watch?v=1gDhR1R3S0s

Hoochie Coochie Man - Muddy Waters
youtube.com/watch?v=PG199Je0OxQ

Done Somebody Wrong - Clarence L. Lewis , Bobby Robinson , Elmore James
youtube.com/watch?v=EjhsLblrctI

One Way Out - Marshall Sehorn/Elmore James
youtube.com/watch?v=Gg54zkr6IWs

Statesboro Blues - Will McTell
youtube.com/watch?v=ezPZxfS1jys
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top