D&D (Dungeons and Dragons)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ophelia23
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
These things fall under the concept of “opening the door”. It is the same concept Christ speaks about when he says “If you look at a woman lustfully you have already committed adultery”. It is not that most people who look at another lustfully will act on it, but all actions begin in the mind.

The guiding question to ask is: “does this activity bring me closer to Christ or potentially farther away?” Spending hours reading about, meditating on and playing a fantasy game which uses the occult as a fundamental principle in the playing probably falls into the “farther away” category (No sarcasm intended).

Realistically, all who are damaged by the occult go into it thinking they are not in danger. Whether the occult in a game, ghost hunters, ouji boards, reiki, etc… That’s how they enemy works… “It’s not dangerous… he says”. Sort of like “He didn’t really say not to eat the fruit from that tree…”

Rhetorical question: Of those of you who use spells in the game: Who has never, not even once thought “what would it be like to be able to do that in real life?”. No one. Everyone one has had that thought, that’s why they play the game. That act, of wondering if it’s possible to actually do it, is the door being opened. All who play are contemplating the concept of using dark spiritual forces for harming another person, even if just a fantasy, thinking about using occult forces to hurt someone else is a problem spiritually speaking. Even if you have no intention of ever carrying it out.

The answer I gave was to the OP. For those of you who play, keep playing, enjoy it. I’ll stay away and suggest to those who ask to do the same.

PAX
 
I often find the terms Chaotic VS Lawful even more ambiguous than Good VS Evil. In some cases, real life Catholicism is more of the latter but in times of persecution it leans to the former. (This is something I don’t know whether to find stupid or interesting about the Church. Meh, we can always classify this as Neutral.)

As for myself, I actually despise Lawful just as much as I dislike Evil. Lawful implies rigid legalism and lacks moral foresight towards the greater good (at least from my experience). BP (And on a side note, my friends like to joke about how Lawful Good actually translates into Lawful Stupid.)

That’s why in terms of both DnD and M:tG, I never see myself as a Lawful character. I always play characters that are often Neutral or Chaotic Good and I absolutely loathe the popular principles of White mana.
Both lawful and chaotic eventually wind up shooting themselves in the foot. Imho, any smart character will gravitate toward the neutrals (whether good, evil, or true).
 
These things fall under the concept of “opening the door”. It is the same concept Christ speaks about when he says “If you look at a woman lustfully you have already committed adultery”. It is not that most people who look at another lustfully will act on it, but all actions begin in the mind.

The guiding question to ask is: “does this activity bring me closer to Christ or potentially farther away?” Spending hours reading about, meditating on and playing a fantasy game which uses the occult as a fundamental principle in the playing probably falls into the “farther away” category (No sarcasm intended).

Realistically, all who are damaged by the occult go into it thinking they are not in danger. Whether the occult in a game, ghost hunters, ouji boards, reiki, etc… That’s how they enemy works… “It’s not dangerous… he says”. Sort of like “He didn’t really say not to eat the fruit from that tree…”

Rhetorical question: Of those of you who use spells in the game: Who has never, not even once thought “what would it be like to be able to do that in real life?”. No one. Everyone one has had that thought, that’s why they play the game. That act, of wondering if it’s possible to actually do it, is the door being opened. All who play are contemplating the concept of using dark spiritual forces for harming another person, even if just a fantasy, thinking about using occult forces to hurt someone else is a problem spiritually speaking. Even if you have no intention of ever carrying it out.

The answer I gave was to the OP. For those of you who play, keep playing, enjoy it. I’ll stay away and suggest to those who ask to do the same.

PAX
The least you could do, however, is be accurate. The occult is in no way, shape, or form involved in the game of D&D, much less being a “fundamental principle” of the game. It’s rather tiresome to deal with people who feel that accuracy is irrelevant when condemning something (whether it is the Harry Potter novels or D&D or whatever new bête noire may crop up in the future). If you don’t want to play, that’s fine. All I ask is that you don’t lie about it.

Fact is, I have played many spellcasters (mage and cleric both), and the idea of “what would it be like to really do that” is not something in my mind. But then again, I do have a reasonably solid grasp of the difference between reality and fiction. I have played thieves, as well, and never thought about wanting to steal; I have played fighters, yet never thought about killing someone. Then again, there aren’t too many orcs rampaging through my neighborhood, either.

You said:
“All who play are contemplating the concept of using dark spiritual forces for harming another person”

I say:
Completely, utterly false. There are no dark, spiritual forces involved in the game. Nor do “all who play” contemplate using “dark spiritual forces” (or sharp blades or solid bludgeoning weapons or any other in-game device) to harm another person.

If you do not want to play, that is fine. When someone asks, simply admit you don’t know enough about the game and choose other recreational pursuits. But, please, refrain from lying about the game.

Facts:
The occult is not part of the game.
There are no causal links between playing the game and suicide (unless it’s a negative link–the facts are that suicide rates are lower amongst gamers than non-gamers). Playing a spellcaster in the game doesn’t open doors to the occult, just as playing a thief in the game doesn’t lead to a RL career of robbery.
Persons with impaired capacity for discerning fact from fiction should refrain from playing the game.
I am a DM on a play-by-post website. If you’re interested in playing, PM me.
 
There’s nothing wrong with it. It’s like playing any video/computer game without the technology.
 
The answer I gave was to the OP. For those of you who play, keep playing, enjoy it. I’ll stay away and suggest to those who ask to do the same.
Gamer or not, people should have the moral obligation to suggest they don’t give you an ear. Preaching views that are based on a false premise and logical fallacies are all sins of bearing false witness. Both me and another poster have clearly laid it out for you but you refused to address or concede. That’s intellectual dishonesty, another form of false witness. So in addition, I would suggest any decent Catholic to either ignore or challenge your views than blindly accept.

Does the disorder of a lactose-intolerant give him the license to tell people to avoid dairy products? No.
These things fall under the concept of “opening the door”.
Nope, they do not. This is the false premise I was speaking of.
It is the same concept Christ speaks about when he says “If you look at a woman lustfully you have already committed adultery”.
Apples and oranges. That’s another logical fallacy from you.
It is not that most people who look at another lustfully will act on it, but all actions begin in the mind.
In the mind, people do things that science and physics don’t allow. There’s one hint that you need to evaluate your premise.
The guiding question to ask is: “does this activity bring me closer to Christ or potentially farther away?” Spending hours reading about, meditating on and playing a fantasy game which uses the occult as a fundamental principle in the playing probably falls into the “farther away” category (No sarcasm intended).
  1. The world doesn’t revolve exclusively around heavily religious activity or thought. We’re humans, not mindless robots of piety. So what if something doesn’t explicitly call us to religion? Our Lord Himself performed His first miracle was at a wedding party! (And may I add that, in-game, the farther my mage is from religious affiliations, the better. BD)
  2. Repeat: You. False premise. Review.
Realistically, all who are damaged by the occult go into it thinking they are not in danger. Whether the occult in a game, ghost hunters, ouji boards, reiki, etc… That’s how they enemy works… “It’s not dangerous… he says”. Sort of like “He didn’t really say not to eat the fruit from that tree…”
I’ve seen people who dabble into the occult and these are the same people who hang out at discos and poke fun at gamers such as myself. Do you need any more proof how an orange differs from the apple?
Rhetorical question: Of those of you who use spells in the game: Who has never, not even once thought “what would it be like to be able to do that in real life?”. No one. Everyone one has had that thought, that’s why they play the game. That act, of wondering if it’s possible to actually do it, is the door being opened.
Why would I deny this? Why would I deny the liberating sensation of doing things this boring reality would never permit? It doesn’t even need religion to enforce its mundane laws of physics! In fact, are these not the same laws that atheists champion when they criticize religion? Oh the irony… :rotfl:

More seriously though, it’s due to the lack possibility that your non-existent door isn’t opening.

To assume that possibility is to presume an entirely different world that doesn’t act on the same cosmological principles as this one.
All who play are contemplating the concept of using dark spiritual forces for harming another person, even if just a fantasy, thinking about using occult forces to hurt someone else is a problem spiritually speaking. Even if you have no intention of ever carrying it out.
Following your logic, mentioning ‘dark spiritual forces’ is unnecessary. Anybody can wish harm without carrying it out. Wishing harm isn’t automatically a sin either. Ever been wronged? Even Jesus wished harm and pain on the fig tree and acted on his anger towards the money changers.

How is that any different from a mage going wild after being treated like some kind of monster? How is that any different from the samurai swearing to avenge the death of his lord or lover (maybe gasps both)?

Finally, there’s the false premise of ‘dark spiritual forces’. The Church’s definition of such forces and the theology behind them operates on a different cosmology. For one, mages don’t invoke spiritual forces. They invoke a force that is native to their fictional universe.

And as Warlock is my favorite class in DnD, it is actually the best example of how magic can draw from no outside force but within. The magic of the Warlock is a power infused into his/her very soul and is not always the result of dark actions on their part.
 
These things fall under the concept of “opening the door”. It is the same concept Christ speaks about when he says “If you look at a woman lustfully you have already committed adultery”. It is not that most people who look at another lustfully will act on it, but all actions begin in the mind.
Your analogy is horrible. Why? Because it hinges on the intent of the looker. Translate your analogy back to the subject of this thread, and the only way it is “opening the door” is if the player has any belief in the validity of magic and the magic system in the game. A point I made earlier. If a player knows it’s all BS than there is no “opening the door” or even a door to open.

The guiding question to ask is: “does this activity bring me closer to Christ or potentially farther away?” Spending hours reading about, meditating on and playing a fantasy game which uses the occult as a fundamental principle in the playing probably falls into the “farther away” category (No sarcasm intended).
You mean like posting comments about a silly game on an internet forum?

Realistically, all who are damaged by the occult go into it thinking they are not in danger. Whether the occult in a game, ghost hunters, ouji boards, reiki, etc… That’s how they enemy works… “It’s not dangerous… he says”. Sort of like “He didn’t really say not to eat the fruit from that tree…”
You can’t really group D and D with the others. The have a different focus and purpose. You’re basically trying to say that driving a car is dangerous because airplanes crash all the time.

Rhetorical question: Of those of you who use spells in the game: Who has never, not even once thought “what would it be like to be able to do that in real life?”. No one. Everyone one has had that thought, that’s why they play the game. That act, of wondering if it’s possible to actually do it, is the door being opened. All who play are contemplating the concept of using dark spiritual forces for harming another person, even if just a fantasy, thinking about using occult forces to hurt someone else is a problem spiritually speaking. Even if you have no intention of ever carrying it out.
Sounds like you are using magic to read the minds of everyone who as ever played the game. That, or you’re creating a generality that supports your already developed conclusions. Either or.

The answer I gave was to the OP. For those of you who play, keep playing, enjoy it. I’ll stay away and suggest to those who ask to do the same.
And I suggest you do stay away since you seem to place validity in magic as presented by the game.

PAX
 
Gamer or not, people should have the moral obligation to suggest they don’t give you an ear. Preaching views that are based on a false premise and logical fallacies are all sins of bearing false witness. Both me and another poster have clearly laid it out for you but you refused to address or concede. That’s intellectual dishonesty, another form of false witness. So in addition, I would suggest any decent Catholic to either ignore or challenge your views than blindly accept.

Does the disorder of a lactose-intolerant give him the license to tell people to avoid dairy products? No.

Nope, they do not. This is the false premise I was speaking of.

Apples and oranges. That’s another logical fallacy from you.

In the mind, people do things that science and physics don’t allow. There’s one hint that you need to evaluate your premise.
  1. The world doesn’t revolve exclusively around heavily religious activity or thought. We’re humans, not mindless robots of piety. So what if something doesn’t explicitly call us to religion? Our Lord Himself performed His first miracle was at a wedding party! (And may I add that, in-game, the farther my mage is from religious affiliations, the better. BD)
  2. Repeat: You. False premise. Review.
I’ve seen people who dabble into the occult and these are the same people who hang out at discos and poke fun at gamers such as myself. Do you need any more proof how an orange differs from the apple?

Why would I deny this? Why would I deny the liberating sensation of doing things this boring reality would never permit? It doesn’t even need religion to enforce its mundane laws of physics! In fact, are these not the same laws that atheists champion when they criticize religion? Oh the irony… :rotfl:

More seriously though, it’s due to the lack possibility that your non-existent door isn’t opening.

To assume that possibility is to presume an entirely different world that doesn’t act on the same cosmological principles as this one.

Following your logic, mentioning ‘dark spiritual forces’ is unnecessary. Anybody can wish harm without carrying it out. Wishing harm isn’t automatically a sin either. Ever been wronged? Even Jesus wished harm and pain on the fig tree and acted on his anger towards the money changers.

How is that any different from a mage going wild after being treated like some kind of monster? How is that any different from the samurai swearing to avenge the death of his lord or lover (maybe gasps both)?

Finally, there’s the false premise of ‘dark spiritual forces’. The Church’s definition of such forces and the theology behind them operates on a different cosmology. For one, mages don’t invoke spiritual forces. They invoke a force that is native to their fictional universe.

And as Warlock is my favorite class in DnD, it is actually the best example of how magic can draw from no outside force but within. The magic of the Warlock is a power infused into his/her very soul and is not always the result of dark actions on their part.
You know I love that you are here. Aside from that little assurance I’m not crazy because someone thinks just like me it’s nice I don’t have to post it all the time.
 
You can’t really group D and D with the others. The have a different focus and purpose. You’re basically trying to say that driving a car is dangerous because airplanes crash all the time.
Actually, that is an excellent analogy that can be applied to a lot of situations where people criticize the eeeeeevil fantasy genre of games and media in general.
 
Here’s what I don’t get at all.

Traditional Catholics will be the first to slam something like d&d for supposed connections to the occult (despite most players know its just a skin for a game mechanic). But those same Catholics will turn on a dime and say that a troubling dream they had and that chill down their spine was a message from God.

The Church explicitly forbids us from advertising such claims as they until proven otherwise could be wrong and lead people astray.

The correct protical is to shut your mouth, talk to your priest, wait and listen. Any attempt to either blast it to the world or take it as solid fact and act on it without guidance is just as bad as practicing the occult as it sets you up as some kind of self appointed prophet.

Now you may have asked your self " what about Joan of arc?" what about her? Before she did anything God had it worked out in his master plan to have Joan visit the church officials and verify status before she lead any troups anywhere.

The who hypocrisy really rubs me the wrong way here. It’s a game. Frankly you can re-skin it to make it about Si-fi instead of magic. Personal shielding instead of Mage armor, lights sabers instead of flaming sword, alien invasion instead of dragons. At the end of the day you still had a character sheet, you still have dice and you are going chungking soda and joking out " failed dice rolls" that got your party into trouble.

I’m not going to say " get with the times" but really I thing way to many Catholics are afraid of their own shadow.

There’s plenty of catholic rituals that creeped me out and made me wonder how healthy they were at the time but they were just fine.

Skulls are not evil, they are bones.
Darkness is not evil, it was made by God to to force you to rest.
Games are not evil, they just have imagitive stages to convey plot.

It’s what you do with the above that makes them wrong.
 
Here’s what I don’t get at all.

Traditional Catholics will be the first to slam something like d&d for supposed connections to the occult (despite most players know its just a skin for a game mechanic).
I’m a Traditional Catholic, :highprayer: and I’ve been playing D&D since 1978 - primarily Holmes Basic and AD&D 1st Edition, plus a plethora of non-D&D RPGs of various genres.

This is the favorite Scripture quote of Gary Gygax, creator of D&D:

“So let your light shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father who is in heaven.” ~ St. Matthew V:16

If anyone is curious about D&D, RPGs in general, or wants to get a game going, just let me know! :knight1:
 
I’m just stunned that people still play D & D. Rolling dice by hand? How old fashioned!
 
The whole alignment thing is confusing. o:
If you mean by both games? Hmm, I think I see your point. I would say that M:tG is a bit more confusing since each color has its own set of world-views plus the result of combining those views when going duo or tri-colored. 🤓

Then again, those views aren’t really prerequisites to the game whereas it’s also a more significant mechanic in DnD.
 
No computer will ever match the imaginations of an OId School DM and his players. And I like my dice. They never require a patch or an upgrade!
I’m just stunned that people still play D & D. Rolling dice by hand? How old fashioned!
 
Don’t worry about alignment. No one ever did. Players of Paladins… maybe. But don’t sweat it.

Personally, I think of myself as Chaotic Good. 👍

Great! Now I’ve done it…
The whole alignment thing is confusing. o:
 
Don’t worry about alignment. No one ever did. Players of Paladins… maybe. But don’t sweat it.

Personally, I think of myself as Chaotic Good. 👍

Great! Now I’ve done it…
That’s ok. There’s room in my game if you want to play 😉 It’s play-by-post but I’ve been called Gygaxian by one of my players who actually once played at the Gygax’s table.
 
Don’t worry about alignment. No one ever did. Players of Paladins… maybe. But don’t sweat it.

Personally, I think of myself as Chaotic Good. 👍

Great! Now I’ve done it…
No wonder I play as a Paladin in Diablo II: Lord of Destruction. o:
If you mean by both games? Hmm, I think I see your point. I would say that M:tG is a bit more confusing since each color has its own set of world-views plus the result of combining those views when going duo or tri-colored. 🤓

Then again, those views aren’t really prerequisites to the game whereas it’s also a more significant mechanic in DnD.
I just don’t understand the whole alignment thing. o:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top