D&D (Dungeons and Dragons)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ophelia23
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s ok. There’s room in my game if you want to play 😉 It’s play-by-post but I’ve been called Gygaxian by one of my players who actually once played at the Gygax’s table.
Gygaxian… Ah, so you keep your players on their toes! And it’s play-by-post, eh? So a turn takes less time than in 4e, I expect 😉
 
For anyone with lingering doubts about Dungeons & Dragons, I offer this most excellent blog, Blood of Prokopius:

bloodofprokopius.blogspot.com/

The author, Fr. Dave, is an Orthodox priest who runs Old School D&D. Well worth a look for his Saintly Saturday entries, alone!
 
2e 4 life!

D&D is harmless fun unless someone takes it too seriously. But that’s true of most things
There is no real magic involved, no real magical rituals or spells. It’s all just plot devices to progress a sort of choose your own adventure story.
 
That’s ok. There’s room in my game if you want to play 😉 It’s play-by-post but I’ve been called Gygaxian by one of my players who actually once played at the Gygax’s table.
I’d take you up on that offer.
 
I’ve really enjoyed reading the posts here about this subject, as I’m in RCIA now and I’m an avid pc gamer. My game of choice(s) are Lord of the Rings Online and Everquest 2, but I dabble in other online games for a few months at a time before going back to my old stand-by’s.

Personally, I love most games and feel like gaming is a great hobby for some. Yes, there are some who take it too far but mostly in terms of spending a little too much time and neglect other aspects of their lives, but most players aren’t heavy duty gamers like that. Take WoW for instance… I could never spend 6 hours raiding like some of them do. That’s just nuts. I’d fall asleep at the keyboard if I had to do that.

All in all, I’m happy to see that there are some fellow gamers here and I feel a lot better knowing that I’m doing something that I don’t feel like I have to hide (i.e., something potentially that could be a sin, etc.)

It’s good meeting you all! 😃
 
I’d just like to point out that my two best friends and I all play in and game master rpg’s for each other. We’re also Fourth Degree Knights of Columbus.

One of those men was my confirmation sponsor and the reason for my joining the Knights…

and if I hadn’t joined the Knights, I wouldn’t be a volunteer youth minister, teen confirmation class teacher, charter org rep for our AHG troop, or discerning the priesthood.

Oh, by the way, we became friends BECAUSE of roleplaying games…

Before I even knew he was Christian let alone Catholic.

P.S. I’m writing up an 3e Paladin for the Forgotten Realms… and using “The Manual of a Christian Knight” by Desiderius Erasmus as my roleplaying guide.👍
 
I’d just like to point out that my two best friends and I all play in and game master rpg’s for each other. We’re also Fourth Degree Knights of Columbus.
Well done! Perhaps we can, at long last, put to rest the notion that D&D is an evil influence.

Still, 3.x and later editions are clearly heretical, and should be placed on the Index of Forbidden Rulebooks. I advise prayer, fasting and a Remove Curse as soon as possible. 😉
 
Apart from the Biblical Proscriptions listed below, there is a danger in opening your household to other spirits. Nobody thinks evil will come to their house until it does. Once in it often goes after those least able to defend themselves (…the little one’s). You are asking because your gut is telling you something is not ok. Even if he plays at a friends house, spirits can come home with him.

You will know the level of infiltration by the level of resistance you receive if you suggest he stop.
Dear ChurchSoldier,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Splendid post and jolly timely. A note of alarm needs to be sounded in our irreligous times, especially given the world-wide increase in occultic activitities.

Sadly, dear friend, our godless culture has desensitzed many (including some professing Catholics) to the very real dangers of the occult and we no longer have a healthy fear of it as we once did. There can be little doubt that the Harry Potter phenomena and RPG’s like Dungeons and Dragons, have contributed considerably to deadening people’s sensitivity to that which is evil and unwholesome. In his book, An Exorcist Tells His Story, Father Gabriel Amorth, an exorcist of the diocese of Rome, warns that modern man is loosing his sense of the reality of supernatural evil. As a result, he says, many have made themselves more vulnerable to the influence of evil spirits who seek to corrupt and destroy souls. Moreover, in this book Father does not hesitate to say that cultural influences such as film, television, music and books play no small part in the lowering of spiritual vigilance. Dungeons and Dragons with its very dark themes and incorporation of basic occultic ideas, can only serve to lower our spiritual vigilance and sensitivity, no matter how strong spiritually we may think that we are - “Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (I Cor. 10: 12). Moreover, our fears are hardly unfounded or alarmist given the proliferation among the young of spiritism, witchcraft and the occult? In the current situation, dear friend, it should come as no surprise that players of Dungeons and Dragons consider any dangers to be so extremely remote as to have no bearing upon their lives. Contrary to what is often asserted, modern culture, as it is today, can and does desensitize men to occultic activities, via casual exposure to occult themes and ideas in media sources, such as films, television, games and books.

Within contemporary Catholicism (even among those who identify as conservative) it is now almost universally taken for granted that men can assimilate a certain amount of unwholesome or immoral entertainment without being adversely affected by it. It is tacitly assumed that if a man has sufficient rational faith, then he will be equipped to sift through the good, bad and ugly material without being spiritually harmed by it, ignoring the bad and ugly content and savouring the good. Thus we are happy to be entertained by television programmes based on an occultic world-view, such as Charmed, *Buffy The Vampire ***Slayer, and Sabrina the Teenage Witch, and despicable comedy shows such as Cheers, Friends, Seinfield and the culturally unhealthy Simpsons. Men will respond by saying that they enjoy the wit, but do they realize how a diet of laughing at what is profoundly unfunny will at length alter their abilty to understand the gravity of immoral conduct. Have not, dear friend, come to a point where we casually accept the normalcy of filth and corruption? Have our powers of spirtual discernment become so blunted that we can no longer identify that which is culturally unwholesome and occultic in theme?

In any event, the focus should not be on whether Dungeons and Dragons is harmful for a man of a mature spiritual dispostion, for as I have remarked above, such people are not immune from falling. Rather, the emphasis ought to be upon whether imagining oneself engaging in such activities and desiring to engage in them in the imagination, is as offensive to our Holy God as actually participating in them in real life. Motivation is wholly irrelevant, for that does not alter the fact that this RPG treats of dark themes and incorporates the basic ideas of the occult. That alone renders it dangerous and unwholesome for those who profess the holy religion of Christ. It is clearly just too close comfort and ought to be shunned by those who are in earnest as regards the pursuit of holiness.

Moreover, it is manifestly obvious that a pious Catholic should not engage in Dungeons and Dragons, or any kind of fantasy, that involves the promotion or neutral use of evil. This would have been readily apparent to former generations of Catholics and it is lamentable that this is not the case today. As with so many other issues, this subject is very much connected with the much broader issue of sanctity and separation from the world and its demoralizing and distracting influences.

God bless and thankyou for your (name removed by moderator)ut. Even if just one person revises their thinking on this issue then that is all to the good, dear friend.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Dear ChurchSoldier,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Splendid post and jolly timely. A note of alarm needs to be sounded in our irreligous times, especially given the world-wide increase in occultic activitities.

Sadly, dear friend, our godless culture has desensitzed many (including some professing Catholics) to the very real dangers of the occult and we no longer have a healthy fear of it as we once did. There can be little doubt that the Harry Potter phenomena and RPG’s like Dungeons and Dragons, have contributed considerably to deadening people’s sensitivity to that which is evil and unwholesome. In his book, An Exorcist Tells His Story, Father Gabriel Amorth, an exorcist of the diocese of Rome, warns that modern man is loosing his sense of the reality of supernatural evil. As a result, he says, many have made themselves more vulnerable to the influence of evil spirits who seek to corrupt and destroy souls. Moreover, in this book Father does not hesitate to say that cultural influences such as film, television, music and books play no small part in the lowering of spiritual vigilance. Dungeons and Dragons with its very dark themes and incorporation of basic occultic ideas, can only serve to lower our spiritual vigilance and sensitivity, no matter how strong spiritually we may think that we are - “Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (I Cor. 10: 12). Moreover, our fears are hardly unfounded or alarmist given the proliferation among the young of spiritism, witchcraft and the occult? In the current situation, dear friend, it should come as no surprise that players of Dungeons and Dragons consider any dangers to be so extremely remote as to have no bearing upon their lives. Contrary to what is often asserted, modern culture, as it is today, can and does desensitize men to occultic activities, via casual exposure to occult themes and ideas in media sources, such as films, television, games and books.

Within contemporary Catholicism (even among those who identify as conservative) it is now almost universally taken for granted that men can assimilate a certain amount of unwholesome or immoral entertainment without being adversely affected by it. It is tacitly assumed that if a man has sufficient rational faith, then he will be equipped to sift through the good, bad and ugly material without being spiritually harmed by it, ignoring the bad and ugly content and savouring the good. Thus we are happy to be entertained by television programmes based on an occultic world-view, such as Charmed, *Buffy The Vampire ***Slayer, and Sabrina the Teenage Witch, and despicable comedy shows such as Cheers, Friends, Seinfield and the culturally unhealthy Simpsons. Men will respond by saying that they enjoy the wit, but do they realize how a diet of laughing at what is profoundly unfunny will at length alter their abilty to understand the gravity of immoral conduct. Have not, dear friend, come to a point where we casually accept the normalcy of filth and corruption? Have our powers of spirtual discernment become so blunted that we can no longer identify that which is culturally unwholesome and occultic in theme?

In any event, the focus should not be on whether Dungeons and Dragons is harmful for a man of a mature spiritual dispostion, for as I have remarked above, such people are not immune from falling. Rather, the emphasis ought to be upon whether imagining oneself engaging in such activities and desiring to engage in them in the imagination, is as offensive to our Holy God as actually participating in them in real life. Motivation is wholly irrelevant, for that does not alter the fact that this RPG treats of dark themes and incorporates the basic ideas of the occult. That alone renders it dangerous and unwholesome for those who profess the holy religion of Christ. It is clearly just too close comfort and ought to be shunned by those who are in earnest as regards the pursuit of holiness.

Moreover, it is manifestly obvious that a pious Catholic should not engage in Dungeons and Dragons, or any kind of fantasy, that involves the promotion or neutral use of evil. This would have been readily apparent to former generations of Catholics and it is lamentable that this is not the case today. As with so many other issues, this subject is very much connected with the much broader issue of sanctity and separation from the world and its demoralizing and distracting influences.

God bless and thankyou for your (name removed by moderator)ut. Even if just one person revises their thinking on this issue then that is all to the good, dear friend.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
If you’re right, then it’s sinful to listen to the Odyssey, the Iliad, or the Aeneid; it’s sinful to read any of Shakespeare’s plays; and it’s sinful to watch old western TV shows. Does that even sound logical?
 
Sadly, dear friend, our godless culture has desensitzed many (including some professing Catholics) to the very real dangers of the occult and we no longer have a healthy fear of it as we once did. There can be little doubt that the Harry Potter phenomena and RPG’s like Dungeons and Dragons, have contributed considerably to deadening people’s sensitivity to that which is evil and unwholesome.
Can you justify this statement, or explain in what senses HP and D&D are occult?
Moreover, in this book Father does not hesitate to say that cultural influences such as film, television, music and books play no small part in the lowering of spiritual vigilance.
Is this singular priest’s authority enough to add to the CCC? If not, then his opinion is noted but not binding.
Dungeons and Dragons with its very dark themes and incorporation of basic occultic ideas,
Namely?
can only serve to lower our spiritual vigilance and sensitivity, no matter how strong spiritually we may think that we are - “Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (I Cor. 10: 12).
This is absurd, and does not follow. The fact that you cannot distinguish between fantasy and reality does not mean others are incapable of doing the same.
Moreover, our fears are hardly unfounded or alarmist given the proliferation among the young of spiritism, witchcraft and the occult?
What proliferation? How many young people? Where are the data showing this trend?
Within contemporary Catholicism (even among those who identify as conservative) it is now almost universally taken for granted that men can assimilate a certain amount of unwholesome or immoral entertainment without being adversely affected by it.
False; “assimilate” should be changed to “be aware of.”
It is tacitly assumed that if a man has sufficient rational faith, then he will be equipped to sift through the good, bad and ugly material without being spiritually harmed by it, ignoring the bad and ugly content and savouring the good.
This is misleading. The Church does not in general regulate fiction. To say that there is “good and bad material” is problematic because you have not actually defined what “good” and “bad” is. For example, the Church does not necessarily consider any character in a fictional work sinning as “bad.”
Thus we are happy to be entertained by television programmes based on an occultic world-view, such as Charmed, *Buffy The Vampire ***Slayer, and Sabrina the Teenage Witch,
None of these shows actually embrace an occultic world-view because the shows are fictional. Even if the maker of the show believes in the occult, the show would still not reflect an occultic world-view because they are fiction, not documentaries.
Men will respond by saying that they enjoy the wit, but do they realize how a diet of laughing at what is profoundly unfunny will at length alter their abilty to understand the gravity of immoral conduct.
You seem to be channeling the thoughts of Jorge from Umberto Eco’s The Name of the Rose. Note that his arguments were erroneous, as our your own, as William of Baskerville demonstrates rather convincingly in the novel.

Sin can be funny in fiction. It should not be funny in reality. If someone is capable of maintaining that distinction, then he may laugh all he wants at fiction. To state that something is impermissible because of a possible and not-inevitable consequence runs contrary to Catholic teaching.
 
Holy Dark Dungeons, Batman!

theescapist.com/darkdungeons.htm

Has this nonsense started up again?

And why is it always a long-winded boilerplate rant?

I’m a veteran of the first attack on D&D back in the '80s. Since it’s release in 1974, Dungeons & Dragons (or any other RPG, for that matter) has not lead to some rising of Servants of Cthulhu, Death Eaters or any other such “cultists.” To suggest that D&D is an “unwholesome or immoral entertainment” is to call it little better than pornography. The latter has destroyed lives and families, whilst the former has not.

If anyone has any questions about D&D, I shall be happy to answer them, for the ignorance of the game displayed here is profound, indeed. Ask, and we shall come to your aid.

Rant, and we shall roll initiative! :knight2:

Honestly, just ask a veteran gamer who has his dice in one pocket and his Rosary in the other. I’m here to help promote understanding.

Zeal for our spiritual welfare is a blessing, and I shall remember you at Adoration tomorrow.
 
If anyone has any questions about D&D, I shall be happy to answer them, for the ignorance of the game displayed here is profound, indeed. Ask, and we shall come to your aid.
No matter how polite you are with Portrait, he’ll never change his views. I’ve done it. I’ve seen others done it. Nothing’s changed since the first I saw him here. The best you can do is use posts like his as an example of what the standard Fundamentalist Catholic thinks of fantasy in general and not actually respond.
Rant, and we shall roll initiative! :knight2:
puts high stat on Dex

😛
 
No matter how polite you are with Portrait, he’ll never change his views. I’ve done it. I’ve seen others done it. Nothing’s changed since the first I saw him here. The best you can do is use posts like his as an example of what the standard Fundamentalist Catholic thinks of fantasy in general and not actually respond.

puts high stat on Dex

😛
If only he would undrestand that the rejection of the trappings of fantasy tales is not at all Catholic. Where would Tolkien and Lewis be without them?
 
Holy Dark Dungeons, Batman!

theescapist.com/darkdungeons.htm

Has this nonsense started up again?

And why is it always a long-winded boilerplate rant?

I’m a veteran of the first attack on D&D back in the '80s. Since it’s release in 1974, Dungeons & Dragons (or any other RPG, for that matter) has not lead to some rising of Servants of Cthulhu, Death Eaters or any other such “cultists.” To suggest that D&D is an “unwholesome or immoral entertainment” is to call it little better than pornography. The latter has destroyed lives and families, whilst the former has not.

If anyone has any questions about D&D, I shall be happy to answer them, for the ignorance of the game displayed here is profound, indeed. Ask, and we shall come to your aid.

Rant, and we shall roll initiative! :knight2:

Honestly, just ask a veteran gamer who has his dice in one pocket and his Rosary in the other. I’m here to help promote understanding.

Zeal for our spiritual welfare is a blessing, and I shall remember you at Adoration tomorrow.
Question- What happens when you drop your bag of infinite holding in the ocean?😛
 
I grew up in a church that was all about dark dungeons and other chick tracts. Now, personally i don’t see anything wrong with D&D, i’m just terrible at it and since this topic is about D&D i thought i’d share my one and only experience as a player.

After college some co-workers invited me to play. I show up, we order chinese, and they explain to me how to play. The DM is putting the final touches on the campaign, the other players are helping me build a character to jump into their game which has been going on for two plus years. I totally don’t get the alignment system and the DM keeps correcting my action. We get to a dungeon about an hour later, 20 minutes later I ask to try something, water fills the dungeon as a trap due to my actions, everyone fails their saving rolls or whatever, and the whole party wipes. I had killed all their characters, 2 years of adventures, in a single evening. Flawless victory.
 
I grew up in a church that was all about dark dungeons and other chick tracts. Now, personally i don’t see anything wrong with D&D, i’m just terrible at it and since this topic is about D&D i thought i’d share my one and only experience as a player.

After college some co-workers invited me to play. I show up, we order chinese, and they explain to me how to play. The DM is putting the final touches on the campaign, the other players are helping me build a character to jump into their game which has been going on for two plus years. I totally don’t get the alignment system and the DM keeps correcting my action. We get to a dungeon about an hour later, 20 minutes later I ask to try something, water fills the dungeon as a trap due to my actions, everyone fails their saving rolls or whatever, and the whole party wipes. I had killed all their characters, 2 years of adventures, in a single evening. Flawless victory.
A Total Party Kill on your first adventure 👍 You’re an Old School DM’s dream.

I hope you kept playing… though I suspect it may have been with a different group. Just sayin’.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top