D&D (Dungeons and Dragons)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ophelia23
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Question- What happens when you drop your bag of infinite holding in the ocean?šŸ˜›
That, Good Sir, can only be answered at 3:00 AM, following the consumption of prodigious amount of take out food and highly caffienated beverages…

… Right before some Halfling PC answers the question once and for all.
 
We’ve all been there. For me it was, ā€œC’mon guys, let’s try one more door before we head back to town.ā€ :doh2:
 
For me it was ā€œi’m going to poke this with my swordā€ and ā€œis there a lever? I want to hit itā€
 
Question- What happens when you drop your bag of infinite holding in the ocean?šŸ˜›
The ocean will flow into the bag until its surface has lowered to level with the bag’s opening.

But, when you pick up the bag, you won’t be able to seal it (the pressure of the entire ocean inside the bag can’t be held back by the rope tying the bag shut), so the ocean will come back out. Uh-oh!
 
Moreover, it is manifestly obvious that a pious Catholic should not engage in Dungeons and Dragons, or any kind of fantasy, that involves the promotion or neutral use of evil. This would have been readily apparent to former generations of Catholics and it is lamentable that this is not the case today. As with so many other issues, this subject is very much connected with the much broader issue of sanctity and separation from the world and its demoralizing and distracting influences.
I’m trying to understand the specific objections surrounding D&D.

What exactly do you think would happen if D&D became a cultural force? What, we’re all going to be running around casting magic missiles at half-orcs? :confused:
 
If only he would undrestand that the rejection of the trappings of fantasy tales is not at all Catholic. Where would Tolkien and Lewis be without them?
Alas, Portrait has spoken on the matter as well. Although, at that point, you’re in luck. You’ve driven them to the corner that’s full of straws for grasping.

No matter what these types say, when you speak against magic in one particular fantasy universe, you’ll inevitably speak against fantasy as a whole.

Those who deny this are only fooling themselves. It’s sad. Seriously.
Take 2d6 damage. Where’s the Cleric?
Sorry, only a Hellfire Warlock here. Gimme a call when you want something melted. 8P
What exactly do you think would happen if D&D became a cultural force? What, we’re all going to be running around casting magic missiles at half-orcs? :confused:
Oh yeah, that’ll be the life. Heck, seeing as how this thread is also about M:tG as well (Am I the only one who notices they’re both WotC products?), I go beyond that and dream about hopping various magical dimensions. šŸ˜›

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m returning to finish work so I can return to my favorite plane. šŸ˜›
 
I’ve played since 3rd edition came out in 2000, as well as a number of other RPGs.

The best way I’ve hit upon to describe it to folks who have no idea what roleplaying games are is a ā€œcollaborative storytelling exercise.ā€ I describe the role of the DM/GM/Storyteller setting up the world, and how the players help to create stories in that world, one piece of action or politics or the like at a time.

Also, been play-testing the new D&D Next system (skipped right over the unfortunate mishap that was 4th edition) with my crew, and it’s pretty good. If any of ya’ll need a bit of a diversion from your regular games, I’d look up the play-test pages over at Wizards of the Coast and give it a go.
 
Anything like this or asscoiated with the Occult is an invitation for Demons and evil spirits from Satan. Do not participate in these types of games, for they aren’t safe.
 
Anything like this or asscoiated with the Occult is an invitation for Demons and evil spirits from Satan. Do not participate in these types of games, for they aren’t safe.
The 80’s called, they want their misinformation back.
 
Still, 3.x and later editions are clearly heretical, and should be placed on the Index of Forbidden Rulebooks. I advise prayer, fasting and a Remove Curse as soon as possible. šŸ˜‰
We are trying to get together enough people for a 1st Edition game and I want to try to get a West End Games Star Wars campaign going!😃

The only game we play that isn’t out of print is GURPS.šŸ˜›

In response to those decrying D&D as occult and dangerous, I’d like to point out that all you have so far are words. Words are powerful, but action is more powerful still. Look to the lives of the faithful Catholics who are avid gamer’s to prove or disprove your assertions. I’ve made my fair share of mistakes and committed sin aplenty, but I can honestly say that rpg’s have never contributed to those mistakes and poor choices. My choice to return to God and the Church he founded on the other hand, can be directly associated with the relationships I formed through playing rpg’s.

If these games are sinful and evil, and sin is willful separation from God, then how did these games and my willful choice to play them lead me closer to Him?

ā€œWhy do you look at the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, ā€˜Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ and behold, the log is in your own eye? ā€œYou hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye. Matthew 7:3-5
 
Anything like this or asscoiated with the Occult is an invitation for Demons and evil spirits from Satan.
Demons? Sorry, don’t have a need to invite demons right now. For this dungeon raid, I’m only inviting:

White Mages
Black Mages
Summoners
Ninjas
Samurai
Dragoons

… and reads last entry Cannoneers?

turns to party leader What for? o_O

Party Leader: Cuz I’m one stupid. šŸ˜› Now don’t ask again or I’ll stuff you in my cannon next.

But I thought only items can-

Party Leader: Zip it! -.-

Yes ma’am! D8
Do not participate in these types of games, for they aren’t safe.
What are you talking about? Fantasy adventures are perfectly safe!! 8D

nearby wall crashes and little Cleric girl runs out while chased by giant troll

Cleric: Kyaaaaah! Save me!! ToT

Er… excuse me. >_> torches troll with typical flamethrower spell

Now, where was I? ._.

Cleric: Hwaaah… thank you. ^w^ heals

pop-up window opens

You have been invited to join Cleric’s party. Accept?
 
I’m trying to understand the specific objections surrounding D&D.

What exactly do you think would happen if D&D became a cultural force? What, we’re all going to be running around casting magic missiles at half-orcs? :confused:
Don’t be silly. We would cast magic missile against the darkness. šŸ˜‰
 
If you’re right, then it’s sinful to listen to the Odyssey, the Iliad, or the Aeneid; it’s sinful to read any of Shakespeare’s plays; and it’s sinful to watch old western TV shows. Does that even sound logical?
Dear Godfoller,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your response.

What is problematic, dear friend, is that whilst there is no direct connection to occult activities in the real world, there are, nevertheless, disturbing parallels to them. Now because Satan and his forces of evil have deeply invaded man’s social and cultural structures there is a clear and present danger that he will lure people into thinking that occultic practices are innocuous and even fun. Herein lies the danger and the unwholesome nature of Dangeons and Dragons and the inferior Potter tales. They have a tendency to desensitize men to the dangers of the real world of the occult, to say nothing of evoking the baser passions.

Moreover, dear friend, it is not a question of not be able to distinguish fact from fantasy. Dungeons and Dragons is, I freely admit, using ā€˜pretend’ supernatural powers (though not of God I may hasten to add), but the problem is that it all too often becomes an all-encompassing ā€˜reality’ game because it parallels the occult so closely that the lines become blurred. In any event, the use of supernatural powers that do not derive from God are condemned in Sacred Scripture (Deut. 18: 9-14) and therein lies the chief argument against this unwholesome and culturally unhealthy pastime.

Sadly, many devotees of this game, including some professing Catholics, are in denial as to what constitutes sorcery, witchcraft and magic, which is using supernatural powers that are not of divine origin. The defenders of this unsavoury game have been unable to demonstrate that pretending to use such powers is not analogous to the sorcery, witchcraft and magic of the real world. It really does beggar belief that those who are supposed to be engaged in the pursuit of holiness would ever want to befoul their souls with a game of this sort, given its clear and unmistakeable parallels with the real world of the occult. Moreover, dear friend, it is a shameful misuse of time that could be otherwise employed in much more worthier and nobler pursuits. St. Paul exhorts us to give ourselves to ā€œwhatever is true, whatever is honourable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is gracious, if there is anything worthy of praise, think about these thingsā€ (Phillip. 4: 8). Dungeons and Dragons falls woefully short of this, methinks.

As for those old time Westerns, of which I am an enthusiast, they are not even remotely like this Dungeons and Dragons and the vast majority are jolly splendid morality tales.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Anything like this or asscoiated with the Occult is an invitation for Demons and evil spirits from Satan. Do not participate in these types of games, for they aren’t safe.
Dear Escopiliatese,

Cordial greetings and a warm welcome to the world of CAF. Do hope that you find your time here informative and spiritually enriching.

Jolly well said, dear friend, this dreadful game is just too close for comfort to the real world occultic subculture and we ought to give it a wide-berth. You are quite right, these sort of RPG’s are decidedly spiritually unsafe and the Devil could well use them to draw men into the realm of darkness. We are not ignorant of his evil devices.

God bless and thankyou for your (name removed by moderator)ut, dear friend.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
I’m a Traditional Catholic, :highprayer: and I’ve been playing D&D since 1978 - primarily Holmes Basic and AD&D 1st Edition, plus a plethora of non-D&D RPGs of various genres.

This is the favorite Scripture quote of Gary Gygax, creator of D&D:

ā€œSo let your light shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father who is in heaven.ā€ ~ St. Matthew V:16

If anyone is curious about D&D, RPGs in general, or wants to get a game going, just let me know! :knight1:
shakes cane about I remember when elf was a CLASS, dog-gone it!
I’m just stunned that people still play D & D. Rolling dice by hand? How old fashioned!
He see’s me rollin. He hatin.
Question- What happens when you drop your bag of infinite holding in the ocean?šŸ˜›
No such thing as an infinate bag of holding. They only go up to 5,000 pounds. And that’s an epic artifact of epic epicness. Otherwise you’d have people doing things like, well, dropping them into the ocean. Just… don’t use a bag of holding to hold your bags of holding.
 
What is actually disturbing is that, in railing against D&D and other RPGs, detractors such as Portrait would never flinch at repeating falsehoods over and over.

Fact is that there is zero relationship between D&D and occult practices. There are no parallels between D&D and the occult. The only time I have ever heard of D&D being an ā€œall-encompassing ā€˜reality’ gameā€ is in the ridiculous comic Dark Dungeons (a Jack Chick product–and we all know that Jack Chick never lets a little thing like truth stop him from making outrageous claims).

This is an example of an actual game of AD&D (2nd ed with a few 1st ed bits) in play.

Quite frankly, I am FAR more worried about the souls of those who will willfully lie to support a position than I would be about anyone who plays RPGs.
 
Seems adversity has revealed to us a stalwart party of gamers on CAF. It does this old Grognard’s heart good to see our banners still fly. I got my start with Avalon Hill/SPI wargames, then on to Holmes Basic D&D back in '78. I prefer to play Holmes, 1st edition AD&D or a good simulacrum like Adventurer, Conqueror, King System (ACKS). And you can’t be an Old Schooler without playing Traveller! [Sarcasm]No magic, but it does have psionics to imperil my immortal soul.[/Sarcasm]

Our friends Escopiliatese and Portait put me in the mood for some Warhammer 40K. I suspect their protestations conceal heresy…

…So let’s all offer a Saint Michael prayer for them. It will do them good. :highprayer:

By the way, TheDoors is right. Elf is a class!

Oh, and Lost Wanderer, before their were mice, there were dice. Get thee to a tabletop and play a real game! šŸ˜‰

Grognard rant over. :hey_bud:
 
I’m trying to understand the specific objections surrounding D&D.

What exactly do you think would happen if D&D became a cultural force? What, we’re all going to be running around casting magic missiles at half-orcs? :confused:
Dear VeritasLuxMea,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Hope all is well.

The specific problem, dear friend, with this D&D game is that it has a magical world-view, in contrast to a Christian world-view, where magic is a neutral force, something akin to gravity. Your characters learn to use magic to manipulate the universe so as to get what they want. Moreover, people use spells and magical instruments to manipulate the magic toward their desired objective. Essentially the world-view of D&D is anti-Christian and anti-Catholic because it presents to us a universe without a transcendent benevolent God. The deities of this game are mythical, along the lines of the ancient pantheon of the Roman gods and goddesses.

Proponents of the game, dear friend, will never tire of pointing out its ā€˜morality’, but the overall morality is pragmatic at best and amoral at worst. For example, in D&D it is far better to be evil, for one gets more advantage in being evil and it is easier to continue and not have to trouble yourself about what to do and what not to do. Thus if for some reason you decided that you did not trust someone, then you could chop him down from behind as an evil character and there is no penalty for it. Hardly a Christian way of doing things is it?

Whether the debate is Harry Potter or D&D, the objection inevitably arises that this is a make-believe world and pure fiction; fairy-tale magic does not exist in the real world, ā€œcan you not distinguish between fantasy and reality/ā€. Indeed, there is a huge difference between working actual magic and pretend magic and it must be conceded that in some ultra Evangelical literature this is not sufficiently acknowledged. However, the parallels between the two are still, nevertheless, very disturbing from the Christian standpoint and whilst the distinction may well be clear in the minds of players, there is no certainty that they may not open themselves to the realm of darkness. However, whilst the possibility, at least, of contact with the Satanic realm cannot be dismissed as arrant nonesense, my greatest concern is that involvement in this game could create a pre-disposition toward actual occultic activity. Now whether the numbers who would be drawn into the occultic subculture is relatively small or not is really immaterial, for even one precious soul is a grave cause for concern. Even if a man considers himself spiritually strong, it is still an unwholesome world in which to immerse oneself - and possibly a dangerous one.

Frequently people reference the magic in the works of Messers Tolkein and Lewis by way of defence. However, dear friend, that sort of fantasy magic is decidedly different from what we meet with in D&D because the (Christian) world-view of the literature is unapologetically biblical and therefore wholesome, being consistent with the world that God made. Behind all the ā€˜magic’ in those eminent works is a good, transcendent and holy God, which is just what one would expect from these Christian gentlemen. The magic does not have a life and power of its own, as a force to be manipulated. Moreover, the magic in the fantasy works of Messers. Tolkein and Lewis is viewed passively by the reader, whilst in D&D the player is immersed in the story and actively uses occult style magic as a part of the game.

God bless and hope that was of some help, dear friend.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
No matter how polite you are with Portrait, he’ll never change his views. I’ve done it. I’ve seen others done it. Nothing’s changed since the first I saw him here.
Ah yes; good times.

So, 5th edition D&D is in public playtest. Anyone have any comment?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top