Date of Isa's crucifixion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Spirithound
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Spirithound

Guest
Dear Muslim friends, Do you commemorate the date of Isa’s crucifixion?
 
Spirithound said:
Dear Muslim friends, Do you commemorate the date of Isa’s crucifixion?
Click to expand...
Muslims do not believe that it was really Jesus who was crucified. Therefore, they do not recognize His death by crucifixion.
 
Juliebug108 said:
Muslims do not believe that it was really Jesus who was crucified. Therefore, they do not recognize His death by crucifixion.
Click to expand...
Oh! Thank you. I thought that some of them held to the idea that he was put on the cross, but taken down before he died, and then was resuscitated.
 
Some do ; those that have worked out the ridiculousness of the other solutions they try to apply to the denial of Christs death on the Cross. But even Modern day medicine would struggle to ressusitate someone who had incurred on their body what Christ had. 🙂

Why would they bring to mind what the must Ignore; when you think of all the verses in the Quran all Mohammed could offer to deal with the CENTRALITY of Christianity was 1 verse to say it didn’t happen it was just a trick. 😃

ABRACADABRA there guys that sorts the Christ problem now lets get on with the Killing :mad:
 
Spirithound said:
Oh! Thank you. I thought that some of them held to the idea that he was put on the cross, but taken down before he died, and then was resuscitated.
Click to expand...
That they said (in boast), “We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah”;- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not:- … (Al-Qur’an, Surah An-Nisa, Ayat 157)

Although there are a few weak ahadith concerning the subject, generally speaking, if any Muslim wishes to believe in something additional to what is written in the Qur’an regarding what happened to Prophet Jesus (pbuh) during this alleged crucifixion, then he or she would merely be following conjecture.
 
Jesus’/Isa’s crucifixion is not an agreed upon matter in Islam. As hamba’s post shows, the only thing that is agreed upon is that Jesus/Isa did not die on the cross. The rest is all hypothetical, as - to the best of my knowledge - the rest of the Islamic Passion’s details are obscure.

I believe that the two popular opinions are: a) Jesus/Isa was on the cross, but Allah raised him to heaven before he died; and b) it was actually someone else that was crucified who was made to look exactly like Jesus. Muslims like to say that that person was actually Judas. The latter seems to agree more with the verse hamba posted.
 
There were hundreds of witnesses to the event of Jesus’ resurrection. Muhammad was only one person hundreds of years later AFTER the fact. Which sounds more believable? If you take the one witness guy hundreds of years later, you would have a major issue in understanding much of anything in life.
 
hamba2han said:
Although there are a few weak ahadith concerning the subject, generally speaking, if any Muslim wishes to believe in something additional to what is written in the Qur’an regarding what happened to Prophet Jesus (pbuh) during this alleged crucifixion, then he or she would merely be following conjecture.
Click to expand...
Amir_the_Masihi said:
Jesus’/Isa’s crucifixion is not an agreed upon matter in Islam. As hamba’s post shows, the only thing that is agreed upon is that Jesus/Isa did not die on the cross. The rest is all hypothetical, as - to the best of my knowledge - the rest of the Islamic Passion’s details are obscure.
Click to expand...
Thank you both. I was recently contemplating the question “What is ‘today’?” and I considered how Christianity and Judaism use similar methods to determine the date of Easter and Passover, respectively, and I was wondering whether Islam also commemorates an event that would have been, at least originally, tied to these first two, and whether you would calculate that date in a similar kind of lunar-solar hybrid calendar, or on Islam’s purely lunar calendar.
 
Juliebug108 said:
Muslims do not believe that it was really Jesus who was crucified. Therefore, they do not recognize His death by crucifixion.
Click to expand...
In the Thread of “Who is Isa in Quran”, we have demonstrated the false logic behind the Muslim’s idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top