Dating and a return to virtue

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Doesn’t change the fact that they’re just as much the highlights of the Bible as in many cases of fiction.

And why are you even persisting here? My point is you’re just as guilty of raising expectations as the romanticizers.

The only thing you’re right about is that I do believe I’m due a lotta things. Not only that, I’m bent on taking it. The best part is that there’s nothing you can do because you were never in any position to tell me what I do or don’t deserve. You don’t even know me personally enough to even make that assumption.

Does it matter? Four wives is four wives. I know plenty engaged in hookups who certainly wouldn’t complain as much as Jacob.:rolleyes:

I’m sure I’d have a successful love life as well. :rolleyes:

But again, you are clearly pretending there’s no elephant in the room.
I guess we’re just on very different wavelengths.
 
I guess we’re just on very different wavelengths.
Can we go back to the dating thing? For some reason I’m pretty sure that edwest2’s model isn’t the only way to find a marriage partner, and it might not even be the best way (certainly it’s not the best for every person). I’m sure it’s got flaws.
40.png
edwest2:
  1. First dates are for fun and not much more. You go out with a few people to get a sense of what dating’s like.
  2. Sometimes, each person wants to go on more dates, which means there is not just a physical attraction but an “I like to be with this person because he’s fun and treats me nice.”
These first two steps presuppose that there was physical attraction first, then the first date, and then the sense of “oh hey this person is actually pretty cool”. It presupposes that the relationship is first and foremost a romantic one, that the person has always been an object of romantic interest, and that the two people have not gotten to know each other much at all in any other setting.

Now, I’m no expert. I’ve never even been on a one-on-one date “with a person of legitimate romantic interest”, as the article says. But I’ve been to my fair share of group activities, and I really don’t see what’s so awful about hanging out with people in a group of friends first. If we’re focusing on virtue, group settings (provided the group takes purity somewhat seriously) act as a kind of buffer to keep things from getting too serious too fast. Group settings allow you to get to know people a little bit before declaring romantic interest- maybe even before you have romantic interest.

Your model is also iffy, just in terms of applying it, for people like me. If I waited to have “physical attraction” before interacting with someone, I would never have any male friends. I certainly wouldn’t be going on any dates (not that that happens anyway). 😛
  1. Going steady means “I want to get to know you better. I want you to be my friend.” This must involve being open and honest, which results in earning each other’s trust and respect."
Again, this presupposes that physical attraction was the only reason that both parties went on the initial date, and that they are not any level of friends until they decide to go steady. That’s just… Odd. I can’t imagine entering an official relationship with someone I didn’t already know to an extent. Given that my interest in people is largely fueled by their personalities and interests, I can’t imagine waiting 4+ dates before I decided that I wanted to be friends. More likely “I want to be friends” is a prerequisite for spending free time with someone at all, and a “date” would mean that I am also open to the possibility of romance.

I mean, again, there’s nothing wrong with your model, if the person in question is physically attracted to many people and sees attraction as a good enough reason to spend an hour or two with someone. But if you get someone who legitimately notices people based on personality, the model breaks down. Maybe liking people’s personalities is a symptom of modern moral decay, but I really don’t see how.
  1. If marriage gets brought up, the relationship enters the courtship phase. You must meet each other’s parents and get to know them too. The apple doesn’t fall too far from the tree.
  1. You do other, non-dating things together. Things you both like to do and things that only the other person likes to do. The only reason I went to a play was because my girlfriend was interested, and we both enjoyed it.
No objections in principle, although I’m pretty sure going to a play counts (or can count) as a date. And again, I’m not sure why you would wait to do non-dating things together until after you’re seriously courting someone.
  1. If you find you trust, respect and feel respected by the other person, an engagement may occur. It should last at least one year and should involve parents on both sides. You talk about your plans for the future and how you are going to achieve them.
No objections to this part at all (although given my lack of available parents, I expect it would be difficult in practice). But no, planning is good. And a one-year engagement is good. What I disagree about is how to get to that point.

Don’t misunderstand, your plan sounds great for a certain type of person. In your plan, basically what happens is that people will slowly get to know each other in the safe environment of dating. Then, they start by confirming physical attraction, then “fun” (a sense of humor? A shallow understanding of personality?), and finally they decide that someone would be a good friend. Then they enter a relationship. But it isn’t until the two parties are seriously thinking about marriage that they do “non-dating” things together, and seriously become a part of each other’s lives. Until then, apparently, all of their interaction takes place during dates. They have to accept a low-level commit first, and then get to know someone.
 
The model I’m more familiar with is a bit different, and I acknowledge the possibility that some of those differences have something to do with this new “hook-up culture.” Basically, you have a certain amount of experience with a person before formalizing your relationship. This has the advantage of lessening the amount of “serial monogamy”, as Naskor put it. You don’t make a commitment (on any level) until you know that there’s someone there that you want to commit to.

So I guess my model would be more like this:
  1. Do things with friends. Because you have moral, responsible, interesting friends, their friends will also tend to be moral, responsible, and interesting. That way, you can be introduced to people who are more likely to be of interest to you, either as additional friends or as romantic interests.
  2. Once you already know many of these people and have confirmed that they are both interesting and moral, you may find that you have some level of romantic interest in one of them. Ask this person on a date. If they are interested, awesome. You go on an official date and have fun, because fun is awesome. And having fun should be pretty easy, because you already know this person somewhat.
  3. Once you have gone on a date, you determine whether you are still interested in them. Maybe you tried it and it didn’t work, and that’s OK. Let the person know whether you would like to go on more dates.
  4. If you do decide to go on more dates (it may only take a few, because you are also interacting with them outside of dates), and those dates are also good, you will probably decide to formalize the relationship and make things some level of official. At this point, romantic exclusivity is a given (note that it was probably a given back when you went on the second date, but now going on a date with anyone else would definitely be cheating). Note that you are already good friends with the person, have confirmed that they are interesting and awesome, and the dates have allowed you to confirm your romantic interest.
  5. Now that you’re in a relationship, there isn’t so much an addition of friendship as there is an addition of seriousness. Both the friendship and the romance gain depth after this point. You really get to know someone, in both dating and non-dating activities. While in a relationship, you discern whether or not this person is a possible marriage partner, while getting to know them better and better. If you have parents, you introduce your girl/boyfriend to them. If not, you introduce them to close friends, so that you can get second opinions from somewhere, and so that other people can make sure that you have thought about things in practical terms.
  6. Hooray, you have been in an official relationship for at least a year or so, you have weighed the pros and cons of being with this person, you know them well both as a friend and a romantic partner, you have talked about the future and other serious things, you have a healthy relationship based on mutual trust and respect, and you are sure that this is the person you want to spend your life with. Somebody asks “will you marry me”, the engagement commences, you take a pre-cana class and think seriously about what is to come. Then you get married. Congrats.
The main difference between these models is that in mine, you’ve already gotten to know people quite a bit before the first official “date”, and the official courtship phase is really the same thing as “going steady”. You do more things with people sooner, before making a commitment (even if that commitment is as low-level as entering a dating relationship). Naturally, there are pros and cons to this.

Pros:
-Fewer breakup experiences, since you get to know people before committing. Breakups aren’t the end of the world or anything, but hey, better to avoid breaking a commitment if possible, right?
-Don’t have to be alone with people you barely know, which is a plus in terms of social ease and in terms of safety.
-You have other people involved from the beginning, and those people can help you think about the practical concerns of a relationship with someone.
-Not expected to make a commitment until you have enough information to go on.

Cons:
-Have to get to know people before asking them on dates.
-Less structure than edwest2’s model; at the beginning, it’s difficult to box someone away as either a friends or a romantic interest, since they could easily revert to being a friend again.
-Chance of losing numerous friends if the dating thing doesn’t go well. This is real risk, and is the risk you take on for having a lessened chance of late-relationship breakups. Although you’ll have fewer breakups, the ones you do have can potentially be more damaging, since you’re already good friends with someone.

It’s mainly that last one that convinces me that the this model also isn’t the only way. But it’s a way, and I really don’t see anything objectively wrong with it.

It does, in some ways, resemble the hook-up culture’s idea of sex without commitment. The difference is that this model isn’t for when to have sex, but for when to get to know someone. I don’t see why it’s necessary, or even helpful, to go on a string of official dates with someone you barely know, when you could easily get to know more people in a group setting with zero commitment and zero hurt feelings. And you get to go do lots of things with a group of people that you are all but guaranteed to like.

I guess like the other people on this thread, I’m a little skeptical that this fifties-style dating of lots and lots of people is the best or only possible foundation for a moral relationship. 🤷
 
Don’t misunderstand, your plan sounds great for a certain type of person. In your plan, basically what happens is that people will slowly get to know each other in the safe environment of dating. Then, they start by confirming physical attraction, then “fun” (a sense of humor? A shallow understanding of personality?), and finally they decide that someone would be a good friend. Then they enter a relationship. But it isn’t until the two parties are seriously thinking about marriage that they do “non-dating” things together, and seriously become a part of each other’s lives. Until then, apparently, all of their interaction takes place during dates. They have to accept a low-level commit first, and then get to know someone.
Unfortunately, this kind of going slow has actually backfired on me and I can vouch, from my own, painful, personal experience that the consequences aren’t just something the ‘counter-culture’ should avoid accountability for.

Alas, instead of that, they opt for the very path that created the culture of hookups: treating partners like countless fish to be snagged, gradually diminishing the very idea of commitment. (It sure does for me at least and I’ll be most dishonest with myself if anyone says I should persist otherwise. Heck, even I could, why would I persist for an ideal that I only have absolute contempt for?)

What’s worse is when, on the rare occasion, someone is bold enough to reject the rejection, to supplant and break the will of another, they implore and beg the disappointed/disillusioned party to reconsider even as they spawn the very hyper-sexual culture they seek to oppose.

Both sides say there’s a war. I find it ridiculous that there are even two sides at all. All I see is a jester’s ouroboros.
 
Unfortunately, this kind of going slow has actually backfired on me and I can vouch, from my own, painful, personal experience that the consequences aren’t just something the ‘counter-culture’ should avoid accountability for.

Alas, instead of that, they opt for the very path that created the culture of hookups: treating partners like countless fish to be snagged, gradually diminishing the very idea of commitment. (It sure does for me at least and I’ll be most dishonest with myself if anyone says I should persist otherwise. Heck, even I could, why would I persist for an ideal that I only have absolute contempt for?)

What’s worse is when, on the rare occasion, someone is bold enough to reject the rejection, to supplant and break the will of another, they implore and beg the disappointed/disillusioned party to reconsider even as they spawn the very hyper-sexual culture they seek to oppose.

Both sides say there’s a war. I find it ridiculous that there are even two sides at all. All I see is a jester’s ouroboros.
I’m kind of confused. I was describing my understanding of edwest2’s plan. I think it can work, but it’s not something I’d be comfortable using myself. I’d rather narrow the field before committing to anyone, because why commit to someone you barely know? Commitment, on any level, out to mean something.

I’m kind of a ridiculously idealistic “friendship!!!” type, though, and I wouldn’t be particularly disappointed if I just ended up with lots of cool friends. So my ideas might not be very useful, either. 😛
 
I guess what bothers me is this idea of commitment before any commitment has actually been made. It sorta-kinda worked in the 1950s because there was a very real chance of pregnancy and so the sexual side of dating was dealt with differently by the two involved and by society in general.

But this is no longer the case, so the sexual side is a problem, along with the fact that the appropriate age at which to marry keeps being put off to older ages.

Biu the commitment aspect is also a problem; in fact, I think the main problem. Why are people “committing” themselves to what is in actuality a sort of test or audition? T’s like working full-time or more for an extended period of time “on spec,” if at the end they like what you’ve produced, they’ll accept it and pay for it; if they don’t like like it, they’ll toss the work back to you.

Working on spec can work when a freelance artist of some sort and potential client are first working together, but in that case the commitment is not total or long-lasting. With dating, the commitment is both total and potentially long-lasting.

So, what is “going steady” a commitment *to? *All it means is that neither shall look upon another until end of pleasure doth them part… or someone with more immediate sex appeal.
There is *no actual commitment. *One will always be more committed than the other, for one thing. One will always be less pleased or have a more rovng eye.

When people get engaged, one does not ask the other to "get engaged; one asks the other *to marry him (or her),.*Engagement is the period of *planning a true commitment, *the ceremony of course, but also how to handle finances, disagreements, children, etc. During this period, which should be a serious period focused on the important aspects of marriage, is when “irreconcilable differences” should come up, not *after *the marriage occurs.

To me, there are a lot of other aspects of dating which render it a bad way of chosing a spouse, most of which are related to this idea of “making a commitment” to nothing at all.
 
So, what is “going steady” a commitment to? All it means is that neither shall look upon another until end of pleasure doth them part… or someone with more immediate sex appeal.
Basically. I mean, really, it can end at any time. I guess it’s more structured than just hanging out with someone. Both parties feel like there are a bunch of rules that they’re possibly supposed to follow, and aren’t really sure what they all are.

Whereas with friendship, which is supposed to be based on mutual enjoyment and very low levels of commitment, you get double the knowledge about people and half the stress. If you decide you’re not interested in them romantically, you’ve still got a friend. Hooray for friendship.
To me, there are a lot of other aspects of dating which render it a bad way of chosing a spouse, most of which are related to this idea of “making a commitment” to nothing at all.
So what’s the alternative? We could revert to even older models, but the only ones I know of are courting and arranged marriage, and both of those sound like they’re not very useful for getting to know people. Or we could embrace the trend of young people hanging out in groups, as friends, and stop attacking that as a sign of moral decay. Those models (or combinations of them) are the only ones I can think of off the top of my head. 🤷
 
The model I’m more familiar with is a bit different, and I acknowledge the possibility that some of those differences have something to do with this new “hook-up culture.” Basically, you have a certain amount of experience with a person before formalizing your relationship. This has the advantage of lessening the amount of “serial monogamy”, as Naskor put it. You don’t make a commitment (on any level) until you know that there’s someone there that you want to commit to.
I know you’ve said that you haven’t actually gotten to try your “model”, but many of my friends did something similar to what you’re describing and it’s working great for them. They were friends first and then later developed romantic desire and formed relationships. Of course this upset a few other friends, they were hard set on dating like Ms. Cronin described. Well, they’re still single 🤷.

I can give an example with 2 friends.

One of my friends (friend A) was very attractive, both physically and her lively personality. She had strong Christian values, and wanted, no demanded that she would enter a relationship “traditional American style”, she wanted a story of meeting “the one”, love at first sight, and a fellow Christian. All very much like the rom-coms and romantic novels she was very much into. This also meant she had a personal rule against dating anyone with her social circle, no friends, no friends of friends, and not allowing her to be set-up because she wanted her story. In high school she didn’t find anyone because everyone in school who shared her same Christian world views and interests were already her friend. She even changed schools so she could try to be “the new girl” there. She transferred back after a few weeks because she didn’t meet anyone. In college she kept up demand and didn’t find anyone either and is still single.

An other friend (friend B) did it opposite friend A, and is still in that relationship :). She had a lot going against her too compared to friend A, overweight, a single mom, and all in high school. All that would make most 1950s kind of guys avoid her like she was a leper! But she let romance grow out of friendship and got herself and amazing boyfriend whom many would think “he’s out of her league”. It’s not just similar interests these two have but the same lifelong goals and desires.

Many other friends dated like her, that is within our circle of friends, and it didn’t cause “drama” or “go wrong” like much media and rumors tell us it does. Most of the breakups (actually I remember one that wasn’t) from relationships formed like this were mutual. How often do you ever see break-ups in the media that were just because the people decided that they were different people with different goals.
 
Basically. I mean, really, it can end at any time. I guess it’s more structured than just hanging out with someone. Both parties feel like there are a bunch of rules that they’re possibly supposed to follow, and aren’t really sure what they all are.

Whereas with friendship, which is supposed to be based on mutual enjoyment and very low levels of commitment, you get double the knowledge about people and half the stress. If you decide you’re not interested in them romantically, you’ve still got a friend. Hooray for friendship.
I don’t understand your objection to “going steady,” as it seems to me #4 in your list is “going steady.”

I guess what you’re saying is you want to be friends with someone before you “go steady”?

My experience with my wife was a bit strange in that it seemed to skirt the line between ed’s ideas and your own. I was technically a stranger to my wife before I first asked her on a date. But, four of her cousins were close friends to me, and we sorta ran on opposite ends of the same social circle. In other words, we had never met, but we were part of the same social group. So in that sense, we were strangers that came pre-loaded with lots of insights and presumptions about each other.
 
I know you’ve said that you haven’t actually gotten to try your “model”, but many of my friends did something similar to what you’re describing and it’s working great for them. They were friends first and then later developed romantic desire and formed relationships. Of course this upset a few other friends, they were hard set on dating like Ms. Cronin described. Well, they’re still single 🤷.

I can give an example with 2 friends.

One of my friends (friend A) was very attractive, both physically and her lively personality. She had strong Christian values, and wanted, no demanded that she would enter a relationship “traditional American style”, she wanted a story of meeting “the one”, love at first sight, and a fellow Christian. All very much like the rom-coms and romantic novels she was very much into. This also meant she had a personal rule against dating anyone with her social circle, no friends, no friends of friends, and not allowing her to be set-up because she wanted her story. In high school she didn’t find anyone because everyone in school who shared her same Christian world views and interests were already her friend. She even changed schools so she could try to be “the new girl” there. She transferred back after a few weeks because she didn’t meet anyone. In college she kept up demand and didn’t find anyone either and is still single.

An other friend (friend B) did it opposite friend A, and is still in that relationship :). She had a lot going against her too compared to friend A, overweight, a single mom, and all in high school. All that would make most 1950s kind of guys avoid her like she was a leper! But she let romance grow out of friendship and got herself and amazing boyfriend whom many would think “he’s out of her league”. It’s not just similar interests these two have but the same lifelong goals and desires.

Many other friends dated like her, that is within our circle of friends, and it didn’t cause “drama” or “go wrong” like much media and rumors tell us it does. Most of the breakups (actually I remember one that wasn’t) from relationships formed like this were mutual. How often do you ever see break-ups in the media that were just because the people decided that they were different people with different goals.
I like Friend B 🙂 and the idea of having a group of friends… it seems like in a way that would actually make it easier to go out one-on-one with someone you know pretty well bit not end up in a “steady” relationship–if they went on dates sometimes but the rest of the time were hanging out with their friends?

One thing about the group of friends is they often tend to have “bull sessions,” where they can discuss in a very general atmosphere their ideas and goals. I think it would be easier to explore and be challenged in one’s ideas if it occurred in a group where everyone was talking, because in a datng situation people will often be more interested in pleasing the other person than in the actual discussion.
 
I’m kind of a ridiculously idealistic “friendship!!!” type, though, and I wouldn’t be particularly disappointed if I just ended up with lots of cool friends. So my ideas might not be very useful, either. 😛
At least you don’t fault those who opt for a second opinion and mark them as enemies of a perceived ‘culture war.’

And speaking of which, it doesn’t help when the dating culture varies between nations (yes, even in this globalized age). Where I am, going slow is only an excuse to hypocritically ‘secure territory’ and those who try to do the same with the same party are cast as villains. There’s no real testing to begin with when your biggest competition wasn’t even given a chance to enter the bloody contest!

It’s why I prefer to keep it simple. What I want, I take. It’s a view I have adopted in not just dating, but in the wholeness of my life.

I certainly don’t advocate this for anyone else. But just as there are those who work best with love-at-first-sight, BFF love, or even casual flings, there are also those who are better off ordering the public beheading of their foes ala Dragon Emperor while gaining affections via mildly induced Stockholm syndrome.
 
I know you’ve said that you haven’t actually gotten to try your “model”, but many of my friends did something similar to what you’re describing and it’s working great for them. They were friends first and then later developed romantic desire and formed relationships. Of course this upset a few other friends, they were hard set on dating like Ms. Cronin described. Well, they’re still single 🤷.

I can give an example with 2 friends.

One of my friends (friend A) was very attractive, both physically and her lively personality. She had strong Christian values, and wanted, no demanded that she would enter a relationship “traditional American style”, she wanted a story of meeting “the one”, love at first sight, and a fellow Christian. All very much like the rom-coms and romantic novels she was very much into. This also meant she had a personal rule against dating anyone with her social circle, no friends, no friends of friends, and not allowing her to be set-up because she wanted her story. In high school she didn’t find anyone because everyone in school who shared her same Christian world views and interests were already her friend. She even changed schools so she could try to be “the new girl” there. She transferred back after a few weeks because she didn’t meet anyone. In college she kept up demand and didn’t find anyone either and is still single.

An other friend (friend B) did it opposite friend A, and is still in that relationship :). She had a lot going against her too compared to friend A, overweight, a single mom, and all in high school. All that would make most 1950s kind of guys avoid her like she was a leper! But she let romance grow out of friendship and got herself and amazing boyfriend whom many would think “he’s out of her league”. It’s not just similar interests these two have but the same lifelong goals and desires.

Many other friends dated like her, that is within our circle of friends, and it didn’t cause “drama” or “go wrong” like much media and rumors tell us it does. Most of the breakups (actually I remember one that wasn’t) from relationships formed like this were mutual. How often do you ever see break-ups in the media that were just because the people decided that they were different people with different goals.
I can only hope that things go that well for me! Yes, that’s what I’m talking about. Currently I’ve just got lots of friends, which is a fine state of being for now. 🙂
I don’t understand your objection to “going steady,” as it seems to me #4 in your list is “going steady.”

I guess what you’re saying is you want to be friends with someone before you “go steady”?
Basically. I’m not opposed to “going steady” per se, I’m opposed to going steady with someone I’ve only interacted with in a dating environment. If I’m going to enter a relationship, I want to know someone well enough beforehand that the period of “going steady” also serves as a period of serious discernment. My plan is to get to know people first, before introducing the possibility of romance.

But again, that’s just me. I find it a lot easier to interact with friends, and I don’t think I’ll be disappointed with relationships that never progress past that. The idea of entering a relationship (or even going on a date) with someone I don’t really know is pretty unappealing. If it works for other people, that’s great- I just don’t think it’s the only way, or the best way for me. I don’t want to equate “a return to virtue” with a certain mode of dating.
My experience with my wife was a bit strange in that it seemed to skirt the line between ed’s ideas and your own. I was technically a stranger to my wife before I first asked her on a date. But, four of her cousins were close friends to me, and we sorta ran on opposite ends of the same social circle. In other words, we had never met, but we were part of the same social group. So in that sense, we were strangers that came pre-loaded with lots of insights and presumptions about each other.
That seems like a good way of doing things, too. As long as your method is both effective and moral, that’s great. I don’t think it’s wise to plan these things exactly, anyway.
 
At least you don’t fault those who opt for a second opinion and mark them as enemies of a perceived ‘culture war.’
Sure. I don’t think edwest2’s plan is evil, or even that it’s particularly misguided. I just don’t think it’s the only way to do things, or the best way for any given person.
And speaking of which, it doesn’t help when the dating culture varies between nations (yes, even in this globalized age). Where I am, going slow is only an excuse to hypocritically ‘secure territory’ and those who try to do the same with the same party are cast as villains. There’s no real testing to begin with when your biggest competition wasn’t even given a chance to enter the bloody contest!
It’s why I prefer to keep it simple. What I want, I take. I certainly don’t advocate this for anyone else. But just as there are those who work best with love-at-first-sight, BFF love, or even casual flings, there are also those who are better off ordering the public beheading of their foes ala Dragon Emperor while gaining affections via mildly induced Stockholm syndrome.
You know, I can never tell how much of your relationship advice is a joke. :eek: But if whatever you’re describing is both effective and moral (and I have no idea whether that’s the case, given the intensity of that metaphor), then more power to you. I will be over here, probably analyzing Star Trek and playing D&D with anyone and everyone, enjoying myself immensely. 😛
 
You know, I can never tell how much of your relationship advice is a joke. :eek: But if whatever you’re describing is both effective and moral (and I have no idea whether that’s the case, given the intensity of that metaphor), then more power to you. I will be over here, probably analyzing Star Trek and playing D&D with anyone and everyone, enjoying myself immensely. 😛
The thing with metaphors is that it’s more of the idea behind them really than the actual words. 😉 Some people just become their best (including being the best partner) when they value themselves above all else. And at times, that requires standing up even against those whose affections you wish to win over. Sometimes you shouldn’t be afraid to be the real monster.

Besides, I’m actually quite glad there are those who don’t feel called to my more aggressive take on this subject. I’ll have less competition that way. :cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top