I guess we’re just on very different wavelengths.
Can we go back to the dating thing? For some reason I’m pretty sure that edwest2’s model isn’t the only way to find a marriage partner, and it might not even be the best way (certainly it’s not the best for every person). I’m sure it’s got flaws.
edwest2:
- First dates are for fun and not much more. You go out with a few people to get a sense of what dating’s like.
- Sometimes, each person wants to go on more dates, which means there is not just a physical attraction but an “I like to be with this person because he’s fun and treats me nice.”
These first two steps presuppose that there was physical attraction first, then the first date, and
then the sense of “oh hey this person is actually pretty cool”. It presupposes that the relationship is first and foremost a romantic one, that the person has always been an object of romantic interest, and that the two people have not gotten to know each other much at all in any other setting.
Now, I’m no expert. I’ve never even been on a one-on-one date “with a person of legitimate romantic interest”, as the article says. But I’ve been to my fair share of group activities, and I really don’t see what’s so awful about hanging out with people in a group of friends first. If we’re focusing on virtue, group settings (provided the group takes purity somewhat seriously) act as a kind of buffer to keep things from getting too serious too fast. Group settings allow you to get to know people a little bit before declaring romantic interest- maybe even before you
have romantic interest.
Your model is also iffy, just in terms of applying it, for people like me. If I waited to have “physical attraction” before interacting with someone, I would never have any male friends. I certainly wouldn’t be going on any dates (not that that happens anyway).
- Going steady means “I want to get to know you better. I want you to be my friend.” This must involve being open and honest, which results in earning each other’s trust and respect."
Again, this presupposes that physical attraction was the
only reason that both parties went on the initial date, and that they are not any level of friends until they decide to go steady. That’s just… Odd. I can’t imagine entering an official relationship with someone I didn’t already know to an extent. Given that my interest in people is largely fueled by their personalities and interests, I can’t imagine waiting 4+ dates before I decided that I wanted to be friends. More likely “I want to be friends” is a prerequisite for spending free time with someone at all, and a “date” would mean that I am
also open to the possibility of romance.
I mean, again, there’s nothing
wrong with your model, if the person in question is physically attracted to many people and sees attraction as a good enough reason to spend an hour or two with someone. But if you get someone who legitimately notices people based on personality, the model breaks down. Maybe liking people’s personalities is a symptom of modern moral decay, but I really don’t see how.
- If marriage gets brought up, the relationship enters the courtship phase. You must meet each other’s parents and get to know them too. The apple doesn’t fall too far from the tree.
- You do other, non-dating things together. Things you both like to do and things that only the other person likes to do. The only reason I went to a play was because my girlfriend was interested, and we both enjoyed it.
No objections in principle, although I’m pretty sure going to a play counts (or can count) as a date. And again, I’m not sure why you would wait to do non-dating things together until
after you’re seriously courting someone.
- If you find you trust, respect and feel respected by the other person, an engagement may occur. It should last at least one year and should involve parents on both sides. You talk about your plans for the future and how you are going to achieve them.
No objections to this part at all (although given my lack of available parents, I expect it would be difficult in practice). But no, planning is good. And a one-year engagement is good. What I disagree about is how to get to that point.
Don’t misunderstand, your plan sounds great for a certain type of person. In your plan, basically what happens is that people will slowly get to know each other in the safe environment of dating. Then, they start by confirming physical attraction, then “fun” (a sense of humor? A shallow understanding of personality?), and finally they decide that someone would be a good friend. Then they enter a relationship. But it isn’t until the two parties are seriously thinking about marriage that they do “non-dating” things together, and seriously become a part of each other’s lives. Until then, apparently, all of their interaction takes place during dates. They have to accept a low-level commit first, and then get to know someone.