Dating Catholic women

  • Thread starter Thread starter 900MHZ
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You can help who you fall in love with. Falling in love is a choice. It is not a passive thing.

It is not wise to choose to fall in love with and commit to someone who is going to compromise you living your faith.

BTDT
And also, don’t buy into the “there’s one special person for me” bit. You find a special person and pursue them. You can know you will marry them on your second “date” but there’s always someone else if that doesn’t work out.

At least, until you get married. Then there’s nobody else, at that point, they ARE the special someone 🙂
 
Myself, being Catholic, my first choice is to marry a Catholic convert like myself, my 2nd choice to marry a cradle Catholic, my 3rd choice to marry a woman who converts before we wed.
What about Christian women? I guess if the catholic church is the one and only church, then your Christian wife would not be with you in heaven, so stick with catholic?
 
What about Christian women? I guess if the catholic church is the one and only church, then your Christian wife would not be with you in heaven, so stick with catholic?
Non-Catholic Christians can still go to heaven. Catholic women ARE Christian women. The issue here is choosing a spouse who shares our Catholic faith. Sadly, our separated non-Catholic Christian brothers and sisters do not share our complete faith. But we look forward to the day when they are united with the Catholic Church.

Sincerely,

Maria1212
 
Oh yeah, and improve your girl-getting techniques…but that’s a different thread. You need to make yourself irresistible.
Oh yes, but still remember to be yourself. It’s fine to learn how to establish contact, how to be interesting and all, but it makes absolutely no point convincing girls that you’re something different from what you are. They will find out, it will just take longer before you get dumped. This is why I say manners fine, great even. Gym fine, sure. Nice clothes, great. Learning languages, finding hobbies, great. Overdoing on the confidence/mystery/humour thing women seem to love - not fine. If a relationship is based on something like that, it will last only so long as the base does. So… learn things but don’t pretend anything, I say. They only thing you can pretend is that you aren’t cold when you’ve given her your jacket. 😛 😃
Thanks Reformed Rob. I think the Catholic definiton of chastity and practicing natural family planning (while not using artificial birth control) are things that a non-Catholic person might view as a burden, and that could lead to them resenting the Catholic person and vice versa. I think these are hard teachings for many Catholics to follow as it is, and I don`t want the teachings of the Church to become a burden that my spouse would resent me for.
Sorry to chime into your exchange, but I’ve got to say I agree completely. And I’ve had some first hand experience with that (not marriage yet, but sort of planning the future).
 
And also, don’t buy into the “there’s one special person for me” bit. You find a special person and pursue them. You can know you will marry them on your second “date” but there’s always someone else if that doesn’t work out.

At least, until you get married. Then there’s nobody else, at that point, they ARE the special someone 🙂
Pretty much exactly…
 
What about Christian women? I guess if the catholic church is the one and only church, then your Christian wife would not be with you in heaven, so stick with catholic?
.
Hi Unknown,

I don’t know exactly what you are getting at. For me, it’s more about God’s will being done on earth as it is in heaven.
 
And also, don’t buy into the “there’s one special person for me” bit. You find a special person and pursue them. You can know you will marry them on your second “date” but there’s always someone else if that doesn’t work out.

At least, until you get married. Then there’s nobody else, at that point, they ARE the special someone 🙂
Wise words, Rob. Very wise words.
 
Unlike the majority of the responses in this thread, I thank God he brought me a Catholic woman who, although very concerned with my lack of religious conviction at the time, decided to marry me nonetheless. One of the really strange things many years ago, I knew without a shadow of a doubt from the very first time I met her, that she would be my wife. (She didn’t realize this 🙂 ). We dated several years before marrying.

Her faith, and my lack of, never presented any major issues for 19 years of marriage. We had agreed beforehand to raise our children Catholic with traditional Catholic values. I occasionally attended Mass with my family not for a personal need or want, but only to support my wife in her Christian ideology, and my children’s development, growth, and formation.

Funny thing happened little over a year ago. For reasons that really did not involve my wife or family, I joined RCIA and converted. As a trusted and admired Deacon told me before I enrolled in RCIA, “the Holy Spirit works within each of us in different ways and at different times. She is calling you now”.

How true.

My conversion has only strengthened our bonds and has brought new platitudes in our marriage and family I never could have previously imagined.

So personally, I’ve been blessed that my Catholic wife didn’t have a ‘Catholic husband’ high on her list of qualifying traits in a husband.
 
Unlike the majority of the responses in this thread, I thank God he brought me a Catholic woman who, although very concerned with my lack of religious conviction at the time, decided to marry me nonetheless. One of the really strange things many years ago, I knew without a shadow of a doubt from the very first time I met her, that she would be my wife. (She didn’t realize this 🙂 ). We dated several years before marrying.

Her faith, and my lack of, never presented any major issues for 19 years of marriage. We had agreed beforehand to raise our children Catholic with traditional Catholic values. I occasionally attended Mass with my family not for a personal need or want, but only to support my wife in her Christian ideology, and my children’s development, growth, and formation.

Funny thing happened little over a year ago. For reasons that really did not involve my wife or family, I joined RCIA and converted. As a trusted and admired Deacon told me before I enrolled in RCIA, “the Holy Spirit works within each of us in different ways and at different times. She is calling you now”.

How true.

My conversion has only strengthened our bonds and has brought new platitudes in our marriage and family I never could have previously imagined.

So personally, I’ve been blessed that my Catholic wife didn’t have a ‘Catholic husband’ high on her list of qualifying traits in a husband.
Don’t you sort of wish you had been Catholic all along through out your marriage?
 
Don’t you sort of wish you had been Catholic all along through out your marriage?
Each one of us has his/her own faith journey. Only when the time is right. Give the Holy Spirit time to work within us.
 
Umm… I don’t want to be unkind, but the Holy Spirit isn’t really female.
 
Each one of us has his/her own faith journey. Only when the time is right. Give the Holy Spirit time to work within us.
I’m a convert too. I just wish I knew all that I know now as a Catholic when I was considering marriage…and knowing what I know now, both as a Catholic and as someone who has been through a divorce, I think the best advice for someone who is Catholic and looking for a marriage partner is to keep your faith your priority.

Yes, you can make plenty of mistakes and still come out right in the end, but there is no reason to make those mistakes if you can avoid them.

I’m just saying wouldn’t it be nice to have a spouse who attends Mass regularly with you from the beginning, who shares your faith, and who models it for your children. Isn’t it nice for children to grow up with that security and guidance? What reason is there to choose something less than that?
 
Don’t you sort of wish you had been Catholic all along through out your marriage?
Good & fair question, but isn’t that like asking a blind man, blind from birth, what he misses about not being able to see?

Yes, my conversion has strengthened our relationship & marriage. But I, and I imagine many converts, smack our head in true Homer Simpson style and say “Duh, what took me so long”.
 
Good & fair question, but isn’t that like asking a blind man, blind from birth, what he misses about not being able to see?

Yes, my conversion has strengthened our relationship & marriage. But I, and I imagine many converts, smack our head in true Homer Simpson style and say “Duh, what took me so long”.
I’m definitely one who is doing that myself. 🙂
 
One of the really strange things many years ago, I knew without a shadow of a doubt from the very first time I met her, that she would be my wife. (She didn’t realize this 🙂 ). We dated several years before marrying.
That reminds me of an awesome story about how a guy proposed to his girlfriend.

He is somewhat a well known person, I’m not going to say who it is. Let’s call him “Bob.” Bob had been seeing this girl for a short period of time, maybe a couple months or so. They were both Catholic, and he knew deep down that this was the woman he wanted to marry.

So one day he bought her a Rosary. But not just any Rosary, he called it his “stealth Rosary” because he had taken the Crucifix on it apart, put in there a rolled up piece of paper with “Will You Marry Me?” written on it. Put it all back together, and gave it to her.

Well, about a couple years later, as they were praying together at Adoration, Bob said to her “you got that Rosary I gave you?” and she did, and he said “take it apart.” She didn’t quite know what he meant, but she figured it out. When she found the paper, it took her a second but she realized that he had prepared that just for her over 2 years ago!

Wow!! They are married today! 🙂
 
From the experiences of people I’ve known, marriages usually work or fall apart because of the CHARACTER of the husband or wife. While the Catholic faith can play an important part in forming an individual’s character, marrying a Catholic does not guarantee a marriage free from abuse or divorce just as marrying a non-Catholic does not doom you to a failed marriage. I’ve seen mixed marriages where the Catholic spouse cheated. And I’ve seen a lot of marriages where the non-Catholic spouse converted. I think IDEALLY you should marry someone of the same faith, but I would not say to rule out someone solely because they were not Catholic.

Now that being said, I always felt more comfortable dating Catholics because there was more of myself that I could share and they could understand. But I never really resolved to never date non-Catholics…I just tried to meet more Catholics.🙂
Heck, there was this Catholic girl in our church, met a Presbyterian, got married in HIS church, and are living happily ever after…she hasn’t been back to Mass since.
 
That is why I had told the OP that it should be a plus… To the OP: disparity of cult and faith is a big problem in marriages… if you have the choice of dating and marrying someone Catholic over a Protestant or someone of another faith, choose the Catholic one.
I beg to differ…as long as they are Christian, that’s all that matters. I’d marry a Catholic as much as I would marry a Methodist.
 
I beg to differ…as long as they are Christian, that’s all that matters. I’d marry a Catholic as much as I would marry a Methodist.
You realise that some Christians have radically different views of marriage? Few believe in indissolubility, for instance.
 
I beg to differ…as long as they are Christian, that’s all that matters. I’d marry a Catholic as much as I would marry a Methodist.
I would even marry a German! As long as she were Catholic 🙂
 
I would even marry a German! As long as she were Catholic 🙂
I should explain that comment 🙂

Before Mass one day, my priest asked a couple people to bring the hosts forwards. One of them wasn’t Catholic. They told him that they were surprised he asked them, because the previous pastor wouldn’t let them do that, since one of them wasn’t Catholic.

My priest said “Oh no, you don’t have to be Catholic to bring the hosts forward, you could even be German!”

Our priest tries to involve people as much as possible, even people who are going through hard times, to keep them in touch.

Didn’t mean to sidetrack the thread, sorry!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top