Dealing with the anti-contraception crowd

  • Thread starter Thread starter petitsourice
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

petitsourice

Guest
Hello all. I could really use a hand in coming up with some ways to deal with the public’s complete abhorrence with the decision my wife and I have made to NOT use contraception.

We also don’t use NFP. NFP I realize is OK to use, however we honestly want to just leave it entirely up to God.

Now, as a result, we have been married 5 years and have 3 kids. 😃

I have a problem with the way that the entire planet – read: friends, family, coworkers, and other Catholics – feels the need to pipe up about how stupid we are for not using contraception. The only people who support our decision to not use contraception and even to not use NFP is only supported by priests, deacons, and nuns.

I have heard every argument on the planet in favor of using contraception. We live near New York City, which means that housing is ridiculously expensive. I would MOVE before I would start using contraception.

Anyway, can ya’ll give me some help on how to deal with this? Have tried:

“She is my wife, not my girlfriend.” ← seriously, this is true. I think contraception is disgustingly unattractive and I can’t imagine sex with it. The problem with this one is its insulting to others, particularly Catholics, who use contraception.

“We’re Catholic.” ← the #1 response i get to this is, “So?” And then I have to explain, even to Catholics, that contraception is wrong. This is a very hard discussion to have because so many people don’t want to face up to the problems with contraception. Contraception makes kids a choice and an ornament to a marriage and not part of or a result of the marriage. Its very selfish and self centered. I actually had someone recently try and sell me the idea that we should “stop” at 4 kids because they get expensive. I view our children as a part of the marriage, a result of it, and a real part of the family. I do not see them as burdens which is what the rest of the planet sees them as.

And how do I combat this: “What about college?” I can tell you what about college. With college tuition at most universities costing $2-$5k a semester, I doubt that we would be able to put one kid through college. What we can do is offer them a home to live in while going to college. No, they will not get to live on campus or go to an out of town University because we would never be able to afford rent.

The Church is right on its stance on Contraception. However, as with all heresy, initially they are abhorred (1930s – doctors would not prescribe contraception unless you had a handful of kids already), then tolerated (1973 - Roe v. Wade), and then embraced (2010 - P. Sourice is catching flak for having children).
 
Why is your sex life a topic of conversation?

I would suggest you establish boundaries, not think of comebacks.
 
Good question re: why is it a topic.

People make it a topic usually. Ie. my parents (my inlaws are more comfortable with it). And then at work, well, people have no problem piping up that we should not have any more than we already have.
 
I would just stop talking about it. Your business is your own. When someone tries to butt in, do your best to ignore them, don’t answer them, or try to redirect them.

If they’ve really got you in a corner, I would just calmly and courteously remind them how much you value them but this topic is not up for discussion. It’s between you and your wife and no one else. And as they are free to live as they do, so are you.

Though, when you have the energy, it would be a good teaching opportunity 😃

Go through the reasons why contraception is not good for a woman, or the marriage relationship. Discuss the benefits of NFP for both parties and their relationship. And discuss the teachings of the Church in relation to trusting in God and carrying out your responsibilities for bringing more Catholic children into the world. You can use many resources from Humanae Vitae to the catechism. But…that’s only when you have the energy to teach 🙂
 
My sister has six kids and she doesn’t go around telling people about her sex life, but people seem to enjoy talking about it. I am assuming those who have wondered why this topic has come up has never had someone come up to them and tell them they have too many kids or ask if you know how kids are made. People seem to have no problem telling someone they have too many kids.

I will say that instead of trying to justify yourself, tell people that it is not their business. And then change the subject.

I love seeing big families and I wish you all the best.
 
Why is your sex life a topic of conversation?

I would suggest you establish boundaries, not think of comebacks.
This is the crux of the issue…

Why on this green earth are you openly discussing your sexual life with people other than your wife?

Secondly, I’ve not once met anyone who questioned a " normal" middle class family from having three children.

People will start making jokes at 4 kids and people will jokingly label you certifiably insane at 5 kids, but no one is going to " seriously" come down on you for having lots of kids.

Just who do you socialize with anyway that this is even an issue!?
:confused:
 
I love seeing big families and I wish you all the best.
I do too. I truly don’t understand why some people have a problem with it. I guess someone will always be around to complain about something that doesn’t have anything to do with them in the first place.

How rude to comment on how many kids a person shouldn’t have :confused:
 
When people ask you personal questions, you could use Ann Landers’ reply: Look them in the eye and, with a puzzled expression on your face, ask them “Why would you need to know that?”

Or you could come up with something more fun.
Rude Individual: Are you guys done, now?
P S: Done what? Having sex? I sure hope not!

R I: You do know what causes that, right?
P S: Yes, but she won’t stop drinking the water.

R I: Don’t you guys have a TV?
P S: We do, but there’s never anything on we want to watch.

If they get more personal, or seriously question your choices, you might have an opening to evangelize. Or you could tell them that it’s none of their business.
 
Just to let you know . . . I just graduated from a private university (with no financial support from my family), and tuition per semester was more than double the numbers you quoted, not counting fees. 😦

Tell your kids to work hard, and make the financial situation about college clear from the start. There are ways to go to a more prestigious school, but they have to be willing to work for it.

At work, just say something along the lines of “My sex life is not open for discussion.” and walk away. If the commenters have any manners, they’ll be embarrassed.

If it’s your extended family, I would hope they get the message that comments like that are putting a strain on your relationship and refrain. You could even say something along those lines to them: “You’re making me uncomfortable, and I really want myself and all the kids to be able to feel comfortable with you.” I mean, can you imagine how a child might feel overhearing a conversation like that? “Grandma doesn’t think me/baby brother/sister should be here. Why doesn’t she like us?” 😦
 
It’s the same way for people who don’t have kids. People assume things…and feel it’s their business. They ask rude questions.

Seriously…what if a couple is unable to have children and don’t want to adopt. Why is that anyone elses business but theirs and God.

Same for you…why is it anyone else’s business? Maybe something like…“don’t worry–I’m not asking you to raise them…”
 
If sex is just for pleasure; then why draw any distinctions between contraception, adultery, polygamy, masturbation or prostitution? 🤷

It is wonderful that you are open to God’s gift of children - I can only say that setting a sound moral example, and providing a happy and moral home for your children is more important than any college education - and it always will be. Jesus’ disciples didn’t need degrees to be wise, happy and good men.

👍
 
Just tell them how blessed you are and how much love is in your life because of your children. Most of all, tell them the true peace that comes from following God’s will in your life.

I applaud you. I am single and female but if I were married, I know that I probably wouldn’t use NFP either. Money and education have become false gods in our society. It is so subtle for most people that they don’t even know it recognize it. It is far more important to raise your children to be holy and to put God first in their lives than to get a “college education.” Wouldn’t it be better to have child who is a hair dresser or cleaning lady and who truly devotes his/her life to God than a child who is a doctor or lawyer and is a complete atheist or agnostic?
Of course, society would completely scoff at that idea. Most Catholics would, too.

But the truth of the matter is, you don’t necessarily have to get a college education as soon as you graduate from high school. Your children can get a job and have their employer pay for part of it.
 
My sister has six kids and she doesn’t go around telling people about her sex life, but people seem to enjoy talking about it. I am assuming those who have wondered why this topic has come up has never had someone come up to them and tell them they have too many kids or ask if you know how kids are made. People seem to have no problem telling someone they have too many kids.

I will say that instead of trying to justify yourself, tell people that it is not their business. And then change the subject.

I love seeing big families and I wish you all the best.
You bring up a good point. People dont have a problem discussing that we have 3 kids in 5 years.

The issue really isn’t anyone else’s business, but I still am offended that “choice” seems to be OK to shove down my throat by society. Its the whole freedom from religion, not of religion issue america has right now.

I am hoping for a big family and thank God we can actually have kids – my wife was worried about us not being able to b/c I would not do fertility treatments either.

And to others in this thread, good points. I guess I am just fed up with defending my faith here. And having a large family (especially in stupid expensive new england, home of the dinks) makes us stand out. Along with the 2nd hand cars we drive. =)

But those 2nd hand cars, the smaller house so we can afford Catholic school, and the inevitable hand-me downs are just part of what I consider to be a healthy, loving home. (and for what its worth, even after 5 years of being married the wife and i are still head over heels in love).
 
When people ask you personal questions, you could use Ann Landers’ reply: Look them in the eye and, with a puzzled expression on your face, ask them “Why would you need to know that?”

Or you could come up with something more fun.
Rude Individual: Are you guys done, now?
P S: Done what? Having sex? I sure hope not!

R I: You do know what causes that, right?
P S: Yes, but she won’t stop drinking the water.

R I: Don’t you guys have a TV?
P S: We do, but there’s never anything on we want to watch.

If they get more personal, or seriously question your choices, you might have an opening to evangelize. Or you could tell them that it’s none of their business.
One of my favorites:

Which one of our children do you think we should not have had?
 
Just tell them how blessed you are and how much love is in your life because of your children. Most of all, tell them the true peace that comes from following God’s will in your life.

I applaud you. I am single and female but if I were married, I know that I probably wouldn’t use NFP either. Money and education have become false gods in our society. It is so subtle for most people that they don’t even know it recognize it. It is far more important to raise your children to be holy and to put God first in their lives than to get a “college education.” Wouldn’t it be better to have child who is a hair dresser or cleaning lady and who truly devotes his/her life to God than a child who is a doctor or lawyer and is a complete atheist or agnostic?
Of course, society would completely scoff at that idea. Most Catholics would, too.

But the truth of the matter is, you don’t necessarily have to get a college education as soon as you graduate from high school. Your children can get a job and have their employer pay for part of it.
You will likely be quite a catch for someone. Best of luck to you there.

You have hit a nerve with this statement: “Money and education have become false gods in our society.” How true. It took me a LONG time – sadly even after getting married – to come to the realization that money and career are not always worth it. Case and point us moving from the South to new england. My line of work (computer related) has dried up everywhere in the u.s. except for New York City. So, we had to move.

Shortly after getting here though, it dawned on me that there are LOTS of happy people who aren’t forced to carry a blackberry around to be at the mercy of a corporation 24/7 and to never get to take a vacation without bringing the blackberry. Thats the cost of my successful career – being on 24 hour call 365 days a year. And I am not alone, lots of corporate jobs are like that now a days. Especially in computers though. Ie. last night i had to work from 2 am to 4 am b/c something broke.

Anyway, you are so right about money and education being false gods. One of the most liberating things that has ever happened to me is realizing that I could be happy “digging ditches” again instead of the corporate career. In the 80s they told us kids that if we studied hard we would get a good job and not have to work so hard to get by. The truth is though that no matter how much education you have, you will pay in time for money. Physicians are a great example of this. Horrible hours, but great pay. Computers as well, horrible hours, good pay. And that is really sad – that noone can make a decent living without having to work 60+ hours a week.

And for what its worth, if the 40 hour week were enforced and salaried employees not asked to work that extra 20 hours for free, then there would instantly be thousands of new jobs in most medium and larger cities.
 
This is the crux of the issue…

Why on this green earth are you openly discussing your sexual life with people other than your wife?

Secondly, I’ve not once met anyone who questioned a " normal" middle class family from having three children.

People will start making jokes at 4 kids and people will jokingly label you certifiably insane at 5 kids, but no one is going to " seriously" come down on you for having lots of kids.

Just who do you socialize with anyway that this is even an issue!?
:confused:
You don’t understand – people have come down on me for having lots of kids. i only have 3 and we catch a lot of flak about it. It may depend on where you live. Add in that they know you are Catholic – which is sort of hard to avoid disclosing when your employer wants you to work 7 days a week and you have to explain the bit about needing to go to church.

And as I said – the entire planet (including family members) minus priests, nuns, and my in laws has had no issue asking me if I am planning on having more children or if I am using birth control.

Hence the reason for this post.
 
When people ask you personal questions, you could use Ann Landers’ reply: Look them in the eye and, with a puzzled expression on your face, ask them “Why would you need to know that?”

Or you could come up with something more fun.
Rude Individual: Are you guys done, now?
P S: Done what? Having sex? I sure hope not!

R I: You do know what causes that, right?
P S: Yes, but she won’t stop drinking the water.

R I: Don’t you guys have a TV?
P S: We do, but there’s never anything on we want to watch.

If they get more personal, or seriously question your choices, you might have an opening to evangelize. Or you could tell them that it’s none of their business.
I have had a good amount of success with the humor approach. “I don’t know why she keeps getting pregnant, but my mother in law claims she has a good idea of how it keeps happening.”

Being abrasive though – especially since its not strangers on the street saying things to me but family, friends, and co workers – is not a good idea. Such as saying, “Its none of your business.” That puts people off and is just not worth damaging a relationship over.

The humor approach works well – I originally posted trying to see how / if anyone else deals with it. I got aggravated defending it recently with a friend who had no problems telling me that 4 kids should be enough.
 
You don’t understand – people have come down on me for having lots of kids. i only have 3 and we catch a lot of flak about it. It may depend on where you live. Add in that they know you are Catholic – which is sort of hard to avoid disclosing when your employer wants you to work 7 days a week and you have to explain the bit about needing to go to church.

And as I said – the entire planet (including family members) minus priests, nuns, and my in laws has had no issue asking me if I am planning on having more children or if I am using birth control.

Hence the reason for this post.
Like I say, I’m in my mid 30’s, have 3 kids and not once in my entire life has anyone asked my wife or I what our preferred method of birth control is.

People have jokingly asked if I’m going to have 4th child and I let them know that there is no way I’d ever have more than three.
 
If sex is just for pleasure; then why draw any distinctions between contraception, adultery, polygamy, masturbation or prostitution? 🤷

It is wonderful that you are open to God’s gift of children - I can only say that setting a sound moral example, and providing a happy and moral home for your children is more important than any college education - and it always will be. Jesus’ disciples didn’t need degrees to be wise, happy and good men.

👍
Trust me, they are happy. All of them. Even the strangely comedic 9 month old. And he IS comedic. The boy was laughing when he was 3 months old. My 4 year old recently hid under the bed so she could spook her mother while they were cleaning up. And the 2 (almost 3) year old is one of the most loving kids I have ever seen.

And of course, the misses is happily married still – she’s out of town visiting her family at the moment. I catch a lot of flak about me not having a problem with her visiting relatives 1600 miles away for 2-3 months in the summers as well. “Aren’t you afraid of her/him cheating?” ← we both hear that. Easy one to answer though: “No.”

My wife is a HUGE gem and I am lucky I got her before someone else did! And you are right – raising the kids in a happy home is paramount. And the possibility of having more kids – and the possibility that God will decide not to give us any more – is a good part of our home as well.

Its entirely possible that we will not be as fortunate with having more kids as we both get older. Lots of people have to try for 2-3 years before they get pregnant. In our case every time she says, “Boy, I would love to have another baby,” God hears and gives us one. Even if she changes her mind in a week. =) Hehe. Our 1st was expected, the other 2 kids are our “little surprises” (not accidents).

The idea that education == money earning potential is also a myth that needs to be busted. Even a medical degree (in the u.s.) is so expensive to obtain that its not necessarily worth it (or the hours you have to work afterwards). And the $200k wall street jobs that require you to rent a room in NYC so you can work 12 hours a day w/o riding the train are not worth it for a family man.

And thats where the world is falling apart. Family is a dirty word now. Families interfere with profits and getting people to work for free. Dads want to go spend time with their wife and kids – the nerve! How dare you turn off the blackberry while you are in church! Well, the bit about having to leave the blackberry on in church is true. Last job I had required me to have it on and to answer texts even if I was in church. (illegal, yes, prosecutable? not really - they gave me a severance and made me promise not to sue them for laying me off b/c I went to church)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top