Dealing with your cultural background

  • Thread starter Thread starter divinefaith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

divinefaith

Guest
How would someone in this scenario manage reconciling ‘2 cultures’?:

Say you and your family live in a Western country (e.g. U.S, Canada, Australia, Germany etc.) but have an ethnic background which seems to hinder their child’s freedom e.g. it is expected parents always have a say if their adult children can have a late night, where they can work and what sort of dating is allowed. I have met a few people who in their adult years still obey these rules and wouldn’t move out as respect for their culture and parents. In your opinion, what decisions should a person make?
 
CCC - " 2251 Children owe their parents respect, gratitude, just obedience, and assistance. Filial respect fosters harmony in all of family life.** "**

CCC - " 2217 As long as a child lives at home with his parents, the child should obey his parents in all that they ask of him when it is for his good or that of the family.
“Children, obey your parents in everything, for this pleases the Lord.”
Children should also obey the reasonable directions of their teachers and all to whom their parents have entrusted them. But if a child is convinced in conscience that it would be morally wrong to obey a particular order, he must not do so.
As they grow up, children should continue to respect their parents. They should anticipate their wishes, willingly seek their advice, and accept their just admonitions. Obedience toward parents ceases with the emancipation of the children; not so respect, which is always owed to them. This respect has its roots in the fear of God, one of the gifts of the Holy Spirit. "

I would say that when an adult lives in their parents home, or is finacially supported by their parents, there is a stronger link to obedience.
Note the word “emancipation” in the quote from the CCC. To be emancipated one must be financially independent.
So college students and others who do not financially support yourselves - obedience is required in all that is not sinful.
 
The Catholic encyclopedia defined emanicipation as when children acquire their majority, which is their adult age. So I find this term vague. Someone who is still supported by their parents will have rules to meet but does that mean ALL rules?
 
How would someone in this scenario manage reconciling ‘2 cultures’?:

Say you and your family live in a Western country (e.g. U.S, Canada, Australia, Germany etc.) but have an ethnic background which seems to hinder their child’s freedom e.g. it is expected parents always have a say if their adult children can have a late night, where they can work and what sort of dating is allowed. I have met a few people who in their adult years still obey these rules and wouldn’t move out as respect for their culture and parents. In your opinion, what decisions should a person make?
We cannot say what decisions they should make. Simple as that.

In the above, you say that they act this way out of respect for their parents and culture. Fine, that is their choice. The legal structure of the western countries (so far as I know) does not hinder this decision. Likewise, if a child from such a culture decided to break with such tradition there would be nothing to prevent them.

I really don’t see the problem.

Peace
James
 
I’m american, raised by americans but I often employ children of mexicans, putericans and other latin American countries.

Here’s a few things that their parents don’t understand…I run into this daily. This will cover the work.
  1. Lateness IS a firable offence. It dosn’t matter if your mamma needed you to take out the trash.
  2. It is not appropriate to constantly bring food to share.
  3. smelly food is not a great way to make friends
  4. you can’t just change your schedule because aunt/uncle/3 cousin twice removed has a birthday party.
  5. I am paying you to work. If I ask you to stay an extra 30 minutes and you AS an adult agree I better not hear from your mother/father/ 3 cousin twice removed that I’m overworking you.

Basically, to hold down an American job you have to buck some traditions. Do it.​

Socially- sorry, but if you’re under someone’s roof you must abide by their schedule. It dosn’t matter if it’s your mother becuase she owns the house or your the father who comes home back to live with the child due to old age.

Dating- Respect your parents while doing your own thing. Watch My big fat greek wedding. I wouldn’t say lie, but simply what they don’t know can’t hurt them.
 
How would someone in this scenario manage reconciling ‘2 cultures’?:

Say you and your family live in a Western country (e.g. U.S, Canada, Australia, Germany etc.) but have an ethnic background which seems to hinder their child’s freedom e.g. it is expected parents always have a say if their adult children can have a late night, where they can work and what sort of dating is allowed. I have met a few people who in their adult years still obey these rules and wouldn’t move out as respect for their culture and parents. In your opinion, what decisions should a person make?
My best friend is actually Muslim living in a large American city. Her parents won’t let her date anybody who not only is Muslim but was born in the same country they were born in, for example an Egyptian Muslim wouldn’t be suitable, and any other race is out of the queston.

She is away at school, an hour from her parents, and her parents made her take out a loan to cover her rent for a year because she is not allowed live with a non Muslim person, nor a non wed Muslim woman as they are afraid it will make men think she is also unmarriable.

She obides by every rule they set, has got herself into so much debt, s doing well at school - basically she is following every rule and social norm of the Muslim & Christian society, trying to please everyone, but is so miserable!!

This obviously isn’t the right answer, but what else can she do? Her parents would literally kick her out of their family if she slips up. If her parents say “be back in 30minutes” she HAS to drop everything and go! No employer understands that, no teacher understands that, but she has to go!!

If I was her I would do the exact same thing. Honor thy parents. It’s pretty high up there on the list! :confused:
 
How would someone in this scenario manage reconciling ‘2 cultures’?:

Say you and your family live in a Western country (e.g. U.S, Canada, Australia, Germany etc.) but have an ethnic background which seems to hinder their child’s freedom e.g. it is expected parents always have a say if their adult children can have a late night, where they can work and what sort of dating is allowed. I have met a few people who in their adult years still obey these rules and wouldn’t move out as respect for their culture and parents. In your opinion, what decisions should a person make?
To be fair I don’t see this as a religious issue so much a sociological one.

I come from a background where to an extent this tension exists but it’s not something we even reflect on. Seems it sorts itself out, one way or another.
 
How would someone in this scenario manage reconciling ‘2 cultures’?:

Say you and your family live in a Western country (e.g. U.S, Canada, Australia, Germany etc.) but have an ethnic background which seems to hinder their child’s freedom e.g. it is expected parents always have a say if their adult children can have a late night, where they can work and what sort of dating is allowed. I have met a few people who in their adult years still obey these rules and wouldn’t move out as respect for their culture and parents. In your opinion, what decisions should a person make?
It’s an incredibly taxing experience to be dating with that kind of difference involved. Then, just think about getting marital consent from someone who needs parental consent just to come back past a certain hour from a date with you.
 
My best friend is actually Muslim living in a large American city. Her parents won’t let her date anybody who not only is Muslim but was born in the same country they were born in, for example an Egyptian Muslim wouldn’t be suitable, and any other race is out of the queston.

She is away at school, an hour from her parents, and her parents made her take out a loan to cover her rent for a year because she is not allowed live with a non Muslim person, nor a non wed Muslim woman as they are afraid it will make men think she is also unmarriable.

She obides by every rule they set, has got herself into so much debt, s doing well at school - basically she is following every rule and social norm of the Muslim & Christian society, trying to please everyone, but is so miserable!!

This obviously isn’t the right answer, but what else can she do? Her parents would literally kick her out of their family if she slips up. If her parents say “be back in 30minutes” she HAS to drop everything and go! No employer understands that, no teacher understands that, but she has to go!!

If I was her I would do the exact same thing. Honor thy parents. It’s pretty high up there on the list! :confused:
First, of all did this friend ask you for help? If she did not, then I would not volunteer advice.

I don’t quite understand ‘she is following every rule and social norm of the Muslim & Christian society,’ because these 2 contradict. most Muslim’s would be upset to find out their child is living a Christian lifestyle and vice versa

Also, teacher and ESPECIALLY employers should NOT have to understand that an adult child must run home at the drop of the hat because their parents just feel like it. Workers have a responsibility to their employer more than to their parents during work hours

And there is a BIG difference between ‘honor thy parents’ and ‘be thy parents doormat’. This girl is an individual with her own free will. If she is choosing this, that is her right and she must accept the consequences of her employer firing her. She also can choose to go against it and be banned from her family. Not a fun place to be, but nonetheless, her personal decision

CM
 
We cannot say what decisions they should make. Simple as that.

In the above, you say that they act this way out of respect for their parents and culture. Fine, that is their choice. The legal structure of the western countries (so far as I know) does not hinder this decision. Likewise, if a child from such a culture decided to break with such tradition there would be nothing to prevent them.

I really don’t see the problem.

Peace
James
ok, so you say its ok for the child to make their own decisions regardless of living with the family?

Socially- sorry, but if you’re under someone’s roof you must abide by their schedule. It dosn’t matter if it’s your mother becuase she owns the house or your the father who comes home back to live with the child due to old age.

Dating- Respect your parents while doing your own thing. Watch My big fat greek wedding. I wouldn’t say lie, but simply what they don’t know can’t hurt them.
Socially you say abide by the schedule, but do they have a right to say you cant go to so so, for e.g. a bar, just trying to clarify your post further lol.
To be fair I don’t see this as a religious issue so much a sociological one.

I come from a background where to an extent this tension exists but it’s not something we even reflect on. Seems it sorts itself out, one way or another.
How is it not religious if theres an obligation for children to obey their parents until they are ‘emanicipated’? Dont know if that would refer to when the child reaches adulthood or when they move out. The definition could possibly depend on the rule they have in place for the child and the rights of both the child and the parents (considering its the parents household) but not sure 🤷
 
Perhaps this will help you with the answers, although perhaps not with casuistic precision:
2217 As long as a child lives at home with his parents, the child should obey his parents in all that they ask of him when it is for his good or that of the family. "Children, obey your parents in everything, for this pleases the Lord."22 Children should also obey the reasonable directions of their teachers and all to whom their parents have entrusted them. But if a child is convinced in conscience that it would be morally wrong to obey a particular order, he must not do so.
As they grow up, children should continue to respect their parents. They should anticipate their wishes, willingly seek their advice, and accept their just admonitions. Obedience toward parents ceases with the emancipation of the children; not so respect, which is always owed to them. This respect has its roots in the fear of God, one of the gifts of the Holy Spirit.
It would be good to find some wholesome, orthodox commentary that doesn’t mix morality with e.g. Victorian bourgeois etiquette, although one should probably err on the side of deference (if not outright obedience) in doubtful cases.

I can see why in a family with a strong leadership the head of the family, feeling responsible for the safety of its members, would want everybody reporting under his protection for the night. I could see why anybody would like his house to stay quiet and avoid noisy returns, particularly if some people in the house sleep lightly and need to get up in the morning. I can even sympathise, to an extent, with some considerations of propriety.

However, I’m very ill at ease with e.g. fathers micromanaging clearly adult daughters that don’t have a separate dwelling, especially if those fathers seem to enjoy having their authority felt and/or enjoy treating legal adults on par with adolescent children. I wouldn’t presume to judge foreign cultures, subcultures or even the habits of specific social “classes”, let alone to encourage “rebellion”, but such parent-children relationships aren’t proper in my mostly steadfast opinion.

I’m particularly opposed to the idea of parents making actual decisions in areas related to marriage. No human force, not even the pope (let alone some kind of grandfather or head of a tribe), can supplant his own consent for that of the woman (or the man for that matter). I do not believe obedience or deference to such authority to be a good motivation in choosing one’s spouse (Biblical and historical examples could be used convincingly but not conclusively to prove me wrong, but I remain attached to my position).

Due to the above reasons I believe that parents have no authority to expect their children to marry or date a certain specific person. I suppose parents have the right to forbid a child from seeing somebody specific, but I believe only until the child reaches a certain age or level of maturity. On the other hand, parents are free to dispose of their house or inheritance, which complicates matters for a non-compliant child living under their roof.

At any rate, marriage can’t be invalidated or evented by lack of parental consent for those old enough, which should be a basis for thought. Generally, Catholic theology and canon law should be the guide in such matters.

I suppose it could be argued that compliance with directives treating a person close to his or her mid twenties like a school child would be contrary to reason or morality (although such a person can generally be expected to get out, get a job and get a house on his own). It could probably be better even for the father’s sake to remind him of the obvious and give him an opportunity to fix his approach.
 
40.png
cmscms:
Just curious but why is this innaproriate? It goes on all the time where I work
Occasinally bringing a treat is ok but constantly bringing meals or even other treats is not. Food has a social aspect, but johnny’s enchaladas and him being a free lunch ticket is way too easily abuse by both ends. This is work afterall.

[edited] Perhaps things like this which seem innocus arent.
 
Please don’t take jabs at me, it is not charitable

CM
oh please give me a break. Dont be hypocritical. Your complaints about your workplace are no secret. By mentioning your work in this thread you brought it up. Im just saving the OP the trouble of reseructiong the threads herself. However, I can link you to the half dozen threads if you wish.
 
It is not appropriate to constantly bring food to share.
This goes on in many workplaces. It does get excessive as no one usually brings fresh fruit and plain fresh vegetables it is usually: cookies, pizza, candy, sodas, more cookies, cakes, pies, birthday cake, cookies, bagels, doughnuts, candy again, chips, more cookies.
 
This goes on in many workplaces. It does get excessive as no one usually brings fresh fruit and plain fresh vegetables it is usually: cookies, pizza, candy, sodas, more cookies, cakes, pies, birthday cake, cookies, bagels, doughnuts, candy again, chips, more cookies.
that is not bringing food. I mean bringing food as i full on lunches.

Actually, the need to feed that most applies to latino cultures seems to apply to deep-fried paistry meat. There is not only a ton of waste but a secondary culture that develops around this glut of food. A few cookies are one thing, but I have had to sit young adults down to explain that it will not get them ahead in the workplace even though they insist it will. (among other problems). I have even felt the backlash of other employess when I had to fire the kid who brought empaladas. They didnt care he didnt do work…they even did his. They were daarn good empaladas but you cant run a business that way.

Apparently, however, on puter rico this behavior is not only tolerated, its normative. Which is why I feel its important to let a non-westerner know that its not a good idea.
 
Perhaps this will help you with the answers, although perhaps not with casuistic precision:

It would be good to find some wholesome, orthodox commentary that doesn’t mix morality with e.g. Victorian bourgeois etiquette, although one should probably err on the side of deference (if not outright obedience) in doubtful cases.

I can see why in a family with a strong leadership the head of the family, feeling responsible for the safety of its members, would want everybody reporting under his protection for the night. I could see why anybody would like his house to stay quiet and avoid noisy returns, particularly if some people in the house sleep lightly and need to get up in the morning. I can even sympathise, to an extent, with some considerations of propriety.

However, I’m very ill at ease with e.g. fathers micromanaging clearly adult daughters that don’t have a separate dwelling, especially if those fathers seem to enjoy having their authority felt and/or enjoy treating legal adults on par with adolescent children. I wouldn’t presume to judge foreign cultures, subcultures or even the habits of specific social “classes”, let alone to encourage “rebellion”, but such parent-children relationships aren’t proper in my mostly steadfast opinion.

I’m particularly opposed to the idea of parents making actual decisions in areas related to marriage. No human force, not even the pope (let alone some kind of grandfather or head of a tribe), can supplant his own consent for that of the woman (or the man for that matter). I do not believe obedience or deference to such authority to be a good motivation in choosing one’s spouse (Biblical and historical examples could be used convincingly but not conclusively to prove me wrong, but I remain attached to my position).

Due to the above reasons I believe that parents have no authority to expect their children to marry or date a certain specific person. I suppose parents have the right to forbid a child from seeing somebody specific, but I believe only until the child reaches a certain age or level of maturity. On the other hand, parents are free to dispose of their house or inheritance, which complicates matters for a non-compliant child living under their roof.

At any rate, marriage can’t be invalidated or evented by lack of parental consent for those old enough, which should be a basis for thought. Generally, Catholic theology and canon law should be the guide in such matters.

I suppose it could be argued that compliance with directives treating a person close to his or her mid twenties like a school child would be contrary to reason or morality (although such a person can generally be expected to get out, get a job and get a house on his own). It could probably be better even for the father’s sake to remind him of the obvious and give him an opportunity to fix his approach.
In some cases the adult child doesn’t move out because it would be so hard for them to go thru the conflict. They might also fear living alone especially if their parents didn’t encourage that form of independence. Others might even choose not to bring ‘shame’ to the family considering some cultures consider moving out a taboo. In my opinion, moving out is fine but we cant expect it from everybody, since they have different views and concerns about it. It is up to them.

A family friend I know was only permitted to date a man from her culture. They were only to date for a short time before her dad stepped in to say ‘you either get engaged or you leave him.’ I can also imagine she had possibly been warned against all physical affection, since all kissing was considered unchaste by her parents. If I were in her situation I don’t know what I’ll do. I would consider the morality of continuing to date this guy and whether disobeying them in terms of my way of affection would be sinful. Any further thoughts?
 
The way I understand it, religion aside, is that age is nothing to do with it. If someone, anyone, is dependent on others to support them, that person should courteously follow the rules of the house.

If they don’t like the rules of the house, they are welcome to get a job, pay their own bills and move out, assuming they are legally an adult.

It’s good manners and common sense.
 
The way I understand it, religion aside, is that age is nothing to do with it. If someone, anyone, is dependent on others to support them, that person should courteously follow the rules of the house.

If they don’t like the rules of the house, they are welcome to get a job, pay their own bills and move out, assuming they are legally an adult.

It’s good manners and common sense.
But how far do house rules go? Would you think they go as far as the personal life of the child which he\she has outside of the house?
 
But how far do house rules go? Would you think they go as far as the personal life of the child which he\she has outside of the house?
Look. We cannot say “oh such restriction is abuse.”

the duggars…and other fundie protestants…require their children to not only live at home for college but do online college. They are not even allowed to live on there own unless they are married. The cannot hold outside jobs. I dont think any learn to legally drive until well after 18. They cannot be alone with the opposite sex.

In our modern society we ascribe cult to these ideals. The natural pull of family competing with the need for individuality. The fear of rejection.

The person needs to decide what they want. A free ride at mom and dads with manipulation but loyality. Or to step away, start fresh and risk loosing their security.

Without depraved abuse its a tough decision. But its a personal decision none-the-less. When you are in the house you play by house rules.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top