Dealing with your cultural background

  • Thread starter Thread starter divinefaith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Look. We cannot say “oh such restriction is abuse.”

the duggars…and other fundie protestants…require their children to not only live at home for college but do online college. They are not even allowed to live on there own unless they are married. The cannot hold outside jobs. I dont think any learn to legally drive until well after 18. They cannot be alone with the opposite sex.

In our modern society we ascribe cult to these ideals. The natural pull of family competing with the need for individuality. The fear of rejection.

The person needs to decide what they want. A free ride at mom and dads with manipulation but loyality. Or to step away, start fresh and risk loosing their security.

Without depraved abuse its a tough decision. But its a personal decision none-the-less. When you are in the house you play by house rules.
Adult children of the Duggar family would be sinning if they rebelled by being around the opposite sex, simply because
they still live under their parents’ roof?
:confused: I find it hard to decide the ethics of such a situation
 
In some cases the adult child doesn’t move out because it would be so hard for them to go thru the conflict. They might also fear living alone especially if their parents didn’t encourage that form of independence. Others might even choose not to bring ‘shame’ to the family considering some cultures consider moving out a taboo. In my opinion, moving out is fine but we cant expect it from everybody, since they have different views and concerns about it. It is up to them.
I agree. I don’t belong to fast movers-out myself either, for that matter.
A family friend I know was only permitted to date a man from her culture. They were only to date for a short time before her dad stepped in to say ‘you either get engaged or you leave him.’ I can also imagine she had possibly been warned against all physical affection, since all kissing was considered unchaste by her parents. If I were in her situation I don’t know what I’ll do. I would consider the morality of continuing to date this guy and whether disobeying them in terms of my way of affection would be sinful. Any further thoughts?
I fear that if I were to continue to discover and express my thoughts on that matter, I would begin to sound much more like a democrat than a traditional theologian. My belief, as a lawyer and as a human person (if the two are compatible :p) is that a person’s decision shouldn’t be so easily overriden or thwarted, and that authorities, including parents, shouldn’t invade the world of feelings, affections and sexuality. I’m an enemy (not even opponent) of strip-searches by the police, obligatory medical examinations by doctors of the opposite sex (happens at schools), teachers expecting students to take part in stage kissing during plays, putting social pressure by anybody on anybody to give someone a dance, a date, a specific intimate gesture (e.g. in greeting) and so on and so forth. I say this as a person who wouldn’t mind adultery being a crime, and a fan of public decency laws, so this is not a question of libertinism on my part.

However, restricting teenagers’ behaviours with the opposite sex is necessary, as is enforcement of the rules. There must be clarity as to the fact that premarital sex is wrong and no light matter. But this needs to be done skillfully in order to avoid inflicting traumas on those young people by penalising them for just being themselves and trying to come to terms with their nature like everybody has to do and has done at that same age. Aggressive enforcers of decency have the power to cripple a person’s personality and psychic constitution permanently when they mishandle whatever they are doing. People who enjoy commanding 15 year olds to bed at 9 p.m. as if they were toddlers shouldn’t be handling a dating 18 year old. Arrested development…
Adult children of the Duggar family would be sinning if they rebelled by being around the opposite sex, simply because
they still live under their parents’ roof?
:confused: I find it hard to decide the ethics of such a situation
In the light of typical theology, there is a chance. And that chance is well substantiated because our religion puts a lot of emphasis on obedience and Our Lord Himself gave a perfect example of it. The Apostles were very all-out on obedience too. On the other hand, early saints did e.g. perform marriages for people whose parents opposed the union or who were forbidden from marrying at all.

I believe they wouldn’t be sinning for moving out to live on their own though.
 
I agree. I don’t belong to fast movers-out myself either, for that matter.

I fear that if I were to continue to discover and express my thoughts on that matter, I would begin to sound much more like a democrat than a traditional theologian. My belief, as a lawyer and as a human person (if the two are compatible :p) is that a person’s decision shouldn’t be so easily overriden or thwarted, and that authorities, including parents, shouldn’t invade the world of feelings, affections and sexuality. I’m an enemy (not even opponent) of strip-searches by the police, obligatory medical examinations by doctors of the opposite sex (happens at schools), teachers expecting students to take part in stage kissing during plays, putting social pressure by anybody on anybody to give someone a dance, a date, a specific intimate gesture (e.g. in greeting) and so on and so forth. I say this as a person who wouldn’t mind adultery being a crime, and a fan of public decency laws, so this is not a question of libertinism on my part.

However, restricting teenagers’ behaviours with the opposite sex is necessary, as is enforcement of the rules. There must be clarity as to the fact that premarital sex is wrong and no light matter. But this needs to be done skillfully in order to avoid inflicting traumas on those young people by penalising them for just being themselves and trying to come to terms with their nature like everybody has to do and has done at that same age. Aggressive enforcers of decency have the power to cripple a person’s personality and psychic constitution permanently when they mishandle whatever they are doing. People who enjoy commanding 15 year olds to bed at 9 p.m. as if they were toddlers shouldn’t be handling a dating 18 year old. Arrested development…
Your points are wise (and lawyers are wise lol). In brief words you say a parent must show proper authority on a teenager, but then let go of being way too intrusive and authoritative on an adult?
 
Adult children of the Duggar family would be sinning if they rebelled by being around the opposite sex, simply because
they still live under their parents’ roof?
:confused: I find it hard to decide the ethics of such a situation
Sin? Who knows.
I am, however, a firm believer in purse strings. If you do not like your living situation then support yourself.

I do not believe in manipulating adults. That being said 20-30 years from now if I have an adult child who lives at home they will be expected to contribute, leave things better than they found them, never have opposite-gender sleepovers in their room, and let me know their basic schedule as well as expecting quiet after a reasonable hour. In today’s society that would be condidered being “mean”. This, of course, provided that a adult child had a reason to be living at home.

You, your friend, whatever…house rules are house rules no matter how dumb society thinks they are.
 
Lawyers are understanding of human rights haha thats why they know how to defend (in many cases at least)
 
Your points are wise (and lawyers are wise lol). In brief words you say a parent must show proper authority on a teenager, but then let go of being way too intrusive and authoritative on an adult?
The answer in the post above tends to be right. It’s about human rights and non-abuse of authority. Parents shouldn’t be living vicariously through their children nor use their children as pawns in some kind of family social standing game. This gets trickier when families are basically small homelands and like a country has a king, the tribe has its patriarch, to whom family members are loyal as if to the tribe itself, and they do care for that tribe the same as if for a small version of their own country (think about princes agreeing of their own free will to marry for the sake of a military alliance rather than personal happiness, then apply it to petty lords, then to basically any tribe or family interacting with other such units). So these are not easy things to discuss, we can’t go around pushing our understanding of freedom and rights on them. It’s definitely easier to discuss them from the point of view of our laws than actual morality, especially with obedience (to any legitimate authority, including family) and respect for parents being such greatly important things in our religion. I’m very afraid of turning out wrong when I’m inclined to go on a spree defending individual rights.
 
The Catholic encyclopedia defined emanicipation as when children acquire their majority, which is their adult age. So I find this term vague. Someone who is still supported by their parents will have rules to meet but does that mean ALL rules?
Golden rule = he who has the gold makes the rules.

I am a middle aged woman, if I were to move into my parents home, I’d abide by their rules.

Perhaps you can arrange to pay your family rent and then work out a more tenant role with understood rules?
 
The answer in the post above tends to be right. It’s about human rights and non-abuse of authority. Parents shouldn’t be living vicariously through their children nor use their children as pawns in some kind of family social standing game. This gets trickier when families are basically small homelands and like a country has a king, the tribe has its patriarch, to whom family members are loyal as if to the tribe itself, and they do care for that tribe the same as if for a small version of their own country (think about princes agreeing of their own free will to marry for the sake of a military alliance rather than personal happiness, then apply it to petty lords, then to basically any tribe or family interacting with other such units). So these are not easy things to discuss, we can’t go around pushing our understanding of freedom and rights on them. It’s definitely easier to discuss them from the point of view of our laws than actual morality, especially with obedience (to any legitimate authority, including family) and respect for parents being such greatly important things in our religion. I’m very afraid of turning out wrong when I’m inclined to go on a spree defending individual rights.
I remembered how St Paul in the Bible commanded that children obey their parents. This however is in a similar context of your description where you just mentioned those families who live in tribes where obedience is mandatory.
You are right, our view of obedience and childrens rights comes from the Western legal view where the child can do certain things as they become adults e.g. An adult can smoke without the approval of parents. I can clearly understand the legal and social view, as for the moral view, even after reading this Im still questioning. I dont see anything wrong with you referring to legal rights since there can be compatibility between that and religion (in many cases at least). I do question whether or not an adult should go their own way while living with their parents. It makes sense to say its their legal right but are they living as ‘users’ by doing so 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top