Debate: a Catholic and an Atheist

  • Thread starter Thread starter Omyo12
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

Omyo12

Guest
My cousin is doing a project for his Sculpture class. The “piece” could be on any medium including video and sound.

He’s planning on recording a debate between myself and his friend who is an atheist.

I feel ready more or less, however, there is one HUGE question that will probably stump me…

why do I believe in the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob?
(I feel rather confident defending Christianity over Judaism and Islam… I also feel confident defending Catholicism over Protestantism, Mormonism, etc)

However, why not Hinduism, Shintoism, or Buddhism?

are there any tips on tackling this?
 
…because they do not follow christ, isn’t that good enough reason? 🤷
I needed a basis for believe in Christ in the first place.

Here’s how my argument will flow:
  1. Based on philosophy, I believe there’s a “god of the philosophers”
  2. Based on ____???_____, I believe there is a personal God who revealed Himself to humanity specifically in the Jewish religion, and not the Hindu, Buddhist, or Shintoist religions
  3. I therefore believe in God who is called Yahweh
  4. Based on the Old Testament prophesies, I believe Jesus of Nazareth to be the Messiah
  5. I am therefore a Christian
  6. Based on history, I believe the Catholic Church is the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church.
  7. I am therefore a Catholic
I was thinking an argument based on philosophy and the nature of the Triune God

However, just wondering if anyone had any more tips
 
Ask them to explain how a deity in their religion can possibly understand human suffering if they never took the form of a human being and never suffered the way Christ has suffered. In all the religions you listed above, the gods are to be revered and worshiped but frankly don’t give a damn about the human condition be it suffering, sin, starvation, etc. Human beings are worth nothing to them. Christianity is all about the worth of an human being and an individual.
 
My cousin is doing a project for his Sculpture class. The “piece” could be on any medium including video and sound.

He’s planning on recording a debate between myself and his friend who is an atheist.

I feel ready more or less, however, there is one HUGE question that will probably stump me…

why do I believe in the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob?
(I feel rather confident defending Christianity over Judaism and Islam… I also feel confident defending Catholicism over Protestantism, Mormonism, etc)

However, why not Hinduism, Shintoism, or Buddhism?

are there any tips on tackling this?
Here is something that might help. A friend of mine and I came up with it. I call it Pascal Gamble-extended:
We dived the world’s religions by those who accept reincarnation those who don’t. Those who accept reincarnation should be rejected. Why? Because if they are right I will come back again anyway and have another chance to try them.
The liner religions( point A to point B–birth to either heaven/hell) of Judism, Christianity and Islam are my best chances. If they are wrong I have had at least the experience of them and will by this be more enlightened, when I am reincarnated.

Which religion one of these is my best bet?
Which one tells me how to save my soul? Get to point B!
Judism can’t because they have no infallible judge on this earth to tell me. Orthodox Jews will say to turn on a light switch on the Sabbath is mortal sin. But a reformed would say its nonsense. No infallible guide to decide in this world.

Islam the same problem. They say one needs to be 51% good to go to heaven when weighed on Ala’s sword. But what is a sin and how is it forgiven? No one knows. If you murder a man they don’t tell you what you need to do to pay it back. By their system one could lie and then do two good deeds …etc…thus always keeping at least 51% good balance. No infallible source like a Pope again. ( remember these religions DONT even CLAIM an infallible judge in this world.)

Now we come to Christianity. You can take it from here. Only the Catholic CLAIMS infallible source proven by history and revelation, for what is need to go to heaven and the means to that end. Catholicism is one’s best bet. If they are wrong then you come back as a cow or something.
 
Bishop Fulton Sheen has a good book on why Christ? Because he was the only one ever preannounced.
 
Here is something that might help. A friend of mine and I came up with it. I call it Pascal Gamble-extended:
We dived the world’s religions by those who accept reincarnation those who don’t. Those who accept reincarnation should be rejected. Why? Because if they are right I will come back again anyway and have another chance to try them.
The liner religions( point A to point B–birth to either heaven/hell) of Judism, Christianity and Islam are my best chances. If they are wrong I have had at least the experience of them and will by this be more enlightened, when I am reincarnated.

Which religion one of these is my best bet?
Which one tells me how to save my soul? Get to point B!
Judism can’t because they have no infallible judge on this earth to tell me. Orthodox Jews will say to turn on a light switch on the Sabbath is mortal sin. But a reformed would say its nonsense. No infallible guide to decide in this world.

Islam the same problem. They say one needs to be 51% good to go to heaven when weighed on Ala’s sword. But what is a sin and how is it forgiven? No one knows. If you murder a man they don’t tell you what you need to do to pay it back. By their system one could lie and then do two good deeds …etc…thus always keeping at least 51% good balance. No infallible source like a Pope again. ( remember these religions DONT even CLAIM an infallible judge in this world.)

Now we come to Christianity. You can take it from here. Only the Catholic CLAIMS infallible source proven by history and revelation, for what is need to go to heaven and the means to that end. Catholicism is one’s best bet. If they are wrong then you come back as a cow or something.
Very well said. I’m not sure if it really addresses: “I can believe in science, evolution, accidents, etc. vs. a religion” but still a great way to encompass it all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top