Although the texts from Matthew and 1 Cor are classic as regards celibacy and certainly constitute a convincing biblical defense, you need to spell out how Rev 14:4 can be used. Some problems I see are the following:
…(3) The apparent equation of “not defiled with women” and “chaste” and celibacy in your blog is disturbing. Faithfully married man are “defiled with women” and not “chaste?”
Excellent observations and kudos for refuting one of your own (a rare occurrence here). I recently had the opportunity to defend celibacy against some of my own–people who think that if it’s Catholic it must be wrong.
I used the same classic texts you mentioned above. But with one caveat. It’s not that celibacy per se is wrong; rather it is the mandatory imposition of celibacy as a condition for being a presbyter (a priest in Catholicism) that is problematic.
- Matthew clearly makes celibacy optional. “Let the one who is able.” And nowhere does Jesus make this a requirement for “clergy” (a bit anachronistic to use that term here, but I think you can see my point).
- Likewise Paul states a strong preference and gives the practical implications: “is busy with the things of the Lord.”
I see two theological implications here. First, celibacy is radically eschatological. It clearly pictures life as it will be, and at the final Resurrection, they “neither marry nor are given in marriage” (Matt. 22:29-30). So the celibate pictures life in the eschaton in one way, even as marriage pictures the final marriage of the lamb to his bride. Neither the one or the other are “superior” in any sense and the longstanding cultural assumption to revere celibacy as somehow a higher and more holy calling is simply error.
If I may add a third observation: All Christians are at least temporarily called to be celibate. This follows from the biblical mandate to abstain from illicit sexual relations outside of marriage. That said, Paul is enough of realist to know that rather than “burn” for one another, if we find ourselves feeling the normal procreative passions, then it is better to marry.
Next, when we see what the actual qualifications for an “elder” are in scripture, over and over again we are told things like, “husband of one wife,” “kids under control” etc. In other words, if there is a “normative” standard (rather than an absolute one) from scripture, it would be for elders to be drawn from the ranks of married men. We should couple all this with the fact that elders are “appointed,” not “ordained” (in any sacramental sense).
So when I put 2 and 2 and 2 more together, I am happy to endorse biblical celibacy and think Catholics are on track when they defend it–especially for those in religious orders, monasteries or even those called to be single. But I think Rome and her defenders are way off base to impose celibacy on their clergy, that they are in fact setting up the opposite norm (if Latin rite priests are in fact “elders”) making celibacy the norm rather than married.
Next, as for the classic objection that celibates don’t know any better because they’re not married–I think we call can reject that as a non-sequitur. But let us not forget the rhetorical question from 1 Timothy 3:5 “if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he care for God’s church?”. We might well put that to any number of “elders,” in the church of Rome.
Further, as for the idea that any church as the right to impose celibacy, that in and of itself is problematic. For Paul, who chose celibacy for himself, nevertheless insists on his right to take a Christian wife. “Don’t we have the right to take a believing wife along with us, as do the other apostles and the Lord’s brothers and Cephas?” (1 Cor. 9:5).
Finally, if it be objected that Paul himself was a priest/elder, yet chose celibacy, I would offer two replies. First–he never describes himself as either; rather he sees himself as an apostle and clearly rejected the notion that celibacy is essential to being an apostle; rather he sees it as eminently practical so that he is free to be about the things of the Lord. Second, elders who become widows (or perhaps even divorced), do not necessarily cease to be elders in my mind, since they have already demonstrated their qualifications to be elders back when they were married. This situation doesn’t seem to be directly envisioned in scripture–but I think we might infer that it is what happen to Peter.
Peter is an apostle, but also calls himself “a fellow elder.” We know he was married, but there is no mention of his wife–only of his mother-in-law. Given his missionary focus, and no mention of the wife, we might plausibly infer that she had died, perhaps even before he had become a disciple.