Defending catholic priests and celibacy. Please help

  • Thread starter Thread starter kancharles
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

kancharles

Guest
Please help me defend the following statement:
“How can Catholic priests give marriage advice when they have no first hand experience on that matter?”
Someone made this argument with me when we were discussing about Catholic priests and celibacy.
Thank you.
 
Please help me defend the following statement:
“How can Catholic priests give marriage advice when they have no first hand experience on that matter?”
How can an OB/GYN give pregnancy advice when he has no first hand experience with the matter?

How can a counselor who has no first hand experience give advice to the mentally ill? The financially ruined? The drug addict?

Hmmm, perhaps because he is trained professionally to do so.
Someone made this argument with me when we were discussing about Catholic priests and celibacy.
Somebody lacks experience in the world.
 
Priests can give good advice because they have given themselves entirely to our Lord, offering themselves completely and for life. This self-giving is the key to relations and growth in holiness.

Priests are keenly aware we live only for a short time and then face particular judgment and then final judgment. Our end will be either heaven or hell - for eternity. A couple has an advantage for attaining heaven by the way of mutual support through hard times mutual promotion of growth in holiness. The priest can shine light on this advantage so the couple uses it effectively.

In my opinion, the most intelligent people you can interact with are those that know who we are (creatures), where we are (exiled from the Garden of Eden), and where we should go (heaven). Priests, not all of them of course but a good portion, have this wisdom. They can impart this and other points of wisdom to a couple if they are ready to receive.
 
Interesting. Thanks for that…
You’re very welcome. Most n-Cs who argue against celibacy will, even if you point out that their celibacy does not preclude their good advice, then attack it on their scriptural bias, and that’s when this article really comes into its own.

May Our Lord grant you words and wisdom than none of your opponents can withstand. (See Luke 21:15)
 
Jesus and Paul were both celibate and both taught about marriage.

Other passages on the power of a celibacy:

Matthew 19:12 For there are some eunuchs, which were so born from their mother’s womb: and there are some eunuchs, which were made eunuchs of men: and there be eunuchs, which have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven’s sake. He that is able to receive it, let him receive it.

1 Corinthians 7:1,7 It is well for a man not to touch a woman…I wish that all were as I myself am. But each has his own special gift from God, one of one kind and one of another.

1 Corinthians 7:32,38 The unmarried man is anxious about the affairs of the Lord, how to please the Lord; but the married man is anxious about worldly affairs, how to please his wife, and his interests are divided…So that he who marries his betrothed does well; and he who refrains from marriage will do better.
 
Please help me defend the following statement:
“How can Catholic priests give marriage advice when they have no first hand experience on that matter?”
Someone made this argument with me when we were discussing about Catholic priests and celibacy.
Thank you.
How can a doctor give smoking and drug adive if he has not tried it? How can a trainer give advice to player if the plays worse than them? How can a therapeut give advice on depression if he is not depressed.

How can a marriage councelor give advice on divorce if he is not divorced? Or give some hints on poligamy, if he is not poligamous?

And how you educate your first child if you never educated any one? And how do you prepare death if you never died?
 
Please help me defend the following statement:
“How can Catholic priests give marriage advice when they have no first hand experience on that matter?”
Someone made this argument with me when we were discussing about Catholic priests and celibacy.
Thank you.
Sometimes a view from the outside is more honest than a view from the inside. People who are married have biases based on their experience. A priest who is not married looks at other married people and be more objective.

Many bad advice comes from people who offer advice based on their experience. Oftentimes they think what worked for them will work for everyone else. That is not true.
 
Tell 'em to take it up with our Lord Jesus Christ. Here’s an article I wrote on my blog that should give you a lot of defensive apologetic ammo.
Priestly celibacy is unBiblical. NOT!
Although the texts from Matthew and 1 Cor are classic as regards celibacy and certainly constitute a convincing biblical defense, you need to spell out how Rev 14:4 can be used. Some problems I see are the following:

(1) The 144,000 is the symbolic number of the redeemed Rev (7:4; 14:1). If the phrase “not defiled with women” is taken as referring literally to the ascetical practice of celibacy in verse 4, it would suggest that only celibate males are saved.
The Vulgate footnote on the Holy See’s web site reads: “One hundred and forty-four thousand: the square of twelve (the number of Israel’s tribes) multiplied by a thousand, symbolic of the new Israel (cf Rev 14:1-5; Gal 6:16; James 1:1) that embraces people from every nation, race, people, and tongue (Rev 7:9).”

(2) Parthenos in Greek is a noun and, in this context, refers to a virgin. The vulgate translates it as “virgines enim sunt.” It is not an adjective. It is the opposite of porne used figuratively in Revelation for those who oppose God, i.e., the “world,” and live in such vices as idolatry, murder, theft, witchcraft, as well as illicit sexual intercourse.
Again, the footnote for Rev 14:4 in the Vulgate reads: “Virgins: metaphorically, because they never indulged in any idolatrous practices, which are considered in the Old Testament to be adultery and fornication (Rev 2:14-15, 20-22; 17:1-6; cf Ezekiel 16:1-58; 23:1-49). The parallel passages (Rev 7:3 [sic]; 22:4) indicate that the 144,000 whose foreheads are sealed represent all Christian people.”

(3) The apparent equation of “not defiled with women” and “chaste” and celibacy in your blog is disturbing. Faithfully married man are “defiled with women” and not “chaste?” This sounds like Jerome’s (in)famous quote referring to Jn 21 and Peter’s being bound by another: “Here we have a proof that virginity does not die, and that the defilement of marriage is not washed away by the blood of martyrdom . . .” Against Jovinianus I, 26]
 
Although the texts from Matthew and 1 Cor are classic as regards celibacy and certainly constitute a convincing biblical defense, you need to spell out how Rev 14:4 can be used. Some problems I see are the following:
…(3) The apparent equation of “not defiled with women” and “chaste” and celibacy in your blog is disturbing. Faithfully married man are “defiled with women” and not “chaste?”
Excellent observations and kudos for refuting one of your own (a rare occurrence here). I recently had the opportunity to defend celibacy against some of my own–people who think that if it’s Catholic it must be wrong.

I used the same classic texts you mentioned above. But with one caveat. It’s not that celibacy per se is wrong; rather it is the mandatory imposition of celibacy as a condition for being a presbyter (a priest in Catholicism) that is problematic.
  1. Matthew clearly makes celibacy optional. “Let the one who is able.” And nowhere does Jesus make this a requirement for “clergy” (a bit anachronistic to use that term here, but I think you can see my point).
  2. Likewise Paul states a strong preference and gives the practical implications: “is busy with the things of the Lord.”
I see two theological implications here. First, celibacy is radically eschatological. It clearly pictures life as it will be, and at the final Resurrection, they “neither marry nor are given in marriage” (Matt. 22:29-30). So the celibate pictures life in the eschaton in one way, even as marriage pictures the final marriage of the lamb to his bride. Neither the one or the other are “superior” in any sense and the longstanding cultural assumption to revere celibacy as somehow a higher and more holy calling is simply error.

If I may add a third observation: All Christians are at least temporarily called to be celibate. This follows from the biblical mandate to abstain from illicit sexual relations outside of marriage. That said, Paul is enough of realist to know that rather than “burn” for one another, if we find ourselves feeling the normal procreative passions, then it is better to marry.

Next, when we see what the actual qualifications for an “elder” are in scripture, over and over again we are told things like, “husband of one wife,” “kids under control” etc. In other words, if there is a “normative” standard (rather than an absolute one) from scripture, it would be for elders to be drawn from the ranks of married men. We should couple all this with the fact that elders are “appointed,” not “ordained” (in any sacramental sense).

So when I put 2 and 2 and 2 more together, I am happy to endorse biblical celibacy and think Catholics are on track when they defend it–especially for those in religious orders, monasteries or even those called to be single. But I think Rome and her defenders are way off base to impose celibacy on their clergy, that they are in fact setting up the opposite norm (if Latin rite priests are in fact “elders”) making celibacy the norm rather than married.

Next, as for the classic objection that celibates don’t know any better because they’re not married–I think we call can reject that as a non-sequitur. But let us not forget the rhetorical question from 1 Timothy 3:5 “if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he care for God’s church?”. We might well put that to any number of “elders,” in the church of Rome.

Further, as for the idea that any church as the right to impose celibacy, that in and of itself is problematic. For Paul, who chose celibacy for himself, nevertheless insists on his right to take a Christian wife. “Don’t we have the right to take a believing wife along with us, as do the other apostles and the Lord’s brothers and Cephas?” (1 Cor. 9:5).

Finally, if it be objected that Paul himself was a priest/elder, yet chose celibacy, I would offer two replies. First–he never describes himself as either; rather he sees himself as an apostle and clearly rejected the notion that celibacy is essential to being an apostle; rather he sees it as eminently practical so that he is free to be about the things of the Lord. Second, elders who become widows (or perhaps even divorced), do not necessarily cease to be elders in my mind, since they have already demonstrated their qualifications to be elders back when they were married. This situation doesn’t seem to be directly envisioned in scripture–but I think we might infer that it is what happen to Peter.

Peter is an apostle, but also calls himself “a fellow elder.” We know he was married, but there is no mention of his wife–only of his mother-in-law. Given his missionary focus, and no mention of the wife, we might plausibly infer that she had died, perhaps even before he had become a disciple.
 
A couple of more thoughts on the celibacy issue…

In any event, the pastoral epistles give us the normative criteria for being an elder. Your church reverses that polarity by imposing celibacy as the norm. This is not only unbiblical, it also has some practical implications. For once one is required to make this calculation: “I want to be a priest, but I have to be celibate in order to do so,” there will be a number of people who choose priesthood in spite of the celibate requirement and simply resolve to make their celibacy their sacrifice–their “cross to bear.” But celibacy is never described as a self-imposed burden; rather it is “given” as a gift. Second, and I think recent history bears this out, celibacy drastically reduces the “pool” of candidates to the Catholic priesthood, even as a shortage of priests creates a need to draw from that shrinking pool. The result is that many bishops are now taking candidates that they would have never taken in the past. You can’t be too picky when you don’t have much to choose from. It isn’t speculation to say that some of these people are surely imbalanced–not because celibacy is per se wrong; rather because the clergy (in any denomination) has always attracted its fair share of cooks. Unfortunately, it is often the “cooks” who make the calculation that they can put up with the celibacy in order to get the power of the priesthood.

This has happened quite a bit in this country. What has been Rome’s response? Move them to another parish and hope it doesn’t happen again. But would these kind of scandals have been as common if there had been a wider pool of qualified candidates to draw from–educated, godly men, who are able to teach, have good standing in the community and who manage their households well. I know many Catholic men who fit this bill. They would all make good priests and if ever a majority of guys like that could become clergy–things would change for the good in Rome.

Here’s another issue. The priesthood is a magnet for men who self-identify as having a homosexual orientation. That’s undeniable. In fact it makes perfect sense. Since homosexual expression is sinful, celibacy is their only biblical option. When you have an entire profession in which celibacy is the key requirement, your going to get large number of men like these joining. In this case, most of these men actually want to be celibate (though not all). So that can be a good thing for them–but a bad thing when they rise in the ranks of leadership in Rome and in religious orders. What you have, essentially, is a dominant homosexual clergy (in places) calling all the shots. Guess what these guys are not likely to do? Give up power. That would happen if they removed celibacy as a requirement, for then all the heterosexual men who are qualified to be priests would soon swell the ranks of the priesthood, and in a generation or two, the clergy at hits highest levels would be run by non-celibate family men. No one is saying this would be without its problems as well. But to my way of thinking, it would be far more preferable–not to mention biblical.
 
A couple of more thoughts on the celibacy issue…

In any event, the pastoral epistles give us the normative criteria for being an elder. Your church reverses that polarity by imposing celibacy as the norm. This is not only unbiblical, it also has some practical implications. For once one is required to make this calculation: “I want to be a priest, but I have to be celibate in order to do so,” there will be a number of people who choose priesthood in spite of the celibate requirement and simply resolve to make their celibacy their sacrifice–their “cross to bear.” But celibacy is never described as a self-imposed burden; rather it is “given” as a gift. Second, and I think recent history bears this out, celibacy drastically reduces the “pool” of candidates to the Catholic priesthood, even as a shortage of priests creates a need to draw from that shrinking pool. The result is that many bishops are now taking candidates that they would have never taken in the past. You can’t be too picky when you don’t have much to choose from. It isn’t speculation to say that some of these people are surely imbalanced–not because celibacy is per se wrong; rather because the clergy (in any denomination) has always attracted its fair share of cooks. Unfortunately, it is often the “cooks” who make the calculation that they can put up with the celibacy in order to get the power of the priesthood.

This has happened quite a bit in this country. What has been Rome’s response? Move them to another parish and hope it doesn’t happen again. But would these kind of scandals have been as common if there had been a wider pool of qualified candidates to draw from–educated, godly men, who are able to teach, have good standing in the community and who manage their households well. I know many Catholic men who fit this bill. They would all make good priests and if ever a majority of guys like that could become clergy–things would change for the good in Rome.

Here’s another issue. The priesthood is a magnet for men who self-identify as having a homosexual orientation. That’s undeniable. In fact it makes perfect sense. Since homosexual expression is sinful, celibacy is their only biblical option. When you have an entire profession in which celibacy is the key requirement, your going to get large number of men like these joining. In this case, most of these men actually want to be celibate (though not all). So that can be a good thing for them–but a bad thing when they rise in the ranks of leadership in Rome and in religious orders. What you have, essentially, is a dominant homosexual clergy (in places) calling all the shots. Guess what these guys are not likely to do? Give up power. That would happen if they removed celibacy as a requirement, for then all the heterosexual men who are qualified to be priests would soon swell the ranks of the priesthood, and in a generation or two, the clergy at hits highest levels would be run by non-celibate family men. No one is saying this would be without its problems as well. But to my way of thinking, it would be far more preferable–not to mention biblical.
I appreciate your measured and thoughtful reflections on this subject. A few observations.

(1) RE the justification for mandatory celibacy a great deal depends on one’s ecclesiology and, behind that, one’s view on how God’s word is transmitted.
These are perennial debates, but you probably know enough about RC theology to be familiar with the reasoning.

(2) Celibacy is not the key requirement for the priesthood: a discerned call from God to ministry is. Celibacy is a disciplinary part of it. Although I think you have some valid points about homosexuality, and you accurately describe a dynamic that has occurred in pockets, there’s no evidence that it is either pervasive or peculiar to RC ministry. Nor is child abuse. Nor is a dearth of vocations to ministry. These are societal issues affecting all denominations.

(3) The RCC’s response to child abuse is complicated by the fact that technical understanding of the pathology was almost at zero in the 50s. True some bishops seem to have just moved clergy and hoped that a stern warning was enough. But most took the prudent steps available to them at the time including listening to the advice of psychologists who said the men were ready to return to ministry. The addictive and irreversable nature of the pathology just was not known then.
 
Miguel you do understand that the Catholic Church doesn’t force anyone to be a priest anymore than it forces anyone into consecrated religious life. Additionally celibacy for the Roman Rite priests is a discipline though there are some doctrinal reasons for the discipline. The Church can dispense with the discipline on an individual basis based on a limited set of circumstances. The Eastern Rite Churches in union with Rome may ordain married men to the priesthood. But single men or widowed men who are priests in the Eastern Rite Churches may not marry. Additionally married priests in the Eastern Rite may not become Bishops. I think I have my facts right.

No one is forced to become a priest or enter consecrated religious life. Therefore no one is forced to embrace life long celibacy.

Permitting married clergy does itself carry risk. Married clergy is hardly a cure all. It was in large part contracepting clergy in the Church of England that caused that communion to deny that contraception is sinful. The rest of the Protestant communities followed. Also who can deny that the fact that some married Protestant clergy will divorce has not had a part in the acceptance of divorce and remarriage in nearly all Protestant traditions.
 
i cannot accept not getting married to the man i believe God put in my life for us to be better people together and to serve God in our marriage together, but a priest doesnt have to have our experience to know what a good marriage is, he can be consecrated to God in i would say married to the Church, and in a way to Jesus as the church is to be the bride, he can know better than me what a good marriage is because he can accept being married to God and the Church without a human experience to prove it to him, unlike people with a vocation to marriage because we need our marriage to understand why Jesus is telling us he is the Husband, i wouldnt doubt that the Holy Spirit could teach a priest more than i could know if he was consecrated in his heart and mind to be loyal only to Jesus and serve the Church. I would think that a priest could help me better deal with my marriage than a married woman who i can not trust her motives cause she may or may not be loyal to me. who would you rather talk to about not bieng a statistic? someone dedicated to God and the church, or someone who you were friends with before you and your women friends got a man and got married? i wouldnt trust a woman to tell me what God says i should do if she were single or married if she were not a nun dedicated to Serving God, i wouldnt trust one of my mans friends to tell me how to deal with my problems in my marriage who isnt a priest dedicated to God to serve the church. I am sure that the Holy Spirit that invented marrriage for us can help us better through people married to God and guide us better through them, cause they may be human, but they are probly less likely to cause a break up or a fight with my fiance or when we are married a divorce than people who dont make themselves chaste for God’s sake and ours. that is my opinion. you may think different. but i just had a nightmare about a woman trying to make a man of God that was a priest part of her times and it was very sad. the poor priest in my nightmare became an eunuch physically by her cause she was so angry that he wouldnt leave the church. this world is trying to do that stuff to Jesus through our mistrust of the Holy Spirit and how GOd can make someone complete and wise without having a mind like ours. i’m not saying i had a revelation of importance. im saying that to dream that was so horrific, the preist in my dream was so devoted to God and the woman was so angry that he loved the church and God with all his body and soul and heart and mind that she castrated him and tried to take his man hood away and the priest did not abuse her, it hurt so bad to have a nightmare like that. i wish that there werent people like that in this world or that our generation would not abuse people who have given themselves to God and the church but it was a nightmare because i think there are people like that in the world. not that you guys are. but it does hurt to look at it like that doesnt it? the church is making Saints, we need to defend them i think.
 
Miguel you do understand that the Catholic Church doesn’t force anyone to be a priest anymore than it forces anyone into consecrated religious life. Additionally celibacy for the Roman Rite priests is a discipline though there are some doctrinal reasons for the discipline. The Church can dispense with the discipline on an individual basis based on a limited set of circumstances. The Eastern Rite Churches in union with Rome may ordain married men to the priesthood. But single men or widowed men who are priests in the Eastern Rite Churches may not marry. Additionally married priests in the Eastern Rite may not become Bishops. I think I have my facts right.

No one is forced to become a priest or enter consecrated religious life. Therefore no one is forced to embrace life long celibacy.

Permitting married clergy does itself carry risk. Married clergy is hardly a cure all. It was in large part contracepting clergy in the Church of England that caused that communion to deny that contraception is sinful. The rest of the Protestant communities followed. Also who can deny that the fact that some married Protestant clergy will divorce has not had a part in the acceptance of divorce and remarriage in nearly all Protestant traditions.
👍 And there are quite a number of cases where this celibacy discipline does not apply.
 
The arguments that people make against cellibacy are fallacious at best. Aside from my formation in theology, I was also a therapist. Being married was not a requirement for those who did marriage counseling, undestanding the issues, family system, male and female psychology, and most importantly, a strong command of communication skills are the important skills. As to experience, well all of us have parents. Many have married siblings, friends and colleagues. There is such a thing as learning through vicarious experience.

The sexual abuse argument does not work either. Marriage does not cure peodophilia. If the person has this disorder, marriage is not going to cure it. We have many married peodophiles. Marriage does not cure homosexuality. Those who engaged in sexual activities with adolscent boys would probably not be inclined to marry a person of the opposite sex. So what does the Church do then, not ordain anyone who does not want to marry because he may be gay or a peodophile?

Marriage is neither a medicine nor a school of human behavior. It does not cure sexual disorders and it does not make you a marriage counselor or a spiritual director.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
The sexual abuse cases are not a valid argument since there is far more abundant evidence that celibacy is not a factor since evidence indicates that it is more prevalent among married men, including n-C clergy. Simple google searches will provide a substantial documentation of same. For example.
Sexual Abuse of Children by Protestant Ministers
sex abuse protestant - Google Search

Might as well drop that point from any such debate of celibacy.
yeah exactly and on top of that alot of pedifiles prefer to marry because they lust after children they lust to create them as well and cannot protect their own children from themselves. its not a “priest issue” its a world issue. if certain “families” were investigated you would find especially where men have more than one wife the crimes sexual and destructive to the soul and the family members are more common sexual offense where men have more than one wife and forty kids. the pedifile wants it all in most cases, the marriage the kids and the experiences that destroy the innocence they pretended to love but they truely lusted after. yeah it happens in families i read about it and since i am a rape victem from age twenty one alot of people have confided in me thier worst experience. even guys in high school gang raped a friend im not in touch with right now and first her uncle raped her over and over, and she asked her friend who took her there why ____ help me____ and she was never the same since. tried suicide, all because one day when she was a child someone had a secret to force on her, and no its everywhere. its not just a few bad priests, and alot of wrongly accused ones. but its all about keeping things quiet is why you dont here right now anyone else in other groups finding a mess of em in thier groups.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top