Defending the Catholic faith

  • Thread starter Thread starter Malia_Belen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Malia_Belen

Guest
I’m interested in the Catholic faith so I’ve been reading books, listening to audios, reading the Bible to try and learn more about the Catholic faith.

Well, I’ve always learned that before you make a decision you should look at both sides in case you have to defend yourself against the other side later. Well, I found website by Protestants(I’m assuming) that I thought I’d look at and see what their objections were. I was thinking that now I could at least defend the Catholic faith in some of these arguments. Well, I got to this sight and they mention all kinds of things…what makes this hard is that I wouldn’t even know where to go to find out if what this sight is saying is wrong or right especially the stumper questions. I know almost nothing when comes to any kind of Church history.

My question: Is there a Catholic website that I could go to now that explains a wide range of topics on objections about the Catholic faith?

I’ve really enjoyed going to Mass this past month and I feel comfortable there but now I’m thinking I need to learn some Catholic apologetics so that I can learn more about the Catholic faith, why it’s the true church and how to use the Bible to defend the Catholic faith. I think I could defend Protestant Christianity…I was brought up protestant but Catholic Christianiy…I don’t know.

Thanks for reading

Oh and here’s the site:

bible.ca/catholic.htm
 
Hi Milia, to start with you are in the right place (or next door). Catholic Answers Home page has lots of material. If you don’t see what you want just use the search to the upper left. They also have links to EWTN and other Catholic sites. Then there is also the good ole Catholic bookstore. You should have one in your area. And of course if you have a question you are in the right place. God Bless
 
If the Roman Catholic church gave the world the Bible, being infallible, then why did Rome reject or question the inspiration of James and Hebrews , then later accept it? Conversely, Rome accepted as scripture books that were later rejected. If the Catholic church really is illuminated by the Holy Spirit so that men can trust her as “God’s organization”, why was she so wrong about something so simple? Should not the “Holy See” have known?
These people simply don’t know their history. The canon was established in the late 4th century and has remained constant ever since. All compendiums of scriptures BEFORE that time were NOT infallible.
If the Roman Catholic church gave the world the Bible in 397 AD, then why did many different versions of canons continue to circulate long afterwards?
without the internet, phones, television, email, radios, etc, it kinda takes a while for information to pass around the world. If they can’t think of the answer to this question, perhaps they should look at their own thought process before looking at our church.
If the Roman Catholic church gave us the Bible, why were the two synods of Hippo (393 AD) and Carthage, (397 AD) African councils, and not initiatives of Rome?
The CATHOLIC church is universal. the LATIN rite is centered in rome, but it is not the ONLY rite of the church, nor are the churches aligned under rome solely loyal to decisions that come out of that specific city. This is another stupid question. The answer to this question makes question number 5 irrelevant.
Since the two synods of Hippo (393 AD) and Carthage, (397 AD) were under the control of what would later become the “orthodox church”, how can the Roman Catholic church claim they determined the Canon? Would not such a claim be more naturally due the Eastern Orthodox church?
This is as stupid as asking “if your grandson murders someone, shouldn’t YOU go to jail?” The fact that specific churches became orthodox or not has NOTHING to do with their participation while they were not in schism. Further, the regions mentioned have both catholics and orthodox members in the area, so this question is doubly irrelevant.
If the Catholic church, “by her own inherent God given power and authority” gave the world the Bible, why did she not get it right the first time? Why did the Roman Catholic church wait until 1546 AD in the Council of Trent, to officially add the Apocrypha to the Canon?
Patent hogwash relying on the fact that people are probably ignorant of history. I happen to have SEEN handwritten copies of the bible dating far before 1546 which include the deuterocanoniacal books. In REALITY, almost all bibles, even protestant translations, included those books until around the 1700s.

the next question is irrelevant. We choose the church with the valid claim to historical apostolic succession.
Provide a single example of where inspired apostolic “oral revelation” (tradition) differed from “written” (scripture)?
This is a trick question, and a stupid one at that. Since sacred tradition and written tradition are BOTH considered infallible truth, they CANNOT conflict (differ) with each other.
How do you account for the vast number of documented theological errors made by the pope and the church in general?
really? Name one.
If the both the Orthodox and Catholic churches follow apostolic oral tradition exactly, how come they teach doctrine so different, that they are not even in communion with each other?
Last time i checked, our doctrine is VERY similar. In fact, almost none of it contradicts. The truth of the matter is that the orthodox church takes a higher stance of mystery than the catholic church does. so what?
Both Tertullian and Jerome …
last time i checked Tertullian and Jerome weren’t apostles, nor did they make ex cathedra statements on the subject. even so, the stumper questions section fails to list catholic practices that DO stand in keeping with the named traditions.
 
Why do Roman Catholics always use 2 Timothy 2:2; 3:14 as Bible proof that extra-biblical oral tradition is to be followed through apostolic succession, when tradition says Timothy became the bishop of Ephesians, which through succession, is now part of the Greek Orthodox church headed out of Constantinople? If 2 Timothy 2:2 proves succession, doesn’t this prove the Roman Catholic church is not part of that succession?
Same point as before. The fact that a FUTURE decision by schismatic members was made does nothing to the past choices by members of the catholic church. Irrelevant question
When you see the word tradition, why do you always assume it to be oral tradition rather than scripture tradition, when the Bible calls scripture tradition in 2 Thess 2:15, and Athanasius call scripture tradition: “the Apostolic tradition teaches in the words of blessed Peter, 'Forasmuch then as Christ suffered for us in the Flesh” Athanasius then quotes: 1 Peter 4:1; Titus 2:13; Heb 2:1 (Athanasius, To Adelphius, Letter 60, 6)?
another irrelevant question. Catholics all know that sacred tradition refers to both oral and written tradition.
The Church Fathers believed what Paul said in Eph 3:3-5, that the scripture could be understood by merely reading it.
To the contrary. Ephesians 3:3-5 says nothing about the scriptures as a whole being written such that ANYONE can infallibly interpret them. What Ephesians 3 states is that PAUL’S LETTER was written to increase the knowledge of Christ. IN FACT, Ephesians 3:5 states that truth is revealed now to the APOSTLES and PROPHETS, so this point relies on the fact that you won’t actually open your bible to see that they are lying.
If each individual possessing a copy of the scriptures is an essential pre-condition to sola Scriptura, then how do illiterate Catholic and Orthodox pew-dwellers know the Catholic and Orthodox Catechisms? If illiterate Catholics and Orthodox can have the Catechisms read to them, then why not the scripture?
stupid question if you attend a mass. The mass is MOSTLY scripture. Further, if you attend sunday mass for 3 years, you will hear 90+% of the bible during that time. If you never even opened the book but faithfully attended mass, you would still encounter more of the bible than most protestants do. Conversely, most catholics aren’t familiar with the catechism at all.
If universal distribution of the Bible in every home is an essential pre-condition of sola Scriptura, then how could Catholic and Orthodox pew-dwellers know the message of the Pope before the time of modern instant live communication?
same way we knew the scriptures. Announcements at mass.
If the ability to read is an essential pre-condition to sola Scriptura, then how do the illiterate Catholic and Orthodox commoner know for certain that the priest is faithfully teaching the dogma, canons and edicts of councils if they could not read the documents?
this ignores the fact that the church has had ways to police itself for its entire existance.
If the earliest, universal oral tradition clearly states that Paul wrote the book of Hebrews, why does the Roman Catholic church question this tradition to this day? (The Orthodox, are at least consistent in accepting this tradition, not that they are correct.)
I wasn’t aware that we did question this. Next.
Name one sure way or method, that a new believer in Christ, can know that the Roman Catholic church is the one true church. (The challenge: make sure this method cannot apply also to the Orthodox church.)
Succession of first apostles all the way back to Peter, who was appointed himself by Christ. In fact, this wouldn’t apply to ANY other church.
If the personal illumination of the Holy Spirit upon each believer to understand the Bible is not a valid method of determining truth because of the many denominations that use this approach, then does it not follow that apostolic succession and oral church traditions are likewise invalid because the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches are two denominations that use this method yet are divided on doctrine? Does this not prove both methods are wrong and a third method, one which we and the apostolic church practiced must be the correct method?
There is no such thing as “personal illumination of the Holy Spirit.” This isn’t even scriptural. Further, as already stated, the orthodox and the catholics are not doctrinally unsound when compared to each other. HOWEVER, the orthodox church HAS left more undefined in some areas, while defining things that the catholic church has not yet had revealed.
 
I’m interested in the Catholic faith so I’ve been reading books, listening to audios, reading the Bible to try and learn more about the Catholic faith.

Well, I’ve always learned that before you make a decision you should look at both sides in case you have to defend yourself against the other side later. Well, I found website by Protestants(I’m assuming) that I thought I’d look at and see what their objections were. I was thinking that now I could at least defend the Catholic faith in some of these arguments. Well, I got to this sight and they mention all kinds of things…what makes this hard is that I wouldn’t even know where to go to find out if what this sight is saying is wrong or right especially the stumper questions. I know almost nothing when comes to any kind of Church history.

My question: Is there a Catholic website that I could go to now that explains a wide range of topics on objections about the Catholic faith?

I’ve really enjoyed going to Mass this past month and I feel comfortable there but now I’m thinking I need to learn some Catholic apologetics so that I can learn more about the Catholic faith, why it’s the true church and how to use the Bible to defend the Catholic faith. I think I could defend Protestant Christianity…I was brought up protestant but Catholic Christianiy…I don’t know.

Thanks for reading

Oh and here’s the site:

bible.ca/catholic.htm
Although this is a good way of finding out the ‘usual’ misconceptions about The Church, and their refutations, I dislike the “conditions” you place on yourself in order to become Catholic.

If you are serious about becoming Catholic, you should simply learn for yourself WHAT that entails and decide on the merits of your journey and research.

You cannot defend something you do not understand yourself or do not believe in.

Research The Church for yourself so you can make an informed decision about ‘Swimming The Tiber.’ The ‘swim’ you take alone, with God. No one else! He calls you, you swim! We and the Angels may be praying encouragement, but IT IS ENTIRELY YOUR ‘SWIM.’

Thereafter, even with limited knowledge of the faith, whenever you encounter the ‘anti’ views, you will know WHERE TO LOOK for the answers, because The Church will be the anchor of your faith. Not the opinions of Her members!

:cool:
 
I think I could defend Protestant Christianity…I was brought up protestant but Catholic Christianiy…I don’t know.
I’m afraid it’s not possible to defend Protestant Chriastianity. That’s because Protestants strongly disobey Jesus: they reject the leadership of the pope, they have no Eucharist, just bread and wine, no priesthood, no confession, don’t agree with Marian devotion (“I will be blessed by all generations” - not by Protestants, unfortunatelly). In the Catholic Church God shows His power not only by healings or raising from the dead (I admit Protestants can also have it) but also amazing miracles like Eucharistic miralces, Fatima or Guadelupe - they just don’t happen in separated denominations.

What are your doubts about the Catholic Church?
 
I’m interested in the Catholic faith so I’ve been reading books, listening to audios, reading the Bible to try and learn more about the Catholic faith.

Well, I’ve always learned that before you make a decision you should look at both sides in case you have to defend yourself against the other side later. Well, I found website by Protestants(I’m assuming) that I thought I’d look at and see what their objections were. I was thinking that now I could at least defend the Catholic faith in some of these arguments. Well, I got to this sight and they mention all kinds of things…what makes this hard is that I wouldn’t even know where to go to find out if what this sight is saying is wrong or right especially the stumper questions. I know almost nothing when comes to any kind of Church history.

My question:
Is there a Catholic website that I could go to now that explains a wide range of topics on objections about the Catholic faith?

I’ve really enjoyed going to Mass this past month and I feel comfortable there but now I’m thinking I need to learn some Catholic apologetics so that I can learn more about the Catholic faith, why it’s the true church and how to use the Bible to defend the Catholic faith. I think I could defend Protestant Christianity…I was brought up protestant but Catholic Christianity…I don’t know.

Thanks for reading

Oh and here’s the site:

bible.ca/catholic.htmOkay, this is not exactly in compliance with the Banned Topics but since you are asking for answers to this misbegotten a-C site, I am going to respond and do my best to refute it all. Some of it is specious trash, but I’ll deal with that when it comes along.
Code:
   The First Reason I Left Is Because The Catholics Do Not Have The Right Attitude Toward The Truth.
This is hogwash because I for one am well known for testing everything that comes along to insure that I follow the truth. In fact, that is the very reason that I am Catholic. My Testimony
The Next Reason I Left Is Because The Bible Only Is The All Sufficient Guide To Salvation, But The Catholic Church Teaches That It Is Not.
This is the fundamental error of almost all n-C Christian religions. It is not found with the Bible, (not even a Catholic Bible with all 73 books in it!). Sola Scriptura - The Bible Alone? and **** MATERIAL AND FORMAL SUFFICIENCY andWhat Exactly Do You Mean by Sola Scriptura?
**The Third Reason I Left Is Because Christ Did Not Make His Church Infallible As The Catholic Church Teaches. **
These articles will refute this specious statement.
A Fourth Reason I Left Was Because Christ Did Not Make Peter A Pope.
Really? “Pope” is just a title of endearment & respect that Catholics use for the successor or St. Peter, however, papal succession and authority are taught in scripture and the writings of the early church, as the links above have already shown.

(Cont’d)
 
I’m not going to wast time and space refuting all of the second guy’s “testimony” because the above links have already dealt with most of his misrepresentations. I will offer the following links because he does try to allege that the Catholic Church is pagan in origin which is just further specious polemics.
The Anti-Catholic Bible
Anti-Catholic Whoppers
Catholic Inventions
More Catholic Inventions
The Inquisition
The Whore of Babylon Hunting the Whore of Babylon
Is Catholicism Pagan?

I have found some other things in his polemics that can easily be refuted.
Where Is Purgatory?Biblical and Jewish Traditional Beliefs About Purgatory

Indulgences The Key To PurgatoryMore hogwash…
Primer on Indulgences
Myths About Indulgences

Confessing Sins To PriestsCatholic Confession
My Reformation Theory
“I Find No Sacraments In the Bible” he said.
The “Boettner List”: Fact or Fiction?

Images In The Catholic ChurchIconoclasm: Or: Catholics Worship Graven Images NOT
BTW, Catholics have not ever, do not now, and never will, worship Mary.
The Intercession of the Saints (Fathers*)
Praying to the Saints
Saint Worship?
Do Catholics Worship Statues?
Relics

The Worship Of Mary The Goddess Of HeavenThe glories of Mary is not doctrine…it’s a devotion of a very holy man. In fact it is more of a love letter to her than anything else. Most of the clowns who attack this have never even read it so the yank stuff out of context and run with it, which is what this particular a-C clown has done. As for the Rosary… The Rosary

(Cont’d)
 
Mother Of God
This is laughable. Look at what the three "Pillars of the Reformation had to say about this.

The three “pillars of the reformation”, Luther, Calvin, and Zwingli, all believed that Mary was the mother of God.

Mother of God

Martin Luther: “In this work whereby she was made the Mother of God, so many and such good things were given her that no one can grasp them… Not only was Mary the mother of Him who is born [in Bethlehem], but of Him who, before the world, was eternally born of the Father, from a Mother in time and at the same time man and God.” (The Works of Luther, English translation by Pelikan, Concordia, St. Louis, Vol. 7, page 572)

John Calvin: “It cannot be denied that God in choosing and destining Mary to be the Mother of His Son, granted her the highest honor…Elizabeth calls Mary Mother of the Lord, because the unity of the person in the two natures of Christ was such that she could have said that the mortal man engendered in the womb of Mary was at the same time the eternal God.” (Calvini Opera, Corpus reformatorum, Braunschweig-Berlin, 1863-1900, Vol. 45, page 348 and 335.)

Ulrich Zwingli: “It was given to her what belongs to no creature, that in the flesh she should bring forth the Son of God.” ( Zwingli Opera, Corpus reformatorum, Berlin, 1905, in Evang. Luc., Op. Comp., Vol.
6, I, page 639.)

The Perpetual Virginity of Mary:

Martin Luther: “ It is an article of faith that Mary is Mother of the Lord and still a virgin… Christ, we believe, came forth from a womb left perfectly intact.” ( Works of Luther, Vol. 11, pages 319-320; Vol. 6, page 510.)

John Calvin: “ There have been certain folk who have wished to suggest from this passage [Matthew 1:25] that the Virgin Mary had other children than the Son of God, and that Joseph had then dwelt with her later; but what folly this is! For the gospel writer did not wish to record what happened afterwards; he simply wished to make clear Joseph’s obedience and to show that Joseph had been well and truly assured that it was God who had sent His angel to Mary. He had therefore never dwelt with her nor had he shared her company… And beside this Our Lord Jesus Christ is called the first-born. This is not because there was a second or a third, but because the gospel writer is paying regard to the precedence. Scripture speaks thus of naming the first-born whether or no there was any question of the second.” (Sermon on Matthew 1:22-25. Published in 1562.)

Ulrich Zwingli: “I firmly believe that Mary, according to the words of the gospel, as a pure Virgin brought forth for us the Son of God and in childbirth and after childbirth forever remained a pure, intact Virgin.” ( Zwingli Opera, Vol. 1, page 424.)
(Cont’d)
 
I think that should sufficiently rack up these arguments, but if you find more just PM me and let me know and I’ll burn them down too.

These guys try to tell people that Catholics are all ignorant dupes of some conspiracy theory anti-Christ church and that is so far from the truth that it makes them look like precisely what they are… liars.

If you want a link to a couple of sites that will give you strong defenses of the Catholic faith then here are two good ones and my own blog.
The Catholic Answers Online Library
Bible Christian Society
Apocalypsis
 
Thank you so much everyone especially Promethius and Church Militant for your answers and links to different places so that I can learn about the Catholic Church 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top