Defending the Faith-links needed

  • Thread starter Thread starter Wayward_Wind
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

Wayward_Wind

Guest
Friends and family and not-so-friends have been taking the opportunity to offer me their perspective on the stories flying all over the news media about “pedophile priest and the Church’s cover-up”. I want to defend the Church armed with facts; good and bad but truthful.

Over the past several weeks I’ve read, as I’m sure many other Catholic posters have, fact-based articles that put in perspective the events which really took place which have embroiled the Catholic Church and led to so many attacks from outside the Church. But I can’t recall if any covered the story in total (e.g. Ireland, Milwaukee, etc.)

I need one or two really good links to articles that do the best job of explaining what really went wrong, what has been and is being done to correct it and offer perspective of problems magnitude.
 
If this happened with ANY OTHER group besides CATHOLICS, it wouldn’t even be on the radar.There are 46,000 Roman Catholic priests in the United States and about 0.7% were involved in abusing children. So 0.7% of 46,000 is 322. There are about 10,000,000 teachers in the US. 5% have abused children. 5% of 10,000,000 is 500,000! More than 1,500 times as many teachers are abusers than priests. In about 16% of the cases, administrators worked to cover it up, so 16% of 500,000 - thats 80,000. So the public schools covered up almost 250 times as many cases of abuse then were committed by all Roman Catholic priests.

Where’s the outrage? Where are the news stories? These are people who’s PRIMARY job is to be with children unlike a priest whose primary job is not to be with children, thus giving teachers more opportunity to abuse more children. 80,000 of them were shuffled around to do it all over again.

Just to put this into perspective since folks may have a hard time grasping the large numbers …

You have 1 priest who SOMETIMES interacts with children and abuses them. You also have 1,552 teachers who ALWAYS interact with children and abuse them. And, 248 of those teachers escape punishment because they are shuffled around to do it again.

Anyone who focuses on the one priest while not paying AT LEAST, if not GREATER, attention to the fifteen hundred teachers, is clearly not motivated by justice or the safety of the children. The question needs to be asked: what is their true motivation?
 
There is a great set of links to relevant (and very helpful) articles on the Pope’s fan site. Go to:

ratzingerfanclub.com/

Under the banner/picture at the top there is a list of links. The one on the far right is “The Crisis”. The links there are terrific - I teach RCIA and I used much of the info in defending the Holy Father.

Hope they help you too.
 
If this happened with ANY OTHER group besides CATHOLICS, it wouldn’t even be on the radar.There are 46,000 Roman Catholic priests in the United States and about 0.7% were involved in abusing children. So 0.7% of 46,000 is 322. There are about 10,000,000 teachers in the US. 5% have abused children. 5% of 10,000,000 is 500,000! More than 1,500 times as many teachers are abusers than priests. In about 16% of the cases, administrators worked to cover it up, so 16% of 500,000 - thats 80,000. So the public schools covered up almost 250 times as many cases of abuse then were committed by all Roman Catholic priests.

Where’s the outrage? Where are the news stories? These are people who’s PRIMARY job is to be with children unlike a priest whose primary job is not to be with children, thus giving teachers more opportunity to abuse more children. 80,000 of them were shuffled around to do it all over again.

Just to put this into perspective since folks may have a hard time grasping the large numbers …

You have 1 priest who SOMETIMES interacts with children and abuses them. You also have 1,552 teachers who ALWAYS interact with children and abuse them. And, 248 of those teachers escape punishment because they are shuffled around to do it again.

Anyone who focuses on the one priest while not paying AT LEAST, if not GREATER, attention to the fifteen hundred teachers, is clearly not motivated by justice or the safety of the children. The question needs to be asked: what is their true motivation?
I’ve been away for a while (Rome for a great tour of the Holy sites and relics!) and I just returned. This is a great quote fellow Knight; can you provide sources that I can reference?
 
If this happened with ANY OTHER group besides CATHOLICS, it wouldn’t even be on the radar.There are 46,000 Roman Catholic priests in the United States and about 0.7% were involved in abusing children. So 0.7% of 46,000 is 322. There are about 10,000,000 teachers in the US. 5% have abused children. 5% of 10,000,000 is 500,000! More than 1,500 times as many teachers are abusers than priests. In about 16% of the cases, administrators worked to cover it up, so 16% of 500,000 - thats 80,000. So the public schools covered up almost 250 times as many cases of abuse then were committed by all Roman Catholic priests.

Where’s the outrage? Where are the news stories? These are people who’s PRIMARY job is to be with children unlike a priest whose primary job is not to be with children, thus giving teachers more opportunity to abuse more children. 80,000 of them were shuffled around to do it all over again.

Just to put this into perspective since folks may have a hard time grasping the large numbers …

You have 1 priest who SOMETIMES interacts with children and abuses them. You also have 1,552 teachers who ALWAYS interact with children and abuse them. And, 248 of those teachers escape punishment because they are shuffled around to do it again.

Anyone who focuses on the one priest while not paying AT LEAST, if not GREATER, attention to the fifteen hundred teachers, is clearly not motivated by justice or the safety of the children. The question needs to be asked: what is their true motivation?
Hi sir knight.
That is an interesting post. It’s good to see the actually numbers of abuses are so low. (it would be even better if they were zero, but it isn;t a perfect world) I would like to use those figures you posted in a debate i am having with a atheist. But i know he will demand a link. To back up those figures. Do you have one?
While on the topic. Could anyone explain this persons claims.
richardsipe.com/Click_and_Learn/2005-10-05-Celibate_Myth.html

It was posted by someone to prove that the number of pedophile priest is around 7.8 %
Supposedly this post proves it But maybe I’m a little slow. But i can;t see any hard evidence that proves anything of the sort.
 
I started a thread in another forum, but I think it applies to this thread as well, and will help you with what you need. I have just about every link that you can think of in this thread. In here you will find letters from Justin Martyr that date back to about 150 A.D., that explain the celebration of the Catholic Mass perfectly. You will find a website that is loaded with Eucharistic miracles, threads & stories about different saints, A great Catholic website that teaches and defends the Catholic faith, quotes from many great Saints of the Catholic Church and much much more.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=440185

Please let me know if this helps and God bless friend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top