Defensive or abusive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SDMom82
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m sorry that you had such an unpleasant experience. It seems to me that you both play a part in your problems. You obviously need to learn how to communicate with each other better and of course some counseling could help you.

Here are some observations though. It’s clear you can see the errors that your dh makes in your relationship, but are you able to sit back and evaluate your actions more clearly and how you contributed to the scenario. Not about the fact that YOU slapped him, but long before that ever came about.

From just the tiny bit of insight I can get into your relationship, I can’t help but wonder if you constantly need to ask him for just a little more, or to do things exactly as you want. That every decision he makes is not good enough and you need to ask him to do better or more.

He wanted to park, you wanted to get closer despite it seems that it is obviously a very busy place you were going to. He wanted to leave, and you had already said you were cold and tired, carrying a heavy baby, and YET, you wanted just 5 more minutes.

These probably seem like little things to you, HOWEVER, I see little signs that some may not see. You, may have a need to always have things be YOUR way, you may always need to make the decisions and then when you are wrong, you want him to fix them. Telling him to park a little closer, telling him not to bring the stroller just because you didn’t see anybody else with one and then wanting him to go back and get it when you do, wanting just 5 more minutes when obviously the night had already not gone that well, you were both cold, tired and cranky etc.

If these were isolated incidents, sure it seems like no big deal, but my bet would be, that these are the kind of things you always do, which leads him to feel like any decision he ever makes is wrong, or not good enough and so then he reverts to acting childish and giving you the silent treatment and unwilling to move on

So while you both need to work on your communication and reactions, I think it’s really easy in a marriage to see our spouse’s faults but to ignore the constant nagging and tearing down we do of our partner.

Most marriages don’t erode because of some big crisis, they erode because of the little, yet constant, pick, nag, never good enough, your wrong wrong wrong, type of messages that one spouse gives another.

I pray your dh’s mother is OK and I pray that the two of you learn to love and respect each other the way that need to, in order to make a marriage work.

God Bless
great post!👍
 
Stepping in quickly as a humble husband, I see your husband did not act like prince charming - but he was pushed over the edge. In your weariness and eventual anger you made very little sense and made a lot of noise showing it.

Not hearing his side of the story, it appears you were the abuser.

Good luck and God bless!
I agree, she is the abuser and abusers often blame their abusive actions on their spouse (her husband). She is in complete denial that she physically abused him.
 
Hi all, thank you so much for your prayers, thoughtful concerns and comments. You are all so wonderful! *sending prayers back to each of you

What a difference a day made. Last night I was still angry when I wrote that post. Now everything seems to make sense. Time (and sleep!) really is a wonderful thing.

I agree that this is rather intimate, and my anonymity in the internet has been a blessing. I am rather reluctant to share this w/ family & friends irl because that would create a faction. Both of us are really wonderful, fun-loving and warm persons that people want to hang out with. Only last weekend… well we really sorry for the couple that has to witness THAT.

My husband has fault of his own and he can regress to a child when he goes berserk, but since I am the one who posted here I will take responsibility for my side of the story.

I think both of us are really hot-headed in our own ways. He is more visible since he’s an extrovert - shouting, scoffing, pouting and refusal to do stuff. I’m more invisible, and the way I express my anger is through put downs in a condescending way (Mrs know-it-all syndrome) - I’m aware of this as it happened so often and I realize that this is a shortcoming.

If the table is turned, I may not be as forgiving as he is right now. There is no excuse for my behavior. Let’s just say that I gain a new outlook for all the domestic violence and how it really started. I used to be very judgmental and blaming the perpetrator for losing control, and always identified myself with the victims. Now I can look back and see the struggle faced by the perpetrators before it happened.

I’m very surprised that it escalated to that point. Now I can see that Vanity is my greatest cross… I always pride myself of having better judgement, better knowledge and better control. So for me to be out of control when “The jar overflow”, it is such a humbling experience. It is so disconcerting since I was the one who asked him to go to church, taking bible lessons, reading Catechism on a regular basis, and Imitation of Christ is one of my favorite book. Again, I discover that I’m not invisible to evil doings. On Saturday Night, I prayed Our Father and gain a new understanding on the phrase: “Lead us not into TEMPTATION, but deliver us from EVIL”

Thanks again for your prayers, comments & concerns. As for now, the hubby will have to leave overseas to take care of family matter and I pray that this break will give us the time to prepare for a good & fruitful marriage counseling.

Peace be with you!
I just read this post. Good for you! You understand a lot.

I’m in counselling right now and it’s helping me a lot. It takes a big person to admit they need help.

When my son had colic, my husband shoved me once (not hard) and it shocked me. He can be verbally abusive also, but it scared me when he shoved me. He hasn’t done it since and I hope he never does.

You’re not alone. I’d say that half of married couples have had domestic violence peer it’s ugly head into their marriage at least once.
 
I was about to post the same before I read Havard’s post. There’s trouble there. A woman could do that in despair but a normal man does not threaten to call 911 or a lawyer on a woman or even think about pressing domestic violence charges out of retaliation. When I read “lawyer”, I thought “divorce”.

As for your fight, I can’t comment with reliability because you were both tired, worked up, prone to fighting, both crossed the boundaries, and I only have your version. I can say your husband’s behaviour was not normal but you overreacted too (and pardon my saying this so directly but both of you could use better anger management). This may be and probably is a sign of deeper underlying problems or it could be an occasional snapping out of two tired people (loss of sleep does work this way, as does tiredness, stress, and a feeling of being treated unfairly… this is why doctors, lawyers and other such overworked professionals sometimes blow up and dazzle others).

What’s definitely not acceptable for him is to belittle you in front of friends, as long as he was addressing the friends and telling them about you or making a show for their benefit (merely failing to control himself more tightly while people are present is still a problem but a lesser one), or telling you he just wouldn’t be carrying or holding or calming the baby. It is simply not acceptable for a grown man to take a woman to carry the baby around because he won’t be doing it (doesn’t care to do it, actually), or refuse to calm a crying baby. It worries me that he wouldn’t take responsibility for his baby, and that he would call 911 on a woman, both of which very unmanly behaviours, sort of acting like a boy, not a man. Gotta either man up or stop cracking up in my uneducated opinion. I won’t be writing more because it would be lucky guessing and don’t have training or experience to do it reliably.

Yeah but he gets no rights to lord it over her and use at as a weapon. In our culture we have this mindset that actual physical violence, even of a very slight degree, is so much more unacceptable than whatever psychic torment other people employ. In my view his treatment of her was likely more abusive than hers of him (even considering we only have the OP’s version of the events), she only violated a bigger outward taboo than he did.

@OP: If he does file some sort of report, go to a lawyer, as liability can be reduced in such cases (basing on your statement that essentially you snapped and “something happened” automatically as a result of his building up the pressure on you).

EDIT: I’ve just thought It’s also not acceptable to take charge and start meting out punishment by first making you drive (especially with shouts and whatnot), then forcing you to carry the baby etc. A spouse does not have this kind of authority over the other, and the other spouse does not need to submit to that (we’re not talking about “if you don’t like the way I wash the dishes/hang the laundry, you can do it yourself”). That was plenty of violence already. I’m not saying this to set you (i.e. the OP) against him but to help you know where your behaviour stands and where his behaviour does, so that you don’t get manoeuvred into thinking you did something horribly wrong and he did not. In fact, manipulating non-assertive people into violent outburst is a known tactic, conscious or not (children sometimes do that, as do mean sons of guns in certain job lines). It allows the bully to make his victim feel helpless because there’s no way of defence (talking doesn’t work, nothing works… so violence is employed, and violence makes it look like the victim, not the bully is guilty in the first place, totally defeating the victim). I’m not saying this happened here, not in the extreme version, but there are some similarities.
Great post! Also, I recommend Retrouvaille marriage workshops as the alternative to marriage counseling. My concern is that if you go to marriage counseling, then the “slap” will be documented and can be used against you in divorce court. And yes, it can be taken seriously by a court system. Even if you work individually with a therapist, your records can be ordered by the court. I am concerned that your husband has threatened your child’s custody, and this needs to be taken very seriously. Custody fights happen for lots of reasons, one of them being for a spouse to get out of paying child support, despite the effect it may have on the child. His threat sounds like a threat against the wellbeing of the child. Of course, I don’t know the entire situation, but this does sound really concerning. Assuming you have never harmed your child, and that you have never slapped your husband before, threats to call a lawyer are not typically the first thing to pop up during a marital fight. If you go to Retrouvaille, the marriage work you would do would not be documented, as far as I know. This is a better option. I also would start working with a priest or nun and have regular contact with them for possible help should your husband actually file for divorce in a few years from now. Your slap may very well have been a one time error in judgement, but I have concerns that your husband’s comments may indicate that he has been considering to end the marriage. The fact that he was still talking about the potential of having called 911 over a face slap a day after the incident happened reinforces this concern and makes it look like he may be willing to use unfair tactics.
Blessings and good luck!
 
Great post! Also, I recommend Retrouvaille marriage workshops as the alternative to marriage counseling. My concern is that if you go to marriage counseling, then the “slap” will be documented and can be used against you in divorce court. And yes, it can be taken seriously by a court system. Even if you work individually with a therapist, your records can be ordered by the court. I am concerned that your husband has threatened your child’s custody, and this needs to be taken very seriously. Custody fights happen for lots of reasons, one of them being for a spouse to get out of paying child support, despite the effect it may have on the child. His threat sounds like a threat against the wellbeing of the child. Of course, I don’t know the entire situation, but this does sound really concerning. Assuming you have never harmed your child, and that you have never slapped your husband before, threats to call a lawyer are not typically the first thing to pop up during a marital fight. If you go to Retrouvaille, the marriage work you would do would not be documented, as far as I know. This is a better option. I also would start working with a priest or nun and have regular contact with them for possible help should your husband actually file for divorce in a few years from now. Your slap may very well have been a one time error in judgement, but I have concerns that your husband’s comments may indicate that he has been considering to end the marriage. The fact that he was still talking about the potential of having called 911 over a face slap a day after the incident happened reinforces this concern and makes it look like he may be willing to use unfair tactics.
Blessings and good luck!
These are all very good points.
 
Print your post, get important documents, pack for you and baby and go to a domestic violence shelter now.

Do not get in the car with him again. This is one of those situations where in a few monts someone (wife, husband or child) ends up dead.

If he does call 911 or have the poliece over have this post ready. But your best bet is to leave now. Your life…and your sons…may depend on it.
this is absolutely sensationalist advice, especially the part bolded. Both sides in this argument have much to improve upon (I’d like to hear the husband’s side), but nothing is helped by telling a woman who slapped her husband after a rough day that her life and her child’s are in no uncertain terms likely in danger!
 
I can relate to this story, to some degree. My husband slips into rages sometimes, even though he’s normally a very kind and considerate man. When he’s in a rage, he gets unreasonable and will often say things that he doesn’t mean (he’s never physically violent or even verbally threatening, but he can say hurtful things). I have learned to leave him alone until he calms down, and the rages are reducing over the years. Sometimes I can get through to him, but only if I stay calm (the husband-whisperer ;)).

It sounds like the situation you were in was just a major stressor. Difficulty finding a carpark, crowded shopping, carrying a baby, long hours spent shopping. Neither of you were at your best. I wonder if it would have been better to just go home and try again another time. These are the situations that bring out our worst. I imagine that you were feeling resentful at having to drive and then carry baby, and your husband was feeling resentful at being told what to do (and the things he was told turned out to be the wrong choice). In both of you, there was the feeling of being right, and being slighted.

Remember that the only person you can change or control is yourself. BUT, often when you control yourself and modify your behaviour, it affects others and they therefore change their behaviour. So rather than dwell on feelings of superiority, try and really be the better person, and see what comes of it.
 
Dear Friend in Christ,

I understand your exhaustion and the concerns you have as a wife and mother of a young child. As to your husband being a good father, I’m sure there are times when he pitches in to help, but he must be made to realize that a great part of being a good father is showing respect for one’s wife, the mother of his child. The same goes for wives, but you are in a troubling situation here.

There are people, male and female, who seem to have a psychological need to vent, to explode with anger and verbal abuse, and then suddenly they will stop and act as if nothing has happened. This causes everyone around them to feel as if they have to walk on eggshells. The verbal abuser can’t remember the ferocity of his or her maniacal behavior and wonders why the others seem to be holding a grudge.

Meanwhile, you have also felt insulted after your unbelievable experience in traffic, followed by having to carry your child, shivering inside the store with a husband acting like a selfish tyrant.

To drive with a child and spouse in the car means taking the responsibility for precious souls. Counseling is certainly needed for you both, as this is escalating dangerously. I do worry for your child too, who may grow up in this environment if things don’t change.

There is always hope: If one of your friends or relatives can take you in while you gather your thoughts together, or if you can find a safe shelter, you might find the time you need to rest so that you can make important decisions. After the emergency with his overseas relative comes to a head, the same problems will still be there, so counseling will be an ongoing need. You’re not alone, but you’re unique and precious in God’s sight, as is your little one.

The constant roller coaster of being with someone with a trigger temper is exhausting. You cannot walk on egg shells after each explosive episode and then be expected to act as if nothing has happened. Please know that my prayers are with you, that you find a safe place to rest where you and your baby can have some quiet time while you consider your plans.

Our Lady surely grieves for your hurt feelings, and She is also One who can inspire us to respect our dignity as women and mothers. God sees your husband’s heart too, but your safety and your child’s is paramount here. If you would let your parish priest know of the situation as well, and surround yourself with friends who care, you will have time to think this through. We all need help in these confusing times, and prayers from people who care about us, and that you have here in abundance.
Peace in Christ.
 
Please don’t leave your husband like one poster suggested. Work it out with him. 😦
Talk to a priest. I’ll be praying for you and your marriage and child. God bless you.
 
I agree, she is the abuser and abusers often blame their abusive actions on their spouse (her husband). She is in complete denial that she physically abused him.
I’ve retyped this post several times by now. We don’t know what happened there, that is how mean exactly he was to her and how hard exactly she slapped him. There’s a whole world of difference between an unwarranted hard slap on the face and an impulsive reaction of a woman driven to her last limits by a man’s rude behaviour. The last has little to do with real domestic violence or abuse. In fact, using the abuse language is prone to making us fall for the magic of words and summarily assign the entire blame to the wife while allowing the husband to get away with however mean he was to provoke it. This is the same mechanic kids in school use to lure other kids into striking first. The one who throws the punch gets labelled as the abuser, while in reality he was less versed in the art of trading insults while keeping one’s cool. The people who are fast to throw a punch or slap when faced with mean behaviour (emotional aggression) are not necessarily on the lower moral ground than those who can keep up exchanging emotional aggression while staying clear of physical. And stopping the car and yelling on a woman until she takes the driver’s seat isn’t that far from physical aggression actually. In fact, I see more abusive patterns in the husband’s behaviour than in the wife’s.

There may be cultural difference here. Some people believe that, “sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me,” others are more the, “tis’ just a flesh wound,” way. Myself, if I were married, I’d rather have my wife slap me on the face in anger than talk about lawyers (even though I am one and I love the courtroom more than anybody ever should) and custody. I believe an honest, straightforward person can be provoked to violence with “mere” words and finding it easier to resist doesn’t necessarily come from higher moral ground; it may come from superior experience in being mean (the rookie just snaps). The more civilised approach is not necessarily morally superior.

EDIT: Please note I’m not talking about the act of slapping someone in general. It would be very different if a man slapped a woman. I certainly am not saying that hitting someone on the face in general is no big deal.
 
👍
I’ve retyped this post several times by now. We don’t know what happened there, that is how mean exactly he was to her and how hard exactly she slapped him. There’s a whole world of difference between an unwarranted hard slap on the face and an impulsive reaction of a woman driven to her last limits by a man’s rude behaviour. The last has little to do with real domestic violence or abuse. In fact, using the abuse language is prone to making us fall for the magic of words and summarily assign the entire blame to the wife while allowing the husband to get away with however mean he was to provoke it. This is the same mechanic kids in school use to lure other kids into striking first. The one who throws the punch gets labelled as the abuser, while in reality he was less versed in the art of trading insults while keeping one’s cool. The people who are fast to throw a punch or slap when faced with mean behaviour (emotional aggression) are not necessarily on the lower moral ground than those who can keep up exchanging emotional aggression while staying clear of physical. And stopping the car and yelling on a woman until she takes the driver’s seat isn’t that far from physical aggression actually. In fact, I see more abusive patterns in the husband’s behaviour than in the wife’s.

There may be cultural difference here. Some people believe that, “sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me,” others are more the, “tis’ just a flesh wound,” way. Myself, if I were married, I’d rather have my wife slap me on the face in anger than talk about lawyers (even though I am one and I love the courtroom more than anybody ever should) and custody. I believe an honest, straightforward person can be provoked to violence with “mere” words and finding it easier to resist doesn’t necessarily come from higher moral ground; it may come from superior experience in being mean (the rookie just snaps).
👍
 
this is absolutely sensationalist advice, especially the part bolded. Both sides in this argument have much to improve upon (I’d like to hear the husband’s side), but nothing is helped by telling a woman who slapped her husband after a rough day that her life and her child’s are in no uncertain terms likely in danger!
The husband and wife are both in horrible places. She made a somewhat naggy request and he let a infant scream for TWO hours while his wife tried to find a spot. He systematically harassed and belittled his wife in front of others.
Then she slapped him.
He…for whatever reason did not attack back. He continued to remind her of legal recourse against her and her.

This is a powderkeg situation. You have a explosive man, an implosive women being driven to the edge and a baby who is being allowed to scream for 2 hours with no comfort. The couple needs to separate immediatly before someone ends up dead.

That is my opinion. Sensationlist or not.
 
I can relate to this story, to some degree. My husband slips into rages sometimes, even though he’s normally a very kind and considerate man. When he’s in a rage, he gets unreasonable and will often say things that he doesn’t mean (he’s never physically violent or even verbally threatening, but he can say hurtful things). I have learned to leave him alone until he calms down, and the rages are reducing over the years. Sometimes I can get through to him, but only if I stay calm (the husband-whisperer ;)).
I’ve known a couple of people like that. Some very bad childhoods come to mind, as well as often very bad current situations, to the point I’d actually believe in a partial insanity defence in any legal action. Think the novel battered woman defence that works in some parts of the world. This is the point where some people are taken before they start being violent. It doesn’t always result from being an ogre. Others like the kid who threw a punch when somebody insulted him too far—they strike at the first time, they don’t do it again.
It sounds like the situation you were in was just a major stressor. Difficulty finding a carpark, crowded shopping, carrying a baby, long hours spent shopping. Neither of you were at your best. I wonder if it would have been better to just go home and try again another time. These are the situations that bring out our worst. I imagine that you were feeling resentful at having to drive and then carry baby, and your husband was feeling resentful at being told what to do (and the things he was told turned out to be the wrong choice). In both of you, there was the feeling of being right, and being slighted.
I agree but having the woman carry the baby for 2 hours because he just simply wouldn’t do it is beyond words. It’s beyond my imagination that a man could say, “I’m not going to carry the baby for 2 hours,” and have the wife do it. Feeling slighted doesn’t excuse that because it falls into a different category of things, there’s little common ground there. You don’t shift a physical burden from yourself onto a woman, let alone your baby. This is my primary beef with the man and the major reason I’m having trouble respecting him. Belittling her in public sounds like something subject to interpretation but the incident with the baby does not. Except maybe in the sole hypothetical situation when the woman had basically nagged the man into going both at the same time and taking the child along despite having better alternatives, but even then the response doesn’t fit (it would have been something like, “it was your idea, so you carry the baby,” not just, “I’m not going to”). I’m sorry to be so blunt and direct but I’m having trouble regarding a man who behaves like that as a responsible adult. It sounds like a child and not a healthy one.
The husband and wife are both in horrible places. She made a somewhat naggy request and he let a infant scream for TWO hours while his wife tried to find a spot. He systematically harassed and belittled his wife in front of others.
Then she slapped him.
He…for whatever reason did not attack back. He continued to remind her of legal recourse against her and her.

This is a powderkeg situation. You have a explosive man, an implosive women being driven to the edge and a baby who is being allowed to scream for 2 hours with no comfort. The couple needs to separate immediatly before someone ends up dead.

That is my opinion. Sensationlist or not.
I tend to agree, unless there’s more to the story than we know (e.g. talks of divorce, separation, where from the lawyer and custody talk otherwise?) and unless the OP’s account was extremely exaggerated. If not, then there are very serious problems with the husband. I can see myself offering silent treatment and pouting for several hours over a perceived insult, or even lashing out when being nagged too much too hard (especially when already tired and over the edge from stress at work) or even quarrelling in public, but leaving a baby screaming or refusing to carry it? Fighting one’s wife is one thing, taking it out on the baby and leaving her alone with it is something else. Again, unless there’s something else to the story.

I’m definitely of the mind that counselling should be the answer, not leaving, though.
 
Great post! Also, I recommend Retrouvaille marriage workshops as the alternative to marriage counseling. My concern is that if you go to marriage counseling, then the “slap” will be documented and can be used against you in divorce court. And yes, it can be taken seriously by a court system. Even if you work individually with a therapist, your records can be ordered by the court. I am concerned that your husband has threatened your child’s custody, and this needs to be taken very seriously. Custody fights happen for lots of reasons, one of them being for a spouse to get out of paying child support, despite the effect it may have on the child. His threat sounds like a threat against the wellbeing of the child. Of course, I don’t know the entire situation, but this does sound really concerning. Assuming you have never harmed your child, and that you have never slapped your husband before, threats to call a lawyer are not typically the first thing to pop up during a marital fight. If you go to Retrouvaille, the marriage work you would do would not be documented, as far as I know. This is a better option. I also would start working with a priest or nun and have regular contact with them for possible help should your husband actually file for divorce in a few years from now. Your slap may very well have been a one time error in judgement, but I have concerns that your husband’s comments may indicate that he has been considering to end the marriage. The fact that he was still talking about the potential of having called 911 over a face slap a day after the incident happened reinforces this concern and makes it look like he may be willing to use unfair tactics.
Blessings and good luck!
I can tell you right now, if my husband slapped me across the face, I would be talking lawyers and divorce.

He’s only human!
 
I agree but having the woman carry the baby for 2 hours because he just simply wouldn’t do it is beyond words. It’s beyond my imagination that a man could say, “I’m not going to carry the baby for 2 hours,” and have the wife do it. Feeling slighted doesn’t excuse that because it falls into a different category of things, there’s little common ground there. You don’t shift a physical burden from yourself onto a woman, let alone your baby. This is my primary beef with the man and the major reason I’m having trouble respecting him. Belittling her in public sounds like something subject to interpretation but the incident with the baby does not. Except maybe in the sole hypothetical situation when the woman had basically nagged the man into going both at the same time and taking the child along despite having better alternatives, but even then the response doesn’t fit (it would have been something like, “it was your idea, so you carry the baby,” not just, “I’m not going to”). I’m sorry to be so blunt and direct but I’m having trouble regarding a man who behaves like that as a responsible adult. It sounds like a child and not a healthy one.

**I agree here with you. My husband (no matter how angry with me) would never let me carry the baby for 2 hours or make me drive around to look for a parking spot instead of him. My husband would yell verbal insults at me in the car for a couple of minutes and then we wouldn’t be talking to eachother. Then when we saw our friends, we would have put on a charade that everything is great and by the end of the day, my DH and I would have fogotten about our fight. To kep the fight going on all day in front of friends is just immature and malicious. **

I’m definitely of the mind that counselling should be the answer, not leaving, though.

I agree with this too. If he’s willing to go to counselling, then they should give it a try at least.
Marital counselling is not effective about 80% of the time (I read this statistic once recently), so different things work for different couples.

As I mentioned before, I am in counselling to learn to be more effective in stressful family situations. My counsellor asked me to come up with 5 common situations that set DH and I into an argument. We’ll see what advice I get.
 
I tend to agree, unless there’s more to the story than we know (e.g. talks of divorce, separation, where from the lawyer and custody talk otherwise?) and unless the OP’s account was extremely exaggerated. If not, then there are very serious problems with the husband. I can see myself offering silent treatment and pouting for several hours over a perceived insult, or even lashing out when being nagged too much too hard (especially when already tired and over the edge from stress at work) or even quarrelling in public, but leaving a baby screaming or refusing to carry it? Fighting one’s wife is one thing, taking it out on the baby and leaving her alone with it is something else. Again, unless there’s something else to the story.

I’m definitely of the mind that counselling should be the answer, not leaving, though.
The reason I suggest separation is because the couple has proven themselves incabable of behaving in public. Experiance in this sort of thing dictates that if someone cannot/is not behaving in public, it’s worse at home. My greatest concern is that both parties let an 8mo cry for 2 hours…and the father with no emathy towards the infant. Had this been a couple without kids, I’d say go to councelling within the week, but this involves a child and because of that I am concerened.

I’m not even an anti cry it out person, I think that babies can cry for a few minutes…in an extreme case…like you’re in the middle of no where and it’s not safe to stop or you’re tending to another child who’s injured…maybe even a half hour in the most extreme circumances. But 2 hours? That’s neglectful.

It also concerns me…if he treats his wife like that (stonewalling, ignoring, belittling) how is he going to treat his child? Is he going to shame his kid when he dosn’t grow fast enough? At the same time a DV shelter will help the wife becuase what’s going to happen when the kid talks and eventually says “I hate you mommy!” (which every kid does)…is she going to slap him?

In this case I believe the baby is safer with the mother, as neglect towards the baby has been perpetrated by the father (with the mother acting as a secondary offender) but the mother has not acted out against the baby.
 
The reason I suggest separation is because the couple has proven themselves incabable of behaving in public. Experiance in this sort of thing dictates that if someone cannot/is not behaving in public, it’s worse at home. My greatest concern is that both parties let an 8mo cry for 2 hours…and the father with no emathy towards the infant. Had this been a couple without kids, I’d say go to councelling within the week, but this involves a child and because of that I am concerened.

I’m not even an anti cry it out person, I think that babies can cry for a few minutes…in an extreme case…like you’re in the middle of no where and it’s not safe to stop or you’re tending to another child who’s injured…maybe even a half hour in the most extreme circumances. But 2 hours? That’s neglectful.

It also concerns me…if he treats his wife like that (stonewalling, ignoring, belittling) how is he going to treat his child? Is he going to shame his kid when he dosn’t grow fast enough? At the same time a DV shelter will help the wife becuase what’s going to happen when the kid talks and eventually says “I hate you mommy!” (which every kid does)…is she going to slap him?

In this case I believe the baby is safer with the mother, as neglect towards the baby has been perpetrated by the father (with the mother acting as a secondary offender) but the mother has not acted out against the baby.
True. My husband would never let any of our kids cry for more than 2 minutes. To let a child cry for 2 hours is disburbing to me too.
 
That is my opinion. Sensationlist or not.
It’s armchair psychology. Amchair psychology regarding a story we have only one side for – and some of the details are very hazy (for example, I find it hard to believe they drove around for 2 whole hours looking for a parking space, but I might be wrong). Recommending counseling seems accurate. At the very least having a heart-to-heart certainly couldn’t hurt. But nothing of substance is added by a warning that life and limb may be in danger when there is no evidence to support it.

In a situation which was made worse by escalating overreactions, the advice given shouldn’t be the product of overreaction too. Advising a anonymous couple to separate after a single bad instance when an entire 50% of the story is unknown is rash and unlikely to actually solve the problem.
 
Okay, his lack of compassion and generally selfish and impatient behavior is disconcerting, **but what really bothers me is that he threatened to call 911 and/or get a lawyer involved. His mind should not be going anywhere near there, and the fact that it is, to me, says that his mind is open to some very extreme solutions to your marital problems. ** I hope you do talk to your priest or a good marital counselor, and when you do, bring this up. Because, maybe it’s just me, but when at least one, if not both parties to a couple are even able to consider such an adversarial (not to mention irreversible) approach like this, it means a lot erosion in the relationship (or at least his perception of it) must have already occurred.

Secondly, I want to say that you have to take full responsibility for slapping him. The only justifiable excuse for physical violence is absolute necessity. Lots of things can rile a person up, push their buttons, set them off, et cetera. It may not be easy, but we still have to be in control of our actions.
I agree. I also agree with Chevalier. first most important thing don’t ever slap him ever again or do anything that can be held against you in court. how many times I read these kinds of post and wish we would all get some great advice from a lawyer’s point of view. we need more lawyer’s like you Chevalier. keep in mind that some people especially with radical solutions may come from abusive past themselves, maybe it was their mother or father or husband etc. abuse past can drastically change the way a person interoperates the details of a story. for example for victim of abuse may always blame the mothers because their mother abused them.
maritalhealing.com/conflicts.php you both may be to blame. learn about each others faults, its hurts, makes you angrier, and makes things worse at first but you have to understand it first in order to forgive and change the bad behavior. you have to go through the pain of uncovering the issues before you can resolve them. you can’t force someone else to change but you can learn how to avoid conflict anyway. the link above is the best way to do that.
 
I agree. I also agree with Chevalier. first most important thing don’t ever slap him ever again or do anything that can be held against you in court. how many times I read these kinds of post and wish we would all get some great advice from a lawyer’s point of view. we need more lawyer’s like you Chevalier. keep in mind that some people especially with radical solutions may come from abusive past themselves, maybe it was their mother or father or husband etc. abuse past can drastically change the way a person interoperates the details of a story. for example for victim of abuse may always blame the mothers because their mother abused them.
maritalhealing.com/conflicts.php you both may be to blame. learn about each others faults, its hurts, makes you angrier, and makes things worse at first but you have to understand it first in order to forgive and change the bad behavior. you have to go through the pain of uncovering the issues before you can resolve them. you can’t force someone else to change but you can learn how to avoid conflict anyway. the link above is the best way to do that.
I ment interpret the details of a story not interoperates
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top