Defensive or abusive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SDMom82
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I feel sorry for the child in this situation where the parents are acting like immature children. What a horrible example they are setting not to mention the fear and anxiety that poor little baby was feeling.

They are both wrong here. Very wrong.
 
The reason I suggest separation is because the couple has proven themselves incabable of behaving in public. Experiance in this sort of thing dictates that if someone cannot/is not behaving in public, it’s worse at home. My greatest concern is that both parties let an 8mo cry for 2 hours…and the father with no emathy towards the infant. Had this been a couple without kids, I’d say go to councelling within the week, but this involves a child and because of that I am concerened.
I’m worried about the father’s empathy or lack of it. Under huge stress and/or when particularly angry, people can behave as if their empathy were seriously lacking. However, a habitual lack of empathy is a problem, for example certain personality disorders are marked by it (NPD).
It also concerns me…if he treats his wife like that (stonewalling, ignoring, belittling) how is he going to treat his child?
I’d say depending on the extent of such behaviour, as well as some other parameters, we don’t know if it’s more a normal person cracking up and having a bad day, or someone with serious problems. There are plenty of people who quarrel in public and it’s only natural that what they say is considered belittling by the other party (and probably is, at least to some extent, but it goes both ways). It’s natural that we worry about such a situation repeating itself but if we applied this kind of reasoning to everybody, then basically everybody would be a dangerous or otherwise problematic person. A single quarrel is definitely not enough data to suggest separation. 🙂
Is he going to shame his kid when he dosn’t grow fast enough? At the same time a DV shelter will help the wife becuase what’s going to happen when the kid talks and eventually says “I hate you mommy!” (which every kid does)…is she going to slap him?
Well, it’s not the end of the world if a kid gets slapped for having a bad mouth. A while ago it would be taken for granted.
In this case I believe the baby is safer with the mother, as neglect towards the baby has been perpetrated by the father (with the mother acting as a secondary offender) but the mother has not acted out against the baby.
Again, there’s not enough data to go that far but either counselling or some other way for the father to get his stuff in order is necessary.
 
Hi all, I didn’t realize my story would warrant so much replies and turns out to be a good discussion.

To clarify some facts:
  1. The baby didn’t cry continuously during the 2 hours. He was sleeping for the first hour or so… and when he wake up he was fussy which escalated to full-blown crying. When I reflected back, I could have just say “Sorry” and went home since we both aren’t in a good mood. Instead I feel like pressing through & continuing our plan since going to Balboa Park Xmas Night is a yearly tradition for us.
Next year, we wouldn’t even think about finding parking nearby the park. Just take the Shuttle! balboapark.org/decembernights/parking
  1. Please remember that this is an episode of him going berserk - which only happened once or twice in a year. 99% of the time he is a very good father and provider. He is well-liked by so many people and is a people-pleaser.
Conflict resolution is #1 on our list… that is how to avoid him going into berserk mode, and the proper way to react to him when he goes berserk (timeout?). Anger management is #2 and it’s for both of us.

I was wondering if anyone know any conflict resolution exercise after a horrible episode like this?
 
I can tell you right now, if my husband slapped me across the face, I would be talking lawyers and divorce.
It’s way, way different if a man slaps a woman on the face than the other way round. When a woman slaps a man for bad behaviour towards her it’s basically a stronger way of saying, “you son of gun.” Little to do with a physical attack, it’s more of an insult. Any physical pain that a man might actually feel as a result is completely irrelevant.

The other way round, now that’s dishonourable behaviour and yes, violence.
 
  1. The baby didn’t cry continuously during the 2 hours. He was sleeping for the first hour or so… and when he wake up he was fussy which escalated to full-blown crying. When I reflected back, I could have just say “Sorry” and went home since we both aren’t in a good mood. Instead I feel like pressing through & continuing our plan since going to Balboa Park Xmas Night is a yearly tradition for us.
Okay, that clarifies a lot. Still, you’re now excusing your husband’s behaviour too much, although it wasn’t as bad as the initial impression we got, at least I did.
  1. Please remember that this is an episode of him going berserk - which only happened once or twice in a year. 99% of the time he is a very good father and provider. He is well-liked by so many people and is a people-pleaser.
People pleasers sometimes blow up. Some people are bossy or pushy on a daily basis but never erupt into anything more serious. Others are nice people and put up with a lot until their limits are crossed… not necessarily by the events which immediately preceded the outburst. As I said in the beginning, overworked and overstressed people are rather volatile.
Conflict resolution is #1 on our list… that is how to avoid him going into berserk mode, and the proper way to react to him when he goes berserk (timeout?). Anger management is #2 and it’s for both of us.
My opinion is that people with a tendency to violent outbursts shouldn’t be walked around on eggshells (Hitler, Monachium, 1938, comes to mind as a far parallel). Sure, one should avoid triggering their explosions, but they need to control themselves and at least avoid taking it out on their families, especially noncombatants (e.g. a child that didn’t actually participate in the quarrel). Actually, this includes also your outburst. After all, you actually slapped him when you had too much. Both of you need to learn to rein in the anger but both of you also need to learn to voice your needs and opinions (and complaints) in a direct and nonconfrontational way. Basically not bottling it up until explosion but providing some real-time feedback so that you know where you stand. You seem to have forgotten you play in the same team. It would be good to reclaim that feeling.
I was wondering if anyone know any conflict resolution exercise after a horrible episode like this?
I’m pretty sure the counsellor will be able to provide reference. This is basically similar to negotiation and mediation training people receive in certain professions. Until you get the appropriate coaching, I suggest, for starters, focusing on the fact you play in the same team and reminding yourselves to cut completely on gratuitous jabs, any form of ridicule, humiliation etc., and you shouldn’t be inflicting emotional pain intentionally on each other. When you want a solution you shouldn’t be negotiating like bitter enemies that divide the pie but rather you should focus on creating more value by cooperating (each of you gains more from acting together than from dividing the pie between the two of you). You need to stand up for each other, not just for yourselves. You may need to build some trust for this.
 
I agree. I also agree with Chevalier. first most important thing don’t ever slap him ever again or do anything that can be held against you in court. how many times I read these kinds of post and wish we would all get some great advice from a lawyer’s point of view. we need more lawyer’s like you Chevalier. keep in mind that some people especially with radical solutions may come from abusive past themselves, maybe it was their mother or father or husband etc. abuse past can drastically change the way a person interprets the details of a story. for example for victim of abuse may always blame the mothers because their mother abused them.
Thanks. Yes, abuse perpetuates itself among other things by summary assignment of blame to one party by default (e.g. teachers always siding with the one kid, parents having selected one child to be always right in any disputes with siblings, people always siding with the superior against a subordinate or the other way round, with the female against the male etc.). There must be justice and fairness or abuse won’t ever end. If someone is selected to be guilty by default, that person is free game for abuse and can’t defend his rights. This sometimes occurs in the battered woman cases where the husband is a “pillar of the community”, e.g. high-profile job, good degree, charity donations, active in some church, and people won’t believe the wife.
 
Hi all, I didn’t realize my story would warrant so much replies and turns out to be a good discussion.

To clarify some facts:
  1. The baby didn’t cry continuously during the 2 hours. He was sleeping for the first hour or so… and when he wake up he was fussy which escalated to full-blown crying. When I reflected back, I could have just say “Sorry” and went home since we both aren’t in a good mood. Instead I feel like pressing through & continuing our plan since going to Balboa Park Xmas Night is a yearly tradition for us.
Yes, looking back, it would have been better to turn around and cut your losses for this year.

Next year, we wouldn’t even think about finding parking nearby the park. Just take the Shuttle! balboapark.org/decembernights/parking
  1. Please remember that this is an episode of him going berserk - which only happened once or twice in a year. 99% of the time he is a very good father and provider. He is well-liked by so many people and is a people-pleaser.
You married a good guy!

Conflict resolution is #1 on our list… that is how to avoid him going into berserk mode, and the proper way to react to him when he goes berserk (timeout?). Anger management is #2 and it’s for both of us.

Good for you!
I was wondering if anyone know any conflict resolution exercise after a horrible episode like this?
Yes I do and I’ll share them in a bit. I have to be somewhere right now.

Good for you!
 
The husband and wife are both in horrible places. She made a somewhat naggy request and he let a infant scream for TWO hours while his wife tried to find a spot. He systematically harassed and belittled his wife in front of others.
Then she slapped him.
He…for whatever reason did not attack back. He continued to remind her of legal recourse against her and her.

This is a powderkeg situation. You have a explosive man, an implosive women being driven to the edge and a baby who is being allowed to scream for 2 hours with no comfort. The couple needs to separate immediatly before someone ends up dead.

That is my opinion. Sensationlist or not.
I’m a native San Diegan and I’m just saying that there’s NO WAY, however crowded it was for December Nights, that it took two hours to park. This sticks out as a blatant exaggeration and I wonder what else was exaggerated to suit the purposes of her story of “abuse”. I don’t say this to be mean, I’m just pointing out factual discrepancies.
 
I’m a native San Diegan and I’m just saying that there’s NO WAY, however crowded it was for December Nights, that it took two hours to park. This sticks out as a blatant exaggeration and I wonder what else was exaggerated to suit the purposes of her story of “abuse”. I don’t say this to be mean, I’m just pointing out factual discrepancies.
Half an hour with a crying baby in the car and no parking space and a grumpy husband could seem like a year!!! I think the OP did admit that on that particular evening everything was very overwhelming… I just wish I were there to give her a hug and tell her that we are praying for her…
 
Okay, that clarifies a lot. Still, you’re now excusing your husband’s behaviour too much, although it wasn’t as bad as the initial impression we got, at least I did.

People pleasers sometimes blow up. Some people are bossy or pushy on a daily basis but never erupt into anything more serious. Others are nice people and put up with a lot until their limits are crossed… not necessarily by the events which immediately preceded the outburst. As I said in the beginning, overworked and overstressed people are rather volatile.

My opinion is that people with a tendency to violent outbursts shouldn’t be walked around on eggshells (Hitler, Monachium, 1938, comes to mind as a far parallel). Sure, one should avoid triggering their explosions, but they need to control themselves and at least avoid taking it out on their families, especially noncombatants (e.g. a child that didn’t actually participate in the quarrel). Actually, this includes also your outburst. After all, you actually slapped him when you had too much. Both of you need to learn to rein in the anger but both of you also need to learn to voice your needs and opinions (and complaints) in a direct and nonconfrontational way. Basically not bottling it up until explosion but providing some real-time feedback so that you know where you stand. You seem to have forgotten you play in the same team. It would be good to reclaim that feeling.

I’m pretty sure the counsellor will be able to provide reference. This is basically similar to negotiation and mediation training people receive in certain professions. Until you get the appropriate coaching, I suggest, for starters, focusing on the fact you play in the same team and reminding yourselves to cut completely on gratuitous jabs, any form of ridicule, humiliation etc., and you shouldn’t be inflicting emotional pain intentionally on each other. When you want a solution you shouldn’t be negotiating like bitter enemies that divide the pie but rather you should focus on creating more value by cooperating (each of you gains more from acting together than from dividing the pie between the two of you). You need to stand up for each other, not just for yourselves. You may need to build some trust for this.
"Quote:
I was wondering if anyone know any conflict resolution exercise after a horrible episode like this? "

this link maritalhealing.com/conflicts.php

you both need to learn about each others faults (anger) whatever you want to call it, it will hurt, makes you angrier, and makes things worse at first but you have to understand it first in order to forgive and change the bad behavior (to move on and correct it).

**you have to go through the pain of uncovering the issues before you can resolve them. **
 
I was wondering if anyone know any conflict resolution exercise after a horrible episode like this?
An exercise that helps me: some evenings I take some time for myself and write even only one episode I didn’t react to well.
I then focalize what did I think, and after I focus on which negative feelings I felt (as fear, anger).
Then, I think about how could I’ve reacted better, and which thoughts could help me react in a positive way.
And then, I exercise to apply the “good intention”.

For example, once a friend of mine I was saying goodbye to at the station (he was leaving), when we hugged, he pushed me away saying out loud: “You smell smoke!!! Disgusting!!!”
I felt humiliated, and answered vulgarlily and went away.
That evening, I realized I reacted badly because I felt angry for his behaviour in front of everyone.
So, first of all, I called him to say I was sorry for my rude answer and to explain the reason of it. Since then, I simply stopped smoking when I know I’ll pass some time with him… and he also thought about what happend, and now, if something annoys him, he simply tells me serenily, avoiding critics in piblic…
 
God bless you both.

You slapped your husband…not the end of the world but don’t make a habit of it.
Apologize to him. and go to confession for that one.

The car is one of the most dangerous places to argue. Please avoid this in the future!

There are a lot of stresses in life if we go looking for them and they can ruin a marriage. Only take on stressful things if they are unavoidable. Parking lots in crowded shopping malls are definitely avoidable.

The shopping mall may be exciting but was it worth loosing your peace over?
 
Hi all, thank you so much for your prayers, thoughtful concerns and comments. You are all so wonderful! *sending prayers back to each of you

What a difference a day made. Last night I was still angry when I wrote that post. Now everything seems to make sense. Time (and sleep!) really is a wonderful thing.

I agree that this is rather intimate, and my anonymity in the internet has been a blessing. I am rather reluctant to share this w/ family & friends irl because that would create a faction. Both of us are really wonderful, fun-loving and warm persons that people want to hang out with. Only last weekend… well we really sorry for the couple that has to witness THAT.

My husband has fault of his own and he can regress to a child when he goes berserk, but since I am the one who posted here I will take responsibility for my side of the story.

I think both of us are really hot-headed in our own ways. He is more visible since he’s an extrovert - shouting, scoffing, pouting and refusal to do stuff. I’m more invisible, and the way I express my anger is through put downs in a condescending way (Mrs know-it-all syndrome) - I’m aware of this as it happened so often and I realize that this is a shortcoming.

**If the table is turned, I may not be as forgiving as he is right now. There is no excuse for my behavior. Let’s just say that I gain a new outlook for all the domestic violence and how it really started. I used to be very judgmental and blaming the perpetrator for losing control, and always identified myself with the victims. Now I can look back and see the struggle faced by the perpetrators before it happened.
**
I’m very surprised that it escalated to that point. Now I can see that Vanity is my greatest cross… I always pride myself of having better judgement, better knowledge and better control. So for me to be out of control when “The jar overflow”, it is such a humbling experience. It is so disconcerting since I was the one who asked him to go to church, taking bible lessons, reading Catechism on a regular basis, and Imitation of Christ is one of my favorite book. Again, I discover that I’m not invisible to evil doings. On Saturday Night, I prayed Our Father and gain a new understanding on the phrase: “Lead us not into TEMPTATION, but deliver us from EVIL”

Thanks again for your prayers, comments & concerns. As for now, the hubby will have to leave overseas to take care of family matter and I pray that this break will give us the time to prepare for a good & fruitful marriage counseling.

Peace be with you!
You will be in my prayers.

I ‘bolded’ a part of what you said above. Domestic violence is very serious. The victims of domestic violence often blame themselves until it is too late or until they see the light. You ( all of 98 poungs) slapped a 182 pound man. While violence is never the answer, what you did can never be equated to what has been done and is done to victims of domestic violence. The fact that he put his feelings and anger above the welfare of your child is very telling.

Verbal and emotional abuse is still abuse.

You need the help of experts not us. God bless.
 
Okay, that clarifies a lot. Still, you’re now excusing your husband’s behaviour too much, although it wasn’t as bad as the initial impression we got, at least I did.

People pleasers sometimes blow up. Some people are bossy or pushy on a daily basis but never erupt into anything more serious. Others are nice people and put up with a lot until their limits are crossed… not necessarily by the events which immediately preceded the outburst. As I said in the beginning, overworked and overstressed people are rather volatile.

My opinion is that people with a tendency to violent outbursts shouldn’t be walked around on eggshells (Hitler, Monachium, 1938, comes to mind as a far parallel). Sure, one should avoid triggering their explosions, but they need to control themselves and at least avoid taking it out on their families, especially noncombatants (e.g. a child that didn’t actually participate in the quarrel). Actually, this includes also your outburst. After all, you actually slapped him when you had too much. Both of you need to learn to rein in the anger but both of you also need to learn to voice your needs and opinions (and complaints) in a direct and nonconfrontational way. Basically not bottling it up until explosion but providing some real-time feedback so that you know where you stand. You seem to have forgotten you play in the same team. It would be good to reclaim that feeling.

I’m pretty sure the counsellor will be able to provide reference. This is basically similar to negotiation and mediation training people receive in certain professions. Until you get the appropriate coaching, I suggest, for starters, focusing on the fact you play in the same team and reminding yourselves to cut completely on gratuitous jabs, any form of ridicule, humiliation etc., and you shouldn’t be inflicting emotional pain intentionally on each other. When you want a solution you shouldn’t be negotiating like bitter enemies that divide the pie but rather you should focus on creating more value by cooperating (each of you gains more from acting together than from dividing the pie between the two of you). You need to stand up for each other, not just for yourselves. You may need to build some trust for this.
I must say that you have been posting good advice.👍
 
I can tell you right now, if my husband slapped me across the face, I would be talking lawyers and divorce.

He’s only human!
He is a man!!! He is twice her size!!! No court would do anything to her. A man threatning a woman after his disgusting treatment of her? You think it is the same thing? Most men who behave that way will eventually resort to violence. What was done is NEVER the same thing as to what HE did. Yes she was wrong to slap him but his treatment of her is way over the top. The responses here except for a few have shown a stunning lack of knowledge of verbal and emotional abuse.

Yes go to retrovouille!!! Please read up on verbal and emotional abuse and how many times it leads to physical violence. Even if it doesn’t a man who treats his wife like that is STILL and abuser!

I will pray for both of you at Mass tonight!
 
I’m a native San Diegan and I’m just saying that there’s NO WAY, however crowded it was for December Nights, that it took two hours to park. This sticks out as a blatant exaggeration and I wonder what else was exaggerated to suit the purposes of her story of “abuse”. I don’t say this to be mean, I’m just pointing out factual discrepancies.
Yes but I have been around San Diego and near the beach and parking can take forever. Even if what you say is true you have just validated his horrible treatment of her. If it was only a half hour who cares? My husband would think any man who did that to his wife and baby should be put up for public shame.
 
Yes but I have been around San Diego and near the beach and parking can take forever. Even if what you say is true you have just validated his horrible treatment of her. If it was only a half hour who cares?
It is completely relevant to the story. An account has to be reliably assumed not to have exaggerations in order to be taken into account as objective and neutral, as much as possible. Otherwise, the question is raised, what other details have been left out or overplayed?
 
He is a man!!! He is twice her size!!! No court would do anything to her. A man threatning a woman after his disgusting treatment of her? You think it is the same thing? Most men who behave that way will eventually resort to violence. What was done is NEVER the same thing as to what HE did. Yes she was wrong to slap him but his treatment of her is way over the top. The responses here except for a few have shown a stunning lack of knowledge of verbal and emotional abuse.

Yes go to retrovouille!!! Please read up on verbal and emotional abuse and how many times it leads to physical violence. Even if it doesn’t a man who treats his wife like that is STILL and abuser!

I will pray for both of you at Mass tonight!
I so agree with your assessment of emotional and verbal abuse…but I also believe that her husband could hurt her in court with the incident if she is not careful who she shares this information with. Retrovouille would be great, priests would be great, nuns would be great…however, therapists (marriage and family therapists, social workers, licensed counselors) legally have to document this type of thing (along with everything else mentionned) and her husband could use the records in court some 5, 10 years from now. Some states do not have laws to protect therapists from handing records over…that means that whatever she may discuss in therapy is not necessarily confidential. To make matters worse,courts proceedings are not always fair and honest. A dishonest attorney could present the simple face slap as a supposed indication of habitual domestic violence. Being the husband has already made some fairly large threats, I would take his word seriously and at face value and be very careful for the sake of the child and the child’s potential custody if I were the mother. Just recommending she be very clever. I hope these type issues never materialize. But it is smart to be careful.
 
It is completely relevant to the story. An account has to be reliably assumed not to have exaggerations in order to be taken into account as objective and neutral, as much as possible. Otherwise, the question is raised, what other details have been left out or overplayed?
We still need to take this young mother’s concerns seriously…
 
It is completely relevant to the story. An account has to be reliably assumed not to have exaggerations in order to be taken into account as objective and neutral, as much as possible. Otherwise, the question is raised, what other details have been left out or overplayed?
First off I know the area very well and it could have been 2 hours. Second I know how a man should treat his wife and baby and that wasn’t it. Even if it was a half hour the whole thing is wrong. My husband, father-in-law, and my Dad would never do what this man did. Verbal and emotional abuse leaves a scar that lasts langer than any bruise.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top