Defensive or abusive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SDMom82
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
šŸ‘
First off I know the area very well and it could have been 2 hours. Second I know how a man should treat his wife and baby and that wasn’t it. Even if it was a half hour the whole thing is wrong. My husband, father-in-law, and my Dad would never do what this man did. Verbal and emotional abuse leaves a scar that lasts langer than any bruise.
šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘
 
He is a man!!!
I’m sorry, but just because he is a man DOES NOT mean that you have the right to initiate physical violence against him, nor does it mean that it’s ā€œno big deal.ā€ That is repulsive.
 
I’m sorry, but just because he is a man DOES NOT mean that you have the right to initiate physical violence against him, nor does it mean that it’s ā€œno big deal.ā€ That is repulsive.
This quote is taken out of context of the meaning the poster was trying to say…she was trying to put things in proportion…she was not trying to say that open handed slaps were a-okay. At least that is my interpretation of it…
 
Both of these people were in the wrong here. AND neither of them was thinking about their child.

Unsubscribing now.
 
This quote is taken out of context of the meaning the poster was trying to say…she was trying to put things in proportion…she was not trying to say that open handed slaps were a-okay. At least that is my interpretation of it…
Thank you! That is what I was trying to say!
 
Okay, so this thread was made on Monday… and the OP wrote:
I just had a very confusing weekend.
I just slapped my husband on last Saturday.
So the parking lot incident happened last weekend, on December 3rd, right? OP, you seem to confirm this in your later posts.

Here’s the part I don’t get:
It started on him noticing an empty parking spot on a crowded San Diego Balboa Park on Xmas night.*
I’m not trying to be uncharitable, but I have to wonder, why would you write this all took place on Christmas night? Christmas night was over 11 months ago, this doesn’t make any sense. :confused:

*Bold/underline mine, for emphasis.
 
He is a man!!! He is twice her size!!! No court would do anything to her. A man threatning a woman after his disgusting treatment of her? You think it is the same thing? Most men who behave that way will eventually resort to violence. What was done is NEVER the same thing as to what HE did. Yes she was wrong to slap him but his treatment of her is way over the top. The responses here except for a few have shown a stunning lack of knowledge of verbal and emotional abuse.

Yes go to retrovouille!!! Please read up on verbal and emotional abuse and how many times it leads to physical violence. Even if it doesn’t a man who treats his wife like that is STILL and abuser!

I will pray for both of you at Mass tonight!
I agree with you, I was rather surprised by many of the responses. She is 98 lbs and her husband is 182 lbs, how could her slap done any physical harm to him. He forced her to drive and to me that is at so wrong. He was not interested in the baby’s welfare and made her do all the carrying. It must have been difficult but she did it and did not put the baby down, stamp her feet.
Yes, we only hear her side but that applies to all people who post here for advice. I think it was telling when shespoke t of abused women and trying explaining sympathetically the actions of abusers.
 
Half an hour with a crying baby in the car and no parking space and a grumpy husband could seem like a year!!! I think the OP did admit that on that particular evening everything was very overwhelming… I just wish I were there to give her a hug and tell her that we are praying for her…
:)šŸ‘
 
I’m not trying to be uncharitable, but I have to wonder, why would you write this all took place on Christmas night? Christmas night was over 11 months ago, this doesn’t make any sense. :confused:

*Bold/underline mine, for emphasis.
I understand the confusion, but this part of the story does check out — ā€œBalboa Park December Nights, the nation’s premier holiday festival, will take place for the 34th consecutive year on Friday, Dec. 2, 5-10pm, and Saturday, Dec. 3, noon-10pmā€
 
Last thing I remembered is this woman is not on trial…she humbly came here asking for support, not just for herself, but for help with her family that she treasures. What’s going on here??? She is a young mother with a baby!!! And in a very difficult situation. And from what I can see likely a rather emotionally abusive one. If the man was of goodwill I doubt his rude comments would have continued to the next day… Obviously her faith is very important to her… I recommend we stop critiquing her so harshly on this thread and offer some compassion…
 
It is completely relevant to the story. An account has to be reliably assumed not to have exaggerations in order to be taken into account as objective and neutral, as much as possible. Otherwise, the question is raised, what other details have been left out or overplayed?
This.

Btw, I take emotional and physical abuse extremely seriously. My father was abusive to my mother and I for years before it reached a breaking point. BUT, I can’t help but feel certain details of this young mother’s story were exaggerated to condone her own bad behavior while vilifying her husband.

When I read the story, I actually sympathized with both husband and wife. Clearly the healthy choice would have been to either head home when it became apparent that both husband and wife were running on empty (by the first paragraph I could foresee that a bad day was brewing), or to make the adult decision to bury the hatchet and have a good day. That did not happen.

Wife nagged and nagged, played the blame game, and at the end of the night when it became apparent that the evening was shot, refused to leave. Her behavior was childish. Another thing that stands out to me as a bit strange is her emphasis on her petite size as an excuse not to carry her own child. She seemed to whine about having to hold her baby, which I found strange because size has nothing to do with it. (I am 100 pounds and a nanny. I regularly carry both boys, who are five months old and 22 months old, without a problem.)

As for the husband, he reacted quite childishly as well. I don’t think his ā€œmaking her driveā€ was a case of emotional manipulation, though. I think it was a case of being fed up with having been nagged. A sort of ā€œwhy don’t YOU drive since you know best?!ā€ Immature, but not abuse. His threat to call the police or lawyer seems like another knee-jerk emotional reaction, not a case of systematic abuse. I’d bet that in his mind, he’d been treated badly all day and forced to stay at the park when nothing was really getting better. His wife is unhappy, he is unhappy. Then his wife disrespects him by slapping him? He’s hurt (emotionally). This is a low point in their marriage for sure, probably not what he imagined when he envisioned a happy marriage with children. And, neither husband nor wife have the equipment to adequately talk it out in a healthy way. So he resorts to a threat to even it out. She hurt him by slapping him, he hurt her by threatening.

Was either method the healthiest way to go about an argument? No. Could this situation have been avoided? Certainly.

But this is not a case of abuse. Not as the wife tells it, exaggerations and all. I would definitely sign up for marital counseling if I were her, though, because that cycle of built-up anger and violent outbursts is not good for anyone.

I do feel bad for the wife, but I just want to balance it out with pointing out that the husband also deserves a little sympathy.
 
My exact concern is because the wife clearly indicated that it was not a ā€œknee jerkā€ reaction and that he continued his stance of maintaining the threat the next day. If the husband woke up the next day, noticed his wife’s sorrow and also felt sorrow, my understanding of this situation would be very different. But the husband got up and continued by saying he almost called 911. This does not seem like words simply misplaced out of upset or emotional duress.
 
You will be in my prayers.

I ā€˜bolded’ a part of what you said above. Domestic violence is very serious. The victims of domestic violence often blame themselves until it is too late or until they see the light. You ( all of 98 poungs) slapped a 182 pound man. While violence is never the answer, what you did can never be equated to what has been done and is done to victims of domestic violence. The fact that he put his feelings and anger above the welfare of your child is very telling.

Verbal and emotional abuse is still abuse.

You need the help of experts not us. God bless.
I disagree…abuse is still abuse. She abused him when she slapped him.

What a double standard!!! NO wonder abused men are afraid to speak up!
 
He is a man!!! He is twice her size!!! No court would do anything to her. A man threatning a woman after his disgusting treatment of her? You think it is the same thing? Most men who behave that way will eventually resort to violence. What was done is NEVER the same thing as to what HE did. Yes she was wrong to slap him but his treatment of her is way over the top. The responses here except for a few have shown a stunning lack of knowledge of verbal and emotional abuse.

Yes go to retrovouille!!! Please read up on verbal and emotional abuse and how many times it leads to physical violence. Even if it doesn’t a man who treats his wife like that is STILL and abuser!

I will pray for both of you at Mass tonight!
I disagree once again. I can do that.
 
He is a man!!! He is twice her size!!! No court would do anything to her. A man threatning a woman after his disgusting treatment of her? You think it is the same thing? Most men who behave that way will eventually resort to violence. What was done is NEVER the same thing as to what HE did. Yes she was wrong to slap him but his treatment of her is way over the top. The responses here except for a few have shown a stunning lack of knowledge of verbal and emotional abuse.

Yes go to retrovouille!!! Please read up on verbal and emotional abuse and how many times it leads to physical violence. Even if it doesn’t a man who treats his wife like that is STILL and abuser!

I will pray for both of you at Mass tonight!
How do you know he’s an abuser??? Did she say that he called her a name?

Yes, he was being a jerk, but abuser is over the top.
 
Both of these people were in the wrong here. AND neither of them was thinking about their child.

Unsubscribing now.
YES YES YES…they are both as bad as eachother IMO too.

They were being mean to eachother that day and I also pray that they learn from it too.

What a double standard this is becoming!!!
 
Last thing I remembered is this woman is not on trial…she humbly came here asking for support, not just for herself, but for help with her family that she treasures. What’s going on here??? She is a young mother with a baby!!! And in a very difficult situation. And from what I can see likely a rather emotionally abusive one. If the man was of goodwill I doubt his rude comments would have continued to the next day… Obviously her faith is very important to her… I recommend we stop critiquing her so harshly on this thread and offer some compassion…
a slap is a slap…physical abuse is physical abuse.

ppl are just calling her on her part in this…
 
This.

Btw, I take emotional and physical abuse extremely seriously. My father was abusive to my mother and I for years before it reached a breaking point. BUT, I can’t help but feel certain details of this young mother’s story were exaggerated to condone her own bad behavior while vilifying her husband.

YES.

When I read the story, I actually sympathized with both husband and wife. Clearly the healthy choice would have been to either head home when it became apparent that both husband and wife were running on empty (by the first paragraph I could foresee that a bad day was brewing), or to make the adult decision to bury the hatchet and have a good day. That did not happen.

YES

Wife nagged and nagged, played the blame game, and at the end of the night when it became apparent that the evening was shot, refused to leave. Her behavior was childish. Another thing that stands out to me as a bit strange is her emphasis on her petite size as an excuse not to carry her own child. She seemed to whine about having to hold her baby, which I found strange because size has nothing to do with it. (I am 100 pounds and a nanny. I regularly carry both boys, who are five months old and 22 months old, without a problem.)

YES

As for the husband, he reacted quite childishly as well. I don’t think his ā€œmaking her driveā€ was a case of emotional manipulation, though. I think it was a case of being fed up with having been nagged. A sort of **ā€œwhy don’t YOU drive since you know best?!ā€ Immature, but not abuse. **His threat to call the police or lawyer seems like another knee-jerk emotional reaction, not a case of systematic abuse. **I’d bet that in his mind, he’d been treated badly all day and forced to stay at the park when nothing was really getting better. His wife is unhappy, he is unhappy. **Then his wife disrespects him by slapping him? He’s hurt (emotionally). This is a low point in their marriage for sure, probably not what he imagined when he envisioned a happy marriage with children. And, neither husband nor wife have the equipment to adequately talk it out in a healthy way. So he resorts to a threat to even it out. She hurt him by slapping him, he hurt her by threatening.

YES

Was either method the healthiest way to go about an argument? No. Could this situation have been avoided? Certainly.

YES AGAIN!!!

But this is not a case of abuse. Not as the wife tells it, exaggerations and all. I would definitely sign up for marital counseling if I were her, though, because that cycle of built-up anger and violent outbursts is not good for anyone.

YES YES YES

I do feel bad for the wife, but I just want to balance it out with pointing out that the husband also deserves a little sympathy.
YES YES YES YES YES šŸ‘
 
My exact concern is because the wife clearly indicated that it was not a ā€œknee jerkā€ reaction and that he continued his stance of maintaining the threat the next day. If the husband woke up the next day, noticed his wife’s sorrow and also felt sorrow, my understanding of this situation would be very different. But the husband got up and continued by saying he almost called 911. This does not seem like words simply misplaced out of upset or emotional duress.
The next day IS a knee jerk reaction…the hurt was fresh in his mind. It often takes ppl a few days to simmer down after they are upset. This is normal behaviour.

They are both being immature. They are both at equal fault.

I have to say that I have NEVER slapped my husband ever and I have been very very angry with him. It is wrong to slap someone b/c you’re angry.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top