Denying Communion question

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nick
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

Nick

Guest
Wasnt there a situation in the past where a U.S. Catholic Bishop denied Holy Communion to a politician who opposed civil rights, or maybe it was that he advocated slavery? I am trying to think of an example that shows that there is indeed precedent in the U.S. of Bishops denying Holy Communion to dissident politicians outside of the present situation. Thanks.
 
Wasnt there a situation in the past where a U.S. Catholic Bishop denied Holy Communion to a politician who opposed civil rights, or maybe it was that he advocated slavery? I am trying to think of an example that shows that there is indeed precedent in the U.S. of Bishops denying Holy Communion to dissident politicians outside of the present situation. Thanks.
My bishop, Bishop Peter Jugis of the Charlotte diocese, authored a letter about a year ago indicating he would deny communion to any Catholic politician who publicly supported abortion.

I can find a link to the letter if you need it.

We are blessed to have such a wonderful bishop. He told me he has received death threats over the letter.
 
Wasnt there a situation in the past where a U.S. Catholic Bishop denied Holy Communion to a politician who opposed civil rights, or maybe it was that he advocated slavery? I am trying to think of an example that shows that there is indeed precedent in the U.S. of Bishops denying Holy Communion to dissident politicians outside of the present situation. Thanks.
As I recall it occurred during the Civil Rights struggle of the early to mid 60’s. A bishop, Louisiana I think, excommunicated all politicians who opposed basic civil rights legislation.

This is a fuzzy memory so there may be errors in the details, but I think the general sense is accurately given.
 
To Joe Kelley. You are correct in your recollection. This was in the l960’s in New Orleans, and the Bishop was Archbishop Rommel. (I do not remember his first name) There were either two or three politicians that were excommunicated. The only one I remember was the political boss of a neighboring parish (county). His name was Leander Perez. Going back to memories almost 50 years ago, I believe Perez recanted and was reconciled. I do not remember the names of the others or the outcome.
I only wish that our bishops today were brave enough like Archbishop Rommel, to take a strong stand such as this against those politicians who call themselves Catholic, yet continue to vote for abortion, partial birth, stem-sell, gay marriage, euthanasia, etc.
Deacon Ed B
 
Good memory!

From Wikipedia
Archbishop Rummel formally announced the end of segregation in the New Orleans parochial school system on March 27, 1962. The 1962-1963 school year would be the first integrated school year in the history of the Archdiocese. [4] [8] White segregationists were outraged. Politicians organized “citizen’s councils”, held public protests, and initiated letter writing campaigns. Parents threatened to transfer their children to public schools or even boycott the entire school year. Rummel issued numerous letters to individual Catholics, pleading for their cooperation and explaining his decision. He even went so far as to threaten opponents of desegregation with excommunication, a punishment usually reserved for heretics. The threats were enough to convince most segregationist Catholics into standing down. Nevertheless, some parishioners continued to organize protests. [14] [4]
On April 16, 1962, the Monday before Easter, he excommunicated three local Catholics for defying the authority the Church and organizing protests against the Archdiocese. [15] The first of the three was Judge Leander Perez, 70, a parish judge from St. Bernard Parish, who called on Catholics to withhold donations to the Archdiocese and to boycott Sunday church collections. The second was Jackson G. Ricau, 44, political commentator, segregationist writer, and director of the “Citizens Council of South Louisiana”. The third was Una Gaillot, 41, mother of two, housewife, and president of “Save Our Nation Inc.”. [16] [4] The excommunications made national headlines and had the tacit support of the papacy. [1]
A few months later, the 1963 school year began on September of 1962. A handful of black students were admitted to previously all-white Catholic schools. Earlier threats of boycotts and mass student transfers to public schools never materialized. No violence took place between whites and the black students. Parents and students grudgingly surrendered to Rummel’s decision, and racial segregation in the Archdiocese quietly faded from memory. [4]
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Rummel
 
As I recall it occurred during the Civil Rights struggle of the early to mid 60’s. A bishop, Louisiana I think, excommunicated all politicians who opposed basic civil rights legislation.

This is a fuzzy memory so there may be errors in the details, but I think the general sense is accurately given.
Don’t know about denying communion, but Cardinal Bernard Law, who has since been disgraced on another issue, was very outspoken when he was bishop in his former diocese about civil rights, the sin of racial discrimination and violence, and very vocal about the morality of this issue for forming Catholic conscience.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top