Details of a sin in confession

  • Thread starter Thread starter BraCat
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BraCat

Guest
Hello,

I want to convert after decades of really serious sin and fear of hell. I’m serious, praying the rosary dialy and try to learn, and I need advice about some “minor” details of my confession.

Years ago, I admit that I sort of bullied(I’m not trying to embellish it, just think that it isn’t the exact word) someone, and I’ll confess it no matter what. But I’m ashamed to enter in detail with the priest. It had different scales

I’ll be as accurate as I need to. It’s just that, if possible, I don’t want to tell every action. But I don’t plan to be generic either.

On this matter of detail. I also blasphemed against God. Do I also have to tell what I did in confession?
 
Welcome to CAF.

Welcome to the process to come into the CC.

Not sure where you are in the process, so guessing you will be going through RCIA?

With regard to confession, all the information you will need will be learned in RCIA, where you will be able to ask all the questions you need.

During your first confession, the priest will help you make a good confession.

Welcome again!

Take care,
 
Hello,

I want to convert after decades of really serious sin and fear of hell. I’m serious, praying the rosary dialy and try to learn, and I need advice about some “minor” details of my confession.

Years ago, I admit that I sort of bullied(I’m not trying to embellish it, just think that it isn’t the exact word) someone, and I’ll confess it no matter what. But I’m ashamed to enter in detail with the priest. It had different scales

I’ll be as accurate as I need to. It’s just that, if possible, I don’t want to tell every action. But I don’t plan to be generic either.

On this matter of detail. I also blasphemed against God. Do I also have to tell what I did in confession?
You won’t need to go into the details. Just say you bullied a classmate, X numbers of years ago, for XX period of time. If the priest needs more details then he will ask. If you are in RCIA, the team members will make sure you are well prepared for your first confession.
 
Older sins usually are going to be sketchy - give the general details, be sincere - if the confessor needs more, he will ask for it. Take it from someone who put off confession for decades - it’s worth doing it sooner rather than later! Good luck on your journey!
 
Welcome! 👋

As others have said, the priest and/or those who will assist in RCIA (presuming that’s the path you are on) will help you with this. As the RCIA guy at my parish, I will share with you what I share with my people. I don’t mean to be long-winded, but I’m building to a point (or perhaps several points). 🙂 :o

There are two primary classifications of sin: mortal sin and venial sin. Mortal sin cuts off our relationship with God while venial sin damages it without rupturing it completely. In other words, venial sins bend the stick while mortal sins break it.

For a sin to be mortal, it must fulfill all three of the following: (1) it must be grave, serious matter; (2) it must be something done with full knowledge of the sinfulness of the act; and (3) it must have been chosen freely with complete consent. If any of these three characteristics is missing, the sin is venial, not mortal.

In Confession, we have the opportunity to be forgiven of our sins, both mortal and venial. It is required that we confess all mortal sins. Not only must we confess them, but we must also confess the number of times we committed them. Strictly speaking, we do not have to confess venial sins, but it is nonetheless a good thing to do (because the sacrament gives us grace and can help us to commit even venial sins less often).

Now, this can seem quite intimidating to many, but we must recall that our God is a merciful God and the Church is a merciful mother. The Church does not obligate us to do what is impossible. Very few of us have photographic memories with perfect recall. Particularly for those like yourself who will be confessing for the first time, it is unlikely you will remember the number of times you committed every grave sin. The priest, too, understands this. The important thing is to do your best and not deliberately withhold something.

Now, in many cases, the priest does not need to know (nor does he want to know!) the minutiae of every sin. But, sometimes, details are important. Saying “I was angry and I hit someone” is one thing. If that person was your elderly mother, that would be a detail you need to include because it changes things.

You mention the bullying. Now, the priest may not need to know the specifics. But if he asks a question asking for more details, answer it honestly. And if you think the details are important, ask the priest about it.

Confession can be intimidating, but I think there can be great grace in embracing the uncomfortableness of it. Sin isn’t pleasant. We can’t whitewash it and pretend it’s okay. Sometimes, boldly naming and confronting it, even though it is a major exercise in humility, is exactly what we need to do.

And always remember, the priest has heard it all before and is bound by penalty of excommunication not to ever reveal anything about your Confession. I’ve never known a priest who does not take that absolute secrecy very seriously. They would sooner be tortured and die rather than reveal to someone else what you told them in Confession. So whatever you tell the priest, it will remain private.

God bless you on your journey!
 
Welcome!

I agree with the others. You should tell the kind of sin it was (bullying) and when it occurred. The one thing I might suggest you add is whether or not it was physical or verbal ( or both) Your priest will definitely ask you for more details if he sees fit.
 
Hello,

I want to convert after decades of really serious sin and fear of hell. I’m serious, praying the rosary dialy and try to learn, and I need advice about some “minor” details of my confession.

Years ago, I admit that I sort of bullied(I’m not trying to embellish it, just think that it isn’t the exact word) someone, and I’ll confess it no matter what. But I’m ashamed to enter in detail with the priest. It had different scales

I’ll be as accurate as I need to. It’s just that, if possible, I don’t want to tell every action. But I don’t plan to be generic either.

On this matter of detail. I also blasphemed against God. Do I also have to tell what I did in confession?
NOT TO WORRY:D

1st:As the NORM, entry into the RCC requires participation in RCIA [a course of "Rights if Initiation for Adults]. I co-taught RCIA for 3 years before retiring from active ministry.

It is the NORM for this course to include a FIRST Sacramental Confession:

1 John 1:6-8
1 John 5: 16-17
John 20:19-23

This is accomplished as a one on one encounter with the Priest and the pentenant is
  1. PRIVATE
  2. Unconditionally confidential
  3. And as the NORM [but it depends of the individual confessor] is a "GENERAL Confession. WHY? Because it is impracticable [at best], if not impossible to expect ANY adult to recall ALL of the sins of their past life. :)🙂 So the NORM is just to seek true repentance for past sins, along with a FIRM [real] commitment to change one;s ways and to WITH God’s grace, avoid sinning in the same way i n the future.
But you are correct that also as the NORM for Sacramental Confession the priest has the right [and the need] to expect the details of our sins so that he CAN better suggest how we might overcome them in the future.👍

My friend, DON’T prolong doing what you KNOW is the right thing and what GOD desires you to do based on very human emotions.

Pray much!

Patrick
 
I’m very grateful for all the answers. They really dissipate my doubts.
 
if the details change the gravity of the sin then you should confess them if not you dont have to.

God Bless
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top