Devastated faith after miscarraige

  • Thread starter Thread starter nsm
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nsm

Guest
My husband and I have been praying to get pregnant for a while. Last year during advent, I went to the cathedral in San Francisco and got a St. Gerard prayer card. I prayed the novena for motherhood and on the feast of Mary, Mother of God, I found out that I was pregnant! My husband and I were through the moon, and we immediately ran to church to give thanks. While there, I dedicated the child to him.

We couldn’t keep the wonderful news to ourselves because this would have been our family’s first grandchild so we told our close family, who then told their close friends…soon everyone we knew was excited about the news. Then on Ash Wednesday, just a few days shy of my second trimester, the end of the “danger zone” for miscarriage, I miscarried. To say that I was devastated would be an understatement. The miscarriage was extremely long, and painful. I also ran into some complications while it was progressing so I had to have surgery.

We had a service and burial for our child at a Catholic cemetery. After the service, my parents - who had flown in to California from Chicago to be by my side during the painful miscarriage and subsequent surgery - pulled me aside and told me that my uncle’s house had burned down that night. We’re a very close family, and my uncle’s wife is at a severe stage of early onset Alzheimer’s disease.

About two months later I got pregnant again, but that pregnancy also ended in an early miscarriage. At first I was too broken to feel any anger, but then the questions came. As the weeks past and Mother’s day came and went, and everybody started to wonder why I just couldn’t realize that “those babies just weren’t meant to be” or “I’d get pregnant again,” I started to get angry.

I have always been devoted to God for as long as I can remember. I was raised a staunch Baptist, was involved in campus ministry during college and into my twenties. In 2007, on the first day of advent, my husband and I converted to Roman Catholicism. I’ve had other tragedies but I always took comfort in God. But this hit me harder than any other loss i’d sustained and, I have to admit that I completely lost my faith. I can’t p(name removed by moderator)oint the specific day that it happened but I do know that sometime in May 2012, I stopped going to mass, stopped praying…I stopped believing in God.

This coming week is the day that would have been my due date. Even though I’m sad I can feel that my heart has been softening towards God again. Yet, i’ve been away so long, I feel embarrassed to go back and confess. I’m afraid the priest will judge me, or tell me that my pain was “no big deal” that it “happens to a lot of women.” I also still feel very angry.

Any constructive advice (not judgmental advice, e.g. “other people have it tougher,” or “just get over it” would be appreciated. Also, I’ve read the book of Job many times.) on how to come back to God after something like this would be greatly appreciated.
 
First of all, let me say that I am very, very sorry for your loss. It’s difficult to get over. My wife and I had four miscarriages in the course of just over a year. With the first one, I too was very angry at God. But to be angry at God is to acknowledge his existence and his role in our lives. It doesn’t stop because we might be angry at Him. While I didn’t stop going to church, I had to confess my anger. It is a sin against the first commandment, but our culpability is lessened by the circumstances. I also found fault with people who didn’t understand, which I probably should have confessed at the time too. It was hard, and I didn’t really feel like the priest sympathized. But I don’t need him to, I just need him to say the words of absolution. So don’t be embarrassed, just go do it. It’s like washing the dishes. Nobody wants to do it, but if we don’t we’ll get sick, and the dirty dishes piling up looks gross.

Your children are yours. You love them, even if others can’t understand the depth and reality of that love. They just can’t understand, and it’s not really their fault. They didn’t know the children growing inside of you. They are given ideas by a society that doesn’t consider children people before they are born. They are ignorant, and so they are deserving of your forgiveness, even if it takes a long time to complete that work. Your grief also takes a long time. I still have the ultrasound picture on my computer from prior to the last miscarriage we had, which was about nine months ago. Nobody understands what it is, nor can they.

My advice is to turn away from the anger, and focus on your love for your children. Pray for God’s mercy and justice, and that they remain in his tender embrace, and trust that they are in his embrace. Ask that they pray for you and your family. They are still your children, even if you never had the chance to hold them, and even if society doesn’t sufficiently recognize it. Go to confession, and don’t worry about what the priest is thinking. The priest is in Persona Christi, even if he doesn’t look like he is, so treat it as talking to Jesus.

Remember that Jesus wept at the death of his friend, Lazarus. Christ said “Blessed are they who mourn, for they shall be comforted.” So look for that comfort as you mourn, and confession is a good place to start. But don’t let that mourning become self-destructive. Then you will have lost your children, and Christ. It is better to have Christ with the knowledge that His mercy will also help your children. Right now, you are focused on your loss, but you don’t only have loss. You have children who have died. Feed your children with your prayers. Clothe them with your tears. Hug them with your love. In anger, you cannot offer these things to your children, so let go of it, and know that God will understand and forgive it, and then you can love your babies properly, by giving of yourself spiritually. I cry and pray for you, and ask for your prayers as well.
 
My husband and I have been praying to get pregnant for a while. Last year during advent, I went to the cathedral in San Francisco and got a St. Gerard prayer card. I prayed the novena for motherhood and on the feast of Mary, Mother of God, I found out that I was pregnant! My husband and I were through the moon, and we immediately ran to church to give thanks. While there, I dedicated the child to him.

We couldn’t keep the wonderful news to ourselves because this would have been our family’s first grandchild so we told our close family, who then told their close friends…soon everyone we knew was excited about the news. Then on Ash Wednesday, just a few days shy of my second trimester, the end of the “danger zone” for miscarriage, I miscarried. To say that I was devastated would be an understatement. The miscarriage was extremely long, and painful. I also ran into some complications while it was progressing so I had to have surgery.

We had a service and burial for our child at a Catholic cemetery. After the service, my parents - who had flown in to California from Chicago to be by my side during the painful miscarriage and subsequent surgery - pulled me aside and told me that my uncle’s house had burned down that night. We’re a very close family, and my uncle’s wife is at a severe stage of early onset Alzheimer’s disease.

About two months later I got pregnant again, but that pregnancy also ended in an early miscarriage. At first I was too broken to feel any anger, but then the questions came. As the weeks past and Mother’s day came and went, and everybody started to wonder why I just couldn’t realize that “those babies just weren’t meant to be” or “I’d get pregnant again,” I started to get angry.

I have always been devoted to God for as long as I can remember. I was raised a staunch Baptist, was involved in campus ministry during college and into my twenties. In 2007, on the first day of advent, my husband and I converted to Roman Catholicism. I’ve had other tragedies but I always took comfort in God. But this hit me harder than any other loss i’d sustained and, I have to admit that I completely lost my faith. I can’t p(name removed by moderator)oint the specific day that it happened but I do know that sometime in May 2012, I stopped going to mass, stopped praying…I stopped believing in God.

This coming week is the day that would have been my due date. Even though I’m sad I can feel that my heart has been softening towards God again. Yet, i’ve been away so long, I feel embarrassed to go back and confess. I’m afraid the priest will judge me, or tell me that my pain was “no big deal” that it “happens to a lot of women.” I also still feel very angry.

Any constructive advice (not judgmental advice, e.g. “other people have it tougher,” or “just get over it” would be appreciated. Also, I’ve read the book of Job many times.) on how to come back to God after something like this would be greatly appreciated.
My wife and I lost one…

He’s in heaven.

Thanks be to God.
 
I just wanted to say that I am so sorry for your losses.

What a grace that after what you have been through, you are feeling drawn back to the Church. Please don’t be afraid to go to church and to confess. Your priest has heard it all. If you are afraid of facing him, perhaps go to a parish where there is not face to face confession? This is standard in the extraordinary form parishes, by the way. Don’t despair of God’s mercy.
 
I am sorry for your losses. I had 4 miscarriages after my daughter was born, so I can understand your pain. I also understand your anger. I felt it too. I also felt at times like I lost my faith. I found my way back, though, and I am glad you are too. I don’t have any advice, just empathy and prayers.
 
I’ve been there. We’ve lost children at 11,12,15 weeks gestation.

What I find consoling is knowing those children are with God, and have the ability to pray for us. I can ask them to watch over someone for me, or show me how to truly love as He does, since that’s all they’ve ever known.

/hugs

It is normal to grieve over the death of your children. Don’t let anyone tell you it is not.
 
Any constructive advice (not judgmental advice, e.g. “other people have it tougher,” or “just get over it” would be appreciated. Also, I’ve read the book of Job many times.) on how to come back to God after something like this would be greatly appreciated.
Yell at Him. By yourself so folks don’t think you are nuts, tell Him exactly how angry you are. Say everything that comes into your mind and from your heart. He’s real, and really big, and He can take it. He wants to hear from you. So, go yell at Him. As much as you need.

I’m so sorry for your loss. I’d also be so surprised if a priest didn’t understand how devastated you are and how real your grief is. I didn’t even get to bury mine, so I get how lonely the grief can feel.

Anyway, if you get mad at your husband, you might stop talking to him for a while, but you know that you don’t really get over or through the issue until you air it out. Srsly. Talk to your Father. Yell at Him, be as angry as you really are. Keep talking. BTW, our children are with Him, safe and sound. You can talk to them also.
 
You are really and truly a Momma now, so of course you are still grieving from the loss of your little ones. Give all your pain to the Blessed Mother and she will find a way to comfort you. And remember to ask your little Saints to pray for you and your husband and call them by name-they are always in your heart. Go to confession-you will be so glad to have that Grace and receive the Eucharist as often as you can.
You and yours are in my prayers, too.
 
Will keep you in our prayers to let God’s Mercy shower down upon you
 
You’re on the right path. Keep it up, getting closer to God. He is waiting for you and He is proving your loyalty.
 
If you are looking for something else to read, I would suggest “A Grief Observed” by C.S. Lewis. It is not about miscarriage, or even the death of a child, but it is about the loss of a dearly loved family member (a spouse in this case) and it is brutally honest. At the beginning it can be painful reading because the anguish is so intense. But, by the time you get to the end, a strong element of hope has come in, even though the grief is still there.

God bless you.
 
Yell at Him. By yourself so folks don’t think you are nuts, tell Him exactly how angry you are. Say everything that comes into your mind and from your heart. He’s real, and really big, and He can take it. He wants to hear from you. So, go yell at Him. As much as you need.

I’m so sorry for your loss. I’d also be so surprised if a priest didn’t understand how devastated you are and how real your grief is. I didn’t even get to bury mine, so I get how lonely the grief can feel.

Anyway, if you get mad at your husband, you might stop talking to him for a while, but you know that you don’t really get over or through the issue until you air it out. Srsly. Talk to your Father. Yell at Him, be as angry as you really are. Keep talking. BTW, our children are with Him, safe and sound. You can talk to them also.
This.
 
This coming week is the day that would have been my due date. Even though I’m sad I can feel that my heart has been softening towards God again. Yet, i’ve been away so long, I feel embarrassed to go back and confess. I’m afraid the priest will judge me, or tell me that my pain was “no big deal” that it “happens to a lot of women.” I also still feel very angry.
Hi nsm,
If you can visualize that in going to see your priest that you are one of Jesus’ disciples, and all of you with Him are walking on the way to Mary and Martha’s after Lazarus died. When you go to see the priest, you are actually pulling Jesus aside on the walk and asking if he would talk with you privately.
“Jesus, I have felt so alone and angry and confused with the loss of my baby. It has put up a wall between me and you that I don’t know how to break down. I want to be with you, walk with you, learn of you, and my own feelings are keeping me from you; my own hurt is closing off my heart from loving you.
How can you let me walk with you when I am this way? You are my life, but my hurt and emptiness is saying that I am not truly alive without having my baby. It is a temptation like you faced in the desert when Satan said you were not truly the Son of God without having bread to eat at your command, or like when you will die on the cross and people will say to you that if you are really the Son of God you should come down from the cross and not be there.
Jesus, my King, my Lord, my Friend, I want to be with you; I also desire to have a child. But I want all that I am and all that I have to be from you. Can I stay with you? Would you forgive me and let me walk with you today to Mary and Martha’s house, and everyday, in spite of the hurt, confusion, and anger that I have been experiencing?”
Jesus: “nsm, I am the resurrection, I am the Life. Do you believe that? Come walk with us as one of us”

Refuse the anger, nsm; when you have a child you will want to be a mother who radiates constant love (to God and to your child), not a mother who changes based on good or bad things happening. You will want to raise your child knowing also how to love and hope with this same constancy. Take heart and see your priest. but know you are talking with Jesus.

John Martin
 
Any constructive advice (not judgmental advice, e.g. “other people have it tougher,” or “just get over it” would be appreciated. Also, I’ve read the book of Job many times.) on how to come back to God after something like this would be greatly appreciated.
Yes, you can get angry at God. But … think about this … God is not angry at you. How could he be – He has just been given two new beautiful souls in heaven … souls that He didn’t have before … souls that He couldn’t possibly have had without you. And you, nsm, mother of two children, your children will be re-united with you in heaven, yes, *your children *that could not have ever existed without you; reunited in unconditional love between you, your children, and God who made it all possible, not just for one measly lifetime on earth, but for all eternity, never to leave you again.

I am just a guy, but I know a mother’s love can involve a great deal of pain. That is how you can know that you are, and will always be, a mother.
 
What a devastating experience! I’m so sorry for your loss! I’ve never been in your shoes, but I know that when my sister lost her baby girl, she was offered a support group at a local church. I don’t know if you would find that helpful, but it is something to consider. I was also away from God for a long time and I was really afraid of confessing to a priest when I did come back to the Church. I was so relieved once it was over and I knew I was forgiven. It was a real comfort to know that while I’d given up on God, he hadn’t given up on me.
 
How devastating! I am so sorry for your losses!

Those of us who outlive our children will probably always wonder why. Those of us who suffer tragedy in general often wonder why of all the ways we could suffer that God permits THAT kind of suffering. Why didn’t he protect us from our fallen world THIS time?

But God does offer comfort, even if the people around us who we think should offer comfort don’t seem to know enough to do so.

Please see your priest. If he doesn’t understand then perhaps God has plans for you to be the one to make him understand so he can be sensitive to the women who come to him in the future. Please don’t stay away from the Church.
 
There’s been some very good advice. I’d add:
  1. There’s a very good book entitled What Was Lost: A Christian Journey Through Miscarriage.
  2. The support group idea is a very good one.
  3. I know doctors often wait until after a third miscarriage to begin aggressive investigation of the causes of miscarriage, since once or twice could just be a fluke rather than there being some sort of underlying medical cause. However, that’s a long time to wait, and there are a number of things that can be done medically to improve your chances (a couple things come to mind, but I know that the moderators don’t want commentors giving medical advice on the forum). I would encourage you to either ask for a higher level of care from your OB or to switch practices to somebody with a more aggressive approach to preventing miscarriage. It may just be a fluke, or the underlying cause may be unfixable, but there really are some easy fixes that could save you from an unnecessary repeat miscarriage.
  4. Don’t expect that getting pregnant is going to fix you. It’s a better place to be than just mourning your losses, but it’s going to be a much sadder, more anxious experience than if you had never miscarried.
 
Thank you everyone for your kind replies. I did go to confession and mass this past Sunday and I’m so glad that I did. Its still a long road for me…the anger remains and my faith has still taken a beating, but your responses really filled me with so much courage and love. Thank you all SO MUCH!
 
Yes, you can get angry at God. But … think about this … God is not angry at you. How could he be – He has just been given two new beautiful souls in heaven … souls that He didn’t have before … souls that He couldn’t possibly have had without you. And you, nsm, mother of two children, your children will be re-united with you in heaven, yes, your children that could not have ever existed without you; reunited in unconditional love between you, your children, and God who made it all possible, not just for one measly lifetime on earth, but for all eternity, never to leave you again.

I am just a guy, but I know a mother’s love can involve a great deal of pain. That is how you can know that you are, and will always be, a mother.
**
THIS!!! A Big THIS.
**
I am just finishing up my miscarriage… OH BOY! Nobody tells you how it’s going to be do they?!

Anyway, That thought has kept ME from anything the Devil could use against me…
You know trying to find others going through other things or these very things may help too? Peruse this site! There’s a bigger picture and sometimes their stories help me. If the Lord had to carry His, surely I’ll have to carry mine on this Earth for the Heaven He has awaiting me!

He {MY Son} got there before me! I can’t believe it… Honestly I think it’s beautiful and I might be the weird and only one to think I am GLAD He’s there … WOW. Without having to suffer here, without having to experience a torture …getting shot in a classroom. Without giving me those hurts and others. He is in TOTAL Perfection.
 
Never accept defeat. There is always a way.

Find a doctor who specializes in fertility and prenatal care (within morally acceptable guidelines). Miscarriages are not natural and should never be accepted as “part of the risk”. The only good thing is that the medical research is out there because it happens often enough. They are a sign that something is amiss and needs to be treated. It could be minor. It doesn’t have to be something dangerous to you, but if possible, it needs to be treated before trying again.

God may show us the way, but we still have to walk the path with our own feet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top