Devout Catholic friend who sins regularly?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nimbus123
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nimbus123

Guest
Dear Fellow Catholics, please help me to understand this. I have a dear Catholic friend who is very, very devout, and is a wonderful person. She works very hard and gives a LOT of her income away to the locally indigent. She does a lot of good work. Well, lately I’ve found out (from multiple sources) that she steals from the company she works for, and has falsified records (lied) to cover it up. This money she (allegedly) gives to the poor. A sort of Robin Hood, if you will.

IMO, this is still a sin, and that the end does not justify the means, and this kind of negates her spirituality. I am having trouble sorting this out in my mind. Does anybody care to share their opinion?
 
IMO, this is still a sin, and that the end does not justify the means, and this kind of negates her spirituality. I am having trouble sorting this out in my mind. Does anybody care to share their opinion?
Yes, it is wrong. Very wrong. She’s playing God.

She may think the causes are deserving, and maybe they are. Maybe she also thinks the people she’s stealing from “owe” to the causes, and that’s where she’s playing judge without authorization.

Or she may be “righting” a wrong in her mind somehow. Maybe there is a wrong, but still is it her job to be judge, jury and executioner?

I don’t know if you have any responsibility in all this as far as warning her, (you might but I don’t assume so) but just in your own mind, don’t be deceived just because she apparently is. I can’t say it’s a mortal sin because we don’t know her state of mind, although I’m guessing she doesn’t find anything wrong in what she’s doing. For all we know, she believes she’s doing this for the glory of God. It could be pride, reward-seeking, or any number of things. Who knows, maybe she’s getting kickbacks?

Alan
 
You don’t have first hand knowledge of this. You have only “heard it”. Unless you have first hand knowledge, as in seeing her do it, leave it alone.

Basing your opinions on gossip and rumor is wrong. Participating in gossip and rumor mongering is wrong.

At best, pray for the people telling you this, and pray for your friend on the off chance it is true.

Bottom line, and this is said with all Christian charity. Unless you have first hand knowledge, and are 100% sure, butt out.
 
You don’t have first hand knowledge of this. You have only “heard it”. Unless you have first hand knowledge, as in seeing her do it, leave it alone.

Basing your opinions on gossip and rumor is wrong. Participating in gossip and rumor mongering is wrong.

At best, pray for the people telling you this, and pray for your friend on the off chance it is true.

Bottom line, and this is said with all Christian charity. Unless you have first hand knowledge, and are 100% sure, butt out.
This. Leave it alone, even if there is multiple sources telling you there is a crime taking place, doesn’t mean it may be true. Do you doubt the character of your friend that much that you would believe what other people are saying?
 
Actually, she and I work for the same company, and I witnessed it myself. So it’s not rumor. I was taken aback, and thought maybe it was a one-off thing. Apparently it’s not.

I have no intention to harm her in any way. I was just confused about how to view this spiritually.
 
Actually, she and I work for the same company, and I witnessed it myself. So it’s not rumor. I was taken aback, and thought maybe it was a one-off thing. Apparently it’s not.

I have no intention to harm her in any way. I was just confused about how to view this spiritually.
Then you OP was somewhat misleading.

If you are 100% sure of what you saw, and there is no possibility of misunderstanding, then you are morally obligated to report it.

Again, you have to be 100% sure. There cannot be any doubt, or you are bearing false witness.

You might also talk to her and say, “I saw…X, Did I miss understand?” That way it lets her know she isn’t as sly as she may think, and she may turn things around.
 
Dear Fellow Catholics, please help me to understand this. I have a dear Catholic friend who is very, very devout, and is a wonderful person. She works very hard and gives a LOT of her income away to the locally indigent. She does a lot of good work. Well, lately I’ve found out (from multiple sources) that she steals from the company she works for, and has falsified records (lied) to cover it up. This money she (allegedly) gives to the poor. A sort of Robin Hood, if you will.

IMO, this is still a sin, and that the end does not justify the means, and this kind of negates her spirituality. I am having trouble sorting this out in my mind. Does anybody care to share their opinion?
Sounds like she’s a sinner. Church is a great place for sinners.
 
nimbus, if as many people already know as you say, her bosses may learn soon enough. It’s better she hears it from you first. She is of course, endangering her career. In perspective, not the worse thing on the line, but still.
 
IF she is as good a friend as you say, I would personally talk to her about it and convince her to stop and try to make amends for the damage she has caused to the company.

Let her know that others have also seen this… She will probably be in denial at first, since no one ever admits they are guilty even when spotted first hand.

A true friend does not abandon someone in need… and she defintely needs serious help to turn her life around.
 
What interests me specifically -and this can apply to sin in general- is how a very good and spiritual person reconciles the breaking of the commandments with her conscience.

We see this all around us in society.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top