Did I sell out a friend to get what I want?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ma.Eugenia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your replies.
[Originally posted by **wjp984
] There might be one way to reconcile and truly apologize. Tell your friend that you had no intention of hurting him or getting him and ther others removed from the class. Tell him that when you were asked to give names you thought that they were questioning your honesty and saying prove it. Therefore you thought that if you could show them that you were not lieing and that people were allowed in they would also let you in as well. Your friend will probably still be very upset but might be more understanding.

Thanks for the suggestion. I will try to be as honest as possible when I get the courage to do so. I am still mustering enough courage to say something to him. For one thing, the guy’s so much taller than me and I really am not looking forward to seeing him angry.

So far, it seems, he doesn’t know yet… but…its like waiting for “water to drop from a dripping faucet”.
[Originally posted by **Meggie
] However, I have learned that a student is soley responsible for mapping out their courses for their 2-4 years at a uni. In many ways its your own fault for not figuring this out in a timely manner. You did not investigate all the options at the beginning of the semester…thats YOUR fault and not the schools.

I suppose it depends on the course where prescribed sequencing can be overlooked. For example, a student may perhaps take Math 3 that is supposed to be taken in 2nd year together with English 5 which is a 3rd year subject as the former is not a pre-requisite of the latter.

The dean’s office denied my taking the subjects against the sequence (prescribed by our national education boards), when I heard that many students were able to take it through the “backdoor enrollment” at the registrar department — rightly, because it was like taking “Algebra” before taking Basic Math. One would not expect me to understand fully if I didn’t know the basic.

That is why when the owner (of the school) found out what was going on, he got angry and put a stop to this “backdoor enrollment”. It became a big issue at school.

I realize now, that the sequencing of subjects was prescribed by our local education board and should be followed strictly, moreso, because we are trying to master a healthcare course where the health and lives of people will be in our “hands” as nurses (when we graduate). The subjects that I was talking about were major Nursing subjects. It just wouldn’t do well for our patients if we do not understand our lessons correctly.
[Originally posted by **seekerz
] What you did isn’t necessarily wrong in itself but your motive for doing it is what is important.

If you took a stand against unfair practices because they were wrong, then that’s great - the world needs more people like you. If you did all of this to get the same advantage for yourself that others were getting unfairly then to me that would be wrong.

I am sorry to say that my motive was wrong, as my reason for making the stand was to get the same advantage the others got—even if I knew that the “advantage” was wrong in the first place.

I realize now that over and beyond hurting my classmate by naming him—there was an issue bigger than this: Had I gotten my own way, there is a chance that I will not end up to be the “Nurse” I want to be or my patients will want me to be —all for my selfish reason of wanting to finish early and not be left behind by my other classmates.

More than the need to reconcile with my classmate, I think, I really need to take stock of what is really needed for me to be a good nurse.

I feel I let my friend down, I’ve let myself down but most important of all, I’ve let God down. I should learn to fight only if I have good reason and my motives can be justified in the eyes of God. I wasn’t fighting for right, I was fighting to have a “slice” of a wrong.

I am glad that it is now all out in the open. The school has now implemented stricter policies to make sure that everyone follows the rules.

Though, I admit, given the circumstance and my motives, that it was “no thanks” to me that good still came out of all this mess.
 
I think perhaps there is a bit more to this which hyou have said because of the guilt you feel.
Grace Angel.
The guilt I feel is pretty complex because
  1. The guy was a good friend and I divulged information that was given to me “in good faith” as a friend.
  2. Also, though the result of my actions were beneficial to the school, students and patients, my motives were not pristine.
As I said in my previous post:
I wasn’t fighting for right, I was fighting to have a “slice” of a wrong.
I am learning that if I have to fight…it always should be with the right motives.
 
Ma. Eugenia:
The woman who held a high position in school asked me if I could name a person she allowed to take the subject out of sequence. In anger, I said the name of my friend .
No, your not responsible.

There is no reason why you should accept that the woman was acting in other than a professional manner. You could not know that asking names, or her granting favors(acting in a judiciary manner) was not an option as a part of her job description, nor that her activities are private. If she was doing something she was not supposed to do, then the risk was hers. If there was any concern of privacy, she has as a public employee should tell the person it’s a private matter.

You have every reason to trust that she administers equally among all the students and she is doing her job. If she’s not supposed to, then she has failed you and you are a victim also.

This is called sin compounding. A person can sin and is culpable for the source sin as well as the sins of the effects.

AndyF
 
The guilt I feel is pretty complex because
  1. The guy was a good friend and I divulged information that was given to me “in good faith” as a friend.
  2. Also, though the result of my actions were beneficial to the school, students and patients, my motives were not pristine.
As I said in my previous post:

Ma Eugenia

It is what lies behind the “not pristine” which is causing the guilt.
You need to speak to a trust person, to help you look behind the “not pristine” and then proceed from there.
God Bless
Grace Angel.

I am learning that if I have to fight…it always should be with the right motives.
 
Though, I admit, given the circumstance and my motives, that it was “no thanks” to me that good still came out of all this mess.
Regardless what happened, it sounds like you’ve got your life in the hands of God. That’s just the kind of thing He does for His children: bring something good out of our mistakes even while we learn from them.
 
Thanks everyone for your replies.

A friend forwarded a text message to my cellphone last Easter that said:
“God did not promise to make life easy for you…but He promised to be always with you.”
There are many times, it seems that I tend to fall “flat on my face” because of my temper, my tactlessness (sometimes), my impatience, etc, that gets me in trouble sooo…many times, I realize that God allows me to learn from my mistakes --though, I can be pretty hard headed at times and it does take a lot of “falling” before I really learn the good lesson that I am supposed to learn.

I do thank God for my family at home and also my Catholic family here at Catholic Answers forums for helping pick up life lessons on how to be a good Christian through this post.

God bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top