I don’t think that kind of censorship is right. Freedom of speech should be upheld. While I do not think it is arrogant to say that Catholicism alone has the truth, (In fact, we should be saying it) I do think that it is important to love our neighbor and “play nice” with others even though we disagree. Even though they may be wrong, we can’t just shut them up.
Let’s extend this principle: “that we should protect our neighbor from falsehood by censoring everyone that disagrees with us Catholics, who have the truth”(And I really do firmly believe that we Catholics have the truth)
Suppose you were in a three-way conversation, you are a Catholic of course, another person talking with you is an atheist, and the third is undecided on religious matters. Suppose you interrupted and perhaps even shouted over the atheist whenever he tried to speak. Even if he was saying some nasty and offensive, anti-Catholic things, it would be very impolite and certainly not loving to try to shut him up or make sure he is not heard. But if taking books from mail boxes is right then so is this. Suppose the atheist, on the contrary, was kind and let you talk whenever you wanted to say something. Which religious opinion is the undecided listener more likely to believe when the conversation is over? Probably atheism. He certainly wouldn’t think much of the Catholic Church after that, and would go and talk with the atheist without you present so that he could actually hear what he had to say.
Imagine if a Catholic Apologist tried to interrupt and shut up his opponent during a public debate with a prominent atheist? It would be disastrous. The atheist would most certainly win more hearts and minds, just by being civil. There could never be any debates if people acted this way. We need to allow discussion. It is a way of loving our neighbor and, if people’s hearts are open to it and the truth is presented well, the truth will prevail anyway, because it is true. Moreover, the truth can be shown all the more true when challenged in discussion.
Whenever someone claims “I have the truth.” and then censors everyone who speaks a word against it, people may start to wonder if he’s just shutting everyone else up because he knows his viewpoint won’t hold water under scrutiny. The world looks at him and asks: “If you are so confident that what you say is true, then why do you have to silence everyone else?”. (I bet many a citizen under oppressive dictatorship has asked this question of government propaganda.)
Now let’s extend to politics. It is indeed relevant since we are dealing with truth, and many people are absolutely certain about which ways are best to govern a country with, and would not like their neighbors to fall into error, which could possibly lead to the demise of the country. (Not, in itself, as bad as the demise of a soul, but nonetheless, still relevant). And there are indeed, *objectively *speaking, better ways to govern a country as opposed to others.
Would you take political pamphlets left on people’s doorstep? Would you take down other people’s campaign signs from telephone poles and roadsides? My father gets really annoyed when other people take down the signs that he sets up, or when they try to cover them with the sign of an opponent. Aren’t these dirty tactics? Should we, who have the truth, stoop to such a level? It can be hard to refrain from shutting up people who say extremely irritating things, but we need to. That is what Christ calls us to. Despite how annoyed my father gets, he does not resort to using the same dirty tactics against the other side, he merely replaces his own signs.
We must treat others with kindness and respect by letting them speak (or distribute books). But at the same time, we must stand for the truth by speaking (or distributing books) ourselves, to counter the falsehood.
My verdict:
I think, in the case of the mail box thing, the best thing to do might have been to put some sort of Catholic pamphlet, book, or your own personal note on the mail boxes as well,(or if that’s against the law you could put it on their porch or stick it on their door, wherever your neighbors can see it). but leave the JW book with it. That way, you are still showing love to your neighbor by presenting them with the truth, and still showing love for the JWs by not “shutting them up”. I think that the OP did steal, but it does not seem like he realized what he was doing at the time.