Did I steal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter miguelgar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m shocked people are still trying to justify this behavior. Not for me to judge, but wow. If you truly feel like this is OK, well 🤷
Fascinating that you and Mac are having such a hard time giving a reason why the behavior is problematic, isn’t it? When one side is saying, “You’re stupid, wrong, and judgmental, and I’m not going to tell you why!,” and the other side is explaining their case through rational discussion, guess where charity lies? Continue to hit people on the head with your condescending emotional hammers all you like, it doesn’t amount to sense. 🤷
 
I don’t think that kind of censorship is right. Freedom of speech should be upheld. While I do not think it is arrogant to say that Catholicism alone has the truth, (In fact, we should be saying it) I do think that it is important to love our neighbor and “play nice” with others even though we disagree. Even though they may be wrong, we can’t just shut them up.

Let’s extend this principle: “that we should protect our neighbor from falsehood by censoring everyone that disagrees with us Catholics, who have the truth”(And I really do firmly believe that we Catholics have the truth)

Suppose you were in a three-way conversation, you are a Catholic of course, another person talking with you is an atheist, and the third is undecided on religious matters. Suppose you interrupted and perhaps even shouted over the atheist whenever he tried to speak. Even if he was saying some nasty and offensive, anti-Catholic things, it would be very impolite and certainly not loving to try to shut him up or make sure he is not heard. But if taking books from mail boxes is right then so is this. Suppose the atheist, on the contrary, was kind and let you talk whenever you wanted to say something. Which religious opinion is the undecided listener more likely to believe when the conversation is over? Probably atheism. He certainly wouldn’t think much of the Catholic Church after that, and would go and talk with the atheist without you present so that he could actually hear what he had to say.

Imagine if a Catholic Apologist tried to interrupt and shut up his opponent during a public debate with a prominent atheist? It would be disastrous. The atheist would most certainly win more hearts and minds, just by being civil. There could never be any debates if people acted this way. We need to allow discussion. It is a way of loving our neighbor and, if people’s hearts are open to it and the truth is presented well, the truth will prevail anyway, because it is true. Moreover, the truth can be shown all the more true when challenged in discussion.

Whenever someone claims “I have the truth.” and then censors everyone who speaks a word against it, people may start to wonder if he’s just shutting everyone else up because he knows his viewpoint won’t hold water under scrutiny. The world looks at him and asks: “If you are so confident that what you say is true, then why do you have to silence everyone else?”. (I bet many a citizen under oppressive dictatorship has asked this question of government propaganda.)

Now let’s extend to politics. It is indeed relevant since we are dealing with truth, and many people are absolutely certain about which ways are best to govern a country with, and would not like their neighbors to fall into error, which could possibly lead to the demise of the country. (Not, in itself, as bad as the demise of a soul, but nonetheless, still relevant). And there are indeed, *objectively *speaking, better ways to govern a country as opposed to others.

Would you take political pamphlets left on people’s doorstep? Would you take down other people’s campaign signs from telephone poles and roadsides? My father gets really annoyed when other people take down the signs that he sets up, or when they try to cover them with the sign of an opponent. Aren’t these dirty tactics? Should we, who have the truth, stoop to such a level? It can be hard to refrain from shutting up people who say extremely irritating things, but we need to. That is what Christ calls us to. Despite how annoyed my father gets, he does not resort to using the same dirty tactics against the other side, he merely replaces his own signs.

We must treat others with kindness and respect by letting them speak (or distribute books). But at the same time, we must stand for the truth by speaking (or distributing books) ourselves, to counter the falsehood.

My verdict:
I think, in the case of the mail box thing, the best thing to do might have been to put some sort of Catholic pamphlet, book, or your own personal note on the mail boxes as well,(or if that’s against the law you could put it on their porch or stick it on their door, wherever your neighbors can see it). but leave the JW book with it. That way, you are still showing love to your neighbor by presenting them with the truth, and still showing love for the JWs by not “shutting them up”. I think that the OP did steal, but it does not seem like he realized what he was doing at the time.
 
Fascinating that you and Mac are having such a hard time giving a reason why the behavior is problematic, isn’t it? When one side is saying, “You’re stupid, wrong, and judgmental, and I’m not going to tell you why!,” and the other side is explaining their case through rational discussion, guess where charity lies? Continue to hit people on the head with your condescending emotional hammers all you like, it doesn’t amount to sense. 🤷
:confused:
Objecting to censoring what other people read is not rational?
Objecting to taking things that are not yours nor intended for you…not rational?
Objecting to a condescending attitude that other people are too dumb to decide what they want to read…that’s not rational?

Meanwhile, “rational” is “We have decided that other religion’s literature is smut and it’s our duty to destroy it to keep you from reading it, because we’re catholics and we know best”.
Really?
 
I don’t think that kind of censorship is right. Freedom of speech should be upheld. While I do not think it is arrogant to say that Catholicism alone has the truth, (In fact, we should be saying it) I do think that it is important to love our neighbor and “play nice” with others even though we disagree. Even though they may be wrong, we can’t just shut them up.

Let’s extend this principle: “that we should protect our neighbor from falsehood by censoring everyone that disagrees with us Catholics, who have the truth”(And I really do firmly believe that we Catholics have the truth)

Suppose you were in a three-way conversation, you are a Catholic of course, another person talking with you is an atheist, and the third is undecided on religious matters. Suppose you interrupted and perhaps even shouted over the atheist whenever he tried to speak. Even if he was saying some nasty and offensive, anti-Catholic things, it would be very impolite and certainly not loving to try to shut him up or make sure he is not heard. But if taking books from mail boxes is right then so is this. Suppose the atheist, on the contrary, was kind and let you talk whenever you wanted to say something. Which religious opinion is the undecided listener more likely to believe when the conversation is over? Probably atheism. He certainly wouldn’t think much of the Catholic Church after that, and would go and talk with the atheist without you present so that he could actually hear what he had to say.

Imagine if a Catholic Apologist tried to interrupt and shut up his opponent during a public debate with a prominent atheist? It would be disastrous. The atheist would most certainly win more hearts and minds, just by being civil. There could never be any debates if people acted this way. We need to allow discussion. It is a way of loving our neighbor and, if people’s hearts are open to it and the truth is presented well, the truth will prevail anyway, because it is true. Moreover, the truth can be shown all the more true when challenged in discussion.

Whenever someone claims “I have the truth.” and then censors everyone who speaks a word against it, people may start to wonder if he’s just shutting everyone else up because he knows his viewpoint won’t hold water under scrutiny. The world looks at him and asks: “If you are so confident that what you say is true, then why do you have to silence everyone else?”. (I bet many a citizen under oppressive dictatorship has asked this question of government propaganda.)

Now let’s extend to politics. It is indeed relevant since we are dealing with truth, and many people are absolutely certain about which ways are best to govern a country with, and would not like their neighbors to fall into error, which could possibly lead to the demise of the country. (Not, in itself, as bad as the demise of a soul, but nonetheless, still relevant). And there are indeed, *objectively *speaking, better ways to govern a country as opposed to others.

Would you take political pamphlets left on people’s doorstep? Would you take down other people’s campaign signs from telephone poles and roadsides? My father gets really annoyed when other people take down the signs that he sets up, or when they try to cover them with the sign of an opponent. Aren’t these dirty tactics? Should we, who have the truth, stoop to such a level? It can be hard to refrain from shutting up people who say extremely irritating things, but we need to. That is what Christ calls us to. Despite how annoyed my father gets, he does not resort to using the same dirty tactics against the other side, he merely replaces his own signs.

We must treat others with kindness and respect by letting them speak (or distribute books). But at the same time, we must stand for the truth by speaking (or distributing books) ourselves, to counter the falsehood.

My verdict:
I think, in the case of the mail box thing, the best thing to do might have been to put some sort of Catholic pamphlet, book, or your own personal note on the mail boxes as well,(or if that’s against the law you could put it on their porch or stick it on their door, wherever your neighbors can see it). but leave the JW book with it. That way, you are still showing love to your neighbor by presenting them with the truth, and still showing love for the JWs by not “shutting them up”. I think that the OP did steal, but it does not seem like he realized what he was doing at the time.
👍👍👍👍
 
I think that the OP did steal, but it does not seem like he realized what he was doing at the time.

I will ask again, who was stolen from?
I think, in the case of the mail box thing, the best thing to do might have been to put some sort of Catholic pamphlet, book, or your own personal note on the mail boxes as well,(or if that’s against the law you could put it on their porch or stick it on their door, wherever your neighbors can see it). but leave the JW book with it. That way, you are still showing love to your neighbor by presenting them with the truth, and still showing love for the JWs by not “shutting them up”
I agree with this absolutely. The problem is that most of the people who are so upset about this would probably never ever knock on someones door to share Jesus.
 
Fascinating that you and Mac are having such a hard time giving a reason why the behavior is problematic, isn’t it? When one side is saying, “You’re stupid, wrong, and judgmental, and I’m not going to tell you why!,” and the other side is explaining their case through rational discussion, guess where charity lies? Continue to hit people on the head with your condescending emotional hammers all you like, it doesn’t amount to sense. 🤷
And as noted too many times to count, the behavior is problematic because [OP] has disrupted a private transaction between two parties. Several folks have noted that yes, they WOULD like their “junk mail” or religious materials, regardless of source or delivery method. With that as the background, why is that not enough?

“Well, maybe it isn’t trespassing to reach across an easement and take it off a frame but not actual mailbox, and maybe….”

Wait, what? This has become totally circular in that we’ve (both) gone through these points countless times. The JW didn’t deliver it to the public domain, he put it in the place where I was most likely to find it. Gee what could his intent have possible been? It is my house. I want it, and I want to make the decision on it. You have stolen that opportunity from me and stolen the materials. Why is that not good enough? :confused: I seriously do not know how to say more plainly that theft is the reason the behavior is problematic.
I will ask again, who was stolen from?
And for the umpteenth time, the homeowner. You don’t have to accept it, obviously you never will. If you would have no problem telling your priest or Jesus himself that you think it is OK to take things off from a neighbor’s property because they weren’t delivered in the way you think is appropriate, or it isn’t material that you like, then it certainly doesn’t matter what so many others in this thread say, even when we say we want it.
 
And as noted too many times to count, the behavior is problematic because [OP] has disrupted a private transaction between two parties. Several folks have noted that yes, they WOULD like their “junk mail” or religious materials, regardless of source or delivery method. With that as the background, why is that not enough?

“Well, maybe it isn’t trespassing to reach across an easement and take it off a frame but not actual mailbox, and maybe….”

Wait, what? This has become totally circular in that we’ve (both) gone through these points countless times. The JW didn’t deliver it to the public domain, he put it in the place where I was most likely to find it. Gee what could his intent have possible been? It is my house. I want it, and I want to make the decision on it. You have stolen that opportunity from me and stolen the materials. Why is that not good enough? :confused: I seriously do not know how to say more plainly that theft is the reason the behavior is problematic.

And for the umpteenth time, the homeowner. You don’t have to accept it, obviously you never will. If you would have no problem telling your priest or Jesus himself that you think it is OK to take things off from a neighbor’s property because they weren’t delivered in the way you think is appropriate, or it isn’t material that you like, then it certainly doesn’t matter what so many others in this thread say, even when we say we want it.
And for the umpteenth time. Legally that is not true. 🤷

Prove it belonged to anyone.
 
And for the umpteenth time, the homeowner. You don’t have to accept it, obviously you never will. If you would have no problem telling your priest or Jesus himself that you think it is OK to take things off from a neighbor’s property because they weren’t delivered in the way you think is appropriate, or it isn’t material that you like, then it certainly doesn’t matter what so many others in this thread say, even when we say we want it.
I reckon they’re stuck in their notions (or hooked on this behavior…must be a compelling obsession, the way they defend it).
So not much you or I say will change it. (Maybe they’ll feel a little creepy when they’re doing it).

I’m just glad they don’t live in my neighborhood
And I’m also glad I didn’t read posts on this site before I became catholic.
🙂
 
I reckon they’re stuck in their notions (or hooked on this behavior…must be a compelling obsession, the way they defend it).
So not much you or I say will change it. (Maybe they’ll feel a little creepy when they’re doing it).

I’m just glad they don’t live in my neighborhood
And I’m also glad I didn’t read posts on this site before I became catholic.
🙂
Who is “they” only the OP has done this. Now your rhetoric is that you are glad you don’t live next to me? As if that is some sort of slam on me? Or that if we defend the truth you would not have been Catholic?

Sheesh,

Please, Why did you become Catholic?

Lets stop with the innuendo and passive aggressive slams. You are crossing the line and not being charitable to good posters and good Catholics.

Now perhaps it is you who should feel some shame.
 
Who is “they” only the OP has done this. Now your rhetoric is that you are glad you don’t live next to me? As if that is some sort of slam on me? Or that if we defend the truth you would not have been Catholic?

Sheesh,

Please, Why did you become Catholic?

Lets stop with the innuendo and passive aggressive slams. You are crossing the line and not being charitable to good posters and good Catholics.

Now perhaps it is you who should feel some shame.
Well, no need to take it so personally (unless the shoe fits)…I was referring in general to people who so adamantly defend this (so ardently, in fact, that I assume they engage in the practice themselves).

Yes. I am glad these folks aren’t doing their thing in my neighborhood. Which would include you if you thought you had to remove other people’s material from my mailbox.
I don’t see why I have to be ashamed of that.

No passive aggressive…no innuendo. I have said everything I’ve said pretty straight out there. I thought I’d been real clear.
 
Or that if we defend the truth you would not have been Catholic?

Sheesh,

Please, Why did you become Catholic?

.
I don’t think people defending this “mailbox activity” are “defending truth”. Come on.

Yes…reading some posts on this site (including on this thread) might have given me pause BC…specifically the posts that arrogantly claim that ours is the only truth and everyone else’s religion is wrong. Couldn’t go there. Ever.

The dogma that some think the catholic church has, that it is the only way to salvation was what kept me from it sooner, to be truthful. Gladly, I found that not to be church teaching. But I see posts here that are so entrenched that way…spouting their own dogma as gospel and truth… proffering absolute dictates on things that the Church claims are unknowable…( and as a sidebar, amusingly, they often have all sorts of bling on their posts that tell you what credentialed catholics they are).

Bottom line: YES. I’m glad I didn’t happen on this site and the pious bling catholics until I was fully catholic and content with it. IOW, glad I learned the truth before I encountered some people who think they have it and want to force it onto everyone else.
 
Let’s try to get past your first sentence:
And as noted too many times to count, the behavior is problematic because [OP] has disrupted a private transaction between two parties.
A private transaction between two parties? Since when is dumping un-requested material a “private transaction between two parties”? These kinds of statements have been repeated ad nauseam, and they are bizarre. There is absolutely no grounds for saying that it is a private transaction between two parties. Perhaps you ought to stop repeating this.
 
But I see that’s a stretch, so I withdraw it.
I guess Meddling is better after all.
🤷
👍 I’ll take that. It isn’t stealing, it is “meddling.” Specifically, the OP frustrated the intention of the JW. The JW wanted the homeowner to see the pamphlet, and you caused the homeowner to not see the pamphlet. This is not against the law. You think it is problematic. Check.

(I just wanted to acknowledge this, especially since JSSD is still talking about stealing)
 
I don’t think people defending this “mailbox activity” are “defending truth”. Come on.

Yes…reading some posts on this site (including on this thread) might have given me pause BC…specifically the posts that arrogantly claim that ours is the only truth and everyone else’s religion is wrong. Couldn’t go there. Ever.

The dogma that some think the catholic church has, that it is the only way to salvation was what kept me from it sooner, to be truthful. Gladly, I found that not to be church teaching. But I see posts here that are so entrenched that way…spouting their own dogma as gospel and truth… proffering absolute dictates on things that the Church claims are unknowable…( and as a sidebar, amusingly, they often have all sorts of bling on their posts that tell you what credentialed catholics they are).

Bottom line: YES. I’m glad I didn’t happen on this site and the pious bling catholics until I was fully catholic and content with it. IOW, glad I learned the truth before I encountered some people who think they have it and want to force it onto everyone else.
What is a pious bling Catholic. Since you are labeling me one or at least people who use this site I would like to know what it is.
glad I learned the truth before I encountered some people who think they have it and want to force it onto everyone else
Somebody is forcing things on others? How? Where? or is this just more overstating emotional rhetoric that is not necessary on a thread about a piece of trash…:rolleyes:
 
What is a pious bling Catholic. Since you are labeling me one or at least people who use this site I would like to know what it is.
No…I don’t see “bling” on your posts. You sure are touchy and prone to take everything personally.

I was referring to the many here who decorate their posts elaborately with all sorts of icons and quotations…they often give themselves lofty titles, and post pious pronouncements.
Someone coming here naively might assume they were speaking with some kind of authority…and such a naif might assume they were credible sources of catholic teaching. They aren’t always.
That was my point,by way of answering your question about why I am glad I didn’t read some of this tripe before becoming catholic.
 
👍 I’ll take that. It isn’t stealing, it is “meddling.” Specifically, the OP frustrated the intention of the JW. The JW wanted the homeowner to see the pamphlet, and you caused the homeowner to not see the pamphlet. This is not against the law. You think it is problematic. Check.

(I just wanted to acknowledge this, especially since JSSD is still talking about stealing)
Nope…it’s stealing. Taking something that doesn’t belong to you.

You took my quote out of context… I’m sure that was unintentional.😉
I withdrew the notion that it was a form of bullying.I didn’t allow that it was not stealing.
 
Nope…it’s stealing. Taking something that doesn’t belong to you.
I don’t think that is a proper definition. Stealing is taking something that belongs to someone else. There are many things in this world that belong to nobody. It is not stealing to take them.
 
Well, no need to take it so personally (unless the shoe fits)…I was referring in general to people who so adamantly defend this (so ardently, in fact, that I assume they engage in the practice themselves).
Yep. This is what they call a “dog whistle.” If you hear it, well…. 🤷
And for the umpteenth time. Legally that is not true. 🤷

Prove it belonged to anyone.
See below.
Let’s try to get past your first sentence:

A private transaction between two parties? Since when is dumping un-requested material a “private transaction between two parties”? These kinds of statements have been repeated ad nauseam, and they are bizarre. There is absolutely no grounds for saying that it is a private transaction between two parties. Perhaps you ought to stop repeating this.
I want it. Why is that not enough? BillP wanted it. The JW wanted it delivered, I want to see what it is. How else would you define a private transaction? :confused: It was put on my property for the intent that I receive it and read it. Who else’s is it?

Prove it belonged to someone/anyone? Let’s say I don’t take it off my mailbox top / mailbox frame / porch / whatever. Who is going to come get it? If it is a violation of an HOA or a code of some sort, “it isn’t mine” isn’t going to cut it. $0.02
I don’t think that is a proper definition. Stealing is taking something that belongs to someone else. There are many things in this world that belong to nobody. It is not stealing to take them.
I don’t agree, as do several others above. Stealing is taking something that does not belong to you, and that you have no right to. That’s it. What right does OP have to the contents of my mailbox area? Certainly less claim than I have. $0.02
 
Yep. This is what they call a “dog whistle.” If you hear it, well…. 🤷

See below.

I want it. Why is that not enough? BillP wanted it. The JW wanted it delivered, I want to see what it is. How else would you define a private transaction? :confused: It was put on my property for the intent that I receive it and read it. Who else’s is it?

Prove it belonged to someone/anyone? Let’s say I don’t take it off my mailbox top / mailbox frame / porch / whatever. Who is going to come get it? If it is a violation of an HOA or a code of some sort, “it isn’t mine” isn’t going to cut it. $0.02

I don’t agree, as do several others above. Stealing is taking something that does not belong to you, and that you have no right to. That’s it. What right does OP have to the contents of my mailbox area? Certainly less claim than I have. $0.02
👍
 
Nope…it’s stealing. Taking something that doesn’t belong to you.

You took my quote out of context… I’m sure that was unintentional.😉
I withdrew the notion that it was a form of bullying.I didn’t allow that it was not stealing.
Actually you dropped the “stealing” charge in posts such as this after it was shown to be unsupportable. But I’m done going around the repetitive merry-go-round. 🤷
I don’t think that is a proper definition. Stealing is taking something that belongs to someone else. There are many things in this world that belong to nobody. It is not stealing to take them.
That’s right.
I want it.
You cannot want something that you do not know exists. If you want JW literature, you can ask them to send it to you in the mail, or you can go pick it up from them.
Why is that not enough?
Why would it be enough? 🤷
BillP wanted it. The JW wanted it delivered, I want to see what it is. How else would you define a private transaction? :confused:
A transaction of any kind requires that two parties consent to the transfer of ownership.
It was put on my property for the intent that I receive it and read it. Who else’s is it?
If I put illegal material on your property with the intent that you receive and read it, are you willing to be charged with the crime of owning such material? If it falls off your mailbox are you willing to be charged with littering? (in fact it is already litter in the first place) The law is clear and consistent, but you are presumably inconsistent.
Prove it belonged to someone/anyone?
After the JW litters, it belongs to no one, that’s why its not stealing! 🤷
Let’s say I don’t take it off my mailbox top / mailbox frame / porch / whatever. Who is going to come get it? If it is a violation of an HOA or a code of some sort, “it isn’t mine” isn’t going to cut it. $0.02
So you’re going to pay the fine?

You don’t seem to understand the purpose of the mail service and the laws surrounding it. It is set up in such a way to allow the kind of conditional transfer of ownership that is required for receiving things you may or may not want. The JW’s can simply mail it to you, and everything will be fine. Leaving it on your mailbox is illegal for a number of reasons, and it does not provide the package with the same protection that an authentically delivered package does. If you wrote the laws, someone could walk out to their mailbox, be killed by the bomb that was left there, and be understood to have committed suicide.

The only way to conditionally send a package is to mail it. What the JW is doing is technically littering. They are “leaving it and hoping that someone finds it.” As noted, this is illegal. But more to the point, it is in no way illegal for someone else to pick up such a package. It has been left in the public domain.

Now, all other things equal, I agree that one should not go about frustrating the intentions of others. If I see a reputable citizen place a box of cookies on a mailbox, I will certainly not take it. If I see someone place pornography and a subscription to Playboy on a mailbox, I will throw it away. I suspect that this is our main point of disagreement: the JW literature is more like pornography than cookies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top