Did the Catholic Church build Western civilization?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jimmy_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
**

Your Thoughts?**

I voted yes. However, I am not sure if it’s a simplistic yes. Because you’d have to take into consideration the vast influence of Greek and Roman thought on the development of Western civilization. It was the Catholic Church that preserved that thought, though. Of course, Protestant thought developed much of the political ideals that became Western republicanism, too, but that wouldn’t have happened without the Catholic Church, either.
 
Western Civilization is cumulative. The Greeks invented it with ideas like democracy, voting, juries, patronization of the arts, entertainment, sovereignty, etc. The Romans took and rebooted it, perfecting it even more with law, bicameralesque legislation, the need for a commander-in-chief, better technology, gvoernance, and fairness. The Catholic Church kept alive the great pagan and Judeo-Christian writings that are our heritage like Plutarch, Plato, Virgil, Homer, Aristotle, etc. Were it not for such preservation we’d be bereft of a wealth of literature and classics that have informed Western thinking for hundreds, thousands of years. The Catholic Church brought Christendom to all of Western Europe, civilized the barbarians, established peace and treaties, hospitals, colleges, encouraged the sciences, kept the rule of law, and heavily influenced the moral compass of the West. It was the Protestant Reformation also that continued the evolution. The Protestants brought the idea of the individual having his/her own choices, the idea of freedom of conscience and it broke loose much of the ecclesiastical ties that bound men of art, science, and industry to the Church for so long to explore other ideas, secular ones. The growth of nations came out of the Reformation and it encouraged free thinkers to move on to democracy, revolution, and great things like the Constitution and Bill of Rights. Western Civilization is not so easily bundled into authorship by one man, group, or Church. It is a cumulative masterpiece created by the Hellenics to this current era.

The Battle of Thermopylae in a sense saved Western Civilization. The great Charles Martel saved Western Christendom from Islam’s fist. These conflicts I’d put on as high a pedestal as the Catholic Church’s influences on the West. It’s all important.
 
Oh yes, absolutely.

While I obviously have some disagreements with the Theology developed in the later Middle Ages, without Christianity Art, Architecture, and Music would be fundamentally different. Art is fairly obvious why, simply google Middle Ages art. Architecture is reflected in the Cathedrals, and if there were no God, there would probably be no Vivaldi or J.S Bach, the two most important composers in Western music. So my answer is a yes.
 
My vote is on Mozart!👍
Oh yes, absolutely.

While I obviously have some disagreements with the Theology developed in the later Middle Ages, without Christianity Art, Architecture, and Music would be fundamentally different. Art is fairly obvious why, simply google Middle Ages art. Architecture is reflected in the Cathedrals, and if there were no God, there would probably be no Vivaldi or J.S Bach, the two most important composers in Western music. So my answer is a yes.
 
I don’t believe one can claim any single entity built Western Civilization. It was a process influenced by a number of factors. The Catholic Church was undeniably a very major factor which cannot be overlooked in an attempt to explain the origins of modern Western Civilization, but to say it built it is going too far.
 
Entire books can be (and have been) written about this, but I’ll spare you all one in this post. 😃 I voted a resounding yes.
 
The question is somewhat simplistic, of course. The “Catholic Church” was the church in Europe. Following the reformation, it became known better known as the “Catholic Church”, in distinction with Protestant churches. So, for Catholics now, after almost 500 years of reformation to make this claim as if their church and not the other churches were responsible is sophistry.

For the record, under the church, universities and colleges were established, hospitals built, and many other great achievements were fostered. However, today, the two preeminent universities in the world, Harvard and UC Berkeley, have no direct relation to the Catholic church. Harvard was founded by English dissenters (Congregationalists) as a school for ministers. Berkeley was founded, first as the College of California, as a Protestant school, founded by Congregationalists and Presbyterians, and later joined the public School of Mines to form the University. The Ivy-League universites of the United States were mostly founded by Protestants. Stanford was founded by a Unitarian, and USC was a Methodist school.

In England, Oxford and Cambridge were founded by the pre-reformation church, but since the reformation, these institutions have flourished to become among the top universites in the world.
Did the Catholic Church build Western civilization?

Here
is an interesting online book preview on this subject -

How the Catholic Church built Western civilization

By Thomas E. Woods

http://www.thomasewoods.com/images/cover_churchwciv_lg.jpg

Your Thoughts?
 
Vivaldi? Vivaldi? Oh please. Coffee shop music!

Vivaldi cannot hold a candle to the likes of Mozart, Handel, or JS Bach. I can recognize a Vivaldi piece in a couple of measures. All those repeats. It’s better than I can write, but his work is really not top knotch. And remember, both Handel and Bach were Protestants.
Oh yes, absolutely.

While I obviously have some disagreements with the Theology developed in the later Middle Ages, without Christianity Art, Architecture, and Music would be fundamentally different. Art is fairly obvious why, simply google Middle Ages art. Architecture is reflected in the Cathedrals, and if there were no God, there would probably be no Vivaldi or J.S Bach, the two most important composers in Western music. So my answer is a yes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top