Califman,
God bless you. I think in many ways you are right, but disciplining children to the point of fear is wrong. I don’t know if you have children, but I suspect not. Nonetheless, from a personal standpoint, I do use corporeal punishment and negative punishment to discipline my children, albeit sparingly. Instead, I believe it is more important to teach them the reason things are wrong. It is not easy to do most of the time. Children ages 3-8 are hard to reason with, they have not really reached that “age of reason,” and this is why we break down (usually out of anger, which makes it most wrong) and spank the child. By the time they are 8-10 (depending on the nature of the children) they are capable of grasping right and wrong, holiness, sacred, obedience, etc. Before the age of reason, many children are just self centered. No matter how hard you try, some children just wont get it and all you will get from “sister cracking rulers over hands” in the “good ole days” is a generation who grew up and became the adults who are the “fewer…actually attending mass.” Negative punishment has been proven to be inferior in child rearing compared to positive reinforcement. Like most things, the harder it is to do successfully, the better it is.
There is no need for me to restate what I have already said. Love came to show us the way! Why fight against the teachings of Christ if you are a Christian. I am the least when it comes to my children acting up in church. It drives me crazy, sometimes I lose it. I leave church after mass upset and both kids are in time out, and there is wailing and gnashing of teeth! Well, I think to myself, that is not how it should be. I then turn to my Father, reflect on His mercy and forgiveness for the disobedient things I do all day long, I pray for his patience and strength, and then get back into the Truth. I tell my children to try and understand what they did was wrong, forgive them, and move on witht the day. Maybe they dont learn a “hard” lesson and fear me the next time they think about acting up in church. But they learn forgiveness and mercy, and they learn to control themselves, they learn to from me to pray to God for help, and maybe they begin to understand one day why it is wrong to do this or that.
When I look back on my days of Catholic school, with the nuns and brothers, I dont remeber the ones who would wield the whip. I remeber the ones who spent a little extra time with me, to redirect me, to show kindness. It was the peaceful ones I would turn to when I needed advice, guidence, a shoulder, and a friend. Please, all of you take this to heart, if you raise the child to be strict and behave because they fear your punishment, there will be a day they rebell (they all do) and get in serious trouble. Then, do you think the day they are faced with the prowling devil waiting to devour them (drugs, pornography, social sin in general), will they come to you for advice? Or will they be scared that you will beat them down for trying marijuana for example? I want my children to know that I will always try to understand them. I may get mad, yell and scream, but in the end, I always try to be fair, have kindness, patience and love.
1 cor 13:13 In the end there is faith, hope, and love: the greatest of these is love!
PS, after flooding the earth, God was sorry, promising never to do that again. Will you continue to inflict your wrath? see Jonah 4:1-11. Overwhelmingly, God is mercy, patience, and love. He is slow to anger. Refusing to discipline your children is a sin of omission, but there are better ways to do it than others. Remeber, Love came to show us the way.
The Church is always in my prayers,
Christian Love