Difference Between a Sunday TLM and a Daily TLM

  • Thread starter Thread starter TrueLight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So do the people respond in a low mass, or only the servers?
THere is a form of the EF known as “Dialogue Mass”, it started off in the early to mid 20th century and was legislated for in 1958. Dialogue Mass is a variation on Low Mass; whereas in Low Mass only the servers respond, the entire congregation can respond in Dialogue Mass. There are 4 degrees of this:

  1. The congregation make the most basic responses;
    2. The congregation make all the responses;
    3. They join in with e.g. the Creed and Gloria;
    4. They join in with e.g. the Introit and Gradual.

    Dialogue Mass isn’t universally popular; I’ve never been to a Dialogue Mass in the UK
 
I guess I expected to see the beautiful Liturgy I am used to: the smells, the chants, the music. I understand that daily mass is less fancy then Sunday or Saturday mass.
The smell, the chants, the music is part of the Liturgical renewal: something for us, instead of the strict centering of Christ and Christ alone.

The TLM was mostly Low Mass, no incense, no chant, no music at all. Even in Sunday only one Mass was Missa Cantata or in Cathedrals and Seminaries High Mass. A compromise for the Sunday public Mass at the high altar was the Volk-Mass, with organ and vernacular hymns for the faithful. On weekdays the Cantor was usually supervising the opening of the school, was not present, the Mass was the affair of the priest and the Lord. The few old women present prayed the Rosary.

This is the Traditional Latin Mass: the priest and Jesus Christ, nothing else. The smell, the chant the music is the spirit which (although started earlier) dominated Vatican II: the importance of the faithful.

In my regular church on weekdays usually the pastor says the traditional Low Mass, (no chant, no music, not even vernacular reading and Gospel), the young priest says the mass accommodating to our time: chant, organ, vernacular reading and Gospel, even sermon. It is beautiful in this way. Interestingly they seem to reverse the rule celebrating the new form (this is a dual form parish).
 
Do not listen to Laszlo. He’s simply wrong. The High Mass is not all about the people but is the pinnacle of liturgical celebration in the Latin Church and everything at the Low Mass is but a shadow of that (excluding of course the Most Holy Eucharist).
 
Do not listen to Laszlo. He’s simply wrong. The High Mass is not all about the people but is the pinnacle of liturgical celebration in the Latin Church and everything at the Low Mass is but a shadow of that (excluding of course the Most Holy Eucharist).
When I was child there were 14 priests in that parish where I lived. They celebrated almost 100 masses a week. One of them was Missa Cantata (high Mass only may be once a year) .

I never said that the high Mass is all about the people. But I believe that the center of the Mass is Jesus Christ, then the priest, then at the very end and with very little importance the the incense, the chant and the music. Those are simply not comparable to Jesus Christ and the power of priest. The Mass at the side altar munbled by an old priest has the same worth as the High Mass with 3 bishops and 100 priests and with the lo of incense, chant and music: the Sacrifice of our Lord Jesus Christ.
 
The smell, the chants, the music is part of the Liturgical renewal: something for us, instead of the strict centering of Christ and Christ alone.
Yeah, I knew this was coming eventually.
T
The TLM was mostly Low Mass, no incense, no chant, no music at all. Even in Sunday only one Mass was Missa Cantata or in Cathedrals and Seminaries High Mass. A compromise for the Sunday public Mass at the high altar was the Volk-Mass, with organ and vernacular hymns for the faithful. On weekdays the Cantor was usually supervising the opening of the school, was not present, the Mass was the affair of the priest and the Lord. The few old women present prayed the Rosary.
his is the Traditional Latin Mass: the priest and Jesus Christ, nothing else.
I am so glad there are options to this. If it is the spirit of Vatican II so be it!

There is obviously worship in the mass as well, and I don’t think it should be just the Priest worshipping, but the congregants worshipping as well.

But like I said earlier, that may be the Protestant in me.
 
THere is a form of the EF known as “Dialogue Mass”, it started off in the early to mid 20th century and was legislated for in 1958. Dialogue Mass is a variation on Low Mass; whereas in Low Mass only the servers respond, the entire congregation can respond in Dialogue Mass. There are 4 degrees of this:

  1. The congregation make the most basic responses;
    2. The congregation make all the responses;
    3. They join in with e.g. the Creed and Gloria;
    4. They join in with e.g. the Introit and Gradual.

    Dialogue Mass isn’t universally popular; I’ve never been to a Dialogue Mass in the UK

  1. Is it okay to respond in the low mass if their is a choir? Can we respond in the Creed, Gloria, Asperges, etc? What I’m asking is if it is wrong for the faithful to respond in a mass where there shouldn’t be responses?
 
Is it okay to respond in the low mass if their is a choir? Can we respond in the Creed, Gloria, Asperges, etc? What I’m asking is if it is wrong for the faithful to respond in a mass where there shouldn’t be responses?
There generally is not a choir at Low Mass, since there are no sung responses. Occasionally, for a Sunday Low Mass, there may be additional hymns (sung in vernacular for processional and recessional, since these are not part of the Mass, and maybe a Latin hymn during the offerory and communion), and in that case there could be a choir, but this is not usually the case.

If it is the custom for only the altar servers to respond, then let them handle that. It would indeed be wrong to reply where the Dialogue Mass is not the custom.You may not like it at first, but as others have said, over time you will become accustomed to it and while you may still prefer High Mass (I certainly do), you will come to love the silence of the Low Mass, as well.
 
Is it okay to respond in the low mass if their is a choir? Can we respond in the Creed, Gloria, Asperges, etc? What I’m asking is if it is wrong for the faithful to respond in a mass where there shouldn’t be responses?
A quiet “Et cum spirituo tuo” and such wouldn’t be inappropriate, IMO.
 
So I went to the same church tonight, but the mass was sung and there was a schola and lots of servers and the congregation chanted. It was awesome.

At the end, the choir started singing some latin hymn and the people joined in. I wish they would say where in the hymnal a hymn is because all I could do was listen.

The priest projected really well and his homily was spirited. Yes!

So that is the kind of mass I like.
 
So I went to the same church tonight, but the mass was sung and there was a schola and lots of servers and the congregation chanted. It was awesome.

At the end, the choir started singing some latin hymn and the people joined in. I wish they would say where in the hymnal a hymn is because all I could do was listen.

The priest projected really well and his homily was spirited. Yes!

So that is the kind of mass I like.
So will all Wednesday night’s EF be Sung Masses? St. John Cantius has them as well. I’m glad the congregation joined in.
 
So will all Wednesday night’s EF be Sung Masses? St. John Cantius has them as well. I’m glad the congregation joined in.
Yes, apparently Wednesdays and Fridays at this Parish.

Also, today there were like 6-7 servers. I was happy!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top