Differences between Orders and Congregations

  • Thread starter Thread starter water
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

water

Guest
What are the differences between Orders and Congregations?
For example: the Congregation of the Marians of the Immaculate Conception (marian.org) and a Franciscan order.

Thanks!
 
A good general rule would be that an Order uses solemn vows, while a congregation uses simple vows. There might be exceptions to that though.
 
There are five great orders in the church; Augustinians; Franciscans; Dominicans; Norbertines, and I can’t remember the last one. Might be the Trinitarians.

Then the pope said, “NO MORE ORDERS!”

Okay. . . then the emerging religious communities had to be known as something, so they started using congregation, society, institute, etc.

That’s it in a nutshell.

Blessings,
Cloisters
 
There are five great orders in the church; Augustinians; Franciscans; Dominicans; Norbertines, and I can’t remember the last one. Might be the Trinitarians.

Then the pope said, “NO MORE ORDERS!”

Okay. . . then the emerging religious communities had to be known as something, so they started using congregation, society, institute, etc.

That’s it in a nutshell.

Blessings,
Cloisters
Those new communities need to decide about the rules of life to base their constitutions on something, and they choose among those above.
Also, there are branches in those main Orders, especially in Franciscan…😉
My community was found in 1861 and is called Congregation, we observe the Dominican way of life so we belong to the Dominican Order (and Dominican constitutions are based on Augustinians).
 
**
There are five great orders in the church; Augustinians; Franciscans; Dominicans; Norbertines, and I can’t remember the last one. Might be the Trinitarians.**

**Benedictine is the fourth.

These are the four classical rules in the Western Church.

Norbertines imitate the Cistercians (who are a form of Benedictines) as much as they can. They were founded at time when the Cistercians were not making any new foundations.**
 
There are more then 5 orders. Perhaps you mean the 5 great medicant orders. Franciscans, Dominicans, Carmelites, Augustian Friars, the Minimi friars. There are also the Servites, but I do not ever see them listed as one of the 5. They are an Order though. The Mercadians is another order. Not to mention the Carthusians, Benedictines/Cistercians, and the various Eastern Catholic religious (which are considered to be under Solemn Vows) and the Society of Jesus uses Solemn vows as well I beleive.
 
All groups of religious founded prior to the Counter Reformation are orders. Some groups founded after the Counter Reformation are orders-all of these communities take solemn vows. This includes all orders in the following categories:
monks-Benedictine, Basilian, Cistercian, Carthusian, Camaldolese, Brigittine;

canons regular-of the Lateran, of the Holy Sepulchre, and so on;

friars-Franciscan, Dominican, Carmelite, Augustinian, Servite, Trinitarian, Mercedarian;

clerics regular-Theatines, Somascans, Jesuits;

nuns attached to these orders of men;

orders of nuns such as the Visitandines, Sacramentines, Passionists, and Redemptoristines.

Most communities founded after the Counter Reformation are congregations, in simple vows. They would include the male counterparts of the Visitandines (Oblates of St. Francis de Sales), Passionists, and Redemptoristines (Redemptorists). Almost all communities of women are congregations.
Some communities of men and very few of women are societies of apostolic life, where no vows are taken, but some other sort of sacred bond is normally accepted-Oratorians, Vincentians, Paris Foreign Missions, Missionaries of Africa, Pallotines, Glenmary, for men, and the Daughters of Charity of St. Vincent de Paul and the Sisters of Social Service for women.
Then there are the secular institutes, whose members rank as consecrated laypersons. Some take vows, some take a combination of vows and promises, some make some other sort of profession.
 
Before Vatican 2, there were legal differences between congregations and orders; however, the 1983 Code of Canon Law (which was the end result of a long process of revisions started by Vatican 2) abolished this difference. All religious orders or congregations now fall under the legal umbrella of “Religious Institutes”.

I think the recent change in Canon Law is what’s causing so much confusion (evidenced by the many conflicting responses that we already have in this thread.)

The differences between a congregation and an order are now purely traditional, and no longer imposed by Canon Law. New groups are free to use “congregation”, “order”, “institute”, or whatever term they want to describe themselves, because the words no longer carry their former meaning.

I suggest that you read Canons 607-709 which will tell you all about orders, congregations, vows, and everything else discussed on this thread. Keep in mind that many of the older orders do not strictly obey these Canons because they predate them (see Canons 23-28)
What are the differences between Orders and Congregations?
For example: the Congregation of the Marians of the Immaculate Conception (marian.org) and a Franciscan order.

Thanks!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top