Different Geneologies in Luke and Matthew?

  • Thread starter Thread starter patricius79
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

patricius79

Guest
I am a faithful Catholic, and I don’t absolutely need to know this,

but why are the geneologies of Jesus so different in Luke vs. Matthew. e.g. one of them refers to Nathan as David’s son as I recall. what is going on with that?
 
I am a faithful Catholic, and I don’t absolutely need to know this,

but why are the geneologies of Jesus so different in Luke vs. Matthew. e.g. one of them refers to Nathan as David’s son as I recall. what is going on with that?
btw, I realize these are not exactly biological geneologies, since they are Joseph’s geneologies, and Joseph was not Jesus’s biological father
 
If I recall (and I may not, I’m doing this on the fly), one genealogy was from Mary’s side, and one was from Joseph’s side.
 
usccb.org/nab/bible/luke/luke3.htm

“the son of Melea, the son of Menna, the son of Mattatha, the son of Nathan, the son of David, 13”

13 [31] The son of Nathan, the son of David: in keeping with Jesus’ prophetic role in Luke and Acts (e.g., Luke 7:16, 39; 9:8; 13:33; 24:19; Acts 3:22-23; 7:37) Luke traces Jesus’ Davidic ancestry through the prophet Nathan (see 2 Sam 7:2) rather than through King Solomon, as Matthew 1:6-7.
 
One suggestion I recently learned is that they were focusing on different ancestors. Matthew is writing to Jews and probably wanted to emphasize the kingly line necessary for the Messiah. Luke was writing to gentiles and traced lineage all the way back to Adam. His emphasis on less “regal” descendants of David may have been to make Jesus more approachable for them.
 
usccb.org/nab/bible/luke/luke3.htm

“the son of Melea, the son of Menna, the son of Mattatha, the son of Nathan, the son of David, 13”

13 [31] The son of Nathan, the son of David: in keeping with Jesus’ prophetic role in Luke and Acts (e.g., Luke 7:16, 39; 9:8; 13:33; 24:19; Acts 3:22-23; 7:37) Luke traces Jesus’ Davidic ancestry through the prophet Nathan (see 2 Sam 7:2) rather than through King Solomon, as Matthew 1:6-7.
David also had a son named Nathan.
 
I am a faithful Catholic, and I don’t absolutely need to know this,

but why are the geneologies of Jesus so different in Luke vs. Matthew. e.g. one of them refers to Nathan as David’s son as I recall. what is going on with that?
Each author had different sources, intent, etc. Yes, they don’t agree. Scripture is still inspired and true.

Similarly, in some respects, all the Gospels give different particular accounts of the passion, death, and resurrection.
 
why are some of the earliest 5 ancestors of Joseph–the ones closest to him, including his father–called by different names?

again I have no doubts here, just trying to be ready to answer that question posed in the Dawkins book

could they be using “son of” in terms of being a relative of? e.g. could someone’s nephew be called a “son” in Jewish culture, so that perhaps Matthew is emphasizing people who were more well known or something like that?
 
why are some of the earliest 5 ancestors of Joseph–the ones closest to him, including his father–called by different names?

again I have no doubts here, just trying to be ready to answer that question posed in the Dawkins book
Don’t worry - once you’ve prepared an answer, they’ll never ask. 😃
could they be using “son of” in terms of being a relative of? e.g. could someone’s nephew be called a “son” in Jewish culture, so that perhaps Matthew is emphasizing people who were more well known or something like that?
One author may have been compiling the list of “family patriarchs” - the ancestors who were head of clan during their lifetimes. It’s likely this would have been Matthew since his genealogy follows the kings of Judah after David.

The other author (likely Luke, since he was compiling a history (Luke 1:1-4)) may have followed the exact line.
 
thanks SonCatcher. interesting

so when Matthew says Josephs father was Jacob, then Matthan, Eliazar, Eliud, Achim–which is very different than Luke’s list–Jacob for example could have been Joseph’s eldest uncle or something like that? and Matthan could have been Jacob’s eldest uncle or something like that?
 
There are some knotty issues associated with these inspired texts, and people have suggested various explanations. Here are a couple of views that make sense without sacrificing the historicity of the texts.
  1. Matthew emphasizes Jesus as king. For that reason, it is important to show that Jesus has the right to rule, which comes through his father Joseph, even though Joseph is not his biological father. [Note also that Coniah or Jeconiah is mentioned in this geneology. However, the Old Testament indicates that there was a curse on Jeconiah so that none of his descendants would ever sit on the throne of David. If Jesus were a biological descendant of Jeconiah, he would not be able to be the Davidic King.]
Luke records Mary’s geneology, through her father Eli. That geneology shows that Jesus is a biological descendant of David, through Mary.
  1. Others suggest that Mary’s father had only daughters. Therefore, the right to rule would extend through her husband Joseph to Jesus.
 
why are some of the earliest 5 ancestors of Joseph–the ones closest to him, including his father–called by different names?
These ancestors are not necessarily the ancestors closest to Joseph. The word translated “begat” or “was the father of” does not mean that the person is the immediate father of the one named. All it means is that the person is in the ancestral line.
 
The differences between the two Gospel geneologies is that Matthew traces the biological paternity of Jesus, while Luke traces the legal paternity of Jesus. They are different because under Mosaic law, if a man dies without an heir, his brother is obligated to marry the widow and raise up children for the dead brother. This is described very thoroughly in Eusebius ’ The history of the Church, Book 1, chapter 7. newadvent.org/fathers/250101.htm

Chapter 7. The Alleged Discrepancy in the Gospels in regard to the Genealogy of Christ.
  1. Matthew and Luke in their gospels have given us the genealogy of Christ differently, and many suppose that they are at variance with one another. Since as a consequence every believer, in ignorance of the truth, has been zealous to invent some explanation which shall harmonize the two passages, permit us to subjoin the account of the matter which has come down to us, and which is given by Africanus, who was mentioned by us just above, in his epistle to Aristides, where he discusses the harmony of the gospel genealogies. After refuting the opinions of others as forced and deceptive, he give the account which he had received from tradition in these words:
  2. For whereas the names of the generations were reckoned in Israel either according to nature or according to law—according to nature by the succession of legitimate offspring, and according to law whenever another raised up a child to the name of a brother dying childless; for because a clear hope of resurrection was not yet given they had a representation of the future promise by a kind of mortal resurrection, in order that the name of the one deceased might be perpetuated—
  3. whereas then some of those who are inserted in this genealogical table succeeded by natural descent, the son to the father, while others, though born of one father, were ascribed by name to another, mention was made of both of those who were progenitors in fact and of those who were so only in name.
  4. Thus neither of the gospels is in error, for one reckons by nature, the other by law. For the line of descent from Solomon and that from Nathan were so involved, the one with the other, by the raising up of children to the childless and by second marriages, that the same persons are justly considered to belong at one time to one, at another time to another; that is, at one time to the reputed fathers, at another to the actual fathers. So that both these accounts are strictly true and come down to Joseph with considerable intricacy indeed, yet quite accurately.
  5. But in order that what I have said may be made clear I shall explain the interchange of the generations. If we reckon the generations from David through Solomon, the third from the end is found to be Matthan, who begot Jacob the father of Joseph. But if, with Luke, we reckon them from Nathan the son of David, in like manner the third from the end is Melchi, whose son Eli was the father of Joseph. For Joseph was the son of Eli, the son of Melchi.
  6. Joseph therefore being the object proposed to us, it must be shown how it is that each is recorded to be his father, both Jacob, who derived his descent from Solomon, and Eli, who derived his from Nathan; first how it is that these two, Jacob and Eli, were brothers, and then how it is that their fathers, Matthan and Melchi, although of different families, are declared to be grandfathers of Joseph.
  7. Matthan and Melchi having married in succession the same woman, begot children who were uterine brothers, for the law did not prohibit a widow, whether such by divorce or by the death of her husband, from marrying another.
  8. By Estha then (for this was the woman’s name according to tradition) Matthan, a descendant of Solomon, first begot Jacob. And when Matthan was dead, Melchi, who traced his descent back to Nathan, being of the same tribe but of another family, married her as before said, and begot a son Eli.
  9. Thus we shall find the two, Jacob and Eli, although belonging to different families, yet brethren by the same mother. Of these the one, Jacob, when his brother Eli had died childless, took the latter’s wife and begot by her a son Joseph, his own son by nature and in accordance with reason. Wherefore also it is written: ‘Jacob begot Joseph.’ Matthew 1:6 But according to law he was the son of Eli, for Jacob, being the brother of the latter, raised up seed to him.
  10. Hence the genealogy traced through him will not be rendered void, which the evangelist Matthew in his enumeration gives thus: ‘Jacob begot Joseph.’ But Luke, on the other hand, says: ‘Who was the son, as was supposed’ (for this he also adds), ‘of Joseph, the son of Eli, the son of Melchi’; for he could not more clearly express the generation according to law. And the expression ‘he begot’ he has omitted in his genealogical table up to the end, tracing the genealogy back to Adam the son of God. This interpretation is neither incapable of proof nor is it an idle conjecture.
 
  1. For the relatives of our Lord according to the flesh, whether with the desire of boasting or simply wishing to state the fact, in either case truly, have handed down the following account: Some Idumean robbers, having attacked Ascalon, a city of Palestine, carried away from a temple of Apollo which stood near the walls, in addition to other booty, Antipater, son of a certain temple slave named Herod. And since the priest was not able to pay the ransom for his son, Antipater was brought up in the customs of the Idumeans, and afterward was befriended by Hyrcanus, the high priest of the Jews.
  2. And having been sent by Hyrcanus on an embassy to Pompey, and having restored to him the kingdom which had been invaded by his brother Aristobulus, he had the good fortune to be named procurator of Palestine. But Antipater having been slain by those who were envious of his great good fortune was succeeded by his son Herod, who was afterward, by a decree of the senate, made King of the Jews under Antony and Augustus. His sons were Herod and the other tetrarchs. These accounts agree also with those of the Greeks.
  3. But as there had been kept in the archives up to that time the genealogies of the Hebrews as well as of those who traced their lineage back to proselytes, such as Achior the Ammonite and Ruth the Moabitess, and to those who were mingled with the Israelites and came out of Egypt with them, Herod, inasmuch as the lineage of the Israelites contributed nothing to his advantage, and since he was goaded with the consciousness of his own ignoble extraction, burned all the genealogical records, thinking that he might appear of noble origin if no one else were able, from the public registers, to trace back his lineage to the patriarchs or proselytes and to those mingled with them, who were called Georae.
  4. A few of the careful, however, having obtained private records of their own, either by remembering the names or by getting them in some other way from the registers, pride themselves on preserving the memory of their noble extraction. Among these are those already mentioned, called Desposyni, on account of their connection with the family of the Saviour. Coming from Nazara and Cochaba, villages of Judea, into other parts of the world, they drew the aforesaid genealogy from memory and from the book of daily records as faithfully as possible.
  5. Whether then the case stand thus or not no one could find a clearer explanation, according to my own opinion and that of every candid person. And let this suffice us, for, although we can urge no testimony in its support, we have nothing better or truer to offer. In any case the Gospel states the truth. And at the end of the same epistle he adds these words: “Matthan, who was descended from Solomon, begot Jacob. And when Matthan was dead, Melchi, who was descended from Nathan begot Eli by the same woman. Eli and Jacob were thus uterine brothers. Eli having died childless, Jacob raised up seed to him, begetting Joseph, his own son by nature, but by law the son of Eli. Thus Joseph was the son of both.”
  6. Thus far Africanus. And the lineage of Joseph being thus traced, Mary also is virtually shown to be of the same tribe with him, since, according to the law of Moses, intermarriages between different tribes were not permitted. For the command is to marry one of the same family and lineage, so that the inheritance may not pass from tribe to tribe. This may suffice here.
 
I’m a little late to the game here, sorry for posting two months after the fact (three?). Good information guys! Thanks.

But, I’m still a little confused. I was listening to a Jewish Rabbi the other day and he claimed that if Jesus is descended from the line of Solomon he cannot be the Messiah because Solomon was cursed by God. I haven’t read through the entire Old Testament yet so I’m not clear on what this curse was, or what it’s for but Matthew relating Jesus back to Solomon says to the Jewish people (today) that Jesus couldn’t possibly be the Messiah (because no child of Solomon’s could be the Messiah). So was Jesus descended from Solomon or Nathan?

Also, on a side note, it doesn’t say in Luke’s genealogy that he’s tracing Mary’s bloodline so why is it that people say this is the case? Anybody have any quotes from what the Church fathers say on this issue? :confused:

Sorry again for reviving this old thread, I didn’t want to start a new one just for my silly questions. I have more, that’s what listening to Jewish rabbis will do to a person, but they can wait. 😃
 
I’m a little late to the game here, sorry for posting two months after the fact (three?). Good information guys! Thanks.

But, I’m still a little confused. I was listening to a Jewish Rabbi the other day and he claimed that if Jesus is descended from the line of Solomon he cannot be the Messiah because Solomon was cursed by God. I haven’t read through the entire Old Testament yet so I’m not clear on what this curse was, or what it’s for but Matthew relating Jesus back to Solomon says to the Jewish people (today) that Jesus couldn’t possibly be the Messiah (because no child of Solomon’s could be the Messiah). So was Jesus descended from Solomon or Nathan?

Also, on a side note, it doesn’t say in Luke’s genealogy that he’s tracing Mary’s bloodline so why is it that people say this is the case? Anybody have any quotes from what the Church fathers say on this issue? :confused:

Sorry again for reviving this old thread, I didn’t want to start a new one just for my silly questions. I have more, that’s what listening to Jewish rabbis will do to a person, but they can wait. 😃
Perhaps this will help:

The Genealogy from Adam to Jesus Christ
 
Nickybr 38,

The curse is not in regard to Solomon but in regard to his descendent, Coniah (also called Jeconiah and Jehoiachin). The prophecy says, ‘Write this man down childless, A man who will not prosper in his days; For no manof his descendants will prosper Sitting on the throneof David Or ruling again in Judah.’" (Jer.22:28-30.)

Matthew 1: 11 includes Jeconiah, a descendent of Solomon (1:7), David’s son. In contrast, the genealogy in Luke 3 goes through Solomon’s son Nathan, thereby avoiding Jeconiah (Luke 3:31).

The rabbi is correct regarding a curse in the line of Solomon. Many commentators think that the lineage of Luke 3 is Mary’s physical line. Therefore, the curse is circumvented, because Jesus is not a descendent of Jeconiah.

I hope that helps.
 
I was just checking my earlier post and noticed that I had made in error. I had meant to say that the genealogy in Luke 3 goes through David’s son Nathan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top