Discernment of spirits

  • Thread starter Thread starter moonlight87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

moonlight87

Guest
Until some extend every catholic is able to discern things. We receive certain consolations when we go somewhere or experience an empty feeling when we return from certain places or in conversation with certain people. Also if one makes progress in his spiritual life and in virtue, it is easier to discern things in other peoples behavior. However I was wondering what the difference is between the gift of discernment and the kind of discernment I am talking about and how one can know that he or she has this gift?
 
(a) There is a certain type of discernment of spirits that is reserved for the Church alone. In fact, she uses this grace, it is my understanding, when analyzing the validity of certain apparitions. It is this discernment of spirits, moreover, that makes second-guessing or even ignoring approved apparitions or private revelations often incredibly imprudent: most of us simply lack the grace to make such a judgment.

(b) There are individuals who likewise possess a type of this grace, but I’m quite sure that it’s rare, and the majority of folks who think they have it simply don’t. Exorcists make use of such individuals, who then inform the exorcist of things which pan out to be true beyond question.

(c) There is a common practice of basing one’s spiritual life on one’s emotions. This is to be avoided at all costs, and what you describe sounds to me like an emotional sort of thing. Having “feelings” is not the same thing as discernment. Don’t forget that the demon can move our emotions and imitate all sorts of things that might come across to us as being from God.

(d) I would think that knowing that one has this grace should be the result of seeking the judgment of a holy and prudent and knowledgeable Priest. Don’t forget that these gifts aren’t given for ourselves. They’re given for building up the Church, and one must absolutely cooperate with the Church in order to make full use of these faculties, let alone in discerning whether or not one actually has them.
 
I don’t think someone can know on their own, which would be in keeping with the Church’s teaching on itself as being a body with Christ as the head of the Church. Without a spiritual director, any serious discernment of spirits is a gamble.

I think the average layman can use certain tools such as Church teaching,and examination of results of choices, and prayer along with frequent confession and Eucharist in order to discern spirits on a minor level such as, “what should I do today, Lord?”. Mystics, on the other hand, should do all of the above plus have a spiritual director.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top