Disconnect between myself and immediate family members

  • Thread starter Thread starter DonaNobis_Pacem
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DonaNobis_Pacem

Guest
I wonder if my dad is right: I have one “attitude” for church and another “attitude” for home. Here’s the deal.

It seems like there’s a physical disconnect between myself and the rest of my family members. The only people to whom I feel close, although even that’s rather remote, are my mother and my youngest sister. But I feel as though I can’t talk to them about anything; they don’t understand me as a person, that I have my own ideas and opinions, and that I do sometimes do stupid things or mess up badly and have to suffer the consequences as a result.

At the same time, there also seems to be a spiritual disconnect that affects all of us. The only time we pray together is at dinner now, especially since we’re all going in different directions until rather late at night (usually around 10 p.m.). We don’t offer prayers for family intentions anymore, and haven’t since my aunt passed back in '99 (may God grant rest to her soul). My dad has his saint prayers, various daily prayers, and the Rosary that he prays every day; when he doesn’t work, he also goes to daily Mass at a parish in the next town over. However, I’ve formed a different spirituality than he has, and I’ve also become more conscientious about going to confession when I know I’ve committed serious sin (I’ve also become more conscious about not receiving Holy Communion when conscious of serious sin). My sisters, on the other hand, only seem to go to Mass out of necessity, and because they know our parents would have their heads on poles for not going. At the same time, though, even if they do miss Mass, they think it’s “not a big deal” and they continue to receive Holy Communion; I used to do the same thing, going for a long period of time without going to confession, but as I grew older I gained knowledge about what constitutes serious sin, to confess it before receiving Holy Communion, and to not receive if I haven’t confessed.

The problem is, when I try to encourage my sisters (especially the middle of my three younger siblings) or correct them, I pretty much get a slap in the face for trying to help them live their faith more fully. Granted, I’ve fallen off in devotional prayers, but I am struggling to find the time and the will to pray them. But I ended up going to my room and crying once because my sister took the Holy Name of Jesus in vain…she had been in an accident last year; by the grace of God, the worst of her injuries were a mild concussion, a laceration above her hairline, and otherwise some road rash. She could have died, and this was how she thanked our Lord? I was heartbroken. I myself have made a conscious effort to cease taking God’s name in vain…the fact that she took the Name of Jesus in vain forced me to correct her harshly, and as a result, she flew off the handle at me. It’s as if I’m the only one who knows about regular confession, not receiving Holy Communion if conscious of serious sin, and not taking God’s name or the Name of Jesus in vain.

I would catechize the rest of my family, but I don’t think they’d want to listen to me. After all, my dad told me my “sanctimonious” attitude is reserved for church, while I don’t act “very Christian” at home.

Sorry for the ramble, but I had to get this out. 😦
 
Perhaps it’s time to stop lecturing and live by example. If you aren’t devotional yourself, you can hardly expect your sisters to be so at your command. Take the words of St. Francis of Assisi to heart: “Preach the gospel always. When necessary, use words.” Actions do speak louder than words. And prayer avails much.

Also, don’t despair. You went through a phase similar to that of your sisters. Perhaps they need to work through their faith on their own time, as you did.
 
Sometimes I feel it’s how my spirituality has been developing that makes me feel separated from the other five people with whom I live, even though we’re all crammed into the same house. I know I have a long way to go before I even gain a small measure of holiness in becoming the saint I’m called to be, but living with five other people who don’t understand my personal faith journey makes it more difficult.

I also sometimes wonder if the devotional saint prayers my dad says every day, as well as the Rosary, are more out of habit than for any spiritual nourishment or growth. He hardly acts “very Christian” at home himself; it’s not to say that I’m any better (the Lord knows I’m not), but the apple doesn’t fall very far from the tree. His often abrasive approach to situations and people he does not like is something that’s influenced how I approach similar situations and people. I really want to work on it, though; I did a lot of thinking last night when I wrote my OP, and I found that there’s quite a bit wrong with me that needs fixing.
 
His often abrasive approach to situations and people he does not like is something that’s influenced how I approach similar situations and people.
But does he go around informing others that they should not behave that way? Does he “correct them harshly?” People hate two things more than any other: hypocrisy and holier-than-thou attitudes.

You are extremely dismissive of your family members’ faith lives. Your Dad only prays from habit. Your sisters only go to Mass because they have to. You don’t know their hearts. It may be that they are trying as hard as you are, but failing more obviously. Having someone who also fails come along and go off about how terrible they are is only going to turn them off.
 
Hi DonaNobis-Pacem

Don’t think you need to be sorry for the ramble. Sometimes we need to get things out and just doing so can help.

It is sad that you don’t feel really close to any of your family. When this happens we need to look at why. Sometimes it may be that we are very different people and we have to realise that real closeness may not be possible but it may be possible to become closer by concentrating on what we have in common and doing things together that all enjoy.

It can be very difficult living with people who have very different views on things that are deeply personal - political, religious - and sometimes the best thing can be not to discuss them. Understand that this can feel like betraying your ideals and ideas but this isn’t if you have clearly stated them.

When we try to change people’s ideas behaviour and keep doing so we can end up in a vicious circle which either involves people changing their behaviour on the surface to avoid being criticised or constant arguments, disputes that do not encourage closeness. If this goes on people don’t like being home together or even being together.
 
This is such a good place to come and share what is in our hearts. We all need people to help us see clearer and to grow in life.
The problem is, when I try to encourage my sisters (especially the middle of my three younger siblings) or correct them, I pretty much get a slap in the face for trying to help them live their faith more fully. (
My mother once told me something that really helped me in relating to my sister (she probably told me dozens of times). Anyway she said:

“You are not her Holy Spirit.”

Wow, and you know what?! She was right. God did not appoint me to speak to my sister about how she should live before Him. Jesus promised to send the Holy Spirit, and we must trust Him to lead & guide others (no matter how insufficient of a job we think He is doing).

It really helps for us to realize how greatly we still need Christ’s grace and mercy in our own lives. Our righteousness, even when we’ve been as perfect as possible and we’re in right standing with God, still does not begin to measure up to what we are called to be. We are not better than any sinner that is around us.

We can only hope and pray to behave in a manner that reflects the same love and grace that God is so merciful to give to us. We need to worry about our own relationship and walk with Christ, and entrust the others to Him. 🙂
 
This has really got me looking hard at myself and what sort of person I am right now. It seems that I have an even larger problem with pushing my ideas and behaviors and opinions on other people in my house than I first thought. And it appears that the root of the problem lies with me.

Jen, I’m going to try and keep the words of St. Francis first and foremost in my mind, especially when considering about the faith journeys of the rest of my family. Salonika and Kay, thank you muchly for the advice; I’m going to pray very much that God will grant me the graces and virtue to gain even a small measure of the holiness that I’m called to possess. And capsaicin…thank you for the good whack upside the head. I needed that. 😊

God bless.
J+M+J
 
This is such a good place to come and share what is in our hearts. We all need people to help us see clearer and to grow in life.

My mother once told me something that really helped me in relating to my sister (she probably told me dozens of times). Anyway she said:

“You are not her Holy Spirit.”

Wow, and you know what?! She was right. God did not appoint me to speak to my sister about how she should live before Him. Jesus promised to send the Holy Spirit, and we must trust Him to lead & guide others (no matter how insufficient of a job we think He is doing).

It really helps for us to realize how greatly we still need Christ’s grace and mercy in our own lives. Our righteousness, even when we’ve been as perfect as possible and we’re in right standing with God, still does not begin to measure up to what we are called to be. We are not better than any sinner that is around us.

We can only hope and pray to behave in a manner that reflects the same love and grace that God is so merciful to give to us. We need to worry about our own relationship and walk with Christ, and entrust the others to Him. 🙂
KayFrisco - What a beautiful post. Thank you.

What a great variety of answers we get on this forum and on this thread. All have something to add and make us think about.
 
Salonika that was so sweet to say. While it stung to learn such a lesson (or begin to learn it), it is a gift that my mother could/can be so honest.
And it appears that the root of the problem lies with me.
As bad as it feels to come to this conclusion, it’s also completely freeing to realize that we are only responsible for our own behaviors and attitude - because that’s all we have any control over! 🙂

It’s so hard to feel disconnected from our family members. I’ve been there from time to time, though my mom and I are usually close - most of the time. I wonder if God sometimes allows us to get to that “place” in life to help us draw closer to him and relate to him even more? I don’t know - maybe that’s just a way of looking for the bright side? I hope he will fill that space -that distance- you feel, and will bring you all closer in the end. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top