Discussing infant baptism with a Protestant

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

WesleyF

Guest
I am having a lively discussion with a Protestant (Karim) on the issue of infant baptism. But I need some help.

I’ll copy-paste the discussion over here:

His words are in blue:

Karim: Baptism is immersion in water. It is not sprinkling, it is not pouring, it is immersion. There are different Greek words for pour and sprinkle and the what we now call in English, baptism, is from the Greek word that means to be immersed. Now people are immersed all the time. Why, just the other day, my wife and I were at the beach and we went out pretty far and several waves immersed us. Actually, that is not true. We were not immersed by the waves but submersed by the waves.

To be immersed is to be plunged into water, not to have water come over you. (The Greek word is sometimes translated as “to be plunged into”). Nevertheless, i haev immersed my son, Omar, in a pool several times to try to get him accustomed to having his head under water so he would not be afraid. I also immersed many friends in the pool as a child in horseplay. I have seen many people be immersed at the beach by their friends and many a people were immersed to death by the mob. Immersion in water, typically, only gets you wet.

But please note who is to be baptised. Those who believe in the message. If you do not believe in the message that Jesus is Messiah and son of the Living God, immersion only gets you wet. Those who hold to his teachings, that is those who are obedient. this is born out in the letters of John and also in the words of Jesus in John 8:31-32 where Jesus points out that mere belief is not enough. Also see James 2:9. If you do not follow Christ, immersion only gets you wet.

To bear that out even more, going back to Matt 28:18-20, “Go make disciples of all nations, baptising them…” So you are to immerse those who are followers of Christ, not those who are not yet following. But, since followers of Christ are obedient to him, it only makes sense that they would obey him and be baptised. Let us not go there just yet.

Those who have faith. How does one person being immersed only gets wet while another gets his sins washed away as well and receives the Holy Spirit? Faith. Ephesians 2 bears this out and says a great deal about salvation. It is often quoted out of context such as verse 8 to say, “you were saved by grace,” meaning that you did not earn your salvation, but it says “by grace, through faith!”

Colossians 2:11-12 explains, “having been buried with him in baptism and raised with him through your faith in the power of God…” If immersion is where we are buried in Christ (and get wet), faith is where we come out of the water and are raised to a new life in Christ. Immersing someone without faith only gets them wet.

So those who are to be baptised are those who believe --like Paul and Lydia-- those who hold to his teachings --like Paul and Lydia-- and those who have faith --like Paul and Lydia-- and in doing so, shall die to themselves, wash away their sins as they are buried with Jesus, and --through faith-- rise to a new life in Christ as they rise from the water.

Now here is what is not in the Bible. Any example of infant baptism. Neither the Jailer nor Lydia nor Cornelius nor anyone else whose household were baptised suggest the presence of infants. I, myself have seen households baptised (including one of four generations) and not one infant was among them. It cannot be assumed that because a household was baptised that infants were baptised also.
 
Wesley: Karim, I did do some reading on baptism.

Baptism does mean immersion in water, but the meaning of the Greek word “baptizo” is broad enough to mean pouring. For instance, Luke 11:38 says, “The Pharisee was astonished to see that he did not first wash (baptizo) before dinner.” However, the Pharisees did not practice immersion before dinner.

“For the Pharisees, and all the Jews, do not eat unless they wash (nipto) their hands, observing the tradition of the elders; and when they come from the market place, they do not eat unless they purify themselves (baptizo) …” (Mark 7:3-4)

So we see that baptizo can also refer to cleansing or ritual washing, not just immersion.

Also, even figuratively speaking, baptizo may not mean immersion at all times. For instance, Jesus said to his disciples, “but before many days you shall be baptized with the Holy Spirit.” (Acts 1:5). We know that the disciples were not immersed into the Spirit, rather the Spirit was poured out on them (Acts 2:17-18, Acts 2:33). One one occasion, Peter refers to the Holy Spirit falling upon them when speaking about baptism (Acts 11:15-16).

So baptizo may refer either two immersion or to pouring. The meaning is broad enough to cover both.

We see this even in the early church writings, for instance, in the Didache. Written around 70 AD, it reads thus in Chapter 7, “Concerning baptism, baptize in this manner: Having said all these things beforehand, baptize in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit in living water [that is, in running water, as in a river]. If there is no living water, baptize in other water; and, if you are not able to use cold water, use warm. If you have neither, pour water three times upon the head in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.”

There are quite a few other quotes from the early church. I’ll just copy-paste -

“If water is scarce, whether as a constant condition or on occasion, then use whatever water is available” (Hippolytus of Rome - The Apostolic Tradition, 21 [A.D. 215]).

Pope Cornelius I wrote that as Novatian was about to die, “he received baptism in the bed where he lay, by pouring” (Letter to Fabius of Antioch [A.D. 251]; cited in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, 6:4311).

Cyprian advised that no one should be “disturbed because the sick are poured upon or sprinkled when they receive the Lord’s grace” (Letter to a Certain Magnus 69:12 [A.D. 255]).

Tertullian described baptism by saying that it is done “with so great simplicity, without pomp, without any considerable novelty of preparation, and finally, without cost, a man is baptized in water, and amid the utterance of some few words, is sprinkled, and then rises again, not much (or not at all) the cleaner” (On Baptism, 2 [A.D. 203]).

Therefore, the Catholic Church affirms baptism by both methods, immersion or pouring. The Code of Canon Law states: “Baptism is to be conferred either by immersion or by pouring, the prescriptions of [one’s] national conference of bishops being observed” (CIC 854), and the Catechism of the Catholic Church says, “Baptism is performed in the most expressive way by **triple immersion **in the baptismal water. However, from ancient times it has also been able to be conferred by pouring water three times over the candidate’s head” (CCC 1239).
 
I am sure you would agree that Baptism is the covenant ritual by which we enter into the New Covenant. I would like to come to the subject of baptism by first talking about circumcision, which was the covenant ritual for entering into the Old Covenant.

“You shall be circumcised in the flesh of your foreskins, and it shall be a sign of the covenant between me and you.” (Gen 17:11)

“He received circumcision as **a sign or seal of the righteousness which he had by *faith ***while he was still uncircumcised.” (Rom 4:11)

First of all, a covenant requires mutual consent. It is interesting to note that Paul refers to circumcision as a sign of the righteousness which Abraham had by faith. Yet, in the Old testament we see that primarily infants were circumcized (Gen 17:12). They didn’t give their consent, they certainly didn’t have faith; but if circumcision is a seal of the righteousness by faith, then the only possible conclusion is that their parents exercised it on their behalf.

When Peter talked about baptism, he said, “Repent, and be baptized **every one of you **in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins; and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is to you and to your children and to all that are far off, every one whom the Lord our God calls to him.” (Acts 2:38-39)

The last statement is important, because Christ calls everyoneto him, including infants.

“Now they were bringing even infants to him that he might touch them; and when the disciples saw it, they rebuked them. But Jesus **called them **to him, saying, ‘Let the children come to me, and do not hinder them; for to such belongs the kingdom of God’” (Luke 18:15–16).

And at the same time, we know that no one can enter God’s kingdom without being born again in baptism (John 3:5). So if the kingdom of God is open to children (and therefore infants), then the children must also be born again.
 
Also, in Col 2:11-12 Paul draws a parallel between circumcision and baptism.

“In him also you were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands, by putting off the body of flesh in the circumcision of Christ; and you were buried with him in baptism, in which you were also raised with him through faith in the working of God, who raised him from the dead.” (Col 2:11-12)

Circumcision was usually administered to infants. If baptism was not meant for infants, then circumcision would be a very misleading parallel to the Jews who unquestionably believed in the circumcision of infants.

Moreover, we know that the New Covenant is a better covenant than the old one (Heb 7:22). If infants could enter into the Old Covenant, then there is no reason why the New Covenant (which is better) should exclude them. If parents exercised faith on behalf of the infants in the Old Covenant, why should parents not exercise faith on behalf of the infants in the New Covenant?

There is no direct example of infant baptism in the New Testament, neither is there any condemnation of the same. There is, however, explicit testimony to the practice of infant baptism from the early church, and it is likely that from the beginning of Christianity, when whole households were baptised (Acts 16:15, Acts 16:33, Acts 18:8, 1 Cor 1:16), infants were also included.

Some quotes from the early church -

Irenaeus

“He [Jesus] came to save all through himself; all, I say, who through him are reborn in God–infants, and children, and youths, and old men. Therefore he passed through every age, becoming an infant for infants, sanctifying infants; a child for children, sanctifying those who are of that age . . . [so that] he might be the perfect teacher in all things, perfect not only in respect to the setting forth of truth, perfect also in respect to relative age” (Against Heresies 2:22:4 [A.D. 180]).

Hippolytus

“Where there is no scarcity of water the stream shall flow through the baptismal font or pour into it from above; but if water is scarce, whether on a constant condition or on occasion, then use whatever water is available. Let them remove their clothing. Baptize first the children, and if they can speak for themselves let them do so. Otherwise, let their parents or other relatives speak for them” (The Apostolic Tradition 21:16 [A.D. 215]).

Origen

“The Church received from the apostles the tradition of giving baptism even to infants. The apostles, to whom were committed the secrets of divine mysteries [sacraments], knew there is in everyone innate strains of [original] sin, which must be washed away through water and the Spirit” (Commentaries on Romans 5:9 [A.D. 244]).

Augustine

“What the universal Church holds, not as instituted [invented] by councils but as something always held, is most correctly believed to have been handed down by apostolic authority. Since others respond for children, so that the celebration of the sacrament may be complete for them, it is certainly availing to them for their consecration, because they themselves are not able to respond” (On Baptism 4:24:31 [A.D. 400]).
 
(My words quoted in red)

Karim: Concerning Baptizmo

Baptism does mean immersion in water, but the meaning of the Greek word “baptizo” is broad enough to mean pouring. For instance, Luke 11:38 says, “The Pharisee was astonished to see that he did not first wash (baptizo) before dinner.” However, the Pharisees did not practice immersion before dinner.

Actually, the Greek word means to dip, plunge or immerse. Here is one sentence that uses the words dip/plunge, pour and sprinkle in the same instruction.

He is to dip his finger into the blood and sprinkle some of it seven times before the LORD, in front of the curtain of the sanctuary. The priest shall then put some of the blood on the horns of the altar of fragrant incense that is before the LORD in the Tent of Meeting. The rest of the bull’s blood he shall pour out at the base of the altar of burnt offering at the entrance to the Tent of Meeting. [NIV Lev 4:6-7]

To compare, look at the Septuagint.

Sorry, I thought I had the Septuagint. I have to re-download it and upgrade my software [eSword]

and when they come from the market place, they do not eat unless they purify themselves (baptizo) …" (Mark 7:3-4)

So we see that baptizo can also refer to cleansing or ritual washing, not just immersion.

In Jerusalem (and other towns) they had public purification pools where someone can step down into the pool, dip, plunge or immerse themselves into the water and then keep walking and step out. This is actually how Peter was able to baptise 3,000 men in one day (Acts 2). When the Jews came from the market place, they did in fact immerse themselves. So here, like all other places in the Greek Bible, the word Baptizo still means to dip, plunge or immerse.
 
Also, even figuratively speaking, baptizo may not mean immersion at all times. For instance, Jesus said to his disciples, “but before many days you shall be baptized with the Holy Spirit.” (Acts 1:5). We know that the disciples were not immersed into the Spirit, rather the Spirit was poured out on them (Acts 2:17-18, Acts 2:33). One one occasion, Peter refers to the Holy Spirit falling upon them when speaking about baptism (Acts 11:15-16).

So baptizo may refer either two immersion or to pouring. The meaning is broad enough to cover both.

First, you must realise that two different Greek words are used in this reference, one meaning to pour, the other meaning to dip, plunge or immerse, thus proving the point that every reference of being “baptizo” was a reference to being dipped, plunged or immersed. But that was not your point, (that was my point ).

The phrase, “you shall be baptizo with the Holy Spirit,” may also be translated equally as, “you shall be baptizo in the Holy Spirit.” Now taking that into context of Acts 2:38, “…be baptizo… for the forgiveness of your sins and you will receive the Holy Spirit,…” and the context of Acts 19:2-5, “Did you receive the Holy Spirit…” “No,…” “Then what baptizo did you receive…”, we see that this new baptizo was a baptizo that gave you the Holy Spirit. (I will get into verse 6 shortly).

So what did Joel mean when he said the Spirit will be poured out? We now get into the discussions of the *out pouring *and the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. Simply put, the “pouring out” of something means the manifestation or display of something. So the Holy Spirit was displayed or manifested at Pentecost with the Apostles [Acts 2], the Samaritans [Acts 8] and finally the Gentles [Acts 10] to fulfil what was prophesied, The Word of God would go out from Zion, starting in Jerusalem, to Samaria [Isa 2:3, Mic 4:2] and the whole world.

Yo go on to quote several third century writers who wrote to address a falsehood that started much earlier, a falsehood of which you referenced, the Didache. The Didache has been falsely attributed to the Apostles in Jerusalem* and one of the things that it said --and you referred-- is that baptizo should be done in flowing water if possible, cold water if possible, etc.

This is clearly a falsehood as the first baptizo was done in the immersion pools (purification pools) by the temple at Pentecost. Arguably, the pools at the temple may be considered flowing water as they were filled by water flowing out of the temple, and overflowing into each one until they were all filled. Nevertheless it was never specified that it should be done in flowing/cold water although almost every example we have in the NT was with flowing water (whenever the place of baptizo was specified).

The fact is that the Greek word, baptizo, was **never ever **used to refer to anything but a dipping, plunging or immersing of an item.

By the time the 3rd century writers starting discussing “baptizo by being having water poured or by being sprinkled,” the falsehood was well established and widely accepted as being wrong. It is because of so many saying that “baptizo should be by baptizo” that Cyprian advised Magnus that people who are disturbed by this practice should not be yet he did this without reference to any Apostolic writings or traditions.

*Regarding the Didache

The first part of the Didache, Chapters 1-6, was borrowed almost directly from an older Jewish writing called, The Two Ways. It is the inclusion of these writings that were made popular in the late first century that make many scholars age the Didache as early as 70AD. The second part of this document has its earliest manuscript showing up only as late as the second part of the second century, about 170AD at the earliest.
 
The earliest reference to The Teachings of Jesus the Christ to the Gentiles by the Twelve [Didache] Apostles occurs in the early part of the second century (about 120AD). (Didache roughly means, “the Twelve”). This reference is again to the first six chapters, an adaptation of The Two Ways which was initially a document to teach Hellenistic proselytes about Judaism and adopted by Jewish converts to teach Hellenistic proselytes about Christianity.

The second part of the the Didache is attributed to the same author as The Gospel of Barnabas, widely accepted by most as non-canonical and the work of early gnostics.

About infant baptism

…(Gen 17:11)

…Rom 4:11)

…a covenant requires mutual consent. …Paul refers to circumcision as a sign of the righteousness which Abraham had by faith. Yet, in the Old testament we see that primarily infants were circumcized (Gen 17:12). They didn’t give their consent, they certainly didn’t have faith; but if circumcision is a seal of the righteousness by faith, then the only possible conclusion is that their parents exercised it on their behalf.

…Except that this is a sign of the Abrahamic Covenant between Abraham (singular) and God, made when Abraham was a very old consenting (and brave) adult because of Abraham’s righteousness by faith, not the faith of his offspring nor the righteousness of his offspring. One covenant stipulation was that Abraham’s offspring will be as uncountable as the stars. Every offspring was to be circumcised as a sign of belonging to the covenant, according to the stipulation.

Every time God saved the Israelites, he said they were saved not because of their righteousness but in spite of their rebellion and because of the covenant he made with Abraham (and not the covenant he made with them). Circumcision is a seal of **Abraham’s **righteousness by faith.
 
Peter declared, “Repent, and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins; and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is to you and to your children” (Acts 2:38–39).

Baptism is the Christian equivalent of circumcision, or “the circumcision of Christ”: “In him you were also circumcised with . . . the circumcision of Christ, having been buried with him in baptism and raised with him through your faith in the power of God, who raised him from the dead” (Col. 2:11–12). Thus, like circumcision, baptism can be given to children as well as adults. The difference is that circumcision was powerless to save (Gal. 5:6, 6:15), but “**aptism . . . now saves you” (1 Pet. 3:21).

Romans 5. Verse 12 says that “sin came into the world through one man and death through sin.”

verse 18 says, “Then as one man’s trespass led to condemnation for **all **men”

Original sin is a “contracted” sin, not a sin of commission. One of the results of this original sin is death for all. Infants, children, adults, all must and do die. We can wash away the sin and receive the Holy Spirit. We go from “creatures” of God to “children” of God.

While there may not be anything explict in the bible about baptism for infants, it is certainly implied. What IS explict in the bible is that infant baptism is not forbidden and the bible sets no age limit on baptism. Jesus said, “Unless a man be born again of water and the Holy Spirit he cannot enter heaven” Seems pretty clear when “man” includes all of “mankind”, men, women AND children.**
 
…Peter… said, “Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins; and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is to you and to your children and to all that are far off, every one whom the Lord our God calls to him.” (Acts 2:38-39))

The last statement is important, because Christ calls everyone to him, including infants.

Actually, if you look at the context, Peter was talking to those who believed and were cut to the heart. He was talking to those who had faith and conviction. He was talking to those who could understand what he just preached. He was not talking to children. On the other hand, he did say that the promise is for them, their children, to those far off and to all whom God calls.

Now who are those who God calls? Is it not everyone? So the promise is for everyone! But is everyone saved? No! Only those who accept the teachings of Jesus (believe), put them into practice (obey), have faith and be baptised (we went through that already). This promise is that “if you believe and are baptised (for the forgiveness of your sins) then you will receive the gift of the holy Spirit.” The promise is not just for that generation but to all generations, including us. Their children (the next generation), those who are far off (the Samaritans and the Gentiles) and all whom will be called, (those in this day and age in India, Scandinavia, Austrailia, America, Africa, etc.).

Peter does not say that infants are to be baptised. He is still addressing adults who were cut to the heart and answered them when they asked, “what should they do.” His response starts with repentance from their sins. The action of baptism does not apply to infants but the promise of baptism, to receive the Holy Spirit, is extended to everyone on Earth if they do what is necessary.

…(Luke 18:15–16).

And at the same time, we know that no one can enter God’s kingdom without being born again in baptism (John 3:5). So if the kingdom of God is open to children (and therefore infants), then the children must also be born again.

Again, in context, And he said: "I tell you the truth, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. Therefore, whoever humbles himself like this child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven. [NIV Matt 18:3-4]

Yes, the Kingdom of God is made up of such as these children. We must bear in mind also that in this scripture, people were bringing their children to be blessed, not saved. Jesus had not yet been crucified, buried no raised from the dead so salvation had not yet come and the context of the passage in Luke you referenced was religious pride and humility (starting from verse 9-17). This has nothing to do with salvation through baptism nor with infants entering the Kingdom of God.

“In him also you were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands,… and you were buried with him in baptism, in which you were also raised with him through faith in the working of God, who raised him from the dead.” (Col 2:11-12)

Circumcision was usually administered to infants. If baptism was not meant for infants, then circumcision would be a very misleading parallel to the Jews who unquestionably believed in the circumcision of infants.

Again, the context of the verse is the false teachings that Christians first need to be converted to Judaism before being saved (start reading in verse 8). The idea was not to equate baptizo with circumcision but to say that circumcision was not necessary because something greater is here as you said (Heb 7:22).
 
If infants could enter into the Old Covenant, then there is no reason why the New Covenant (which is better) should exclude them. If parents exercised faith on behalf of the infants in the Old Covenant, why should parents not exercise faith on behalf of the infants in the New Covenant?

You are assuming that parents exercised faith on behalf of the children. I discussed that already but let us discuss the Mosaic covenant now and not the Abramic covenant. Ex 19:3-8 we see God sending Moses to **the people of Israel **to offer them a covenant with him. Moses gathers the **elders of the people **and then [all the people responded together. Clearly, there were no infants responding as they would not understand the request nor could they speak but more (name removed by moderator)ortantly, Moses never went to the infants, only the adults. Likewise, when the people sinned, only the adults were punished. They all died in the desert (except Caleb and Joshua) and only the children entered the promised land. So even in the old covenant, it applied only to the adults.

Again, circumcision was a sign of Abram’s righteousness through faith and not a sign of the child’s righteousness nor faith. You can argue that the same is true for a christening but we are not saved by Abram’s righteousness or faith but by Jesus’ righteousness and our faith in God and christenings are not mentioned anywhere in the NT (or old, for that matter).[/COLOR]

There is no direct example of infant baptism in the New Testament, neither is there any condemnation of the same. There is, however, explicit testimony to the practice of infant baptism from the early church, and it is likely that from the beginning of Christianity, when whole households were baptised (Acts 16:15, Acts 16:33, Acts 18:8, 1 Cor 1:16), infants were also included.

The term, early church is not relevant since we know that heresy entered early as pointed out when people were told to ignore those who say baptizo should be done by βαπτίζω baptizō (immersion) and not by χέω cheō (to pour) or by ῥαντίζω rhantizō (sprinkling). The only early church that we can use as a reliable example is the early to mid first century church whom we know about from the scriptures and other first century writings. (It was for this very reason that the letters of Clement were not placed in the canon since, even though it was known that he had personal contact with the apostle Peter, it could not be established that his letters were the words of Peter and not his own.)

the other issue is that you cannot assume that infants were included in the term, entire household as the term entire assembly (of the people) did not include infants but only adults. Including infants first assumes that infants were present and then assumes, against Jewish tradition, that they were included when a household was counted. Every example we have only counts the adults just as it did at the offering of the Mosaic covenant and the punishment of those who broke it.

Now can I say that I can find an example of the condemnation of infant baptism? No but I can show that baptism was only ordered for those who were not infants (as I already have done) since the things that have to be achieved before baptism can only be achieved by adults.

I withold comments on the early church fathers for reasons already stated.
 
I have not yet responded to the above, just read it today (after a long break). Any suggestions?
 
I scanned through the post to pick up as much as I could in a brief look, please forgive if this is a repeat of something you have already tried….

I may be time to try a different approach. I am willing to bet that if your friend believes so strongly against infant baptism, that he is probably also a Sola Scriptura guy. If that is the case, Scripture means whatever he wants it to mean and it will always mean something against infant baptism.

When I face this problem, I look to the OT for guidance. Start off with Hebrews 10:1 where Paul says that the law is but a shadow of the good things to come. It looks like from your posts that you have covered the fact that baptism is the NT circumcision. In the OT, at what age did someone enter into covenant with God? Eight days. An infant. So now Christ comes along and frees us and gives us baptism, but all of the sudden, infants need not apply? In the shadow, the OT, an infant could enter into covenant with God. But now in the NT, that same infant cannot?

Keep in mind that if he believes in personal interpretation of Scripture, it is highly unlikely you will sway him. It’s like hitting a moving target. Challenge him on the origin of the bible. Ask him where the bible came from, who complied it, who protected it, etc.
 
I am particularly interested in finding out more about the “immersion only” aspect that he has explained. Also, the question as to whether faith is needed on the part of the baptismal candidate.
 
I am particularly interested in finding out more about the “immersion only” aspect that he has explained. Also, the question as to whether faith is needed on the part of the baptismal candidate.
If the exclusive Old Covenant included babies, how can the better and all-inclusive New Covenant exclude babies? That is the question I ask myself to better understand baptism in the light of the Covenants. The Old covenant was exclusive (for the Jews only), the New Covenant is all-inclusive; the individual entry sign into the Old Covenant was circumcision of males (no age limit); the individual entry sign into the New Covenant is baptism of both males and females (no age limit).
Regarding “immersion only”, the Bible seems to show that Saint Paul was not immersed.

placido
 
You might ask him if he knows of what bodies of water flowed through Cornelius’ house and if they were deep enough for immersion when Peter ordered him baptised? 😉

It was not logistically probable that the 3,000 new single-day converts on Pentecost mentioned in Acts 2:21 all formed up at one time into a caravan of ox-wagons and chariots to make the trek to the River Jordon to get immersed in baptism. It is more probable that these were baptised at the Court of the Gentiles at Herod’s Temple.

It turns out that the Mikvahs (ritual baths) of Herod’s temple are by Jewish ritual law made deep enough for full mersion and these were required by law to be “living water” (flowing water from a natural source). But I don’t think that there were any Mikvahs in the outer courts. My personal opinion is that it was more probable that water was simply poured over them with ladles dipped or filled from stone jars of water.

At any rate you might tell him that Catholics have been doing baptisms for 2,000 years and happen to know a thing or two from tradition about how it’s done. We simply don’t need to reverse-engineer the Greek texts to derive hidden meanings that were known for 50-70 years before anyone got around to writing what was spoken in Aramaic and written down in the Greek.

If he insists on playing the literalist game ask him if he has made his mecca to The River Jordan to get his baptism since its the only body of water mentioned by name in the bible so anything else has to come from his own traditions to justify baptism from any other source of water. Either he must remain a literalist or he must be reasonable - he can’t have it both ways without contradicting himself in his own behaviors & practises without undermining his own conviction in a literalist methodology. If you ask me I think the man is immersing himself in his own nonsence and is determined to wet his pants with the fear that he possibly didn’t get his own baptism done correctly. It all brings new meaning to the practise of sprinking. 😉

James
 
Found this on Catholic Answers:

It is true that baptizo often means immersion. For example, the Greek version of the Old Testament tells us that Naaman, at Elisha’s direction, “went down and dipped himself [the Greek word here is baptizo] seven times in the Jordan” (2 Kgs. 5:14, Septuagint, emphasis added).

But immersion is not the only meaning of baptizo. Sometimes it just means washing up. Thus Luke 11:38 reports that, when Jesus ate at a Pharisee’s house, “[t]he Pharisee was astonished to see that he did not first wash [baptizo] before dinner.” They did not practice immersion before dinner, but, according to Mark, the Pharisees “do not eat unless they wash [nipto] their hands, observing the tradition of the elders; and when they come from the market place, they do not eat unless they wash themselves [baptizo]” (Mark 7:3–4a, emphasis added). So baptizo can mean cleansing or ritual washing as well as immersion.

A similar range of meanings can be seen when baptizo is used metaphorically. Sometimes a figurative “baptism” is a sort of “immersion”; but not always. For example, speaking of his future suffering and death, Jesus said, “I have a baptism [baptisma] to be baptized [baptizo] with; and how I am constrained until it is accomplished!” (Luke 12:50) This might suggest that Christ would be “immersed” in suffering. On the other hand, consider the case of being “baptized with the Holy Spirit.”

In Acts 1:4–5 Jesus charged his disciples “not to depart from Jerusalem, but to wait for the promise of the Father, which, he said, ‘you heard from me, for John baptized with water, but before many days you shall be baptized with the Holy Spirit.’” Did this mean they would be “immersed” in the Spirit? No: three times Acts 2 states that the Holy Spirit was poured out on them when Pentecost came (2:17, 18, 33, emphasis added). Later Peter referred to the Spirit falling upon them, and also on others after Pentecost, explicitly identifying these events with the promise of being “baptized with the Holy Spirit” (Acts 11:15–17). These passages demonstrate that the meaning of baptizo is broad enough to include “pouring.”
 
You might ask him if he knows of what bodies of water flowed through Cornelius’ house and if they were deep enough for immersion when Peter ordered him baptised? 😉
Granddude, it is not mentioned whether the people of Cornelius’ house were baptized in the house itself.
If you ask me I think the man is immersing himself in his own nonsence and is determined to wet his pants with the fear that he possibly didn’t get his own baptism done correctly.
No, he is a good man, not a fundamentalist.
It all brings new meaning to the practise of sprinking. 😉
Who practices baptism by sprinkling?
 
Found this on Catholic Answers:

It is true that baptizo often means immersion. For example, the Greek version of the Old Testament tells us that Naaman, at Elisha’s direction, “went down and dipped himself [the Greek word here is baptizo] seven times in the Jordan” (2 Kgs. 5:14, Septuagint, emphasis added).

But immersion is not the only meaning of baptizo. Sometimes it just means washing up. Thus Luke 11:38 reports that, when Jesus ate at a Pharisee’s house, “[t]he Pharisee was astonished to see that he did not first wash [baptizo] before dinner.” They did not practice immersion before dinner, but, according to Mark, the Pharisees “do not eat unless they wash [nipto] their hands, observing the tradition of the elders; and when they come from the market place, they do not eat unless they wash themselves [baptizo]” (Mark 7:3–4a, emphasis added). So baptizo can mean cleansing or ritual washing as well as immersion.

A similar range of meanings can be seen when baptizo is used metaphorically. Sometimes a figurative “baptism” is a sort of “immersion”; but not always. For example, speaking of his future suffering and death, Jesus said, “I have a baptism [baptisma] to be baptized [baptizo] with; and how I am constrained until it is accomplished!” (Luke 12:50) This might suggest that Christ would be “immersed” in suffering. On the other hand, consider the case of being “baptized with the Holy Spirit.”

In Acts 1:4–5 Jesus charged his disciples “not to depart from Jerusalem, but to wait for the promise of the Father, which, he said, ‘you heard from me, for John baptized with water, but before many days you shall be baptized with the Holy Spirit.’” Did this mean they would be “immersed” in the Spirit? No: three times Acts 2 states that the Holy Spirit was poured out on them when Pentecost came (2:17, 18, 33, emphasis added). Later Peter referred to the Spirit falling upon them, and also on others after Pentecost, explicitly identifying these events with the promise of being “baptized with the Holy Spirit” (Acts 11:15–17). These passages demonstrate that the meaning of baptizo is broad enough to include “pouring.”
I have already used that, see post no. 2.
 
I am willing to bet that if your friend believes so strongly against infant baptism, that he is probably also a Sola Scriptura guy. If that is the case, Scripture means whatever he wants it to mean and it will always mean something against infant baptism.
Good point… And if he is a sola scriptura guy, he’s probably also a REFORMATION guy, and maybe you could point to his own heroes of the Reformation, Luther and Wesley. Infant baptism wasn’t one of the reasons for the protestant “reformation.”

If Scripture states that “All have sinned,” then “ALL” should be able to be baptized by water. If we believe infants have sinned, then we must believe that they can also be saved. We cannot separate the grace that comes from the sacrament. If scripture states that “Baptism now saves you” then somehow there is grace imparted through the sacrament.

infant baptism
reformationtoday.tripod.com/chemnitz/id43.html
 
Granddude, it is not mentioned whether the people of Cornelius’ house were baptized in the house itself.
Dude, I have it on good advise that they filled his Roman helmet with bathing water and poured it over him 3 times…
Who practices baptism by sprinkling?
Duh, like dude, “we” Catholics do the “sprinkling” thing my man. Youz gots ta get wit da lingo bro… 😉

*Aspersion (la. aspergere/aspersio), in a religious context, is the act of sprinkling with water, especially holy water. Aspersion is a method used in baptism as an alternative to immersion or affusion. The word is formed of the Latin aspergere, ‘to sprinkle’, of ad, ‘to’, and spargo, ‘I scatter’.

In addition, aspersion is performed as part of certain rites to remind people of their baptism, such as the renewal of baptismal vows performed by the Roman Catholic Church on Easter.

Aspersion is also a normal English usage, usually in the phrase “to cast aspersions upon…”, to mean an attack on somebody’s character or reputation.

More here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspersion*

Got it all together now bro?

😛

James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top