W
WesleyF
Guest
I am having a lively discussion with a Protestant (Karim) on the issue of infant baptism. But I need some help.
I’ll copy-paste the discussion over here:
His words are in blue:
Karim: Baptism is immersion in water. It is not sprinkling, it is not pouring, it is immersion. There are different Greek words for pour and sprinkle and the what we now call in English, baptism, is from the Greek word that means to be immersed. Now people are immersed all the time. Why, just the other day, my wife and I were at the beach and we went out pretty far and several waves immersed us. Actually, that is not true. We were not immersed by the waves but submersed by the waves.
To be immersed is to be plunged into water, not to have water come over you. (The Greek word is sometimes translated as “to be plunged into”). Nevertheless, i haev immersed my son, Omar, in a pool several times to try to get him accustomed to having his head under water so he would not be afraid. I also immersed many friends in the pool as a child in horseplay. I have seen many people be immersed at the beach by their friends and many a people were immersed to death by the mob. Immersion in water, typically, only gets you wet.
But please note who is to be baptised. Those who believe in the message. If you do not believe in the message that Jesus is Messiah and son of the Living God, immersion only gets you wet. Those who hold to his teachings, that is those who are obedient. this is born out in the letters of John and also in the words of Jesus in John 8:31-32 where Jesus points out that mere belief is not enough. Also see James 2:9. If you do not follow Christ, immersion only gets you wet.
To bear that out even more, going back to Matt 28:18-20, “Go make disciples of all nations, baptising them…” So you are to immerse those who are followers of Christ, not those who are not yet following. But, since followers of Christ are obedient to him, it only makes sense that they would obey him and be baptised. Let us not go there just yet.
Those who have faith. How does one person being immersed only gets wet while another gets his sins washed away as well and receives the Holy Spirit? Faith. Ephesians 2 bears this out and says a great deal about salvation. It is often quoted out of context such as verse 8 to say, “you were saved by grace,” meaning that you did not earn your salvation, but it says “by grace, through faith!”
Colossians 2:11-12 explains, “having been buried with him in baptism and raised with him through your faith in the power of God…” If immersion is where we are buried in Christ (and get wet), faith is where we come out of the water and are raised to a new life in Christ. Immersing someone without faith only gets them wet.
So those who are to be baptised are those who believe --like Paul and Lydia-- those who hold to his teachings --like Paul and Lydia-- and those who have faith --like Paul and Lydia-- and in doing so, shall die to themselves, wash away their sins as they are buried with Jesus, and --through faith-- rise to a new life in Christ as they rise from the water.
Now here is what is not in the Bible. Any example of infant baptism. Neither the Jailer nor Lydia nor Cornelius nor anyone else whose household were baptised suggest the presence of infants. I, myself have seen households baptised (including one of four generations) and not one infant was among them. It cannot be assumed that because a household was baptised that infants were baptised also.
I’ll copy-paste the discussion over here:
His words are in blue:
Karim: Baptism is immersion in water. It is not sprinkling, it is not pouring, it is immersion. There are different Greek words for pour and sprinkle and the what we now call in English, baptism, is from the Greek word that means to be immersed. Now people are immersed all the time. Why, just the other day, my wife and I were at the beach and we went out pretty far and several waves immersed us. Actually, that is not true. We were not immersed by the waves but submersed by the waves.
To be immersed is to be plunged into water, not to have water come over you. (The Greek word is sometimes translated as “to be plunged into”). Nevertheless, i haev immersed my son, Omar, in a pool several times to try to get him accustomed to having his head under water so he would not be afraid. I also immersed many friends in the pool as a child in horseplay. I have seen many people be immersed at the beach by their friends and many a people were immersed to death by the mob. Immersion in water, typically, only gets you wet.
But please note who is to be baptised. Those who believe in the message. If you do not believe in the message that Jesus is Messiah and son of the Living God, immersion only gets you wet. Those who hold to his teachings, that is those who are obedient. this is born out in the letters of John and also in the words of Jesus in John 8:31-32 where Jesus points out that mere belief is not enough. Also see James 2:9. If you do not follow Christ, immersion only gets you wet.
To bear that out even more, going back to Matt 28:18-20, “Go make disciples of all nations, baptising them…” So you are to immerse those who are followers of Christ, not those who are not yet following. But, since followers of Christ are obedient to him, it only makes sense that they would obey him and be baptised. Let us not go there just yet.
Those who have faith. How does one person being immersed only gets wet while another gets his sins washed away as well and receives the Holy Spirit? Faith. Ephesians 2 bears this out and says a great deal about salvation. It is often quoted out of context such as verse 8 to say, “you were saved by grace,” meaning that you did not earn your salvation, but it says “by grace, through faith!”
Colossians 2:11-12 explains, “having been buried with him in baptism and raised with him through your faith in the power of God…” If immersion is where we are buried in Christ (and get wet), faith is where we come out of the water and are raised to a new life in Christ. Immersing someone without faith only gets them wet.
So those who are to be baptised are those who believe --like Paul and Lydia-- those who hold to his teachings --like Paul and Lydia-- and those who have faith --like Paul and Lydia-- and in doing so, shall die to themselves, wash away their sins as they are buried with Jesus, and --through faith-- rise to a new life in Christ as they rise from the water.
Now here is what is not in the Bible. Any example of infant baptism. Neither the Jailer nor Lydia nor Cornelius nor anyone else whose household were baptised suggest the presence of infants. I, myself have seen households baptised (including one of four generations) and not one infant was among them. It cannot be assumed that because a household was baptised that infants were baptised also.