Discussion on infallibility - feel like joining in?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Soldier_of_Mary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Soldier_of_Mary

Guest
I thought that I would come here to see if there were any Catholics who would want to enter into a discussion started by a comment of a friend of mine on a Protestant’s blog. I think that the discussion began with the abuse scandal but has moved mainly on towards infallibility:

blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=21597890&postID=1803941815455013648

The main issue is that the Protestants involved think that personal sin on the part of a pope proves that the pope can’t be infallible (not due to a confusion between impeccability and infallibility but based mainly on statements like “I don’t see how a sinful person could claim to be infallible” and Bible quotations about knowing a person by his fruits).

Someone also briefly tried to prove celibacy wrong with the “husband of one wife” argument.

I’d jump in, but I don’t have time at the moment. 🙂
 
I threw in a response but I can’t foresee lurking. There’s an awful lot of obstinance in the thread.
 
It is against forum rules to invite people from this forum to post on a thread in another board.
 
Ah, is it? I didn’t see anything in the forum rules about it. If it is, my mistake (though I would think such a rule unfortunate)! 🙂
 
The main issue is that the Protestants involved think that personal sin on the part of a pope proves that the pope can’t be infallible
I’m not interested in reading the thread, but I do find it amusing when protestants want to tell US what OUR doctrines mean, and then debate us using THEIR definition.
Someone also briefly tried to prove celibacy wrong with the “husband of one wife” argument.
And, of course, celibacy is just a rule, not a doctrine, and thus has nothing to do with infallibility. The Church could change the rules of celibacy any time, but doctrine can never change.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top