Disturbing Article on Life

  • Thread starter Thread starter Qurt
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Q

Qurt

Guest
I am attaching here an article (poorly written) that was sent to me to suggest that the Church’s position on life is flexible when there are monetary interest involved. I believe the case mentioned in this article sadly, may be the breakthrough we need to finally get R v. Wade overturned. In the article a Man’s wife and unborn children tragically die in a Catholic Hospital. He is suing not only for the wrongful death of his wife but, also for his unborn children. The hospital and certainly its insurance company are fighting this case, clearly for financial reasons, and have acted consistent with civil law. When the local clergy, and Bishop have been asked to comment the have declined. The man plans to appeal this until he is satisfied.

guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/jan/25/miscarriage-murder-roevwade-personhood

What if Catholic’s funded his appeals all the way to the Supreme court where the"Person -hood" of the unborn is recognized and damages are awarded. This would be the end of R. v. W. Think about it.
 
I am attaching here an article (poorly written) that was sent to me to suggest that the Church’s position on life is flexible when there are monetary interest involved. I believe the case mentioned in this article sadly, may be the breakthrough we need to finally get R v. Wade overturned. In the article a Man’s wife and unborn children tragically die in a Catholic Hospital. He is suing not only for the wrongful death of his wife but, also for his unborn children. The hospital and certainly its insurance company are fighting this case, clearly for financial reasons, and have acted consistent with civil law. When the local clergy, and Bishop have been asked to comment the have declined. The man plans to appeal this until he is satisfied.

guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/jan/25/miscarriage-murder-roevwade-personhood

What if Catholic’s funded his appeals all the way to the Supreme court where the"Person -hood" of the unborn is recognized and damages are awarded. This would be the end of R. v. W. Think about it.
This issue has come up on the forum a few times now, and the answer has been the same every time. It is NOT the Church here that is arguing that the couple’s child is not a person. It is the attorney who is defending the doctor.

The Church is not responsible for the Hospital’s decisions, and the Hospital is not responsible for the attorney’s decisions; and the attorney is wrong.

The reason the bishops refuse to comment is because there is nothing they can or could do.
 
Qurt, if you intended to link to the Colorado hospital case, it appears that did not work. The link in your post does not, as far as I can see, reference that case. I do not think the Co. case is as easy to read as it may seem.
  1. MSW makes a pretty good case for this being a situation where it could have been handled more clearly, but the lawyers are working within the framework of existing CO law.
ncronline.org/blogs/distinctly-catholic/msw-v-sirico-part-1
  1. commenter at Mark Shea’s blog makes the interesting, and probably too subtle to be intentional, argument that Hospital knows what it is doing, in the sense that the bereaved husband is asking the CO courts to decide that a fetus is a person within the meaning of CO law - - that is, to change the law. If the Hospital agreed to this, it would only apply to this particular case - - the two litigants cannot change how CO interprets its own laws and cases. By opposing that change, the Hospital is forcing the court to choose - - and it may choose to define life in the way the Hospital would want (bad for its case, good for society). If the court upholds the existing interpretation of the law, the hospital wins its case. Win-win, to an extent. patheos.com/blogs/markshea/2013/01/catholic-hospital-fights-for-30-pieces-of-silver.html First comment by Wolfwood.
  2. the entity in the lawsuit is not “the Church”, whatever that means, but a Catholic healthcare nonprofit, IIRC.
Follow up here: patheos.com/blogs/yimcatholic/2013/01/the-catholic-bishops-of-colorado-respond-to-hospitals-legal-refutation-of-unborn-twins-personhood.html
 
Dshix, I am not sure I would let the Hospital off so easily. Yes, the attorney is making the argument, but who makes the call about what argument to use? It certainly should be the client, although of course a lawyer could ask to withdraw from the case if the client wasn’t taking his advice. One cannot tell for sure if the matter was discussed with the client, but it seems to me it would be malpractice to have not discussed it, and it is really hard to imagine that no one realized the impact of that argument.

I thought MSW had the best take on it so far, in the link in my above post, although the second Patheos article is making me think about it some more.
 
Dshix, I am not sure I would let the Hospital off so easily. Yes, the attorney is making the argument, but who makes the call about what argument to use? It certainly should be the client, although of course a lawyer could ask to withdraw from the case if the client wasn’t taking his advice. One cannot tell for sure if the matter was discussed with the client, but it seems to me it would be malpractice to have not discussed it, and it is really hard to imagine that no one realized the impact of that argument.

I thought MSW had the best take on it so far, in the link in my above post, although the second Patheos article is making me think about it some more.
I agree, the hospital definitely has a degree of responsibility; I misspoke before. However, the Church, as in the bishops and the Pope, is not responsible for this debacle.
 
@ choose to love, your "win/win commentary is exactly where I was going with this. I hope the Catholic League and Thomas Moore society are aware. I would think private Catholic money supporting this man and his appeals would be in our best interest.
 
Scenario-
The law- Infanticide (for the sake of the scenario defined as the intentional act of causing the death of a child more than 24 hours after the child’s birth) is illegal

Hospital and hospital staff- affiliated with a religion that teaches infanticide is moral up to 9 months after the child is born (regardless of physical deformities), teaches that it is immoral to let a child with physical deformities live, and that a person only becomes a person 9 months after they are born

Parents- Not members of the religion mentioned above; no strong views either way on infanticide or when a person becomes a person

The parents take their physically deformed 6 month old child to the hospital due to breathing problems brought about by the child’s physical deformity. The staff at the hospital kill the child because of his deformity even though they had the ability to resolve his breathing problems. The parents demand the DA press murder charges against the hospital staff and bring civil suits against the staff and the hospital.

Questions-
-Can the DA file charges since the hospital and staff’s religious views differ from what the law states?
-Can the parents file a civil suit against the hospital and staff since they don’t have an opinion either way on infanticide or when a person is a person?
-Does the court system ignore what the law states and instead base the conclusions of the criminal and civil cases on what the hospital’s and hospital’s staff religion teaches?

Additional questions-
What if the hospital fired a Catholic doctor (who tried to medically treat the child) for malpractice (trying to treat a physically deformed child).
Can the doctor file a civil suit for wrongful termination?
Does the doctor lose his license due to what the hospital deems, but not what the law deems, to be malpractice?
 
Whether the lawyers’ defense was agreed to by the hospital or not does not in necessarily reflect the moral judgments of the hospital itself.

If I’m not mistaken, the lawyers are arguing whether THE LAW treats the fetus as persons, and the Colorado Wrongful Death Act as it stands treats as persons only those who are born alive. Since THE LAW doesn’t see fetuses as humans, wrongful death against fetuses is NEVER ILLEGAL, wrongful or otherwise.

If it is not illegal, the court cannot penalize the hospital with the force of the law. Note though that the legality of an action is in the final analysis, irrelevant to the hospital’s moral judgments. The hospital may still view something as morally wrong and yet if it is not illegal, they cannot be penalized by the government for it.

For example, they may view missing one’s Sunday obligation as morally wrong, but it is not illegal and penalized by law. Hence, they cannot be charged for it even if they view this as morally wrong. The lawyers may not be arguing whether a death of a fetus is morally wrong, but whether the existing laws make it illegal and can be penalized by the government. They are really not arguing whether fetuses are in fact persons, but whether the current laws see them as such.
 
Great answer - Does anybody know if the Catholic league knows about this case?🤷
 
Neither fetal homicide laws or criminalise amendments criminalise miscarridge, what they both criminalise is intentional killing of an unborn baby

Were women who had a natural miscarriage charged with murder or manslaughter before roe vs wade?

Author of the article linked and the other article linked on the claim that highlights Bei Bei Shuai, need to ask themselves, she ate rat poision when she was 8 months pregnant. Doctors didn’t find anything wrong with the baby at first but was delivered 8 days later, premature, and died from brain bleed 3 days after birth

if an individual had forced a woman to take rat posion, I doubt the authors of the 2 articles would say that that inidvidual should not be imprisiopned for whay they did, so why shouldn’t the same standards be extended to those that are pregnant?

needs to ask, for many years fetal homicide laws, not personhood amendments, have been used to charge those who have killed a woman’s unborn child with manslaughter or murder. Does the author not think people should be criminally charged for causing the death of a pregnant woman’s child? Why should a pregnant woman not be exempt if she has purposefully found to have intentionally tried to kill her child?

Fetal homicide laws exist in 38 states and they expose the hypocrisy of legal abortion

If a pregnant woman is going to an abortion clinic is assaulted in the street which causes the death of her unborn child, the individual(s) that assaulted her would be guilty of manslaughter or double murder charge if the attackers killed the woman. But the abortion doctor can legally kill the baby and is not charged with manslaughter

Individual(s) can be charged with double murder if they kill a pregnant woman. Killing the unborn leads to a murder charge, yet killing the unborn in an abortion clinic is legal

Scott Peterson got the death penalty in California after killing Laci Peterson and her unborn child Connor. Killing Laci and Connor meant Scott Peterson got a double murder charge. Killing the unborn in that situation was seen as murder under the Unborn Victim law

Pregnant woman in Indiana was charged with murder after she took rat poison at 33 weeks which killed her unborn child

There is a strange situation in the law where some killing of the unborn is regarded as murder and treated by the law in the way, and abortion which kills the unborn is lawful

Catholic Health Association says on the Angela Carder case

chausa.org/workarea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=4835

In June 1987 a judge in Washington, DC, ordered a cesarean section to be performed on Angela Carder, who was 26 weeks’ pregnant and near death from cancer. She had discussed with her physicians the hope that her life could be prolonged to the 28th week of pregnancy, when the potential outcome for the fetus would be much better. When it appeared her death was imminent, however, the hospital, used substituted judgment (i.e., determined what she most likely would have wanted). The appeals court stated, "We hold that in virtually all cases the question of what is to be done is to be decided by the patient—the pregnant woman—on behalf of herself and the fetus."1

The hospital involved in the case, George Washington University Medical Center, settled the lawsuit brought against it by Carder’s parents at the same time it announced a new hospital pol- icy on decision making with pregnant patients (see Box on p. 21). This policy on decision mak- ing with pregnant patients incorporated the appeals court decision that supports patient and family decision making and stated that judicial intervention is almost never the appropriate way to resolve ethical issues. Although courts have ordered cesarean sec- tions in other cases, few have received the public- ity given the Carder case, and only one other case has reached the ap- peals court level. These cases are often categorized as mater nal-fetal conflicts, sug- gesting that the rights of mother and fetus are in opposition to each other…
 
Personhood Legislation Would Not Criminalize Miscarriages, In Vitro Fertilization, or Hormonal Contraception

rightremedy.org/articles/361

Were women who had a natural miscarriage charged with murder or manslaughter before roe vs wade?

Author of the article linked and the other article linked on the claim that highlights Bei Bei Shuai, need to ask themselves, she ate rat poision when she was 8 months pregnant. Doctors didn’t find anything wrong with the baby at first but was delivered 8 days later, premature, and died from brain bleed 3 days after birth

if an individual had forced a woman to take rat posion, I doubt the authors of the 2 articles would say that that inidvidual should not be imprisiopned for whay they did, so why shouldn’t the same standards be extended to those that are pregnant?

needs to ask, for many years fetal homicide laws, not personhood amendments, have been used to charge those who have killed a woman’s unborn child with manslaughter or murder. Does the author not think people should be criminally charged for causing the death of a pregnant woman’s child? Why should a pregnant woman not be exempt if she has purposefully found to have intentionally tried to kill her child?

Fetal homicide laws exist in 38 states and they expose the hypocrisy of legal abortion

If a pregnant woman is going to an abortion clinic is assaulted in the street which causes the death of her unborn child, the individual(s) that assaulted her would be guilty of manslaughter or double murder charge if the attackers killed the woman. But the abortion doctor can legally kill the baby and is not charged with manslaughter

Individual(s) can be charged with double murder if they kill a pregnant woman. Killing the unborn leads to a murder charge, yet killing the unborn in an abortion clinic is legal

Scott Peterson got the death penalty in California after killing Laci Peterson and her unborn child Connor. Killing Laci and Connor meant Scott Peterson got a double murder charge. Killing the unborn in that situation was seen as murder under the Unborn Victim law

Pregnant woman in Indiana was charged with murder after she took rat poison at 33 weeks which killed her unborn child

There is a strange situation in the law where some killing of the unborn is regarded as murder and treated by the law in the way, and abortion which kills the unborn is lawful

Catholic Health Association says on the Angela Carder case

chausa.org/workarea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=4835

In June 1987 a judge in Washington, DC, ordered a cesarean section to be performed on Angela Carder, who was 26 weeks’ pregnant and near death from cancer. She had discussed with her physicians the hope that her life could be prolonged to the 28th week of pregnancy, when the potential outcome for the fetus would be much better. When it appeared her death was imminent, however, the hospital, used substituted judgment (i.e., determined what she most likely would have wanted). The appeals court stated, "We hold that in virtually all cases the question of what is to be done is to be decided by the patient—the pregnant woman—on behalf of herself and the fetus."1

The hospital involved in the case, George Washington University Medical Center, settled the lawsuit brought against it by Carder’s parents at the same time it announced a new hospital pol- icy on decision making with pregnant patients (see Box on p. 21). This policy on decision mak- ing with pregnant patients incorporated the appeals court decision that supports patient and family decision making and stated that judicial intervention is almost never the appropriate way to resolve ethical issues. Although courts have ordered cesarean sec- tions in other cases, few have received the public- ity given the Carder case, and only one other case has reached the ap- peals court level. These cases are often categorized as mater nal-fetal conflicts, sug- gesting that the rights of mother and fetus are in opposition to each other…
 
I think person-hood granted to the unborn baby could be a step in the right direction.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top