Neither fetal homicide laws or criminalise amendments criminalise miscarridge, what they both criminalise is intentional killing of an unborn baby
Were women who had a natural miscarriage charged with murder or manslaughter before roe vs wade?
Author of the article linked and the other article linked on the claim that highlights Bei Bei Shuai, need to ask themselves, she ate rat poision when she was 8 months pregnant. Doctors didn’t find anything wrong with the baby at first but was delivered 8 days later, premature, and died from brain bleed 3 days after birth
if an individual had forced a woman to take rat posion, I doubt the authors of the 2 articles would say that that inidvidual should not be imprisiopned for whay they did, so why shouldn’t the same standards be extended to those that are pregnant?
needs to ask, for many years fetal homicide laws, not personhood amendments, have been used to charge those who have killed a woman’s unborn child with manslaughter or murder. Does the author not think people should be criminally charged for causing the death of a pregnant woman’s child? Why should a pregnant woman not be exempt if she has purposefully found to have intentionally tried to kill her child?
Fetal homicide laws exist in 38 states and they expose the hypocrisy of legal abortion
If a pregnant woman is going to an abortion clinic is assaulted in the street which causes the death of her unborn child, the individual(s) that assaulted her would be guilty of manslaughter or double murder charge if the attackers killed the woman. But the abortion doctor can legally kill the baby and is not charged with manslaughter
Individual(s) can be charged with double murder if they kill a pregnant woman. Killing the unborn leads to a murder charge, yet killing the unborn in an abortion clinic is legal
Scott Peterson got the death penalty in California after killing Laci Peterson and her unborn child Connor. Killing Laci and Connor meant Scott Peterson got a double murder charge. Killing the unborn in that situation was seen as murder under the Unborn Victim law
Pregnant woman in Indiana was charged with
murder after she took rat poison at 33 weeks which killed her unborn child
There is a strange situation in the law where some killing of the unborn is regarded as murder and treated by the law in the way, and abortion which kills the unborn is lawful
Catholic Health Association says on the Angela Carder case
chausa.org/workarea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=4835
In June 1987 a judge in Washington, DC, ordered a cesarean section to be performed on Angela Carder, who was 26 weeks’ pregnant and near death from cancer. She had discussed with her physicians the hope that her life could be prolonged to the 28th week of pregnancy, when the potential outcome for the fetus would be much better. When it appeared her death was imminent, however, the hospital, used substituted judgment (i.e., determined what she most likely would have wanted). The appeals court stated, "We hold that in virtually all cases the question of what is to be done is to be decided by the patient—the pregnant woman—on behalf of herself and the fetus."1
The hospital involved in the case, George Washington University Medical Center, settled the lawsuit brought against it by Carder’s parents at the same time it announced a new hospital pol- icy on decision making with pregnant patients (see Box on p. 21). This policy on decision mak- ing with pregnant patients incorporated the appeals court decision that supports patient and family decision making and stated that judicial intervention is almost never the appropriate way to resolve ethical issues. Although courts have ordered cesarean sec- tions in other cases, few have received the public- ity given the Carder case, and only one other case has reached the ap- peals court level. These cases are often categorized as mater nal-fetal conflicts, sug- gesting that the rights of mother and fetus are in opposition to each other…