Divorce: Pat Robertson says it's ok if your spouse has Alzheimer's!

  • Thread starter Thread starter legaleagle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

legaleagle

Guest
:eek:

As a former Protestant, I was shocked by this news today. I know from my Baptist days that divorce was becoming more and more accepted in Protestant circles but this latest headline disgusts me and baffles me. Very sad that Robertson is able to mislead possibly millions of viewers on the sanctity of marriage.

If you google his name and Alzheimer’s and divorce, you’ll find tons of news links on it. :mad:
 
I read that online today and found that disgraceful.Doesn’t matter if you are catholic ,protestant or whatever ,that’s just wrong .I am appalled that this religious broadcaster would say this.
 
Maybe he has Alzheimer’s? If not, sounds like something his wife might want to address. 😉
 
:eek:

As a former Protestant, I was shocked by this news today. I know from my Baptist days that divorce was becoming more and more accepted in Protestant circles but this latest headline disgusts me and baffles me. Very sad that Robertson is able to mislead possibly millions of viewers on the sanctity of marriage.

If you google his name and Alzheimer’s and divorce, you’ll find tons of news links on it. :mad:
I too am a former Protestant.Because he made such an heartless comment,I do think the poor old soul bless his heart,may have a touch of Alzheimers himself.You will be in my prayers tonight Pat that you may have a change of heart and soul.Does Pat think that as we get old and our minds deteriate that we should just be thrown away as if we are are rag:shrug: dolls.
 
I do not believe in what he has to say, apparently he doesn’t remember Jesus’ teachings about marriage in the Gospels.
 
You said it best!!! But still,like ones have said that posted before me,"He just spoke to millions of viewers"That in itself is frightening.So many people view his show and have a strong belief in what he says.He may damage alot of marriages thru his spoken stupidy.
 
I too am a former Protestant.Because he made such an heartless comment,I do think the poor old soul bless his heart,may have a touch of Alzheimers himself.You will be in my prayers tonight Pat that you may have a change of heart and soul.Does Pat think that as we get old and our minds deteriate that we should just be thrown away as if we are are rag:shrug: dolls.
 
:eek:

As a former Protestant, I was shocked by this news today. I know from my Baptist days that divorce was becoming more and more accepted in Protestant circles but this latest headline disgusts me and baffles me. Very sad that Robertson is able to mislead possibly millions of viewers on the sanctity of marriage.

fall fox

My father had Alzheimer’s, my sisters and I took a little different approach, we were thinking about and did bring the idea of divorcing dad to our mother. The thing about Catholics is, if they got a civil divorce, in their hearts and in the eyes of God and His Church they are still married. That was in our thinking when we talked to mom. The reason for this was to protect her financially, we would try to get an 80/20 split of assets so that the expense of the care he would need wouldn’t make her destitute. Nothing would change in their lives, dad would remain with her, well with us.
I know that isn’t the reason stated for the divorce Robertson was talking about, he was trying to free them to be married again.

Mom couldn’t do it, and we all understood. We made the best of a bad situation. He lived for a long time with the decease.
 
When is the world, the press, anybody and everybody…going to start ignoring this guy. Most of the teeeveee preachers eventually decend into irrellevance once exposed.

Saddly, he’ll still linger.
 
The Pharisees approached and asked, “Is it lawful for a husband to divorce his wife?” They were testing him. He said to them in reply, “What did Moses command you?” They replied, “Moses permitted him to write a bill of divorce and dismiss her.” But Jesus told them, “Because of the hardness of your hearts he wrote you this commandment. But from the beginning of creation, ‘God made them male and female. For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother [and be joined to his wife], and the two shall become one flesh.’ So they are no longer two but one flesh. Therefore what God has joined together, no human being must separate.” Mark 10:2-9

*Terry Meeuwsen, Robertson’s co-host, asked him about couples’ marriage vows to take care of each other “for better or for worse” and “in sickness and in health.”

“If you respect that vow, you say `til death do us part,’” Robertson said during the Tuesday broadcast. “This is a kind of death.”*

Have you stopped reading your Bible, Mr. Robertson? And what do you mean, “if” you respect that vow? Is there an option on that? Besides, since she is dead, wouldn’t you be justified to stop feeding her, too?

This preacher is admitting divorce of a wife who “isn’t working out for you” as a legal avenue to “avoid” adultery. Jesus said that Moses allowed a decree of divorce in response to hard-heartedness. This latest attempt falls (and fails) in the same category. It is a legalistic attempt at a dodge.
 
Maybe he has Alzheimer’s? If not, sounds like something his wife might want to address. 😉
That was my thought when I saw this, you have to wonder if something’s going on with him to take a position so opposed to the Word of God.
 
I too am a former Protestant.Because he made such an heartless comment,I do think the poor old soul bless his heart,may have a touch of Alzheimers himself.You will be in my prayers tonight Pat that you may have a change of heart and soul.Does Pat think that as we get old and our minds deteriate that we should just be thrown away as if we are are rag:shrug: dolls.
I hope you are not suggesting that Alzheimer’s changes a person’s personality, or their morals.

Someone with Alzheimer’s who is cranky did not become cranky when they got the condition, they were cranky before, but now they may be showing this aspect of their personality more.

In the same way, Pat may just be showing what he really thinks of marriage - not something to be faithful to “in sickness and in health”, etc., but a matter of personal convenience.

People with Alzheimer’s are not dead. They are still human beings with dignity and rights who have an even greater need for love and care from their spouses.

The advice given by that man is disgusting.
 
I hope you are not suggesting that Alzheimer’s changes a person’s personality, or their morals.

Someone with Alzheimer’s who is cranky did not become cranky when they got the condition, they were cranky before, but now they may be showing this aspect of their personality more.
I’m not sure I agree with what you are saying here. People with alzheimer’s DO sometimes change in their personalities and in their morals, depending on the course of the disease and which area of the brain is being most affected. Not everyone is affected in this way, but some are. And Alzheimer’s diminishes the mental capabilities of the person–so that their ability to make sound moral choices does sometimes change. Yes, I suppose it could be argued that all their behavior is latent in the brain and comes out when all inhibitions are gone. But that’s true of everybody on the planet.

But In Alzheimer’s, when those brain synapses aren’t connecting anymore, the person changes. This is the sad, tragic fact of the disease. You can see the same type of thing in people with traumatic brain injury. In many such cases, the personality DOES change, because the brain has changed.

In fact, there are some people with the disease who experience a “happy” transformation–they were cranky when they were younger and the dementia makes them more peaceful, docile and happy…it can go both ways…but most often, it goes the other direction…

That said, Alzheimer’s does not change the WORTH of the human person, or the sancitity of the marriage vows. IMHO, “for better or worse” “in sickness and in health”–if those words don’t apply to the couple affected by Alzheimer’s then to whom do they apply?!
 
This is very true. I have witnessed it in several family members who died of Alzheimer’s. When filters are gone or damaged, people do and say things they would never have dreamed of doing or saying before. It is not a sign that they were always cranky or disagreeable. It is unfortunately the reality of how brain disease/damage works. There are so many studies now on Alzheimer’s and those with traumatic brain damage that show that personality, impulse control, the ability to think ahead are all affected.

Edited to add: I also agree that a person’s worth and the sanctity of the marriage vows are NOT changed by whatever disease, injury, or circumstances.
I’m not sure I agree with what you are saying here. People with alzheimer’s DO sometimes change in their personalities and in their morals, depending on the course of the disease and which area of the brain is being most affected. Not everyone is affected in this way, but some are. And Alzheimer’s diminishes the mental capabilities of the person–so that their ability to make sound moral choices does sometimes change. Yes, I suppose it could be argued that all their behavior is latent in the brain and comes out when all inhibitions are gone. But that’s true of everybody on the planet.

But In Alzheimer’s, when those brain synapses aren’t connecting anymore, the person changes. This is the sad, tragic fact of the disease. You can see the same type of thing in people with traumatic brain injury. In many such cases, the personality DOES change, because the brain has changed.

In fact, there are some people with the disease who experience a “happy” transformation–they were cranky when they were younger and the dementia makes them more peaceful, docile and happy…it can go both ways…but most often, it goes the other direction…

That said, Alzheimer’s does not change the WORTH of the human person, or the sancitity of the marriage vows. IMHO, “for better or worse” “in sickness and in health”–if those words don’t apply to the couple affected by Alzheimer’s then to whom do they apply?!
 
I hope you are not suggesting that Alzheimer’s changes a person’s personality, or their morals.

Someone with Alzheimer’s who is cranky did not become cranky when they got the condition, they were cranky before, but now they may be showing this aspect of their personality more.

In the same way, Pat may just be showing what he really thinks of marriage - not something to be faithful to “in sickness and in health”, etc., but a matter of personal convenience.

People with Alzheimer’s are not dead. They are still human beings with dignity and rights who have an even greater need for love and care from their spouses.

The advice given by that man is disgusting.
I made the remark re. possibility of Robertson having Alzheimer’s with the 😉 Can’t we lighten up a little? The man is 87 yrs. of age. Certainly a possibility which makes it more daft that he’d make such a statement.
And Alzheimer’s does change the way a person thinks and acts. Took care of one who had it.
Sandra Day O’Connor’s husband, who suffers from Alzheimer’s, fell in love with another woman in his facility. He no longer knew O’Connor. She just let them be. In the misty land where he lived, he was happy and had someone.
 
I made the remark re. possibility of Robertson having Alzheimer’s with the 😉 Can’t we lighten up a little? The man is 87 yrs. of age. Certainly a possibility which makes it more daft that he’d make such a statement.
And Alzheimer’s does change the way a person thinks and acts. Took care of one who had it.
Sandra Day O’Connor’s husband, who suffers from Alzheimer’s, fell in love with another woman in his facility. He no longer knew O’Connor. She just let them be. In the misty land where he lived, he was happy and had someone.
This disease is tuff…I have worked with these people. But they need to do something about Robertson making off the wall statements like that. I realize he is 87, probably a contributing factor, but he is making this misleading statement for people to grab onto…not good. I’d say they’d better consider talking him into retiring. It seems to be time.
 
I hope you are not suggesting that Alzheimer’s changes a person’s personality, or their morals.

Someone with Alzheimer’s who is cranky did not become cranky when they got the condition, they were cranky before, but now they may be showing this aspect of their personality more.

In the same way, Pat may just be showing what he really thinks of marriage - not something to be faithful to “in sickness and in health”, etc., but a matter of personal convenience.

People with Alzheimer’s are not dead. They are still human beings with dignity and rights who have an even greater need for love and care from their spouses.

The advice given by that man is disgusting.
No I did not say it the way you have taken it.It is shocking that Mr.Robertson iin the first place would say such a thing to begin with.But my Grandfather did have it.And it did change his dispoition.He went from a very nice man to a mean man.He went from a moral man to where he did not know what he was doing and thought I was my grandmother and tried to touch me inaproperately.Their mind eventually does go.So yes the diease will change them.It definately can change ones being in many ways.Is it their fault ,no.They cannot help themselves.I did not judge my grandfather,It was the disease.Blessings
 
I hope you are not suggesting that Alzheimer’s changes a person’s personality, or their morals.

Someone with Alzheimer’s who is cranky did not become cranky when they got the condition, they were cranky before, but now they may be showing this aspect of their personality more.
Actually, it can and does change a person’s personality. Years ago a friend’s father was diagnosed with Alzheimers. Before, he was the kindest, gentlest, nicest man. He treated his wife very well. As the disease progressed, he became violent and struck out at people, including his wife. He tried to set his house on fire. He threw things at people.
 
I hope you are not suggesting that Alzheimer’s changes a person’s personality, or their morals.

Someone with Alzheimer’s who is cranky did not become cranky when they got the condition, they were cranky before, but now they may be showing this aspect of their personality more.
This is completely untrue. My best friend’s mom had Alzheimer’s. She was a very religious woman. As the illness progressed she began using all kinds of foul language that her children had never once in their lives ever heard their mother utter. She would also become violent, kicking (or trying to) her young grandchildren at times. I knew this woman since I was 12. She was not cranky, she was not mean, and she never cursed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top