Divorce rates

  • Thread starter Thread starter MaryandJoseph
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MaryandJoseph

Guest
I am in a discussion with an atheist relative who says that Christians divorce at a higher rate than atheists do. I am trying to find stats on this but can only find then in atheist or Christian sites, not neutral ones. Looking for some help please.
 
Be sure and inquire where they are getting their information as well…
 
It wouldn’t surprise me if the atheist rate was higher, nominally speaking. What they should do is break out the data between devout Christians, soft Christians, and atheists. It still wouldn’t tell you a great deal, but certainly more to read from the data.
 
I thought I’d read a while back that, statistically speaking, there wasn’t any real difference in the divorce rate among atheists and Christians in America. It was a mainstream news source (I don’t recall which), so the veracity/lack of bias could likely be called into question (most mainstream sources still cite the fallacious 50% divorce rate as fact). There was also an article linked to somewhere on here a while back about the divorce rate among Catholics being much lower than other groups. The only problem with that is that the author kept qualifying what they viewed as Catholics, breaking them up into non-practicing Catholics, practicing Catholics, and “real” practicing Catholics (in other words, the subset of a subset that met the author’s definition of what a “real” Catholic should be). It took most if not all the steam out of the author’s argument.

I’d imagine that Christians at least account for a high number of divorces, if not a higher divorce rate, since they’re more likely to get married than non-believers.

**Edited to add: I should point out that the last statement was based on anecdotal and observational evidence. The vast majority of my atheist friends choose to live together versus getting married, which is also what I’ve been told by multiple friends.
 
I have never heard a satisfactory answer as to how divorce rates are calculated. I have even asked an epidemiologist who specializes in these sorts of statistics and couldn’t get a straight answer.

Consider: some people divorce after 2 years while others after 25 years and everything in between. Some people get divorced and remarried 3 times within the span of 5 years. The only reasonable way to present the data would be likelihood of divorce per year.

The only real way to collect this data is follow a (very large) cohort of married individuals for 50 years and plot when they get divorced. To my knowledge this has never been done. Can someone enlighten me?
 
The only real way to collect this data is follow a (very large) cohort of married individuals for 50 years and plot when they get divorced. To my knowledge this has never been done. Can someone enlighten me?
Although this isn’t quite what you’re looking for, there was a study that came out a few months ago that talked about the likelihood of divorce after xx years of marriage. If I remember right, it stated that something like 70-75% of marriages that do end in divorce do so in the first 10 years of marriage (it may have been 7 years). In other words, once you make it past that point, you’re much less likely to ever get a divorce. I think it broke down other years, but I forget the particulars. I did like the fact that it put at least a somewhat positive spin on longer lasting marriages.
 
I know the “divorce rate” (as commonly cited) is literally a ratio of the number of divorces to the number of a marriages in a given year. If 100 couples got married one year, and 50 separate couples got divorced, that would give you a 50% divorce rate.

The mistake that’s often made is people take that number and start assuming it means that half of all marriages end in divorce.
 
The “divorce rate” for atheists is 21%, and for Catholics is 21%, for Mormons it’s 24% and Protestants are somewhere in the middle. Most people here in the USA think of “Christian” as Protestant Christians, i.e. Catholics are a separate group. But if your friend was indeed referring to Protestants then it is true that the atheists have a lower divorce rate.

But atheists also have high rates of cohabitation, not getting married at all for various reasons (some think marriage is a form of slavery), and they split up all the time. Of course those aren’t counted, because they aren’t marriages.

However for Catholics who practice NFP (as opposed to ABC) it’s <2% according to one study and <1% according to another.
 
I’ve been trying to find some better data and actual reports. I’ve found a lot of contradictory stuff, and links to reports that don’t answer the questions that the link says they’re going to answer.

One thing I did find was a divorce calculator. According to that, I have a 4% chance of my marriage ending in the next 5 years. It’s only based on 4-5 questions, and leaves out things like if you have kids or lived together before marriage, so I’m sure it’s accurate. :rolleyes:

I did find this quote: “Marriages are most susceptible to divorce in the early years of marriage. After 5 years, approximately 10 % of marriages are expected to end in divorce - another 10 % (or 20 % cumulatively) are divorced by about the tenth year after marriage. However, the 30% level is not reached until about the 18th year after marriage while the 40% level is only approached by the 50th year after marriage.” That seems to indicate to me that the secret to a long marriage is to stay married longer.

I found this as well: “For the year 2002: of the 56,236 ordinary hearings for a declaration of
nullity, 46,092 received an affirmative sentence. Of these, 343 were handed out in Africa, 676 in Oceania, 1,562 in Asia, 8,855 in Europe and 36,656 in America, of which 30,968 in North America and 5,688 in Central and South America.” It doesn’t really say how that plays into the divorce rate.

Here’s something that may be just what the OP was looking for, taken from here:
Those of us interested in divorce stats know that everyone slices the data
up idiosyncratically, making it difficult to compare one summary to another.
However, having said that, according to one Gallup report (1) 10% of
Protestants and 10% of Catholics are divorced and (2) 26% of Protestants and
23% of Catholics have been divorced at some point.
And, while I couldn’t put my hands on the report right at the moment, Barna
reports that something like 26-27% of Christians identifying themselves as
“born again” have been divorced.
–snip–
My quest at the moment is to track down a 1980 report which suggested that,
at that time, those who attend church regularly together, pray together
regularly, and read the Bible together regularly have a <1% divorce rate!!
I am planning an updated examination of that alleged report; but first I
need to find the original.
In a related finding, Greeley (1991) reported that only 1% of those who pray
together regularly and report a high quality sexual relationship “think that
divorce is possible” for them. Thus, there is some suggestive evidence that
if we get beyond labels to behaviors (and possibly underlying strongly-held
faith beliefs) we may begin to find some “inoculating” factors against divorce.*
Hope that helps!
 
I know the “divorce rate” (as commonly cited) is literally a ratio of the number of divorces to the number of a marriages in a given year. If 100 couples got married one year, and 50 separate couples got divorced, that would give you a 50% divorce rate.

The mistake that’s often made is people take that number and start assuming it means that half of all marriages end in divorce.
This is exactly the problem. People assume that a 50% divorce rate means that 1:2 marriages end in divorce at some point, which is not true at all. Its very complicated.
 
I did find this quote: “Marriages are most susceptible to divorce in the early years of marriage. After 5 years, approximately 10 % of marriages are expected to end in divorce - another 10 % (or 20 % cumulatively) are divorced by about the tenth year after marriage. However, the 30% level is not reached until about the 18th year after marriage while the 40% level is only approached by the 50th year after marriage.” That seems to indicate to me that the secret to a long marriage is to stay married longer.
Where did you find this quote?
 
I’ve been trying to find some better data and actual reports. I’ve found a lot of contradictory stuff, and links to reports that don’t answer the questions that the link says they’re going to answer.

One thing I did find was a divorce calculator. According to that, I have a 4% chance of my marriage ending in the next 5 years. It’s only based on 4-5 questions, and leaves out things like if you have kids or lived together before marriage, so I’m sure it’s accurate. :rolleyes:

I did find this quote: “Marriages are most susceptible to divorce in the early years of marriage. After 5 years, approximately 10 % of marriages are expected to end in divorce - another 10 % (or 20 % cumulatively) are divorced by about the tenth year after marriage. However, the 30% level is not reached until about the 18th year after marriage while the 40% level is only approached by the 50th year after marriage.” That seems to indicate to me that the secret to a long marriage is to stay married longer.

I found this as well: “For the year 2002: of the 56,236 ordinary hearings for a declaration of
nullity, 46,092 received an affirmative sentence. Of these, 343 were handed out in Africa, 676 in Oceania, 1,562 in Asia, 8,855 in Europe and 36,656 in America, of which 30,968 in North America and 5,688 in Central and South America.” It doesn’t really say how that plays into the divorce rate.

Here’s something that may be just what the OP was looking for, taken from here:

Hope that helps!
So, I played around with that calculator and it’s unbelievable what a role children play on the divorce rate. I used the same data as female only changing whether I had children or not and was shocked to see that a high school dropout, who got married at19-20 and has children has a MUCH lower divorce rate than one in the same boat but without children and even a college graduate who got married at 27-30 and has no children.

I don’t know where I read it but couples are most likely to divorce in the first 3 years, then the next 4 and the next big curve is after 20 years ( when the children are grown)
 
So, I played around with that calculator and it’s unbelievable what a role children play on the divorce rate. I used the same data as female only changing whether I had children or not and was shocked to see that a high school dropout, who got married at19-20 and has children has a MUCH lower divorce rate than one in the same boat but without children and even a college graduate who got married at 27-30 and has no children.

I don’t know where I read it but couples are most likely to divorce in the first 3 years, then the next 4 and the next big curve is after 20 years ( when the children are grown)
That’s interesting. I was only making calculations based on myself, so I didn’t see that if you choose female, you get the options of kids or not. I guess having kids isn’t as big a factor on men when it comes to divorce.
 
If more Christians marry than atheists and 50% of all marriages end in divorce than there will be more Christian divorces because there are more Christian marriages.

In England the divorce rate has fallen because the marriage rate has fallen.

In England many people may refer to themselves as Christian who aren’t, they see England and Christian as the same.

An example would be, somebody who is not a Christian will get married in a church and have their children christened even though they don’t believe in God.

What if a Christian marries an atheista dn it ends in divorce, which statistic would it end up in?

What if two Christians marry but one becomes an atheist before divorce, which statistic would that end up in?
 
I am thankful for all who have responded, but have come to the conclusion that this is a question that will be almost impossible to answer with any neutral stats.

From everything I have read though, it seems that Catholics (and most HIGH churches) and Atheists have about the same divorce rate while the protestant Christians (low church) seem to have higher numbers.
 
Now that I’ve had half a day or so to think it over, I have to make a comment about the article I mentioned before, whose author kept talking about the divorce rate among “real” Catholics. The one quote I posted actually backed up what that author had stated. In other words, if you want to define “real Catholics” (or “real Christians”) as those who attend Mass and pray together regularly, then the divorce rate potentially drops to under 1%. So while one of the studies mentioned in that quote is hearsay (the author couldn’t locate the original study), the other part of the quote references an actual study that at least partially backs it up (the one that concerns couples who pray together and have a good sex life). I’m not sure where stephe1987’s numbers came from, but the numbers I found would seem to indicate that Christians overall have a lower divorce rate (someone has to be making up the difference between the 10-27% and the overall 46-50% divorce rate), while active, practicing Christians who make their religion a daily part of their life have an extremely low divorce rate.
 
I’ve been trying to find some better data and actual reports. I’ve found a lot of contradictory stuff, and links to reports that don’t answer the questions that the link says they’re going to answer.

One thing I did find was a divorce calculator. According to that, I have a 4% chance of my marriage ending in the next 5 years. It’s only based on 4-5 questions, and leaves out things like if you have kids or lived together before marriage, so I’m sure it’s accurate. :rolleyes:

I did find this quote: “Marriages are most susceptible to divorce in the early years of marriage. After 5 years, approximately 10 % of marriages are expected to end in divorce - another 10 % (or 20 % cumulatively) are divorced by about the tenth year after marriage. However, the 30% level is not reached until about the 18th year after marriage while the 40% level is only approached by the 50th year after marriage.” That seems to indicate to me that the secret to a long marriage is to stay married longer.

I found this as well: “For the year 2002: of the 56,236 ordinary hearings for a declaration of
nullity, 46,092 received an affirmative sentence. Of these, 343 were handed out in Africa, 676 in Oceania, 1,562 in Asia, 8,855 in Europe and 36,656 in America, of which 30,968 in North America and 5,688 in Central and South America.” It doesn’t really say how that plays into the divorce rate.

Here’s something that may be just what the OP was looking for, taken from here:

Hope that helps!
4% is a great. Mine was 28% and I have been married 20 years. It goes to 17% if I was married at 29 instead of 24 years old. I can still see the risk of divorce in my group. Once the kids grow up some couples get divorced.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top