Do angels in Heaven have a free will as Satan did when he was kicked out of Heaven

  • Thread starter Thread starter flower_lady
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

flower_lady

Guest
If Satan was kicked out of Heaven because of his ego and vanity thinking he could be equal to God, then God must have given him a free will just as he has given us here on earth. My question is, after we die and those of us who are fortunate enough to be able to get to Heaven have a free will in Heaven as we do down here on earth? If so is it possible for angels or saints to be kicked out of Heaven or is it possible for us to do wrong after we enter into the Kingdom of God. Or are we automatically perfect when we go to Heaven and are no longer capable of sin?
 
If Satan was kicked out of Heaven because of his ego and vanity thinking he could be equal to God, then God must have given him a free will just as he has given us here on earth. My question is, after we die and those of us who are fortunate enough to be able to get to Heaven have a free will in Heaven as we do down here on earth? If so is it possible for angels or saints to be kicked out of Heaven or is it possible for us to do wrong after we enter into the Kingdom of God. Or are we automatically perfect when we go to Heaven and are no longer capable of sin?
Great question, and the answer is Nobody alive knows. We will all find out when we die what happens.
 
If Satan was kicked out of Heaven because of his ego and vanity thinking he could be equal to God, then God must have given him a free will just as he has given us here on earth. My question is, after we die and those of us who are fortunate enough to be able to get to Heaven have a free will in Heaven as we do down here on earth? If so is it possible for angels or saints to be kicked out of Heaven or is it possible for us to do wrong after we enter into the Kingdom of God. Or are we automatically perfect when we go to Heaven and are no longer capable of sin?
We are perfect when we go to heaven and are no longer capable of sin. God bless you.
 
Angels have a different type of will than ours. They are much higher beings, pure spirit and intellect, and they are outside time and space. They were without sin and had uncompromised knowledge and thoughts. All the angels made a one-time, permanent act of their will to choose to follow God or not. Satan and 1/3 of the angels made a permanent choice to form their will against God. That is why there will never be a point where satan or the demons (who are fallen angels) will change their will or mind. They have chosen permanently and eternally to sin against God.

Human beings are much different. We are a lower creature than them. Our wills are not permanent while here on earth. We have the opportunity and ability to change our wills and repent and bring out will in line with Go, or to make an act of the will and sin against Him. We may do this many many times in both directions. Our lives are building up to when we die. At our death, our wills will become fixed at that moment, and if it is aligned with God we will be with Him forever. If we have aligned it against Him, it will forever be against Him.

So if you align your will to God, go to Confession, recieve the Eucharist, perform the good works He has laid in front of you, you will go to Heaven. When you do, you will will be forever fixed toward Him.
 
According to St. Thomas Aquinas, the angels decided at the moment of their creation whether they would serve God or not. Not after this. So the fact of the rebellion of the angels doesn’t really lead to the idea that those in heaven could sin or lose heaven. Catholicism insists that those in heaven are there forever.
 
Angels got tested once and the ones that passed are in heaven, the rest, we all know the answer. The angels in heaven in the present are no longer tested as well as the saints. If there were to be more tests in heaven after humans get in, then heaven would definitely be hell. Jesus went to heaven to prepare a place for us where there is no more tears, fears, sadness etc, etc… This last part is in the Gospels!!!
 
Those who see the Beatific Vision (saints in heaven, angels who chose to serve God), see the Good with a capital G. In this life, our free will presents to us various small goods with lowercase g’s (“apparent goods”) and, informed by our intellect, we “move” our will toward whichever we think will make us happiest. All the while, we are, in a sense, in the dark about what will make us absolutely and truly happy. We can’t fully apprehend the final end of our choices – the Good with a capital G – because we can’t see it. However, once it has been presented to us in its definitive form, in the beatific vision, our will both *cannot *and would not want to choose otherwise. The function of the will is to choose the Good. The Good is directly in front of the will. So there is nowhere else to go. We experience complete satiety, complete happiness, no lack of anything that would be required for our complete joy. This is the case for everyone who has chosen, based on trust in God (faith) and confidence in his promises (hope) to love him by obeying his commandments and loving his children (charity). For the angels, as has been said above, the beatific vision was not immediately presented to them. They were given some knowledge (we don’t know exactly what) and therefore a choice to serve God. Some, Lucifer the first among them, said, "Non serviam." They made their choice based on pride (an unwillingness to trust in God).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top