Do Catholics believe Protestants are going to hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Malia_Belen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Do Catholics believe that Protestants are going to hell?

We Catholics don’t presume to judge for God but in our knowledge of how Holy God calls us each to be we do tend to worry a lot – even when we know that worry is not a work of grace that merits us anything. So instead we try hard to cooperate with Grace and we pray a LOT for Protestants – that is a work of Grace and an act of charity that benefits all of God’s Children. And we also tremble inwardly a lot when we observe God working within each of us and know its all very real and very personal.
👍 The true Catholic heart & mind, forged from faith & reason … this is what all informed Catholic saints believe and need proclaim to the Protestants that God brings here in search of his true Church.
 
The odds of anyone other than Catholics being saved can’t be that good based on their “gravely deficient” condition.
This speaks to objective deficiencies, not to whether particular subjects can or will be saved.
 
Any Catholics here who really think Billy Graham [Protestant, Lordship Salvation Theology Evangelist] … won’t sit ‘at table’ with Christ in Heaven ?

He’s got the WORKS, that Catholics so admire & preach. St. James would sure welcome him … I would think.
 
The Catholic Church does recognize that Protestants have a partially valid relationship with Christ. Still, I’d like to hear an official response from a authoritative source in the RCC on this.

I will say that, if this interpretation is true, the RCC needs to become much more active in evangelical activities to bring errant Christians back into the fold. They need to be sending all their vast resources out into the mission field – leadership and laity. It is their sacred duty to try and rescue as many souls as possible from Hell. You aren’t a “compassionate” worry-wart if all you do is worry; compassion is only evident through activity. At least from my perspective as a Protestant, the Catholic Church doesn’t really try very hard to explain why to people and bring them back into the RCC. I’ve never personally been approached by the RCC and have never heard of an active outreach program run by the RCC. It may be there but it is awful quiet.

.
Would seem that perhaps a majority of Priests & even some Bishops believe our Protestant brethren of sincere faith will not be rejected by our Lord. I’ve spoken to a number of Priests & one Bishop about this matter … and they all told me that Protestants with Trinitarian Baptism, who preservere IN CHRIST will find the mercy of God.
 
No Catholic believes that all Protestants go to hell because that would deny the power and the discretion of God and limit Him only to the sacraments. But God gave us The Catholic Church and the sacraments for our benefit and NOT for the purpose of condeming anyone to hell. But we Catholics DO believe that the NORMATIVE way to gain salvation and eternal beatitude AND be ALL that God calls us to be and to receive our highest heavenly reward is to be in full life long communion with the Catholic Church and her teachings.

My second caution is that those who are imperfectly joined to the Catholic Church (esp. Protestants but also poorly catechized Catholics) are in grave danger of falling out of grace since they do not have the benefit of the sacraments nor the full apostolic teachings so necessary to form their consciences.

The going away message I would leave here is that the spiritual risk of remaining in an estranged or poorly developed communion with the Catholic Church (e.g. only via original baptism without benefit of Eucharist and the sacrament of repentance and full moral teaching etc.) is to fall away, become “disgraced” and not gain salvation at all. All it takes is as single grave sin and failure to repent each and every time one sins. No one is saved by a presumption of Mercy or by mere belief that one is saved. One is saved only by sanctifying grace which can only be know definitively by divine revelation, or by signal grace or by regular exercise of the Church’s sacraments (esp. sacrament of repentance and eucharist) and the Catholic disciplines.

Bottom line - all grace comes through Christ through the Catholic Church and none can escape salvation without grace and staying in grace. It is very difficult but not entirely impossible to remain in grace without being a formal and practising Catholic. The many and diverse Protestant “Faith Communities” have certain limited aspects of Christianity since they all derived from the Catholic Church but are ALL deficient, disordered and wounded in their separation and are hurting themselves by remaining estranged.
Having graduated from Free Grace … to Lordship Salvation … to Catholicism ---- this really is a special explanation of why the Church so essential for all believers & especially those with Prodigal Son/Daughter tendencies.
 
[SIGN][/SIGN]
Hey, no one is forcing you to believe the Gospel. You choose to believe and follow your hierarchy and that is your business; let them take you where they will. As for me, I will follow Christ.

BTW, when and where was this “teaching authority” established? Who are they and how do you know they are teaching you the truth? [SIGN]I mean if the Bible isn’t that important, what do you have to go by?
[/SIGN]

Tradition and teachng’s of the Early Fathers of the Church. BTW where do you think the bible came from. Did you think that the Apostles started out with the Bible? You need to take some time and study history and find out WHEN and WHERE the bible came from. Then you will understand the church.
 
Any Catholics here who really think Billy Graham [Protestant, Lordship Salvation Theology Evangelist] … won’t sit ‘at table’ with Christ in Heaven ?

He’s got the WORKS, that Catholics so admire & preach. St. James would sure welcome him …
SIGN]I would think.
[/SIGN] But we do not know. We cannot say who is getting in as well as who is not! While I admire him I really do not know his heart. Only God truly knows that. While I can judge his works on the outside because I have seen them I would bet odds on him to enter the kingdom.

But as we both know according to the teachings of the Lord only he knows the true story. Just like we can judge someones works on the outside to be unworthy. See what I mean.

We all have special Grace to do certain things from God. Not all are called to preach, etc. Yes he was given a special calling from God to do Gods work. But the Grace was given to him from God.

Just like person who is rich, to us they can be considered a success in life! But are they. Who is the biggest success the person who is rich and helps others for a tax write off. Or the person who is poor and has one loaf of bread. But everyone gets a slice? God knows the whole story. Thats my point. We cannot judege one worthy as well as cannot judge one unworthy.

But we do know that one who lives for Christ and does his work the best they can did indeed fill that obligation and will get in.

We know as Catholic’s that the Pope has the keys to the kingdom because the bible tells us so. But with those keys he is given the knowledge to share with us faith and morals. He was given a huge responsibility because God put him in charge of our souls. So every teaching he gives he is held responsible for from God. Personally he is my hero in this world. Just like Billy Graham are others. Who will be made more worthy in Gods eyes. Simple Ask God. I know who I would pick, but it does not matter. And whos to say it even matters. The point is as RC we know what we must do according to our faith.

If you are RC you are to do what the Pope says. You must have enough faith in God and realize he made you a RC for a reason and be the best RC that you can.

Same with a Protestant if they feel they are where God is putting them and they are living their faith to the best of their ability God knows that too. IF they follow the word of God to the best of their ability they also will get in.

There is a big difference between knowing the difference and flat out rejecting Gods word, then not truly understanding it. We can only live by the Grace that is given to us. And pray for more and more Grace from God to accept and do what he is asking of us in this world.
 
And what mess would that be?
Tomster what I think that what he is saying is what my Mother always said to us.

You worry about your own sins, when you get done confessing them, you will not have time to worry about anyone elses.

That became the GOLDEN RULE in our house. Still is in my house now:D
 
Having graduated from Free Grace … to Lordship Salvation … to Catholicism ---- this really is a special explanation of why the Church so essential for all believers & especially those with Prodigal Son/Daughter tendencies.
But that is the point. You have been given that Grace from God to see what Catholicism really is. Not all have had that chance in life yet. All we can do is try to show and teach what has been given freely to us. And try to be good examples and live our faith.

Trust me I know, To live our faith is so much harder then understanding it and doing it. Trust me I know, I have failed much more on this site alone at being what I should probally then anyone. But I keep praying and asking God for Grace to get it right someday:D
 
Maybe you aught to worry about the mess your own house is in before you point the finger at others.
So, you want to talk about messes? Let’s !

The negative phase of Protestantism and its radical error are the claim that we do not believe with the mind. It might seem that Protestants who still profess Christian doctrine are united with Catholics on the character of faith. Both subscribe to the articles of the Creed, from believing in “God the Father Almighty” to “everlasting life.” In reality the difference is extreme. Catholics hold that faith is an assent of the intellect to accept on divine authority whatever truths God has revealed. Protestants, unless they surrender their own principles, claim that faith is primarily an act of the will - as trust, or love, or abandonment - without prior dependence on the mind. Their opinions on the nature of faith are fluid, and theories range over the whole field of psychology.

The consequences of this notion are far reaching. If faith is not necessarily submission of mind to objective truth, what difference does it make whether I believe that God has three Persons or One, whether He became incarnate in Christ or not, whether His presence in the Eucharist is real or merely symbolic? It makes no difference. I am just as good a Christian and equally on the road to salvation whether I profess, with Luther, that “after Adam’s sin man’s free will was wholly destroyed,” or say, with the Council of Trent which condemned Luther, that if anyone holds this doctrine 'let him be anathema."

In the final analysis the very possibility of affirming that certain propositions are true and necessary for salvation rests on the prior conviction that faith is something intellectual which can be formulated in statements and definitions, to which the mind can freely assent if it wants to. Deny this principle; call faith by whatever name you wish, but say it is not creedal or intellectual, and you reduce the Christian religion to what some investigators are agreed is the essence of Protestant thought: a feeling of dependence on a superior being, whose very existence may be called into doubt. “The proposal,” writes a sympathetic observer, “that religion may be sufficiently founded on feeling comes with too great promise of relief to be lightly dismissed. Grant it, and all dogmatic authority loses its pressure at once. We are set free to be religious beings without the infinite argument and haggling over unreachable and untestable propositions. Creeds we wave aside, or else, we carry them lightly, knowing that they are at one stroke disarmed, put out of conflict with truth as otherwise established.” (William Hocking - "The Meaning of God in Human Experience) The libertarian comfort which this brings to the natural man may explain, in part, the success which the Reformation had in winning so many people to its cause, and still has in retaining the fidelity of millions who would be offended if told their religion is only a shadow of the Catholic substance they have lost. Tasting the perfectly human pleasure of believing what they please, they have no idea of that deeper satisfaction which St. Paul promised to those who bring their mind into subjection to the obedience of Christ, who profess that faith is not feeling or pious sentiment but the acceptance, on the word of God, of things that are not seen.

cont.
 
Hey, no one is forcing you to believe the Gospel. You choose to believe and follow your hierarchy and that is your business; let them take you where they will. As for me, I will follow Christ.

BTW, when and where was this “teaching authority” established? Who are they and how do you know they are teaching you the truth? I mean if the Bible isn’t that important, what do you have to go by?
Brian your thoughts and words are a contradiction in motion. Change the words around and ask yourself:

When was the “teaching authority” of the bible establised?
Was it:

  • *] In 382 AD when Catholic Pope Damascus at the Council of Rome put forth the first official cannon to The Church?
    *]OVER A MILLENNIUM LATER in the 1520s when the Protestant Reformers arbitrarily self appointed themselves their own secular authority according to their own traditions of “because I will have it so” (viz Luther) to banish to 2nd class index reference7 important OT Deuterocanonical books out of the same Catholic Cannon they confiscated from the Catholic Church (and quite nearly elected to strip out 4 more New Testament books from the Catholic Antilegomena List * from the New Testament)?
    *]Was it in 1604 when newly crowned King James I grieving over the various warring Protestant factions (Church of England & Puritans) and general religious tension & dysfunction in Protestant England forced the competing factions to meet under The English King’s authority at the Hampton Court Conference to form a new ad-hoc Protestant Committee to agree on religious matters and to produce a new new Protestant Bible (KJV) that would remove all obnoxious “Catholic words” and form viz committe-action the official King’s version of " God’s Word" for His Kingdom?
    *]Was it in 1623 when the new ad-hoc “Protestant magisterium” of commercial “Bible Printing Companies” who decided all on their own in the “back office” to completely eviscerate the 7 previously deprecated (see B above) Deuterocanonical books from the index to save on printing and shipping costs and improve their business profits?
    *]None of the above - the bible itself NEVER Claims to be a teaching authority nor sufficient for salvation and declares The Church as the Pillar and Foundation of Truth.

    Can you be honest and rational?
    If you choose A then you admit that the Catholic Church has the original authority for recognizing the valid bible books and assembling the bible and is the one same church that still has the sole authority for bible and its interpretation but fail to grasp that the authority was given in apostolic times.

    If you choose B then you are saying that Christ’s Church was corrupted immediately after the resurrection, taken over by a renegade Catholic Church for 1500 years and against scripture that “The gates of hell DID prevail”. You means you think that Christianity is false and we can all go home and stop talking. Or you can say that the church did fail and Christianity is a lie but the Protestants just wanted to keep it alive as a convenient social structure to further their own power and control over society with a “nice” philosophy.

    If you choose C you have already discounted A and B. This means you are are an irrational Christian because you arbitrarily accept that secular Kings and rulers can invent, adapt and endorse any mythology they want to arrive at politically convenient “committe truths” to keep the peace. You believe that God works only through kings who are free to say and endorse what they choose as “practical truths”.

    If you choose D then you are a a mere “Cultural Christian” capitalist with a wounded natural morality that is repulsed by the idea that there is no objective truth but believe that its a valid economic principal to profit by other men’s foolishness.

    If you choose E you are wise in your correct assessment that authority does not reside in an inanimate book (especially when that book makes no claim to authority) but is divinely given from someone who previously had it. If you call yourself Christian then you must know that Authority comes from God through Jesus and is given to individually appointed men (the apostles) who in turn pass it on to their successors in a succession of authority. But you fail to admit that no one gave the Protestants any authority. As well, you don’t seem to want to admit that the true and original Christin Church is the Catholic Church and has been operating for 2,000 years in a continuously unbroken chain of passed down authority. The Catholic “apostolic succession” is a historical chain of bishops each hand selected by their predecessors, physically “laid on hands”, prayed over and apostolically blessed and ordained into that authority. Its irrefutable.

    [continued]

    James*
 
Maybe you aught to worry about the mess your own house is in before you point the finger at others.
If we trust the experience of mature converts, priority of feeling is the heart of the Protestant way of life. For Catholics it is almost a matter of indifference whether the soul realizes, in such a way as to visualize, the facts of revelation and the principles of the spiritual world; the point is that the will should adhere, and command the intellect to assent. But for Protestants, whose theology is fundamentally arbitrary, and among whom authority is really non-existent, it becomes natural to place the center of gravity in the emotions, and to mistake, as one of them put it, the imagination for the soul. The reason for them must be continually suppressed even in its own legitimate sphere; the will must be largely self-centered. And they have left only the experience of feeling as the realm in which their religion operates.

Catholics are generally baffled by one feature of Protestantism that is more easily described than defined: the evident tension that runs through the whole of Protestant culture, horizontally between successive stages in the church’s history, and vertically in every phase of their doctrine and ritual practice. It is more than a conflict between liberal and conservative elements that we may find in any institution, whether secular or religious. It is certainly deeper than the familiar difference betwen caution and the spirit of progress, which is healthy and normal wherever men of different temperments join together for a common cause. The tensionis nothing less than opposition between a “Catholic” and “Protestant” attitude in the denominations, and within the churches in their leaders and affiliated members.

Protestantism can be defined as a form of Christianity whose positive contents are derived from Catholicism, and whose basic error denies that faith is an assent of the mind to revelation. This is more than a statement of fact. It describes the final earmark of the Protestant religion: an interior conflict between fidelity to Christian tradition and autonomous self-sufficiency, whose consequences and attempted solution are a matter of common experience.

cont.
 
[from prior dialog]
40.png
Brian_Culliton:
Now in all answers that are not A or E ask yourself how rational is it to acknowledge the original Roman Catholic authority that writes and delivers the bible then arbitrarily later embrace one of the various “Johnny Come lately” German and English self appointed authorities who came to the party over a MILLENNIUM TOO LATE to save 100’s of millions of Christian souls before them? Do you think Jesus would turn his back on those who He promised He would never abandon? So Brian - Who is YOUR authority? Do you follow Rome, Germany (Wittenberg) or England (Canterbury) or perhaps Waco Texas? Do you follow Yourself? Don’t say “Christ” since He has already given His earthly Authority to The Apostles (Apostolic Succession) until He returns.

Sorry but you can’t hold your bible up as an authority without being forced to admit that you are infallable and without ignoring the profoundly embarrassing and shameful history of how the Protestant Bible came to you. What ever happened to that old Protestant judicial standard of “the WHOLE truth, and nothing but the truth so help you God”? The Protestant Bible is not the whole truth nor by evidence of the legion of Protestant factions a self-evident truth. Truth never divides and compromises itself into factions.

James
 
Hey, no one is forcing you to believe the Gospel. You choose to believe and follow your hierarchy and that is your business; let them take you where they will. As for me, I will follow Christ.

BTW, when and where was this “teaching authority” established? Who are they and how do you know they are teaching you the truth? I mean if the Bible isn’t that important, what do you have to go by?
Brian your thoughts and words are a contradiction in motion. Change the words around and ask yourself:

When was the “teaching authority” of the bible establised?
Was it:

  • *] In 382 AD when Catholic Pope Damascus at the Council of Rome put forth the first official cannon to The Church?
    *]OVER A MILLENNIUM LATER in the 1520s when the Protestant Reformers arbitrarily self appointed themselves their own secular authority according to their own traditions of “because I will have it so” (viz Luther) to banish to 2nd class index reference7 important OT Deuterocanonical books out of the same Catholic Cannon they confiscated from the Catholic Church (and quite nearly elected to strip out 4 more New Testament books from the Catholic Antilegomena List * from the New Testament)?
    *]Was it in 1604 when newly crowned King James I grieving over the various warring Protestant factions (Church of England & Puritans) and general religious tension & dysfunction in Protestant England forced the competing factions to meet under The English King’s authority at the Hampton Court Conference to form a new ad-hoc Protestant Committee to agree on religious matters and to produce a new new Protestant Bible (KJV) that would remove all obnoxious “Catholic words” and form viz committe-action the official King’s version of " God’s Word" for His Kingdom?
    *]Was it in 1623 when the new ad-hoc “Protestant magisterium” of commercial “Bible Printing Companies” who decided all on their own in the “back office” to completely eviscerate the 7 previously deprecated (see B above) Deuterocanonical books from the index to save on printing and shipping costs and improve their business profits?
    *]None of the above - the bible itself NEVER Claims to be a teaching authority nor sufficient for salvation and declares The Church as the Pillar and Foundation of Truth.

    Can you be honest and rational?
    If you choose A then you admit that the Catholic Church has the original authority for recognizing the valid bible books and assembling the bible and is the one same church that still has the sole authority for bible and its interpretation but fail to grasp that the authority was given in apostolic times.

    If you choose B then you are saying that Christ’s Church was corrupted immediately after the resurrection, taken over by a renegade Catholic Church for 1500 years and against scripture that “The gates of hell DID prevail”. You means you think that Christianity is false and we can all go home and stop talking. Or you can say that the church did fail and Christianity is a lie but the Protestants just wanted to keep it alive as a convenient social structure to further their own power and control over society with a “nice” philosophy.

    If you choose C you have already discounted A and B. This means you are are an irrational Christian because you arbitrarily accept that secular Kings and rulers can invent, adapt and endorse any mythology they want to arrive at politically convenient “committe truths” to keep the peace. You believe that God works only through kings who are free to say and endorse what they choose as “practical truths”.

    If you choose D then you are a a mere “Cultural Christian” capitalist with a wounded natural morality that is repulsed by the idea that there is no objective truth but believe that its a valid economic principal to profit by other men’s foolishness.

    If you choose E you are wise in your correct assessment that authority does not reside in an inanimate book (especially when that book makes no claim to authority) but is divinely given from someone who previously had it. If you call yourself Christian then you must know that Authority comes from God through Jesus and is given to individually appointed men (the apostles) who in turn pass it on to their successors in a succession of authority. But you fail to admit that no one gave the Protestants any authority. As well, you don’t seem to want to admit that the true and original Christin Church is the Catholic Church and has been operating for 2,000 years in a continuously unbroken chain of passed down authority. The Catholic “apostolic succession” is a historical chain of bishops each hand selected by their predecessors, physically “laid on hands”, prayed over and apostolically blessed and ordained into that authority. Its irrefutable.

    [continued]

    James*
 
Brian your thoughts and words are a contradiction in motion. Change the words around and ask yourself:

When was the “teaching authority” of the bible establised?
Was it:

  • *] In 382 AD when Catholic Pope Damascus at the Council of Rome put forth the first official cannon to The Church?
    *]OVER A MILLENNIUM LATER in the 1520s when the Protestant Reformers arbitrarily self appointed themselves their own secular authority according to their own traditions of “because I will have it so” (viz Luther) to banish to 2nd class index reference7 important OT Deuterocanonical books out of the same Catholic Cannon they confiscated from the Catholic Church (and quite nearly elected to strip out 4 more New Testament books from the Catholic Antilegomena List * from the New Testament)?
    ]Was it in 1604 when newly crowned King James I grieving over the various warring Protestant factions (Church of England & Puritans) and general religious tension & dysfunction in Protestant England forced the competing factions to meet under The English King’s authority at the Hampton Court Conference to form a new ad-hoc Protestant Committee to agree on religious matters and to produce a new new Protestant Bible (KJV) that would remove all obnoxious “Catholic words” and form viz committe-action the official King’s version of " God’s Word" for His Kingdom?
    *]Was it in 1623 when the new ad-hoc “Protestant magisterium” of commercial “Bible Printing Companies” who decided all on their own in the “back office” to completely eviscerate the 7 previously deprecated (see B above) Deuterocanonical books from the index to save on printing and shipping costs and improve their business profits?
    *]None of the above - the bible itself NEVER Claims to be a teaching authority nor sufficient for salvation and declares The Church as the Pillar and Foundation of Truth.

    Can you be honest and rational?
    If you choose A then you admit that the Catholic Church has the original authority for recognizing the valid bible books and assembling the bible and is the one same church that still has the sole authority for bible and its interpretation but fail to grasp that the authority was given in apostolic times.

    If you choose B then you are saying that Christ’s Church was corrupted immediately after the resurrection, taken over by a renegade Catholic Church for 1500 years and against scripture that “The gates of hell DID prevail”. You means you think that Christianity is false and we can all go home and stop talking. Or you can say that the church did fail and Christianity is a lie but the Protestants just wanted to keep it alive as a convenient social structure to further their own power and control over society with a “nice” philosophy.

    If you choose C you have already discounted A and B. This means you are are an irrational Christian because you arbitrarily accept that secular Kings and rulers can invent, adapt and endorse any mythology they want to arrive at politically convenient “committe truths” to keep the peace. You believe that God works only through kings who are free to say and endorse what they choose as “practical truths”.

    If you choose D then you are a a mere “Cultural Christian” capitalist with a wounded natural morality that is repulsed by the idea that there is no objective truth but believe that its a valid economic principal to profit by other men’s foolishness.

    If you choose E you are wise in your correct assessment that authority does not reside in an inanimate book (especially when that book makes no claim to authority) but is divinely given from someone who previously had it. If you call yourself Christian then you must know that Authority comes from God through Jesus and is given to individually appointed men (the apostles) who in turn pass it on to their successors in a succession of authority. But you fail to admit that no one gave the Protestants any authority. As well, you don’t seem to want to admit that the true and original Christin Church is the Catholic Church and has been operating for 2,000 years in a continuously unbroken chain of passed down authority. The Catholic “apostolic succession” is a historical chain of bishops each hand selected by their predecessors, physically “laid on hands”, prayed over and apostolically blessed and ordained into that authority. Its irrefutable.

    [continued]

    James

    James, you have asked Brian if he can be honest and rational. I have no doubt that he can be honest. As far as being rational, my previous two posts will show that Protestantism will not allow him to be so.
​
 
Hey, no one is forcing you to believe the Gospel. You choose to believe and follow your hierarchy and that is your business; let them take you where they will. As for me, I will follow Christ.

BTW, when and where was this “teaching authority” established? Who are they and how do you know they are teaching you the truth? I mean if the Bible isn’t that important, what do you have to go by?
Brian your thoughts and words are a contradiction in motion. Change the words around and ask yourself:

When was the “teaching authority” of the bible establised?
Was it:

  • *] In 382 AD when Catholic Pope Damascus at the Council of Rome put forth the first official cannon to The Church?
    *]OVER A MILLENNIUM LATER in the 1520s when the Protestant Reformers arbitrarily self appointed themselves their own secular authority according to their own traditions of “because I will have it so” (viz Luther) to banish to 2nd class index reference 7 important OT Deuterocanonical books out of the same Catholic Cannon they confiscated from the Catholic Church (and quite nearly elected to strip out 4 more New Testament books from the Catholic Antilegomena List * from the New Testament)?
    *]Was it in 1604 when newly crowned King James I grieving over the various warring Protestant factions (Church of England & Puritans) and general religious tension & dysfunction in Protestant England forced the competing factions to meet under The English King’s authority at the Hampton Court Conference to form a new ad-hoc Protestant Committee to agree on religious matters and to produce a new new Protestant Bible (KJV) that would remove all obnoxious “Catholic words” and form viz committe-action the official King’s version of " God’s Word" for His Kingdom?
    *]Was it in 1623 when the new ad-hoc “Protestant magisterium” of commercial “Bible Printing Companies” who decided all on their own in the “back office” to completely eviscerate the 7 previously deprecated (see B above) Deuterocanonical books from the index to save on printing and shipping costs and improve their business profits?
    *]None of the above - the bible itself NEVER Claims to be a teaching authority nor sufficient for salvation and declares The Church as the Pillar and Foundation of Truth.

    Can you be honest and rational?
    If you choose A then you admit that the Catholic Church has the original authority for recognizing the valid bible books and assembling the bible and is the one same church that still has the sole authority for bible and its interpretation but fail to grasp that the authority was given in apostolic times.

    If you choose B then you are saying that Christ’s Church was corrupted immediately after the resurrection, taken over by a renegade Catholic Church for 1500 years and against scripture that “The gates of hell DID prevail”. It means you think that Christianity is false and we can all go home and stop talking. Or you can say that the church did fail and Christianity is a lie but the Protestants just wanted to keep it alive as a convenient social structure to further their own power and control over society with a “nice” philosophy.

    If you choose C you have already discounted A and B. This means you are are an irrational Christian because you arbitrarily accept that secular Kings and rulers can invent, adapt and endorse any mythology they want to arrive at politically convenient “committe truths” to keep the peace. You believe that God works only through kings who are free to say and endorse what they choose as “practical truths”.

    If you choose D then you are a a mere “Cultural Christian” capitalist with a wounded natural morality that is repulsed by the idea that there is no objective truth but believe that its a valid economic principal to profit by other men’s foolishness.

    If you choose E you are wise in your correct assessment that authority does not reside in an inanimate book (especially when that book makes no claim to authority) but is divinely given from someone who previously had it. If you call yourself a rational Christian with a well formed conscience then you must know that Authority comes from God through Jesus and is given to individually appointed men (the apostles) who in turn pass it on to their successors in a succession of authority. But you fail to admit that no one gave the Protestants any authority. As well, you don’t seem to want to admit that the true and original Christin Church is the Catholic Church and has been operating for 2,000 years in a continuously unbroken chain of passed down authority. The Catholic “apostolic succession” is a historical chain of bishops each hand selected by their predecessors, physically “laid on hands”, prayed over and apostolically blessed and ordained into that authority. Its irrefutable.

    [continued]
    …
    James*
 
[from prior dialog]
40.png
Brian_Culliton:
Now in all answers that are not A or E ask yourself how rational is it to acknowledge the original Roman Catholic authority that writes and delivers the bible then arbitrarily later embrace one of the various “Johnny Come lately” German and English self appointed authorities who came to the party over a MILLENNIUM TOO LATE to save 100’s of millions of Christian souls before them? Do you think Jesus would turn his back on those who He promised He would never abandon? So Brian - Who is YOUR authority? Do you follow Rome, Germany (Wittenberg) or England (Canterbury) or perhaps Waco Texas? Do you follow Yourself? Don’t say “Christ” since He has already given His earthly Authority to The Apostles (Apostolic Succession) until He returns.

Sorry but you can’t hold your bible up as an authority without being forced to admit that you imagine yourself to be infallable and without ignoring the profoundly embarrassing and shameful history of how the Protestant Bible came to you. What ever happened to that old Protestant judicial standard of “the WHOLE truth, and nothing but the truth so help you God”? The Protestant Bible is not the whole truth nor by evidence of the legion of Protestant factions a self-evident truth. Truth never divides and compromises itself into factions.

James
 
TOMSTER you jumped in between my multi-page post and commented on it before I had it all up and I had to delete it to prevent it from getting other posts between it and making it hard to read as page 1 and page 2…

Too fast on the trigger bro.
James
 
Maybe you aught to worry about the mess your own house is in before you point the finger at others.
Brian,

You must seriously take a look at the radical instability of Protestantism. The result of this inner conflict within Protestantism is a desire for change. We might expect to find alterations in a religious system whose founders themselves made the revolutionary change of leaving the Catholic faith and spent the rest of their lives opposition to their former allegiance. We have seen something of the vagaries in Protestant churches since the Reformation. Compare, if you will, the unqualified supernaturalism in Luther’s Catechism or the Journal of John Wesley with the compromising doctrine of their respective churches and we get some idea of the essential fluidity of Protestant theology.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top