Maybe you aught to worry about the mess your own house is in before you point the finger at others.
So, you want to talk about messes? Let’s !
The negative phase of Protestantism and its radical error are the claim that we do not believe with the mind. It might seem that Protestants who still profess Christian doctrine are united with Catholics on the character of faith. Both subscribe to the articles of the Creed, from believing in “God the Father Almighty” to “everlasting life.” In reality the difference is extreme. Catholics hold that faith is an assent of the intellect to accept on divine authority whatever truths God has revealed. Protestants, unless they surrender their own principles, claim that faith is primarily an act of the will - as trust, or love, or abandonment - without prior dependence on the mind. Their opinions on the nature of faith are fluid, and theories range over the whole field of psychology.
The consequences of this notion are far reaching. If faith is not necessarily submission of mind to objective truth, what difference does it make whether I believe that God has three Persons or One, whether He became incarnate in Christ or not, whether His presence in the Eucharist is real or merely symbolic? It makes no difference. I am just as good a Christian and equally on the road to salvation whether I profess, with Luther, that “after Adam’s sin man’s free will was wholly destroyed,” or say, with the Council of Trent which condemned Luther, that if anyone holds this doctrine 'let him be anathema."
In the final analysis the very possibility of affirming that certain propositions are true and necessary for salvation rests on the prior conviction that faith is something intellectual which can be formulated in statements and definitions, to which the mind can freely assent if it wants to. Deny this principle; call faith by whatever name you wish, but say it is not creedal or intellectual, and you reduce the Christian religion to what some investigators are agreed is the essence of Protestant thought: a feeling of dependence on a superior being, whose very existence may be called into doubt. “The proposal,” writes a sympathetic observer, “that religion may be sufficiently founded on feeling comes with too great promise of relief to be lightly dismissed. Grant it, and all dogmatic authority loses its pressure at once. We are set free to be religious beings without the infinite argument and haggling over unreachable and untestable propositions. Creeds we wave aside, or else, we carry them lightly, knowing that they are at one stroke disarmed, put out of conflict with truth as otherwise established.” (William Hocking - "The Meaning of God in Human Experience) The libertarian comfort which this brings to the natural man may explain, in part, the success which the Reformation had in winning so many people to its cause, and still has in retaining the fidelity of millions who would be offended if told their religion is only a shadow of the Catholic substance they have lost. Tasting the perfectly human pleasure of believing what they please, they have no idea of that deeper satisfaction which St. Paul promised to those who bring their mind into subjection to the obedience of Christ, who profess that faith is not feeling or pious sentiment but the acceptance, on the word of God, of things that are not seen.
cont.