Do Catholics believe Protestants are going to hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Malia_Belen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Where do you feel that billy got his authority? Scripture says it is passed down by the laying of hands. Do you not agree with scripture?
I agree, Absolutely ! Protestants practice annointing with hands.
 
I personally will pray the Divine Mercy chaplet for him that God grants him the abundance of actual grace necessary for him to convert to Catholicism at least in his heart before he dies. This prayer is said to be so efficacious in the hour of death that God calls each soul 3 times with such a progression of grace that is just short of being irresistible by human will and hardened hubris/pride.
I appreciate this CFJ. 👍 I know you are a sincere person, and will do what you promise.

We both know Billy will respond, to whatever his Lord desires of him. He lived a full life in service to God, and probably prays 24-7 and is surely purged of all sin … as his candle grows short. For all those validly Baptized, it only takes a complete, contrite deathbed confession to bypass Purgatory.
 
The words were carefully chosen. There is subtlety here.

Just as God can use the jawbone of an a_ss to slay 1000s (ref. Judges 15: Samson ), and just as God can make an a_ss speak truth (ref. Num 22: Ballam’s a_ss) and just as Jesus can ride an a_ss into his glory does not mean in any way that the instrument that God uses is saved.

I am not trying to call Billy an a_ss but only trying to teach a lesson about the instrument of grace and its distinction from grace’s object. God can apply actual grace to anything he chooses to make it His instrument. But that kind of grace only promotes Divine Providence toward God’s objective end. While actual grace can and does bring people into salvific “sanctifying grace” it is this latter kind of grace that can ONLY save a soul.

We need to be careful to never confuse the instrument of actual grace with the vessel of sanctifying grace - that is the soul.

If Billy retained his Baptismal grace, that is sanctifying grace, and never committed any grave post-baptismal sins (or perfectly repented for any he did commit) then he will be saved. But his elevated knowledge of Catholic doctrine about the need to be a formal member of the Church in communion with Christ and its members could be very problematic for Billy.

I personally will pray the Divine Mercy chaplet for him that God grants him the abundance of actual grace necessary for him to convert to Catholicism at least in his heart before he dies. This prayer is said to be so efficacious in the hour of death that God calls each soul 3 times with such a progression of grace that is just short of being irresistible by human will and hardened hubris/pride.

James
Let me make sure I understand correctly. You believe that Billy Graham needs to convert to Catholicism in order to be saved?

Let me suggest that you read Billy Graham’s book entitled, “How to Be Born Again”.
 
Let me make sure I understand correctly. You believe that Billy Graham needs to convert to Catholicism in order to be saved?

Let me suggest that you read Billy Graham’s book entitled, “How to Be Born Again”.
No. What I will say explicitly is that for Billy to have highest confidence that he is saved and to gain all the helps and graces available to him to gain his highest and best crown in Heaven he must become a formal member of the Catholic Church. This latter thing is another truth that most Protestants don’t get. Not all in God’s Kingdom are spiritually equal. The greater a person’s spiritual capacity to Love the deeper that person can draw into The Eternal Beatific Vision - that is to know God as God knows Himself. When one dies their soul is sealed - they are all they will ever be and have all the grace they will ever have for all eternity. Those who were gravely wounded by even a single unrepented grave sin will loose all grace and fall to hell. Christians should be “Grace Junkies” - seeking out ways to get as much as possible - that is finding more ways to love and serve God and to not fall into sin.

Partaking of the Eucharist a single time on one’s death bed can give more grace than a lifetime of prayer, fasting and alms giving. It all depends on the disposition of the soul to receive grace. This is why a life long Catholic availing herself habitually of the full sacramental graces has an opportunity to advance herself in the spiritual virtues of Faith, Hope and Charity and better serve God and advance His Kingdom and reap the highest reward possible.

I will not judge Billy’s soul with respect to heaven or hell - no Catholic is permitted to do that - not even the pope. But I can say with absolute confidence that Billy will be infinitely better off in the afterlife if he were to become a formal Catholic and come into the fullness of Grace before He meets His Creator to give his accounting for his life.

Let me suggest that you read the greatest work ever assembled on planet earth - The Catholic Bible taken together with the guidance and apostolically authorativeCatholic Catechism.

The Catechism gives crisp and concise teaching of the Holy Spirit and references to deeper works for those who are ready to really advance on their pilgrimage to the Promised Land and sainthood.

James
 
No. What I will say explicitly is that for Billy to have highest confidence that he is saved and to gain all the helps and graces available to him to gain his highest and best crown in Heaven he must become a formal member of the Catholic Church. This latter thing is another truth that most Protestants don’t get. Not all in God’s Kingdom are spiritually equal. The greater a person’s spiritual capacity to Love the deeper that person can draw into The Eternal Beatific Vision - that is to know God as God knows Himself. When one dies their soul is sealed - they are all they will ever be and have all the grace they will ever have for all eternity. Those who were gravely wounded by even a single unrepented grave sin will loose all grace and fall to hell. Christians should be “Grace Junkies” - seeking out ways to get as much as possible - that is finding more ways to love and serve God and to not fall into sin.

Partaking of the Eucharist a single time on one’s death bed can give more grace than a lifetime of prayer, fasting and alms giving. It all depends on the disposition of the soul to receive grace. This is why a life long Catholic availing herself habitually of the full sacramental graces has an opportunity to advance herself in the spiritual virtues of Faith, Hope and Charity and better serve God and advance His Kingdom and reap the highest reward possible.

I will not judge Billy’s soul with respect to heaven or hell - no Catholic is permitted to do that - not even the pope. But I can say with absolute confidence that Billy will be infinitely better off in the afterlife if he were to become a formal Catholic and come into the fullness of Grace before He meets His Creator to give his accounting for his life.

Let me suggest that you read the greatest work ever assembled on planet earth - The Catholic Bible taken together with the guidance and apostolically authorativeCatholic Catechism.

The Catechism gives crisp and concise teaching of the Holy Spirit and references to deeper works for those who are ready to really advance on their pilgrimage to the Promised Land and sainthood.

James
I have read both the Bible and the Catechism. Do you actually believe that the Catechism has equal authority with the Bible? I do not; that is one of the reasons why I am no longer Catholic.
 
I have read both the Bible and the Catechism. Do you actually believe that the Catechism has equal authority with the Bible? I do not; that is one of the reasons why I am no longer Catholic.
The Bible has no authority in and of itself. There is not one statement in the bible where the bible self-declares itself to be an authority. The Bible itself tells us “The Church is the Pillar & Foundation of Truth”. There is an entire apostolic teaching that is handed down to the Catholic Church that goes with the bible. The Bible compels us to take up all matters of Christian dispute “with the Church”. It does not tell us to go write new secular relgious books about “how to be born again” without the Church’s oversight and permission.

The ONLY authority on earth to teach the Bible and the faith are the apostolic bishops. There are two essential dual-gifts God gives humanity for salvation - Faith and His Church. No one can be saved unless he is attached in some way (formally or informally) to the Church. Faith is incomplete outside of The Church since it is given through the Church to start with.

The reason you are no longer Catholic is because you put your faith in some person outside of the Catholic Church to tell you something that sounded “plausible” and “easier” to you. You fell for Satan’s trick. Satan knows that outside of The Catholic Church it is much easier to pick off souls once he has a claw into them with a partial truth belief that he can continue to pull with all while someone presumes they “are saved”.

James
 
I have read both the Bible and the Catechism. Do you actually believe that the Catechism has equal authority with the Bible? I do not; that is one of the reasons why I am no longer Catholic.
Why would the Catechism being authoritative cause you to give up Catholicism?
 
I have read both the Bible and the Catechism. Do you actually believe that the Catechism has equal authority with the Bible? I do not; that is one of the reasons why I am no longer Catholic.
Not me. 😃 I know the bible has no authority. And I know that the Church has IT ALL!😃

So Bible 0 Church 100%😃
 
I agree, Absolutely ! Protestants practice annointing with hands.
EXCUSE ME:D Are you seriously saying that protestants have the authority passed down to them by the CC to be protestants:D Are you saying that they indeed have Holy Orders?:eek:
 
I have read both the Bible and the Catechism. Do you actually believe that the Catechism has equal authority with the Bible? I do not; that is one of the reasons why I am no longer Catholic.
I also agree that the bible does not have the authority of the RCC. Thats why I am Catholic!😃
 
Why would I need a Protestant tell me how to be born again. When I know that the CHurch has the teachings of Jesus Christ and to be born again means to have the sacrament of Baptism to be reborn in the Faith of our dear Lord Jesus Christ!:confused:

Where does the bible or any teachigs of the Early Fathers of the CHurch teach us stray away from the teachings of the Church:confused:
 
The Bible has no authority in and of itself. There is not one statement in the bible where the bible self-declares itself to be an authority. The Bible itself tells us “The Church is the Pillar & Foundation of Truth”. There is an entire apostolic teaching that is handed down to the Catholic Church that goes with the bible. The Bible compels us to take up all matters of Christian dispute “with the Church”. It does not tell us to go write new secular relgious books about “how to be born again” without the Church’s oversight and permission.

The ONLY authority on earth to teach the Bible and the faith are the apostolic bishops. There are two essential dual-gifts God gives humanity for salvation - Faith and His Church. No one can be saved unless he is attached in some way (formally or informally) to the Church. Faith is incomplete outside of The Church since it is given through the Church to start with.

The reason you are no longer Catholic is because you put your faith in some person outside of the Catholic Church to tell you something that sounded “plausible” and “easier” to you. You fell for Satan’s trick. Satan knows that outside of The Catholic Church it is much easier to pick off souls once he has a claw into them with a partial truth belief that he can continue to pull with all while someone presumes they “are saved”.

James
The reason I am no longer Catholic is because I have put my faith in Christ – not in the Catholic Church. Faith in Christ is not a trick of Satan; Faith in Christ is the way of salvation.

John 14:6 says:

Jesus answered “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the father except through me.”
 
The reason I am no longer Catholic is because I have put my faith in Christ – not in the Catholic Church. Faith in Christ is not a trick of Satan; Faith in Christ is the way of salvation.

John 14:6 says:

Jesus answered “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the father except through me.”
Yes, Christ taught that. But, he also placed Peter in charge of the Flock.

Priscilla, Christ annoints with the H.S. This happens for both Catholic and Protestant alike. And even for those outside the church entirely. Like in the case of Paul. Totally against the Church … and yet Christ had mercy on him. Because Paul sincerely believed he was serving God. Anyone who sincerely seeks the Lord … will be given grace to find Him.

However, once we find [or are found by Christ] … we need to align ourselves with his Church. The Catholic Church is the ideal way to persevere in our faith. History clearly proclaims the Catholic Church had all the Apostles and ECF’s in its fold. And, it does have the authority … given it by Christ, thru his Apostles.

You are investigating the Protestant faith. You will eventually discover it offers nothing that the Catholic Church lacks. It came out of the Catholic faith … and one day it will rejoin the Church. So, when you decide to return home … bring your flock with you. Maybe its God’s plan to have you promote Ecumenism … helping unify his flocks as ONE. 👍
 
I have read both the Bible and the Catechism. Do you actually believe that the Catechism has equal authority with the Bible? I do not; that is one of the reasons why I am no longer Catholic.
Hi Priscilla Ann!

According to Providentissimus Deus, Catholics are instructed to prove their doctrines “from the authority of the Bible; ‘for (Theology) does not receive her first principles from any other science, but immediately from God by revelation.’” This is why the Bible has authority: because God is its Author. The first order of business for a professor of Biblical studies is to teach students “how to prove the integrity and authority of the Bible.” And we are even taught that “the divine and infallible magisterium of the Church rests also on the authority of Holy Scripture.”

Protestants and Catholics agree that the Bible is absolutely authoritative, “expressed in apt words and with infallible truth.” Where we differ, as you know, is on how the Bible is to be interpreted.

Although the Catechism contains many of the infallible teachings of the Church, it is not of equal authority with Sacred Scripture. If the Catechism is wrong in paragraph 58 about which Daniel Ezekiel is referring to, that’s OK. This same type of statement could not be made pertaining to Sacred Scripture, and that’s the difference. Scripture is God-breathed. Not so, the Catechism.

Please consider why you left the Catholic Church. Please consider that the Catechism opens up with a Scripture very similar to your John 14:6. “‘There is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved’ (Acts 4:12) - than the name of JESUS.”

We’re off to a strong start! 🙂

In Christ,
Pete
 
The reason I am no longer Catholic is because I have put my faith in Christ – not in the Catholic Church. Faith in Christ is not a trick of Satan; Faith in Christ is the way of salvation.

John 14:6 says:

Jesus answered “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the father except through me.”
Which Christ? and how did you come to know him? And what does your faith entail? Is it an active faith, where you follow in Jesus’ footsteps, loving both God and Neighbor to the best of your ability and striving for perfect holiness by doing God’s will? Or is it a passive faith, where you simply believe Jesus loves you perfectly and with infinite mercy, no matter how much you sin or how little you love?
 
EXCUSE ME:D Are you seriously saying that protestants have the authority passed down to them by the CC to be protestants:D Are you saying that they indeed have Holy Orders?:eek:
She may be referring to that anointing with the Aloe Vera anti-viral hand lotion everyone puts on now after shaking hands in church… 😛

James
 
aspirant,
Judging the salvation of others , especially if you are a christian?? Pray for others instead, We don’t know their heart, but the Lord does. 🙂

Mt.7:1-2 reads “Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the same measure you use, it will be measured to you.”

The Bible also speaks of the sin of pride. it’s in Proverbs.

God bless you,
bluelake
 
The reason I am no longer Catholic is because I have put my faith in Christ – not in the Catholic Church. Faith in Christ is not a trick of Satan; Faith in Christ is the way of salvation.

John 14:6 says:

Jesus answered “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the father except through me.”
No you are not putting your faith in Jesus Christ by leaving the Catholic Church? Who told you this nonsense??? What you are doing is putting your faith in some very ignorant person who put this nonsensical idea in your head. This is the error of “by faith alone”. Having faith in Jesus means having faith in him but also having faith in EVERYTHING he told us and actually obeying and doing all that he commanded. Christ gave the Church to His People as a gift. You can’t seperate Christ from His gifts Priscilla. Having faith in Jesus also means having faith that the gifts he gives us are given for His purposes. What did Mary say to the servants at Canna who needed wine? She said “DO WHAT HE TELLS YOU”. And what did Jesus tell them? FILL THESE JUGS WITH WATER. Having an faith where one does not do what Jesus tells us to do is useless. What if everyone had faith in Jesus at Canna to have the power to make wine but everyone said “What does he need water for? I have faith in Jesus but not those jugs of water. He is God he can do anything - we have faith in him - so lets make him do a full miracle and save us the trouble of filling and carrying those heavy water jars”? What if the servants refused to bring him the jugs of water as he commanded Priscilla? The answer is - THERE WOULD BE NO MIRACLE AND NO NEW WINE.

Are you going to listen to some self appointed minister from some self-accredited Protestant Divinity School tell you how to interpret the bible and tell you what your faith should be over the apostolic Church??? All you have done is swapped out the apostolic teaching authority for a secular teacher who can’t trace his pedigree back more than 50-200 years or so. The Catholic Church can trace her pedigree to Pentecost - 2,000 years ago - we were there.

James
 
Speaking of nonsense…
Free 1,000 Souls From Purgatory & they will pray for you unceasingly all your life!
Please show where Jesus or the apostle taught this.

(But even if we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel to you than what we have preached to you, let him be accursed.)
• Join the Dominican Fathers Rosary Cofraternity for extra indulgences!
Please show where Jesus or the apostle taught us about the rosary and indulgences.

(But even if we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel to you than what we have preached to you, let him be accursed.)
• Pray The Chaplet of Divine Mercy!
Please show where Jesus or the apostle taught us to listen to oracles.

(But even if we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel to you than what we have preached to you, let him be accursed.)
“You fell for Satan’s trick!”
Funny, Priscilla puts her faith in Christ and you say she has fallen for Satan’s trick, but you put your faith in oracles and you possess the truth??? That is about as twisted as it gets.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top