Thank you for the helpful explanation in discerning between grave and mortal sin. I assume that people who miss mass regularly are guilty of a grave sin and complete consent (nobody is holding a gun to their head).
What does “full knowledge” constitute? As Catholics were are obligated to have a moral conscience in accordance with the Catholic Church. I understand that moral relativism and cafeteria Catholicism is bad. However, if a person has studied the faith and with their conscience, albeit malformed (because the CC defines it as such), believes it is not a sin to miss mass on Sunday. Is this a mortal sin? What does the Church ask this person to do in this case? Also, is this person obligated to confess this sin before receiving the Eucharist?
I don’t know that we can assume complete consent as a given. Imagine a school-age child of nominal Catholic parents whose parents refuse to drive him to Mass. Imagine the wife of an atheist man who misses Mass out of fear of the rift it may deepen in her marriage. Imagine all those who legitimately miss Mass because of their profession (doctors, nurses, etc.).
Here’s what the Catechism says about full knowledge:
CCC 1859 Mortal sin requires
full knowledge and
complete consent. It presupposes knowledge of the sinful character of the act, of its opposition to God’s law. It also implies a consent sufficiently deliberate to be a personal choice. Feigned ignorance and hardness of heart [133] do not diminish, but rather increase, the voluntary character of a sin.
[133] Cf. Mk 3:5-6; Lk 16:19-31.
I think some people make too much of full knowledge and others too little. It doesn’t mean we have to have a Masters in Theology in order to have sufficient knowledge to commit mortal sin. But neither does it mean that pretty much everyone has full knowledge because the natural moral law is “common sense.”
If someone is raised in a nominal Catholic home and taught (by priests and parents alike) that it’s “no big deal” to miss Mass on Sunday, does such a person really have full “knowledge of the sinful character of the act”? It’s hard to say.
As far as Confession, I would always encourage people to confess any of their sins, particularly grave ones, regardless of whether or not they felt they were technically “mortal sins.” I would also encourage someone guilty of those grave sins to confess receiving the Eucharist unworthily if they had received Communion in such a state. However, I would never point my finger at them and say “You’re going to hell!” In general, I try to make it a habit to examine my own conscience rather than anyone else’s.
I think a lot of people have questions such as yours. The reason it can seem so nebulous sometimes is because we can’t really read another person’s heart. We don’t really
know the level of another’s knowledge (for the most part). I don’t feel qualified to point my finger at 75% of all Catholics in the U.S. and say “You’re going to hell!” I would rather do all that I can to evangelize and catechize and leave those judgment calls to God. Thanks be to God, I am not God!
