Do Catholics believe that most Catholics are going to hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Koneko
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Koneko

Guest
“about 23 percent attend Mass weekly”
catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=12361

“Those who deliberately fail in this obligation commit a grave sin”
CCC2181

“To die in mortal sin…means remaining separated from him for ever…”
CCC1033

Something doesn’t seem right to me that so many Catholics are damned, yet our Protestant brothers may be saved by following much “easier” teachings.
 
“about 23 percent attend Mass weekly”
catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=12361

“Those who deliberately fail in this obligation commit a grave sin”
CCC2181

“To die in mortal sin…means remaining separated from him for ever…”
CCC1033

Something doesn’t seem right to me that so many Catholics are damned, yet our Protestant brothers may be saved by following much “easier” teachings.
To whom much id given, much is required
 
I don’t believe that all Catholics are going to hell. I believe that as long as you believe in God and don’t commit a mortal sin, regardless of what religion you practice, you will go to Heaven. I also believe that if you ask God to forgive your sins while you are on your “death bed”, he will forgive you. God is forgiving and doesn’t want to see us all in hell. I know quite a few people who have lived their lives the “wrong way” and on their death bed have received confession and last rights. I believe they are not in hell. I think we, as human beings, judge each other worse than how God judges us.
 
“about 23 percent attend Mass weekly”
catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=12361

“Those who deliberately fail in this obligation commit a grave sin”
CCC2181

“To die in mortal sin…means remaining separated from him for ever…”
CCC1033

Something doesn’t seem right to me that so many Catholics are damned, yet our Protestant brothers may be saved by following much “easier” teachings.
The key thing to consider is the difference between grave and mortal sin. All mortal sin is grave, but not all grave sin is mortal.

For a sin to be mortal, there are three conditions that must be preset: it must be a grave sin, and it must be committed with full knowledge and complete consent.

The fact is, we can look at those 77% of Catholics and say they are committing a grave sin by failing to go to Mass every week, but we cannot say that they are committing mortal sin because we do not know the level of their knowledge or the freedom of their consent. We especially do not know how many of this 77% receives the Sacrament of Reconciliation and/or Anointing of the Sick prior to death.

So, while low Mass attendance is a very sad reality that we must work at fixing, we cannot use it as evidence that “most Catholics are going to hell.”
 
What did Jesus tell us? “Many are called but few are chosen.” Also, "“Enter through the narrow gate; for the gate is wide and the road broad that leads to destruction, and those who enter through it are many. How narrow the gate and constricted the road that leads to life. And those who find it are few.” Plus this, “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven. Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name? Did we not drive out demons in your name? Did we not do mighty deeds in your name?’ Then I will declare to them solemnly, 'I never knew you. Depart from me, you evildoers.”
 
The key thing to consider is the difference between grave and mortal sin. All mortal sin is grave, but not all grave sin is mortal.

For a sin to be mortal, there are three conditions that must be preset: it must be a grave sin, and it must be committed with full knowledge and complete consent.

The fact is, we can look at those 77% of Catholics and say they are committing a grave sin by failing to go to Mass every week, but we cannot say that they are committing mortal sin because we do not know the level of their knowledge or the freedom of their consent. We especially do not know how many of this 77% receives the Sacrament of Reconciliation and/or Anointing of the Sick prior to death.

So, while low Mass attendance is a very sad reality that we must work at fixing, we cannot use it as evidence that “most Catholics are going to hell.”
This is a very good point. I would argue that relatively few Catholics who skip Mass every week really understand the importance of it. I think of what it would take for me start skipping mass–I would have to someone become convinced it is not that important. Or, something else extremely pressing comes up in my life, and I simply don’t think about it–in which case, it is not with complete knowledge and consent. Those conditions are really only met if a person is fully aware of the importance of weekly mass, is free to go, and choses not to. This is all the less likely when the potential consequences of that act are realized (and I would argue the potential consequences must be realized for the sinner to have “full knowledge”).
 
“about 23 percent attend Mass weekly”
catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=12361

“Those who deliberately fail in this obligation commit a grave sin”
CCC2181

“To die in mortal sin…means remaining separated from him for ever…”
CCC1033

Something doesn’t seem right to me that so many Catholics are damned, yet our Protestant brothers may be saved by following much “easier” teachings.
Some individual Catholics might believe that. I don’t and none I know do. The Catholic Church doesn’t teach that most Catholics are going to hell.
 
Yeah, most Catholics are probably going to Hell, and yeah, it’s sad. 85% skip weekly mass, 90% use contraception, over 60% deny the real presence . . . catholics in name only.

Christ did say that most people wouldn’t make it though.
 
The key thing to consider is the difference between grave and mortal sin. All mortal sin is grave, but not all grave sin is mortal.

For a sin to be mortal, there are three conditions that must be preset: it must be a grave sin, and it must be committed with full knowledge and complete consent.

The fact is, we can look at those 77% of Catholics and say they are committing a grave sin by failing to go to Mass every week, but we cannot say that they are committing mortal sin because we do not know the level of their knowledge or the freedom of their consent. We especially do not know how many of this 77% receives the Sacrament of Reconciliation and/or Anointing of the Sick prior to death.

So, while low Mass attendance is a very sad reality that we must work at fixing, we cannot use it as evidence that “most Catholics are going to hell.”
Thank you for the helpful explanation in discerning between grave and mortal sin. I assume that people who miss mass regularly are guilty of a grave sin and complete consent (nobody is holding a gun to their head).

What does “full knowledge” constitute? As Catholics were are obligated to have a moral conscience in accordance with the Catholic Church. I understand that moral relativism and cafeteria Catholicism is bad. However, if a person has studied the faith and with their conscience, albeit malformed (because the CC defines it as such), believes it is not a sin to miss mass on Sunday. Is this a mortal sin? What does the Church ask this person to do in this case? Also, is this person obligated to confess this sin before receiving the Eucharist?
 
Thank you for the helpful explanation in discerning between grave and mortal sin. I assume that people who miss mass regularly are guilty of a grave sin and complete consent (nobody is holding a gun to their head).

What does “full knowledge” constitute? As Catholics were are obligated to have a moral conscience in accordance with the Catholic Church. I understand that moral relativism and cafeteria Catholicism is bad. However, if a person has studied the faith and with their conscience, albeit malformed (because the CC defines it as such), believes it is not a sin to miss mass on Sunday. Is this a mortal sin? What does the Church ask this person to do in this case? Also, is this person obligated to confess this sin before receiving the Eucharist?
Disagreement does not equal ignorance and does not diminish ones culpability.

We are to be in a state of grace (no mortal sin) when presenting ourselve for the reception of the Eucharist.
 
Disagreement does not equal ignorance and does not diminish ones culpability.

We are to be in a state of grace (no mortal sin) when presenting ourselve for the reception of the Eucharist.
If a person truly does not know that missing Mass on Sunday is a grave matter, then they are not gulity of a Mortal sin
 
“about 23 percent attend Mass weekly”
catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=12361

“Those who deliberately fail in this obligation commit a grave sin”
CCC2181

“To die in mortal sin…means remaining separated from him for ever…”
CCC1033

Something doesn’t seem right to me that so many Catholics are damned, yet our Protestant brothers may be saved by following much “easier” teachings.
“May” being the operative word.

I certainly don’t believe that “bad” Protestants have leg up on “bad” Catholics in terms of finding themselves in heaven.

Unfortunately, there are plenty of both.

Chuck
 
Thank you for the helpful explanation in discerning between grave and mortal sin. I assume that people who miss mass regularly are guilty of a grave sin and complete consent (nobody is holding a gun to their head).

What does “full knowledge” constitute? As Catholics were are obligated to have a moral conscience in accordance with the Catholic Church. I understand that moral relativism and cafeteria Catholicism is bad. However, if a person has studied the faith and with their conscience, albeit malformed (because the CC defines it as such), believes it is not a sin to miss mass on Sunday. Is this a mortal sin? What does the Church ask this person to do in this case? Also, is this person obligated to confess this sin before receiving the Eucharist?
I don’t know that we can assume complete consent as a given. Imagine a school-age child of nominal Catholic parents whose parents refuse to drive him to Mass. Imagine the wife of an atheist man who misses Mass out of fear of the rift it may deepen in her marriage. Imagine all those who legitimately miss Mass because of their profession (doctors, nurses, etc.).

Here’s what the Catechism says about full knowledge:
CCC 1859 Mortal sin requires full knowledge and complete consent. It presupposes knowledge of the sinful character of the act, of its opposition to God’s law. It also implies a consent sufficiently deliberate to be a personal choice. Feigned ignorance and hardness of heart [133] do not diminish, but rather increase, the voluntary character of a sin.
[133] Cf. Mk 3:5-6; Lk 16:19-31.
I think some people make too much of full knowledge and others too little. It doesn’t mean we have to have a Masters in Theology in order to have sufficient knowledge to commit mortal sin. But neither does it mean that pretty much everyone has full knowledge because the natural moral law is “common sense.”

If someone is raised in a nominal Catholic home and taught (by priests and parents alike) that it’s “no big deal” to miss Mass on Sunday, does such a person really have full “knowledge of the sinful character of the act”? It’s hard to say.

As far as Confession, I would always encourage people to confess any of their sins, particularly grave ones, regardless of whether or not they felt they were technically “mortal sins.” I would also encourage someone guilty of those grave sins to confess receiving the Eucharist unworthily if they had received Communion in such a state. However, I would never point my finger at them and say “You’re going to hell!” In general, I try to make it a habit to examine my own conscience rather than anyone else’s. 😉

I think a lot of people have questions such as yours. The reason it can seem so nebulous sometimes is because we can’t really read another person’s heart. We don’t really know the level of another’s knowledge (for the most part). I don’t feel qualified to point my finger at 75% of all Catholics in the U.S. and say “You’re going to hell!” I would rather do all that I can to evangelize and catechize and leave those judgment calls to God. Thanks be to God, I am not God! 😛
 
I believe that MOST people who call themselves Catholic are Cultural Catholics,Cafeteria Catholics,Cinos,Christmas and Easter Catholics who are so steeped in sin that they do not even realise that they are living sinful lives.They have the obligation to have an informed and developed conscience and pleading ignorance before the Throne will not reduce their personal culpability.
Christ said most will take the wide and easy road,not the narrow and difficult one.I live on a street where there are at least 10 Catholic families.NONE except me and my son attend mass or avail themselves of the sacraments.I offered to take one 12 year old with us to the Saturday vigil mass.when we got there I suggested we all attend Confession;he said,“what’s that?”.this from a kid who was baptised Catholic,received his First Communion and had attended confession prior to his First Communion.His Catholic parents are going to have a LOT to answer for.
My parish priest descibes the majority of Catholic parents(whom he has never seen before)as approaching him to get their children “done”,i.e.baptised.Before the last first communion and before the last confirmation he required ALL parents to attend and read them the riot act about their duties as Catholic Parents to suffer the little children to come unto HIM.We have NEVER seen them or threir parents again(except for 1 or 2)but you can be guaranteed in a decade they’ll all be demanding Catholic marriages.I have actually seen him cry after giving these little angels their first communion because he knows that he won’t see them until they’re 13 for Confirmation.

God is all Merciful but he is all Just.At Fatima Mary describes souls falling into hell like snowflakes.Faithful,devout Catholics are the REMNANT.Christ said he would vomit the lukewarm from his mouth.He also made reference to White Sephulcurs.All you have to do is read the red parts in your New Testament and you will have your answer.
 
We also don’t know about those that my have unusual but good reasons for staying away from Mass in a physical way.

Also, I wonder about our protestantt brothers. Newman says that in the early centuries and beyond peopel were told to have no converse with heretics.

Today, this includes most Catholics and all protestants: but we still don’t know the degree of their knowledge, but there must be serious sin, because the Holy Spirit leads peopel to the Catholic Church and all of her beliefs.
 
I don’t understand, what are you referring to by “this”? Thanks.
I mean by “this” the label “heretic”.

I mean that in my opinion most Catholics today–even Church-going ones–reject parts of Catholic doctrine-- think this is proven in r

eference to contracetion. THis makes them at least material heretics: quiet protestants. All protestants by definititon also are material heretics, though many of them are believers and more Catholic than some of those in the Catholic pews.

However, I wasn’t condeming them, simply showing the real situation.,

I find the whole modern situation very complex, but was simply sayign that the Church has always seen a connection between holiness and orthodoxy, according to Newman.
 
Yeah, most Catholics are probably going to Hell, and yeah, it’s sad. 85% skip weekly mass, 90% use contraception, over 60% deny the real presence . . . catholics in name only.

Christ did say that most people wouldn’t make it though.
He did! It all boils down to “I will not serve!” Satan found out what happened when he took on that attitude. If Catholics truly knew more about the early saints and their love of the Lord, we’d know how much we disobey. Check out the Anonymous Christian Doctrine. Apparently this is the doctrine Catholics have based their rationalization to half serve even though most Catholics are unaware of this “doctrine”.
 
Some individual Catholics might believe that. I don’t and none I know do. The Catholic Church doesn’t teach that most Catholics are going to hell.
It’s true that many priests are not teaching the Truth! Sugar coating the truth doesn’t make it true. No, it would be inappropriate for the Catholic Church to teach that most Catholics are going to hell because that’s God’s judgement. But, when priests water down the Gospel, those in the pews come to the conclusion that being a Catholic doesn’t involve sacrifice, suffering and evangelizing. It’s not a “spectator” religion.
 
It’s true that many priests are not teaching the Truth! Sugar coating the truth doesn’t make it true. No, it would be inappropriate for the Catholic Church to teach that most Catholics are going to hell because that’s God’s judgement. But, when priests water down the Gospel, those in the pews come to the conclusion that being a Catholic doesn’t involve sacrifice, suffering and evangelizing. It’s not a “spectator” religion.
Bravo!You have to be a Catholic at all times ESPECIALLY when its inconvenient or even dangerous.“There will be those who cry Lord,Lord…“And the response will be”,I know you not, whence you are: depart from me, all ye workers of iniquity.”
If we deny Him He will deny us.Yes.I believe most Catholics and Protestants are going to hell.Do I know this?NO.That is God’s purview alone.but I LISTEN to the Scriptural readings at mass and I read the Bible where it is in black and white(actually the most revealing parts about salvation vs.damnation are written in red.)Voiced by Christ himself.
Kumbayah Christians are whistling past the graveyard.There will be a LOT of weeping and gnashing of teeth.
I pray for final persistance and deliverance,like St Paul.
“Oh my Jesus,forgive us our sins and save us from the fires of hell,lead all those to heaven ESPECIALLY THOSE IN MOST NEED OF THY MERCY”.(that would be me)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top