Do Catholics REALLY believed in salvation through works?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JD27076
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JD27076

Guest
I am an RCIA Participant and I alwasy thought the Catholic Church believed in works to salvation. I looked at a few CCC that looked like worked and none shows anything about it. Does the RCC really believe this? If so, may I get some scriptural evidence? [Im not typing in an questionable attitude :p]
 
I am an RCIA Participant and I alwasy thought the Catholic Church believed in works to salvation. I looked at a few CCC that looked like worked and none shows anything about it. Does the RCC really believe this? If so, may I get some scriptural evidence? [Im not typing in an questionable attitude :p]
Protestants have said that Catholicism is a “works based religion” and believes that one has to work to attain his salvation. They then allege that the true doctrine of the Bible is that grace comes through faith alone.

The Catholic teaching is that sanctifying grace - the life of the Blessed Trinity within our souls without which we cannot go to heaven - is a gift from God. We receive sanctifying grace at our baptism. However, one later in life can reject sanctifying grace by committing a mortal sin. In this case, by confessing their sins and gaining absolution, one can be readmitted into the life of sanctifying grace.

These ideas exist in the Sacred Tradition (one of the two pillars of Church teaching) but are rooted in Scripture.

Protestants and Catholics agree that faith is the font from which grace comes, but unlike Protestants Catholics don’t teach that grace comes through faith alone and that no matter your deeds, you will go to Heaven if you “accept Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior.” In Scripture we see the Protestant view debunked in St. Matthew 7:21-29, St. Matthew 25:31-46, 1 Corinthians 6:7-11, Revelation 20:11-15, Revelation 21:8, and Revelation 22:12 among other places.

So, to put it simply, we don’t believe that one earns his salvation. Grace is a free gift of God. But one can reject that gift. Revelation 21:27 says that nothing impure shall enter Heaven. How could anyone say that God, after all of the scripture passages which I have cited, will let murderers, rapists, and thieves into Heaven?
 
Protestants have said that Catholicism is a “works based religion” and believes that one has to work to attain his salvation. They then allege that the true doctrine of the Bible is that grace comes through faith alone.

The Catholic teaching is that sanctifying grace - the life of the Blessed Trinity within our souls without which we cannot go to heaven - is a gift from God. We receive sanctifying grace at our baptism. However, one later in life can reject sanctifying grace by committing a mortal sin. In this case, by confessing their sins and gaining absolution, one can be readmitted into the life of sanctifying grace.

These ideas exist in the Sacred Tradition (one of the two pillars of Church teaching) but are rooted in Scripture.

Protestants and Catholics agree that faith is the font from which grace comes, but unlike Protestants Catholics don’t teach that grace comes through faith alone and that **no matter your deeds, you will go to Heaven if you “accept Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior.” **In Scripture we see the Protestant view debunked in St. Matthew 7:21-29, St. Matthew 25:31-46, 1 Corinthians 6:7-11, Revelation 20:11-15, Revelation 21:8, and Revelation 22:12 among other places.

So, to put it simply, we don’t believe that one earns his salvation. Grace is a free gift of God. But one can reject that gift. Revelation 21:27 says that nothing impure shall enter Heaven. How could anyone say that God, after all of the scripture passages which I have cited, will let murderers, rapists, and thieves into Heaven?
It is not the “Protestant view” that you have stated…it is the view held by Calvinists to an extent…to state it is THE “Protestant view” is false.
 
It is not the “Protestant view” that you have stated…it is the view held by Calvinists to an extent…to state it is THE “Protestant view” is false.
Very correct.

Baptists i.e. teach that we are indeed by grace and faith alon, but that good works are required in that sense that, if one truly loves Jesus and has committed His life to Him because he is fully convinced that He is the saviour; - He will do good works.
As Jesus himself states it, “If ye love me, keep my commandments.” (Jn 14:15)
 
It is not the “Protestant view” that you have stated…it is the view held by Calvinists to an extent…to state it is THE “Protestant view” is false.
I apologize. Let me rephrase. It is not “THE Protestant view,” but rather “A Protestant view.”
 
It is not the “Protestant view” that you have stated…it is the view held by Calvinists to an extent…to state it is THE “Protestant view” is false.
Are you saying Quakers consider themselves Protestants? I thought Quakers protested the protestants. In other words the Lutherans and Calvinists grew out of a protestation of the Catholic Church but the Quakers developed as a response to the erroneous Protestants, i.e. Lutherans, Calvinists, etc.
 
I apologize. Let me rephrase. It is not “THE Protestant view,” but rather “A Protestant view.”
A Protestant antinomian view, to be precise. One which most Protestants don’t hold.

And for the record, Calvinists would argue that murderers, thieves, and their ilk demonstrate by their works that they never really had faith to begin with. Growth in righteousness is intrinsic to a true believer.
 
So, to put it simply, we don’t believe that one earns his salvation. Grace is a free gift of God. But one can reject that gift. Revelation 21:27 says that nothing impure shall enter Heaven. How could anyone say that God, after all of the scripture passages which I have cited, will let murderers, rapists, and thieves into Heaven?
God will let **repentent **murderers, rapists and thieves into Heaven. Catholic teaching is that Baptism brings one into the family of God, clothes one in Christ, and opens heaven’s door. Once baptized one may and often does sin, just as the Apostle acknowledged when he said if we say we have never sinned we are liars. But in repentance for the sin God forgives us. We can be sure of this by going to confession and hearing the words of absolution. Old sins do not have to haunt us.
 
I am an RCIA Participant and I alwasy thought the Catholic Church believed in works to salvation. I looked at a few CCC that looked like worked and none shows anything about it. Does the RCC really believe this? If so, may I get some scriptural evidence? [Im not typing in an questionable attitude :p]
There is NO Catholic teaching of a works salvation. It is false.
However, Works are an evidence of salvation (State of Grace) and an essential piece of evidence.
In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have saving Grace.
Biblically look here:
James 2:14-18
14 What does it profit, my brethren, if a man says he has faith but has not works? Can his faith save him? 15 If a brother or sister is ill-clad and in lack of daily food, 16 and one of you says to them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled,” without giving them the things needed for the body, what does it profit? 17 So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead. 18 But some one will say, “You have faith and I have works.” Show me your faith apart from your works, and I by my works will show you my faith.

It is obvious that a “dead faith” is not a saving faith so we must conclude that Faith and works are intertwined with works being one of the evidences of a proper and saving faith.

I hope this helps some…

Peace
James
 
My abbreviated take on the works v. faith matter.

It seems to me that the Protestants were protesting what they saw as a distortion of the works idea. Remember the context. The priest Tetzel (as I recall his name) was raising money for the building of St. Peter’s. His message was not unlike certain ‘prosperity evangelists’ today. If you give to the project, God has a reward for you. Tetzel emphasized getting loved ones out of purgatory faster. The more you gave the less time loved ones had to suffer pain to purge their sins in purgatory. (Ironic that building St. Peter’s may have sparked the Reformation.)
Code:
I recall as a child the bilinqual (Latin/English) missal for mass. There were prayers in it, and after them would be printed in small print - "10 days indulgence" or "30 days indulgence". The idea was interpreted to me at that early age that each time you said that prayer you (or maybe a loved one, too - I forget) would spent that much less time in purgatory.

 The Protestants took issue with that sort of a point system. Attendance at mass counted toward salvation (and missing was a major sin), Various acts of worship - maybe novenas or retreats or eucharistic adoration, etc. - these all were worth so many points. Even self-inflicted suffering helped. Etc. 

  Protestantism in its various forms rejected this 'point system'. God saved you through your simple and genuine and deep faith. These pious 'good works' didn't do it.

  Where Protestantism sometimes went too far - certain forms of it, anyway - is that they seemed to ignore Matt. 25 when Jesus talks about the judgement day, when we would be judged by how we had compassion and, say, fed the hungry, visited the sick, etc. Or, they may not put an emphasis on the parable of the Good Samaritan, told - remember - after Jesus was asked how to inherit eternal life.

   I have a mixed Catholic/Protestant heritage and my own view, for what it's worth, is that we need to combine a simply faith with works that demonstrate our love and compassion, as commanded by Christ. In I Cor 13, St. Paul is specific. Faith, hope and love, these three - and the greatest of these is love. Faith without works is dead - found in James, as I recall. But I don't see works as pious acts of rite or ritual but lending a helping hand to those who need it. Love thy neighbor far out-trumps saying creeds and professing doctrines. 

  God bless the whole world.
 
My abbreviated take on the works v. faith matter.

It seems to me that the Protestants were protesting what they saw as a distortion of the works idea. Remember the context. The priest Tetzel (as I recall his name) was raising money for the building of St. Peter’s. His message was not unlike certain ‘prosperity evangelists’ today. If you give to the project, God has a reward for you. Tetzel emphasized getting loved ones out of purgatory faster. The more you gave the less time loved ones had to suffer pain to purge their sins in purgatory. (Ironic that building St. Peter’s may have sparked the Reformation.)
Code:
I recall as a child the bilinqual (Latin/English) missal for mass. There were prayers in it, and after them would be printed in small print - "10 days indulgence" or "30 days indulgence". The idea was interpreted to me at that early age that each time you said that prayer you (or maybe a loved one, too - I forget) would spent that much less time in purgatory.

 The Protestants took issue with that sort of a point system. Attendance at mass counted toward salvation (and missing was a major sin), Various acts of worship - maybe novenas or retreats or eucharistic adoration, etc. - these all were worth so many points. Even self-inflicted suffering helped. Etc. 

  Protestantism in its various forms rejected this 'point system'. God saved you through your simple and genuine and deep faith. These pious 'good works' didn't do it.

  Where Protestantism sometimes went too far - certain forms of it, anyway - is that they seemed to ignore Matt. 25 when Jesus talks about the judgement day, when we would be judged by how we had compassion and, say, fed the hungry, visited the sick, etc. Or, they may not put an emphasis on the parable of the Good Samaritan, told - remember - after Jesus was asked how to inherit eternal life.

   I have a mixed Catholic/Protestant heritage and my own view, **for what it's worth, is that we need to combine a simply faith with works that demonstrate our love and compassion, as commanded by Christ. In I Cor 13, St. Paul is specific. Faith, hope and love, these three - and the greatest of these is love. Faith without works is dead - found in James, as I recall. But I don't see works as pious acts of rite or ritual but lending a helping hand to those who need it. Love thy neighbor far out-trumps saying creeds and professing doctrines. **

  God bless the whole world.
Good post! 🙂

That’s exactely what my pastor said when I asked him, “are works needed for salvation?”

And I think quite many protestants think so. (At least Baptists and similar groups)

I like especially what I marked bold! 🙂

God bless you!

in Christ,
 
Very correct.

Baptists i.e. teach that we are indeed by grace and faith alon, but that good works are required in that sense that, if one truly loves Jesus and has committed His life to Him because he is fully convinced that He is the saviour; - He will do good works.
As Jesus himself states it, “If ye love me, keep my commandments.” (Jn 14:15)
I agree with you that " if one truly loves Jesus and has committed His life to Him because he is fully convinced that He is the saviour; - He will do good works."

But what if he stops doing good works? What if he stops obeying the Commandments? Is he still saved? The Protestants I speak to say “yes!” Even without confessing and repenting of that sin. Why? Becasue they are saved by faith alone. Saved by grace “apart from works.”

I listen to a lot of Protestant Pastors on the radio and TV and seldom do I hear that one MUST keep the commandments or he was never really saved to begin with.

Here in Dallas a Baptist professor and pastor from Criswell Bible College has a radio show. A caller told him that his conscience was telling him that he has lost his salvation because he was living with a married woman and commiting adultery. The professor asked him “Have you accepted Jesus as your personal Savior?” The man said “yes”. The professor said, “Then your salvation is secure! You have only hurt your relationship with Christ.”

He never did tell the man to get out of that relaltionship. He never told the man to confess and repent. WHy should he if he is “saved?”

The sad truth is that this man’s conscience was telling him that he was in mortal sin. He was no longer in the state of grace. He has in fact lost his salvation and his conscience is telling him so. What a terrible thing for that pastor to tell him. He should have been told to confess and repent immediately.
 
JRKH,

I have to respectfully disgree with you. You are leaving out the fact that works are necessary to maintain a living faith. They complete our faith and help us to perseverein that faith.

The works result from the assent of our will to do the work prompted us by the Holy Spirit. But the works are not us “buying” our salvation, since they are not of us:

Paul says that God works in us both to will and to do. Willing is the first step. Doing is the second step.

The result of our doing is acting as an instrument of God.

Now the assent of the will to agree with God to do is obviously a gift of God. Yet it is a necessary part of our having a living faith, one that does the works of God.

So works are necessry, not just to show, but to maintain a living faith.

We are not saved by works, but maintained in faith by assenting to them.
There is NO Catholic teaching of a works salvation. It is false.
However, Works are an evidence of salvation (State of Grace) and an essential piece of evidence.
In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have saving Grace.
Biblically look here:
James 2:14-18
14 What does it profit, my brethren, if a man says he has faith but has not works? Can his faith save him? 15 If a brother or sister is ill-clad and in lack of daily food, 16 and one of you says to them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled,” without giving them the things needed for the body, what does it profit? 17 So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead. 18 But some one will say, “You have faith and I have works.” Show me your faith apart from your works, and I by my works will show you my faith.

It is obvious that a “dead faith” is not a saving faith so we must conclude that Faith and works are intertwined with works being one of the evidences of a proper and saving faith.

I hope this helps some…

Peace
James
I would agree with what you said if you said:
"Works (the physical end results) do not gain us salvation. However, by assenting to work we maintain a living faith and gain merit by being conformed to Christ’s obedience.

In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have impetus to maintaining a saving Faith."

instead of:
"However, Works are an evidence of salvation (State of Grace) and an essential piece of evidence.

In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have saving Grace."

peace
steve
 
=JD27076;8271573]I am an RCIA Participant and I alwasy thought the Catholic Church believed in works to salvation. I looked at a few CCC that looked like worked and none shows anything about it. Does the RCC really believe this? If so, may I get some scriptural evidence? [Im not typing in an questionable attitude :p]

My dear friend in Christ,

WORKS is but one of the necessary elements to our Personal salvation.

Here are some bible references for you to consider. By FAR the most frequently quoted is james chapter TWO [see bleow]***

**Heb.6: 10 **“For God is not so unjust as to overlook your work and the love which you showed for his sake in serving the saints, as you still do.”

Rev.2: 23 “and I will strike her children dead. And all the churches shall know that I am he who searches mind and heart, and I will give to each of you as your works deserve.”

**1 Peter 1: 17 **“Now if you invoke as Father him who judges impartially according to each one’s works, conduct yourselves with reverence during the time of your sojourning, “

**“ Matt.19: 17 **“And he said to him, “Why do you ask me about what is good? One there is who is good. If you would enter life, keep the commandments.”

Rom.2: 13 “For it is not the hearers of the law who are righteous before God, but the doers of the law who will be justified.”

**John 3:5 ** “Jesus answered, "Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God.”

**John 3:36 **“He who believes in the Son has eternal life; he who does not obey the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God rests upon him.

John 14: 15 "If you love me, you will keep my commandments. “

Eph. 2:7- 7-10 that in the coming ages he might show the immeasurable riches of his grace in kindness toward us in Christ Jesus. 8 For by grace you have been saved through faith; and this is not your own doing, it is the gift of God – 9 not because of works, lest any man should boast. 10 For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them.

James 2: 14 What does it profit, my brethren, if a man says he has faith but has not works? Can his faith save him? If a brother or sister is ill-clad and in lack of daily food, and one of you says to them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled,” without giving them the things needed for the body, what does it profit? So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead. “ But some one will say, "You have faith and I have works***." Show me your faith apart from your works, and I by my works will show you my faith…*** Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he offered his son Isaac upon the altar? You see that faith was active along with his works, and faith was completed by works, and the scripture was fulfilled which says, “Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness”; and he was called the friend of God. You see that a man is justified by works and not by faith alone. For as the body apart from the spirit is dead, so faith apart from works is dead.

God Bless,
PLEASE let me know if there any other questions I can assist you with:thumbsup:

Pat
 
JRKH,

I have to respectfully disagree with you. You are leaving out the fact that works are necessary to maintaining a living faith. They complete our faith and help us to persevere in that faith.

The works result from the assent of our will to do the work prompted us by the Holy Spirit. But the works are not us “buying” our salvation, since they are not of us:

Paul says that God works in us both to will and to do. Willing is the first step. Doing is the second step.

The result of our doing is acting as an instrument of God.

It is the assent of our will that keeps our faith a living one. Now the assent of the will to agree with God to do His work is obviously a gift of God. Yet it is a necessary part of our having a living faith, one that does the works of God.

So works are necessary, not just to show, but to maintain, a living faith.

We are not saved by works, but maintained in faith by assenting to them.
There is NO Catholic teaching of a works salvation. It is false.
However, Works are an evidence of salvation (State of Grace) and an essential piece of evidence.
In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have saving Grace.
Biblically look here:
James 2:14-18
14 What does it profit, my brethren, if a man says he has faith but has not works? Can his faith save him? 15 If a brother or sister is ill-clad and in lack of daily food, 16 and one of you says to them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled,” without giving them the things needed for the body, what does it profit? 17 So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead. 18 But some one will say, “You have faith and I have works.” Show me your faith apart from your works, and I by my works will show you my faith.

It is obvious that a “dead faith” is not a saving faith so we must conclude that Faith and works are intertwined with works being one of the evidences of a proper and saving faith.

I hope this helps some…

Peace
James
I would agree with what you said if you said:
"Works (the physical end results) do not gain us salvation. However, by assenting to work we maintain a living faith and gain merit by being conformed to Christ’s obedience.

In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have Grace entering you to maintain a living, thus saving, Faith."

instead of:
"However, Works are an evidence of salvation (State of Grace) and an essential piece of evidence.

In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have saving Grace."

peace
steve
 
This is very well stated.
=thenobes;8272410]
The works result from the assent of our will to do the work prompted us by the Holy Spirit. But the works are not us “buying” our salvation, since they are not of us:
Paul says that God works in us both to will and to do. Willing is the first step. Doing is the second step.
The result of our doing is acting as an instrument of God.
Now the assent of the will to agree with God to do is obviously a gift of God. Yet it is a necessary part of our having a living faith, one that does the works of God.
So works are necessry, not just to show, but to maintain a living faith.
We are not saved by works, but maintained in faith by assenting to them.
It is through works of grace that our will is confomed to God’s will. Without cooperating with God 's grace, to do good works, our will remains attracted to sin and we begin to withdraw from God. Non-Catholics want to separate faith from works but that is like separating light from fire. We need both faith and works, both gifts of God, to be saved.
 
JRKH,

I have to respectfully disgree with you. You are leaving out the fact that works are necessary to maintain a living faith. They complete our faith and help us to perseverein that faith.

The works result from the assent of our will to do the work prompted us by the Holy Spirit. But the works are not us “buying” our salvation, since they are not of us:

Paul says that God works in us both to will and to do. Willing is the first step. Doing is the second step.

The result of our doing is acting as an instrument of God.

Now the assent of the will to agree with God to do is obviously a gift of God. Yet it is a necessary part of our having a living faith, one that does the works of God.

So works are necessry, not just to show, but to maintain a living faith.

We are not saved by works, but maintained in faith by assenting to them.

I would agree with what you said if you said:
"Works (the physical end results) do not gain us salvation. However, by assenting to work we maintain a living faith and gain merit by being conformed to Christ’s obedience.

In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have impetus to maintaining a saving Faith."

instead of:
"However, Works are an evidence of salvation (State of Grace) and an essential piece of evidence.

In other words, if you don’t have works, you don’t have saving Grace."

peace
steve
Steve,
Very nice post.
We are very much in agreement.
You have expressed it in a different and somewhat more detailed and integrated way than I did. Thanks 👍

Peace
James
 
If you don’t mind, I will illustrate the Catholic view of salvation in slightly different terms that I have found make them easier for some to understand.

We enter the state of grace through baptism. There are no requirements to do good works to be baptized, merely the desire to become a member of the Church and to live your life in a covenant relationship with Jesus. Entering the state of Grace is a pure gift born of faith. When we are baptized, we are freed of all prior sin, and we are given sufficient grace to do the works we are called to. In exchange, we agree to follow Jesus, which means doing His will , loving God and Neighbor.

If we are in the state of grace when we die, we will go to heaven. However, if we fail to follow Jesus and fall from grace through sin, we have broken the baptismal covenant and will be condemned to hell unless we reconcile with Jesus through the sacrament of reconciliation and reenter the state of grace. Note, that in God’s mercy, he will save us over and over again, not because of good works, but because we ask and because we repent of our sins. So we are saved, not through works but through faith and grace. But we need to do God’s will to stay in the state of grace and go to heaven.
 
Code:
I recall as a child the bilinqual (Latin/English) missal for mass. There were prayers in it, and after them would be printed in small print - "10 days indulgence" or "30 days indulgence". The idea was interpreted to me at that early age that each time you said that prayer you (or maybe a loved one, too - I forget) would spent that much less time in purgatory.

 The Protestants took issue with that sort of a point system. Attendance at mass counted toward salvation (and missing was a major sin), Various acts of worship - maybe novenas or retreats or eucharistic adoration, etc. - these all were worth so many points. Even self-inflicted suffering helped. Etc.
I just wanted to clear up something about this. The “days” that indulgences were describing were not “days” in Purgatory for yourself or a loved one that you could earn for them. The “days” noted for an indulgence were the equivalent of that many days of Penance a person would do. So if you did what was required for an indulgence worth 10 days, you had done works equal to 10 days of penance. It had nothing to do with how many days you could erase in Purgatory.
 
If you don’t mind, I will illustrate the Catholic view of salvation in slightly different terms that I have found make them easier for some to understand.

We enter the state of grace through baptism. There are no requirements to do good works to be baptized, merely the desire to become a member of the Church and to live your life in a covenant relationship with Jesus. Entering the state of Grace is a pure gift born of faith. When we are baptized, we are freed of all prior sin, and we are given sufficient grace to do the works we are called to. In exchange, we agree to follow Jesus, which means doing His will , loving God and Neighbor.

If we are in the state of grace when we die, we will go to heaven. However, if we fail to follow Jesus and fall from grace through sin, we have broken the baptismal covenant and will be condemned to hell **unless we reconcile **with Jesus through the sacrament of reconciliation and reenter the state of grace. Note, that in God’s mercy, he will save us over and over again, not because of good works, but because we ask and because we repent of our sins. So we are saved, not through works but through faith and grace. But we need to do God’s will to stay in the state of grace and go to heaven.
I’ve highlighted some of your words and I would say that confessing and repenting are works. Not natural works, but supernatural works prompted and completed by God’s grace.That is why James can say we are justified by works and not by faith only.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top