Do I need to go to confession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholicboy2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

catholicboy2

Guest
Yesterday, my dad said he was going in town - to Home Depot - and I knew just earlier that Home Depot was some how supporting homosexual marriage and I read many people saying to boycott it. I never read (at that time) not boycotting was a mortal sin (I found out later it wasn’t) and I just based on what I read I thought it might be. However, when I found out he was going there, I just couldn’t say not to go to Home Depot (he doesn’t practice any religion and I wasn’t sure if he’d care and I just couldn’t say anything for some reason). Now since I thought it might be a mortal sin, but yet didn’t do anything, do I need to go to confession?
 
never mind, I’ve decided that I should go to confession. I realize that since I thought I was in mortal sin, but yet continued it, I willfully went against my conscience and violated it in a grave way. It’s just when trying to inform my family on morals (whether they care about them or not) i get extremely nervous and it’s really hard for me say anything about it.
 
Yesterday, my dad said he was going in town - to Home Depot - and I knew just earlier that Home Depot was some how supporting homosexual marriage and I read many people saying to boycott it. I never read (at that time) not boycotting was a mortal sin (I found out later it wasn’t) and I just based on what I read I thought it might be. However, when I found out he was going there, I just couldn’t say not to go to Home Depot (he doesn’t practice any religion and I wasn’t sure if he’d care and I just couldn’t say anything for some reason). Now since I thought it might be a mortal sin, but yet didn’t do anything, do I need to go to confession?
I don’t think so, but go just in case.
 
Your father isn’t a Christian of any sorts by the sounds of it, so to him the concept of sin is different to ours.

You, on the other hand, owe your father a duty of respect and honour (from our first principles, ie. the Commandments). It would not normally be your case to instruct him in the matter of his own behaviour.

As regards confession, you are essentially confessing to an omission - a failure to act and which is thereby sinful. As it is, you now understand that that failure wasn’t sinful, no matter what you believed at the time. Since there was no action that was ACTUALLY sinful in its effect and your knowledge is now more perfect, you can rest assured that there is no need to confess, and certainly no mortal sin was committed.

Regarding boycotts, as I understand it, the Church has not decreed that its adherents should boycott this or that business although clearly one should be cautious about frequenting businesses that are set up exclusively for the purpose of promoting something sinful or immoral (such as pornography shops that might sell a rare product that has no sinful value). As Home Depot’s reason for being is entirely different, I really don’t see the sinfulness in making necessary purchases there. Withholding your custom is a personal choice by which you make your feelings known to the retailer concerned - it is no more than that.
 
Your father isn’t a Christian of any sorts by the sounds of it, so to him the concept of sin is different to ours.

You, on the other hand, owe your father a duty of respect and honour (from our first principles, ie. the Commandments). It would not normally be your case to instruct him in the matter of his own behaviour.

As regards confession, you are essentially confessing to an omission - a failure to act and which is thereby sinful. As it is, you now understand that that failure wasn’t sinful, no matter what you believed at the time. Since there was no action that was ACTUALLY sinful in its effect and your knowledge is now more perfect, you can rest assured that there is no need to confess, and certainly no mortal sin was committed.

Regarding boycotts, as I understand it, the Church has not decreed that its adherents should boycott this or that business although clearly one should be cautious about frequenting businesses that are set up exclusively for the purpose of promoting something sinful or immoral (such as pornography shops that might sell a rare product that has no sinful value). As Home Depot’s reason for being is entirely different, I really don’t see the sinfulness in making necessary purchases there. Withholding your custom is a personal choice by which you make your feelings known to the retailer concerned - it is no more than that.
that’s how I thought about it too for a while, but then I read this in the Rock Quick Questions section

Q:“
If you think that something is a mortal sin (even though it is only venial), and you go ahead and commit the sin, understanding that when you commit a mortal sin you would be cutting yourself off from sanctifying grace and greatly offending God, are you committing a mortal sin?

A:
In this case, the venial sin becomes mortal because a person ignores his conscience and commits a sin that violates his conscience in a grave way.

Under the heading “Erroneous Judgment,” the Catechism states, “A human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience. If he were deliberately to act against it, he would condemn himself. Yet it can happen that moral conscience remains in ignorance and makes erroneous judgments about acts to be performed or already committed” (1790).

When writing to the Romans, Paul speaks of a delicate pastoral situation in the first-century Church. There were many Jewish Christians who still believed that certain foods were unclean or otherwise forbidden (e.g., much of the meat sold in Gentile markets had been sacrificed to idols). Paul explained that none of these foods were really unclean or forbidden, but stressed that his readers should not do things that would tempt people into eating these foods if it would violate their consciences:
Then let us no more pass judgment on one another, but rather decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother. I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean in itself; but it is unclean for any one who thinks it unclean. If your brother is being injured by what you eat, you are no longer walking in love. Do not let what you eat cause the ruin of one for whom Christ died. (Rom 14:13–15)
The mortal consequences of sinning in this way are clear. Paul speaks of an individual being “destroyed” by violating his conscience in this way: “Do not, for the sake of food, destroy the work of God. Everything is indeed clean, but it is wrong for any one to make others fall by what he eats” (Rom 14:20). “But he who has doubts is condemned, if he eats, because he does not act from belief *; for whatever does not proceed from belief is sin” (Rom 14:23).

In the end, when all is said and done, we will stand alone before the judgment seat of God and “Christ will reveal the secret disposition of hearts and will render to each man according to his works and according to his acceptance or refusal of grace”(CCC 682).*
 
Yesterday, my dad said he was going in town - to Home Depot - and I knew just earlier that Home Depot was some how supporting homosexual marriage and I read many people saying to boycott it.
Hmmm…This sounds like a matter of politics not sin.

First of all, if we have to work out whenever we go shopping before we go shopping, which stores and which products are ok and not ok to buy or go to, we will never get anything done any more. Do we want to set up “certified Catholic products” in the same way certain other religions, like say Hinduism, Judaism and Islam do? After all we are supposed to be under the New Covenant; not the old one.

I don’t think that going any kind of depot store has ever been condemned as a sin either in the Bible or by the Church - whether or not a particular store supports gay marriage.

Secondly, mortal sin is the kind of sin that removes you from the grace of God. It kills faith in your life. That’s why it has the title “mortal”. If you are even thinking about whether or not you have committed a mortal sin and need to confess it, then it is more likely that you have not committed a mortal sin.

And yes Paul was speaking about freedom in Christ to do anything, but if anything that was done would cause a weaker person to lose faith then we should not do it. From memory Paul said he would even give up eating meat if eating meat caused someone of lesser faith to fall away.

So Paul was talking about what we do, not what we fail to do. There is a fine line between exhortation and unwanted proselytism. Sometimes just keeping quiet is the better thing to do. Think also about exactly what it was that you could not say to your father:

In this case was it the Love of Christ that you denied and could not proclaim, or just the presumed immorality and evil of Home Depot because they support gay marriage that you could not proclaim? Would it have served any purpose saying “I’m not going to Home Depot because they support gay marriage”? Would that have brought your dad closer to Christ?

If not then you probably did the right thing by not saying anything 🙂
 
It is good that you are going to confession.👍 If you thought you were committing a mortal sin and you went through with the act anyway you would be as guilty as a person guilty of commiting mortal sin. You went against your conscience in what you considered a grave way.
 
What you need to read up on is the distinction of ***material vs. formal cooperation ***in evil.
 
I would say that you sound young and inexperienced enough to have no business or obligation in trying to instruct a parent on complex or borderline moral issues. In my opinion I also think you are heading down the painful road to scrupulosity. That is something you might want to take up with your confessor.🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top