Do "liberal" Catholics really think this way?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AlanFromWichita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
***Quote:
Originally Posted by Monte RCMS
The Bible = women shaving their heads.
…Huh? I don’t understand.

Seriously … do a Google search [lots of hits] … it is a real biggie for neo-pagans who choose to attack the Bible.
Well, hurrah for neo-pagans.:rolleyes:
 
Please forgive my use of this question as an example. If a person is baptized Catholic, then no matter what they are or aren’t willing to do, to call herself Catholic is Truth, according to the Church, and calling herself a non-Catholic would then be a lie.

So to even suggest that she call herself anything other than Catholic, based on behavior, is against Church teachings. I know you were only asking and didn’t specifically call her a non-Catholic, but the implication is that one who isn’t sufficiently zealous cannot correctly call themselves Catholic.

Why not? I can’t think of a better time to ask questions, than when I’m in a class where they are teaching the answers to such questions. What would be a better time and place?

Alan
Yes, an EXTERNAL Catholic. I see your point, but think on that.
 
Adam and Eve questioned God about the forbidden fruit, look what happened to all of us, we were borne with the original sin except for the Virgin Mary.

Maybe instead of using external resource to have your question answered, you could turn within and pray.

No offense but all the sub division of the Catholic faith started with people not agreeing with the Catholic church or bible and came up with their own Christian version.

I took that path also and didn’t resonate with some stories from the bible etc…but today more then ever, i know that the Pope are always guided by the Holy Spirit and i trust them fully and the Catholic bible is to be trusted.

Blessings and love!
Yes, some of which was the Church’s own fault, truth be told. The Church is made of people and we do make mistakes. The more we own up to it the better.
 
Please forgive my use of this question as an example. If a person is baptized Catholic, then no matter what they are or aren’t willing to do, to call herself Catholic is Truth, according to the Church, and calling herself a non-Catholic would then be a lie.

So to even suggest that she call herself anything other than Catholic, based on behavior, is against Church teachings. I know you were only asking and didn’t specifically call her a non-Catholic, but the implication is that one who isn’t sufficiently zealous cannot correctly call themselves Catholic.

Why not? I can’t think of a better time to ask questions, than when I’m in a class where they are teaching the answers to such questions. What would be a better time and place?

Alan
Your doubts could spread to others. It would be wise to stick to independent research.
 
Oh, my. A brand new term: “External.” 😛

BTW I get a kick out of your location “in and out of grace.” ;D

Alan
I didn’t make that up, I promise you. Try looking it up.

As to the “in and out of Grace,” that is sadly no joke.
 
Your doubts could spread to others. It would be wise to stick to independent research.
I suppose this could be a problem if the “teachers” are not properly able to handle such questions. I have no experience in RCIA so I don’t know what those meetings are like.

Alan
 
I suppose this could be a problem if the “teachers” are not properly able to handle such questions. I have no experience in RCIA so I don’t know what those meetings are like.

Alan
Yes, sadly many such teachers are ill-equipped–not all, but many. The Church is in a sorry state as a whole, it would seem.
 
I used to consider myself a “Liberal Catholic”. I did so with pride. I was polluted with many protestant Heresys. I was aware of the dichotomy presented by some of them and spent about 15 years earnestly trying to sort out the Truth in a manner that met Reason and was not a rejection of my own conscience.

Remember these points:
  1. the importance of Reason in determining your Faith, has been upheld since Augustine and other early Church Fathers.
  2. this importance has been re-stressed by many of our recent successive Popes. Especially Benedict and Bl. John Paul II.
  3. the importance and Primacy of Personal Conscience is vital in Catholic Teaching. This however must not be used as an excuse for a poorly educated conscience or obstinate Heresy.
If I dont understand Church Teaching on an issue, but am seeking the truth to the best of my ability I am not a heretic. I may be uninformed or misinformed.

If I know the church teaches something, but it appears to me to be contradictory to other aspects of the Faith and Divine Revelation then I am obligated to Educate my conscience to resolve the conflict. If this results in a necessary conclusion that the Church is in Error, then I am conscience bound to follow that decision. However, that in itself would require me to be in error on the infallibility of the Ordinary Magisterium. Therefore what I now know as an article of faith is that if I see such a dichotomy then I am in error in my judgement and must work harder to resolve the problem correctly.

This was a very long and hard struggle for me.
The importance of Social Justice led me to align myself with Liberal and Socialist political ideologies.
An uninformed partial acceptance of Moral Relitivism led me to believe that a proper Christian view of morality shouldnt be imposed at the ballot box or necessarily preached to those who dont want to hear.

As I grew to know more about my Faith, and about the teachings of The Lord, and His Church I came to realise that my position was in error.
There are many areas of moral teaching and many areas of faith where the Church has not defined Dogmas, but has generally accepted doctrines. There is room for variety of opinion of these areas. However to dissent from the commonly held beliefs would be unwise in many of these areas. The opinions of the Magisterium and the past Fathers and Doctors of the Church should be considered Trustworthy sources.
There are other areas where the church has defined Dogma. These specific teachings (normally simple clear statements of a known Truth), require the definitive assent of all the faithful, and for all time. they are not subject to dissent. If you disagree you are in error. If you are in obstinate disagreement (refusal to accept the Truth) you are committing a grave sin, which may be Mortal. You may be placing yourself in a situation where you are no longer truly in communion with the Church.

Please note there is a big difference between Obstinate Refusal to accept a Dogmatic teaching of the Church, and being misinformed, or being in a state of invincible ignorance. (Invincible ignorance is the moral defence that a person truly does not know that a particular act is sinful or that a belief they hold is an error. It mitigates a sin which is objectively Grave Matter and leaves the sinner guilty of a venial sin or sometimes not guilty of any sin at all).
However if you refuse to investigate why the Church teaches something different from what you believe, then the defense of Invincible Ignorance is greatly reduced or negated.

e.g. A cradle catholic couple in the english speaking world who used A.B.C. for years, might have been unaware of the fact that the church considers this to be Grave Matter, or totally unaware of the fact that she teaches that this is a Sin.
However, due to the hugely public stance the church has taken in the USA on this matter in the past couple of years no catholic could legitimately claim that they were unaware that the church considers this to be a serious matter.
the moral protection of Invincible ignorance is subordinate to the moral imperitave to properly educate your conscience.
It therefore would make me propose that it is extremely unlikely that any english speaking person in the western world could be unaware of how strong a stance the Church has taken in speaking out against the abuse of conscience rights for employers in the area of supplying contraceptive and abortive services in the USA.

No Catholic can claim to have Invincible Ignorance if they have failed to notice the big row, and look at what the church teaches and why.

Of course some will have been led astray by the wolves in shepherds clothing that are the priests, nuns and brothers who reject the churches teaching in this area and insist on teaching a Liberal Agenda. The guilt of those sheep led astray by these false shepherds lies squarely on the souls of the false teachers.
 
For me, my journey to a deeper and more orthodox faith followed this path:
  1. The Eucharist is the true Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ.
  2. Only the Catholic and Orthodox Church have the validly ordained priests to Confect the Eucharist.
  3. “On this Rock I will build my church and the Gates of Hell will not prevail against it.”
  4. therefore there must be one true Church. Therefore it must be either the Catholic Church or the Orthodox Church. (or the combination)
  5. The Keys of Heaven and the power to “Bind and Loose” were granted to the Apostles, and in particuar to the Chair of Peter.
  6. Without an infallible Magisterium there can be no Bible, and no Church. it is essential to any confidence in any concept of True teaching. Therefore The Magisterium have to have the charism of Infalibility. The Primary seat of the Magisterium is the Chair Of Peter, to whom the power was explicitly granted. therefore the occupant of that seat must explicitly weild that power. i.e. the Pope must have the Charism of infallibility.
  7. Therefore any Doctrine which has been defined as belonging to the Deposit of Faith, and to be Definitively held by all believers for all time, or which has in other explicit words been defined as infallible by the Pope or by the Ordinary Magisterium acting together, must be treated as and accepted as infallible.
As I had reached this conclusion but still had major difficulties with some of those dogmas, I realised that I needed to understand why the church came to the conclusion that those doctrines were so important as to need to be defined infallibly.
I needed to overcome my false understandings, and the false teachings I had previously received. From a point of view of Faith, for me these revolved around the Role of Mary, and the doctrines of the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption.
At that point I realised I must not reject these teachings even If it didn’t understand them

There is a big difference between not rejecting a doctrine and understanding, accepting adopting and loving it.

That step took a further 10 years for me.
Since then I have become steadily more and more orthodox and conservative in my beliefs and understanding as my journey in the faith has continued.
 
There is a big difference between not rejecting a doctrine and understanding, accepting adopting and loving it.

That step took a further 10 years for me.
Since then I have become steadily more and more orthodox and conservative in my beliefs and understanding as my journey in the faith has continued.
Wow, thank you for your detailed testimony! 👍

There are a couple items I see some options for a different way to look at them; for example the importance that the Church teaches the same thing over time, compared to the importance that any given believer accepts them. I don’t know that I want to go into that now, or maybe even on this thread. But we have two major issues that I see – one is keeping the Church intact (and protected from going to hell) for the future, so that 100 or 1000 years from now we will at least have what we have now. The other is how many of the faithful actually “make use” of the resources the Church continues to offer. For example, it doesn’t hurt the Church if an individual believer goes off on a tangent, but for bishops or cardinals to go off on tangents, they bring risk to the Deposit of Faith. (If I’m using the term correctly.)

I have to cut this short because I promised my son I’d take him to the mall. There are many great thoughts on this thread. I was a bit concerned it would turn into a :slapfight: but it hasn’t; instead I am very glad I started it because I’m reading some wonderful posts by all of you! :clapping:

Thanks again. :tiphat:

Alan
 
Wow, thank you for your detailed testimony! 👍

There are a couple items I see some options for a different way to look at them; for example the importance that the Church teaches the same thing over time, compared to the importance that any given believer accepts them. I don’t know that I want to go into that now, or maybe even on this thread. But we have two major issues that I see – one is keeping the Church intact (and protected from going to hell) for the future, so that 100 or 1000 years from now we will at least have what we have now. The other is how many of the faithful actually “make use” of the resources the Church continues to offer. For example, it doesn’t hurt the Church if an individual believer goes off on a tangent, but for bishops or cardinals to go off on tangents, they bring risk to the Deposit of Faith. (If I’m using the term correctly.)

I have to cut this short because I promised my son I’d take him to the mall. There are many great thoughts on this thread. I was a bit concerned it would turn into a :slapfight: but it hasn’t; instead I am very glad I started it because I’m reading some wonderful posts by all of you! :clapping:

Thanks again. :tiphat:

Alan
You’re welcome.🙂
 
Adam and Eve questioned God about the forbidden fruit, look what happened to all of us, we were borne with the original sin except for the Virgin Mary.

Maybe instead of using external resource to have your question answered, you could turn within and pray.

No offense but all the sub division of the Catholic faith started with people not agreeing with the Catholic church or bible and came up with their own Christian version.

I took that path also and didn’t resonate with some stories from the bible etc…but today more then ever, i know that the Pope are always guided by the Holy Spirit and i trust them fully and the Catholic bible is to be trusted.

Blessings and love!
To be fair, Mary questioned too, but her questioning was ‘how shall this be?’ and not ‘this doesn’t make sense so why bother?’ or similar.

It probably still didn’t completely make sense even after the angel explained further - in fact probably not until after her Assumption 🙂 but she believed and assented nonetheless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top