Do Non-Christians go to hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter yuzurusan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For a non-Christian to be saved they must die with the supernatural virtues of faith, hope and charity in their souls, and must have true sorrow for all of their sins with perfect contrition. How many non-Christians possess the supernatural virtues with perfect contrition at the point of their death do you think? My guess is that very, very few do.
 
For a non-Christian to be saved they must die with the supernatural virtues of faith, hope and charity in their souls, and must have true sorrow for all of their sins with perfect contrition. How many non-Christians possess the supernatural virtues with perfect contrition at the point of their death do you think? My guess is that very, very few do.
Pope Francis says atheists can do good and go to heaven too!

catholic.org/hf/faith/story.php?id=51077

An atheist has no clue about their sinful ness, nor the need for any contrition.

Jim
 
Perhaps if you engage in dialogue there is a question that you can have answered?
There isn’t really a question I’d like to ask. I find the idea of exclusive salvation through a particular religion to be something of a strange and odd idea given Sikhi teaches that all humanity is the creation of Waheguru and so all people, regardless of culture or religion can find salvation as long as they focus on the love and worship of God. Sikhi is the easiest way to do this, but this is not to say other religions are in any way ‘wrong’.
 
Pope Francis says atheists can do good and go to heaven too!

catholic.org/hf/faith/story.php?id=51077

An atheist has no clue about their sinful ness, nor the need for any contrition.

Jim
Like I said, one must die with the supernatural virtues of faith, hope and charity in one’s soul, along with a perfect contrition. This is what the Church has taught for centuries. And I am with the perennial teaching of the Church. God bless you.
 
Like I said, one must die with the supernatural virtues of faith, hope and charity in one’s soul, along with a perfect contrition. This is what the Church has taught for centuries. And I am with the perennial teaching of the Church. God bless you.
How can an atheist have perfect contrition ?

Jim
 
I wonder if catholics might go to hell also? Like a corrupt pope for example?
 
How can an atheist have faith?
Who knows, but then ask how it is that Pope Francis that even atheist could end up in heaven?

Is he wrong?

I think Pope Francis understands that God does not reveal himself equally to all people, and faith is based on God’s revelation, however that may happen.

A person whom God has revealed himself most, will have more to answer for than one who has not received the gift of faith.

Why some people receive faith and others don’t, is a mystery.

Jim
 
Who knows
I’ll tell you how an atheist can have faith (and perfect contrition). He can have faith if he cooperates with grace. And he can have perfect contrition if he cooperates with grace and has faith, faith leading to hope and charity – charity in his soul being a requirement for perfect contrition. God bless you.
 
I’ll tell you how an atheist can have faith (and perfect contrition). He can have faith if he cooperates with grace. And he can have perfect contrition if he cooperates with grace and has faith, faith leading to hope and charity – charity in his soul being a requirement for perfect contrition. God bless you.
Then he wouldn’t be an atheist by definition but closer to an agnostic.

Jim
 
Then he wouldn’t be an atheist by definition but closer to an agnostic.

Jim
No, he would not be agnostic either (agnostics do not possess the supernatural virtues of faith, hope and charity in their souls while being agnostic at the same time, nor can they have perfect contrition without faith, hope and charity). Implicitly, this former atheist would be Catholic. You were right to say that he wouldn’t be an actual atheist if he had the supernatural virtues of faith, hope and charity in his soul with perfect contrition., but you have failed to recognize that agnostics haven’t faith in God either-- and faith is a prerequisite for hope and charity, which is a prerequisite for perfect contrition… My point is that atheists can not be saved because they have not faith, hope, and charity in their souls along with perfect contrition. – All of these are required for their salvation. Once they possess these, they cease to be atheist and are united implicitly to the Mystical Body of Christ. They then are to be considered Catholic, if only implicitly. God bless you.
 
How can an atheist have faith?
I know this isn’t really what you’re asking, but in general atheists have great faith. Most seem to have great faith in the principle that Science is the answer to all of our questions, even though, paradoxically, Science cannot prove that it is the answer to all of our questions.

In addition, they have great faith in believing things that they’ve been told, even if they never investigate the facts on their own. They believe something because they have faith in the one who told them this particular fact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top