Do Protestants have eternal life abiding in them?

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

WesleyF

Guest
Jesus said “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.” (John 6:53-54)

Since Protestants don’t have the Eucharist, I think a Catholic must believe that they don’t have eternal life abiding in them. What is the Catholic church’s position on this?
 
In paragragh 847 of the CCC, it states
This affirmation is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church:
Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.
The sacraments are normative necessity, not absolutely necessity. Humans are bound to the sacraments because we receive God’s grace through them. However, God is not bound to them, and He will give them salvation if they are in His grace.

People (like Catholics) that knows the true teaching on the Sacrament of the Eucharist are bound to it and must participate in it (unless we are in mortal sin; therefore, we must go to confession before we can participate again). Deliberately not participating in the Eucharist is denying Christ and results into serious consequences.

However, there are people out there (like Protestants) that do not understand this teaching (as well as others) do to various circumstances- concesquence of the Reformation for example. God desires everyone to come to Heaven (1 Tim 2: 4). If a person is invisibly ignorant to the teachings of Christ but are seeking Him, God will not hold them accountable because they do not know what they are doing (Jn 15: 21-22). However, if they deliberately and knowingly denying this teaching (as well as others), they will be severe consequences.
 
In paragragh 847 of the CCC, it states

The sacraments are normative necessity, not absolutely necessity. Humans are bound to the sacraments because we receive God’s grace through them. However, God is not bound to them, and He will give them salvation if they are in His grace.

People (like Catholics) that knows the true teaching on the Sacrament of the Eucharist are bound to it and must participate in it (unless we are in mortal sin; therefore, we must go to confession before we can participate again). Deliberately not participating in the Eucharist is denying Christ and results into serious consequences.

However, there are people out there (like Protestants) that do not understand this teaching (as well as others) do to various circumstances- concesquence of the Reformation for example. God desires everyone to come to Heaven (1 Tim 2: 4). If a person is invisibly ignorant to the teachings of Christ but are seeking Him, God will not hold them accountable because they do not know what they are doing (Jn 15: 21-22). However, if they deliberately and knowingly denying this teaching (as well as others), they will be severe consequences.
Exactly.

Otherwise, infants would likewise be damned, or at least all of those children who had reached the age of reason but not their First Communion.
 
I’m not entirely sure of what you mean by ‘having eternal life abiding in them’.
Although outside the Church, their eternal life might be ‘latent’, so to speak. Through the prayers of the Catholic Church and the Sacrifice of the Mass, along with their own personal faith in Jesus they might have eternal life coming to them.
Does that relate to your pole question?
 
Jesus said “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.” (John 6:53-54)

Since Protestants don’t have the Eucharist, I think a Catholic must believe that they don’t have eternal life abiding in them. What is the Catholic church’s position on this?
As Paul tells us in 1 Cor. 11:27-29 we must examine ourselves before we take the Eucharist which is the body and blood of Christ. The True Presence, the body, soul and divinity of Christ exists only in the Catholic and Orthodox Church through the priesthood.

Paul is telling us that we must be in the state of grace in order to receive communion.Therefore Jesus is giving us a guarantee that whoever eats His flesh and drinks His blood (assuming he is in the state of grace) will have His life within them and will be raised up on the last day.

A Protestant can also have grace within them through baptism and by making a perfect contrition whenever they sin. Because the Catholic Church has seven sacraments it has available for her members, that faithfully partake of them, more means of grace to attain eternal life.
 
**Jesus said to the “good thief”;

"And he said to him, “Truly, I say to you, today you will be with me in Paradise.” (LK 23:43)

God’s Mercy is Infinite & i believe that we will all be given one last chance to repent & believe the Gospel of Jesus Christ, our Lord & Savior, at the moment of our death!
**
Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!

mark
 
I don’t think my question has been addressed properly.

By eternal life abiding in someone, I mean one already has on earth the eternal life, which, I think, Protestants will receive after death only.

A Catholic has Jesus abiding in him in a real and true sense after receiving the Eucharist.** Isn’t this the meaning of eternal life**?? Since Jesus himself is the eternal life (John 14:6), only those who receive the Eucharist could have eternal life abiding in them. Protestants don’t have this. According to me, they will have it after death only.

Otherwise Jesus’ statement, " unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you", doesn’t make any sense.
 
I voted other. Some do and some don’t. Some Protestants may be in a state of grace while others may be in as state of mortal sin.
 
Your question begs the question: do those who are Catholic only by name and repetitive action (i.e. the son who doesn’t really believe in God but takes the Eucharist to pacify his mother) have eternal life? Do you put that in contrast to a Baptist missionary in the Congolese jungle who is spreading the Gospel, who you say does not have eternal life? I think you may be narrowing in a bit too much on John 6 (and also there are many ways that Protestants interpret this message differently, see jesuswalk.com/lords-supper/8_john6.htm for a reference). Perhaps a better question is “Does entering into full communion with God require the Eucharist?”
 
I don’t think my question has been addressed properly.

By eternal life abiding in someone, I mean one already has on earth the eternal life, which, I think, Protestants will receive after death only.

A Catholic has Jesus abiding in him in a real and true sense after receiving the Eucharist.** Isn’t this the meaning of eternal life**?? Since Jesus himself is the eternal life (John 14:6), only those who receive the Eucharist could have eternal life abiding in them. Protestants don’t have this. According to me, they will have it after death only.

Otherwise Jesus’ statement, " unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you", doesn’t make any sense.
Asking if you have eternal life in you is like asking if you are immortal. Immortality cannot be realized or demonstrated until you live forever. So if I claim to have eternal life in me, what would be the evidence for that? How could anyone say I didn’t? Put another way: eternal life means never dying. The only way you could have it is if you never died.

If this isn’t the criterion for eternal life, anyone could say, “Hey, I have eternal life!” and you couldn’t contradict them. The only way to test it is if they would go through physical death and come out alive. Most people are not willing to make this test.

We need to have some definitions here!
 
I need more (name removed by moderator)uts. Nobody has answered to my satisfaction.
 
I need more (name removed by moderator)uts. Nobody has answered to my satisfaction.
The following is just my speculation 🙂
but from what I’ve read on the Eucharist, it seems that when we receive Communion, Jesus becomes one with us on a deeper level than only spiritually. And He imparts His own life to us. Protestants do not have this… they can still obtain eternal life if they are repentant of sin and don’t intentionally and knowingly reject the Church, etc, - God alone knows and can judge people’s hearts, but - here on earth they don’t have this close union with Jesus that we can have in the Blessed Sacrament. That is why we should pray for everyone to come to know this gift too 🙂 the Eucharist is a foretaste of Heaven, it’s a union with God where He gives us Himself and fills us with His grace and life, - and it is eternal life. We have eternal life because we are IN Him and with Him - because we are in Christ and He lives in us. Through Communion, we can start living the type of life that is closest to life in Heaven. I think that maybe that is what Jesus meant 🙂

If eternal life comes from being united to God… and in the Eucharist we are united to Him… then in the Eucharist, we experience eternal life, though we are not yet in Heaven and don’t yet have the beatific vision. Protestants have a limited experience of this because they can only have a spiritual Communion, unfortunately. Though Jesus is with them also, - something different and special happens in Communion.

God bless!
 
Im not sure what you would define present eternal life as (such as for members of the church after baptism but before first holy communion) but the dogmatic constitution on the Church #15 and decree on ecumenism #3 make clear for me that communities and people that are truly called Christian and though the constancy varies among Protestants they " can be rightly described as capable of providing access to the community of salvation."

Although, as stated Christ’s Catholic Church alone is where “the fullness of the means of salvation can be obtained”

Without making the Church life reductionistic, the grace of new life (regeneration) is in baptism, and as our “brothers in the Lord” clearly have the affirmative.

IMO God answers the prayers which we pray, we ask for his presence and get it, Calvinists only ask to be feed spiritually, so its likely the Holy Spirit answers their prayers and Baptists/ Pentecostals only want to remember the cross and passon at communion, so no doubt they remember the passion during their rememberance.

As highlight, this is only my personal opinion and not dogmatic teaching.
 
Protestants have a limited experience of this because they can only have a spiritual Communion, unfortunately. Though Jesus is with them also, - something different and special happens in Communion.
So is it then safe to say that they don’t really have eternal life abiding in them?
 
So is it then safe to say that they don’t really have eternal life abiding in them?
I can’t really say… I don’t know, sorry!

I think since Jesus said that we need the Eucharist for Him to really abide in us, for His eternal life to be in us… then this is what He said, and that means that we do need the Eucharist for this.

It’s hard to understand because Protestants are able to receive eternal life, but… maybe what we’re talking about here is more about a union with God, where He dwells within us and gives us His life… rather than only being saved at one’s death and going to Heaven. Maybe what we’re talking about here is the person’s experience of God here on earth. In that case, - yes Protestants have a limited experience of this due to them not having the Sacraments.

Maybe it’s best to not speculate on the spiritual condition of Protestants and others 🙂
 
Maybe it’s best to not speculate on the spiritual condition of Protestants and others 🙂
Maybe it is. Imagine a Catholic going up to a Protestant and saying, “Don’t you want eternal life to abide in you? Come to the Catholic church. Receive the Eucharist.”

If Protestants can do this to Catholics all the time, why can’t Catholics do the same to Protestants?

Jesus clearly said that unless we eat his flesh and drink his blood we cannot have eternal life. I am talking about eternal life here on earth itself, not after this life. Protestants who are invincibly ignorant of the Catholic faith but faithful to God will receive eternal life after their death, but if we really believe what Jesus said then we must conclude that they cannot receive it here on earth, whereas we Catholics can.
 
You really dont think C.S. Lewis (among others) didnt have eternal life in them? 😃 Sorry, but the idea sounds so ridiculous.

The church can really quote from whichever part of its tradition which it likes.

If you wanted them to have eternal life in the RCs position you would find it, Vatican II calls them christian and they have graces of the Holy Spirit and are communities of salvation.

often people want wedge issues to divide, because they enjoy division. 1 Cor 12-14 teaches that we shouldnt view Christis body this way

I follow Cephas, Apollos and paul.

Think of it this way, The Roman Church looks to Peter and his sucessors, The Orthodox to the Alexandrian among them and the Reformed to Paul’s doctrine of Justification.
 
Maybe it is. Imagine a Catholic going up to a Protestant and saying, “Don’t you want eternal life to abide in you? Come to the Catholic church. Receive the Eucharist.”

If Protestants can do this to Catholics all the time, why can’t Catholics do the same to Protestants?

Jesus clearly said that unless we eat his flesh and drink his blood we cannot have eternal life. I am talking about eternal life here on earth itself, not after this life. Protestants who are invincibly ignorant of the Catholic faith but faithful to God will receive eternal life after their death, but if we really believe what Jesus said then we must conclude that they cannot receive it here on earth, whereas we Catholics can.
if you mean here on earth… it might be like that, since Jesus said this about the Eucharist. 🙂
You really dont think C.S. Lewis (among others) didnt have eternal life in them? 😃 Sorry, but the idea sounds so ridiculous.
we don’t mean about a person’s ultimate salvation… but about a person’s experience of it here on earth. It IS fuller, with the Eucharist. Jesus said this and the Church teaches us the same 🙂 having the Eucharist is significant and important.
often people want wedge issues to divide, because they enjoy division. 1 Cor 12-14 teaches that we shouldnt view Christis body this way
but according to Catholic teaching, Protestants ARE divided from the visible Church. It is not based on truth to pretend that a unity exists, when it does not. They have an imperfect link with the Church but there is no unity… there link is through baptism… they are missing all the other Sacraments

the Bible is talking about division in the Church (Catholic Church) - not about people who have left the Church (Luther et al). If someone has left… the only way to achieve unity is for them to come back… 🙂 keep in mind that we believe the Church is visible not only invisible.

God bless
 
Jesus said “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.” (John 6:53-54)

Since Protestants don’t have the Eucharist, I think a Catholic must believe that they don’t have eternal life abiding in them. What is the Catholic church’s position on this?
Hi Wesley,
Since your focus seems to be on the Eucharist, here is what a fairly well-known Catholic Cardinal said the a Lutheran bishop:
I count among the most important results of the ecumenical dialogues the insight that the issue of the eucharist cannot be narrowed to the problem of ‘validity.’ Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession, such as that which holds in the Catholic and in the Orthodox church, need not in any way deny the salvation-granting presence of the Lord in a Lutheran Lord’s Supper
Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger

Does that respond to your question? 🙂

Jon
 
Hi Wesley,
Since your focus seems to be on the Eucharist, here is what a fairly well-known Catholic Cardinal said the a Lutheran bishop:

Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger

Does that respond to your question? 🙂

Jon
I do not know what he means by “salvation granting presence”. So it doesn’t really respond to my question. By the way, that was said by a cardinal, not an infallible pope, so I am in no way bound to hold to his theological opinions. If by “salvation granting presence”, he means that Jesus is present body, blood, soul and divinity in the Lutheran Lord’s supper, then he is obviously wrong. But I would like to give him the benefit of the doubt and say that he probably means something else by “salvation granting presence”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top