Do Protestants know where we got the Bible?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jim_Dandy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you mean the slavery issue? If so, yes.
I’m impressed, Rag Hanger. I was never told anything about this connection in all my years in Southern Baptist Churches. It was never discussed. I told one of my best friends about it recently. She was shocked. She too grew up in the Southern Baptist Church. We are both in our 50’s.

So, where ever you are; I’d say your Church is doing well to educate your congregation.

Peace,
Anna
 
I’m impressed, Rag Hanger. I was never told anything about this connection in all my years in Southern Baptist Churches. It was never discussed. I told one of my best friends about it recently. She was shocked. She too grew up in the Southern Baptist Church. We are both in our 50’s.

So, where ever you are; I’d say your Church is doing well to educate your congregation.

Peace,
Anna
Thanks. It’s not just us, though. Most Baptist churches I know of have similar classes. In fact, most require a basic working knowledge of Christian doctrine and Christian and Baptist history for membership.
 
My experience is just the opposite. I have yet to meet any Protestant that doesn’t know where the Bible came from.

Sorry I erased the first part of your quote. If your friend really told you this, then she’s the exception, not the rule. Most Baptist churches take church history very seriously.
If Southern Baptist took Church history seriously they would be Catholic! 👍

Matthew
 
If Southern Baptist took Church history seriously they would be Catholic! 👍

Matthew
And if Catholics took the Bible seriously, they’d be Protestants! 👍

See? Two can play at that game. But, personally, I’d rather not because just hurling childish insults at one another isn’t very productive and I don’t consider it to be honoring to Christ…

But look at the bright side: now I know where to start putting people on my ignore list.
 
And if Catholics took the Bible seriously, they’d be Protestants! 👍

See? Two can play at that game. But, personally, I’d rather not because just hurling childish insults at one another isn’t very productive and I don’t consider it to be honoring to Christ…

But look at the bright side: now I know where to start putting people on my ignore list.
Protestants in general only study Church history from the reformation forward!
And NO i’m not playing games. This is a hard core fact my friend.

Matthew
 
And if Catholics took the Bible seriously, they’d be Protestants! 👍

See? Two can play at that game. But, personally, I’d rather not because just hurling childish insults at one another isn’t very productive and I don’t consider it to be honoring to Christ…

But look at the bright side: now I know where to start putting people on my ignore list.
Back to the O.P. Where did we get The Bible? 🍿

Matthew
 
Protestants in general only study Church history from the reformation forward!
It’s unfortunate that you would believe that but, given the many misconceptions about Protestantism I’ve seen here, not surprising.

I’m not sure where you got the idea that we don’t study pre-Reformation Church History, but it isn’t true.
Back to the O.P. Where did we get The Bible?
We got the books that make up the Bible from the men who wrote them under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. We got the canon of scripture from the Church.
 
It’s unfortunate that you would believe that but, given the many misconceptions about Protestantism I’ve seen here, not surprising.

I’m not sure where you got the idea that we don’t study pre-Reformation Church History, but it isn’t true.
Unfortunately it is true. I have many friends that are protestant. When ever religion comes up i will ask if they have ever read the Early Church Fathers? They have no idea what i’m talking about. What are the origins of The Bible? Most have no idea. They only seem to know what they have been thought. I don’t know what they have been thought but it certainly is not early Church history!

Matthew
 
Unfortunately it is true. I have many friends that are protestant.
I’m sorry your friends are lazy, but that doesn’t negate the fact that it is taught. Our seminaries even have degrees in pre-Reformation history. Our church actually had to turn people away from our history classes last semester.
When ever religion comes up i will ask if they have ever read the Early Church Fathers?
And they may not have. But that doesn’t mean that they didn’t have the opportunity within Protestantism to do so.
They have no idea what i’m talking about. What are the origins of The Bible? Most have no idea. They only seem to know what they have been thought. I don’t know what they have been thought but it certainly is not early Church history!
And did they take it upon themselves to seek out any of the countless resources within Protestantism? Did they go to another church to attend their classes? Did they contact a seminary? Did they go to the library? Did they go to Monergism.com and check out any of the more than five pages of pre-Reformation history resources?
 
I’m sorry your friends are lazy, but that doesn’t negate the fact that it is taught. Our seminaries even have degrees in pre-Reformation history. Our church actually had to turn people away from our history classes last semester.

And they may not have. But that doesn’t mean that they didn’t have the opportunity within Protestantism to do so.

And did they take it upon themselves to seek out any of the countless resources within Protestantism? Did they go to another church to attend their classes? Did they contact a seminary? Did they go to the library? Did they go to Monergism.com and check out any of the more than five pages of pre-Reformation history resources?
I’m just speaking from experience from the protestants i know…and i’m in the Bible belt!
Now how about getting back to the question at hand… Where did we get The Bible?

Matthew
 
Matthew P Muehl:
Now how about getting back to the question at hand… Where did we get The Bible?

Matthew
Same answer I gave you last time you asked. If my answer was not clear enough for you, then you may ask me to clarify it for you. But don’t ignore it. That’s just rude.
 
Same answer I gave you last time you asked. If my answer was not clear enough for you, then you may ask me to clarify it for you. But don’t ignore it. That’s just rude.
Where i’m i being rude! You have NOT answered my or the op’s question.
What are the origins of The Bible?

Matthew
 
I’m sorry your friends are lazy, but that doesn’t negate the fact that it is taught. Our seminaries even have degrees in pre-Reformation history. Our church actually had to turn people away from our history classes last semester.

And they may not have. But that doesn’t mean that they didn’t have the opportunity within Protestantism to do so.

And did they take it upon themselves to seek out any of the countless resources within Protestantism? Did they go to another church to attend their classes? Did they contact a seminary? Did they go to the library? Did they go to Monergism.com and check out any of the more than five pages of pre-Reformation history resources?
I know your post is a response to Matthew P Muehl; but you are painting a picture of Protestantism that I’ve certainly not encountered. I grew up in Southern Baptist Churches and have friends who are fundamentalist/evangelical Christians. Most concentrate on Scripture and have no clue about the history of Christianity.

When I started studying on my own, I tried to talk to some of my Protestant friends about what I was reading. It didn’t go over very well.

A long-time friend of mine came for a one-week visit. She was affiliated with a New Life Church, if I recall correctly. She was absolutely horrified by the books I was reading. She refused to discuss anything, clung to her KJV of the Bible, and treated me like I was the Devil himself—and she was my house guest. It was one of the most disturbing and hurtful experiences I’ve ever had with a close friend.

Maybe Protestants are more educated where you live. I will not question what you claim as your experience. I’m simply saying, my experience has been the very opposite of what you describe.

Peace,
Anna
 
I know your post is a response to Matthew P Muehl; but you are painting a picture of Protestantism that I’ve certainly not encountered.
I’m sorry that your experience was not a typical Protestant experience. If it had been, I believe you would have found it quite satisfying.
A long-time friend of mine came for a one-week visit. She was affiliated with a New Life Church, if I recall correctly. She was absolutely horrified by the books I was reading. She refused to discuss anything, clung to her KJV of the Bible, and treated me like I was the Devil himself—and she was my house guest. It was one of the most disturbing and hurtful experiences I’ve ever had with a close friend.
I don’t know what a “New Life” church is, but it doesn’t sound like she would fit in very well at any of the Protestant churches I’m aware of.
 
I know your post is a response to Matthew P Muehl; but you are painting a picture of Protestantism that I’ve certainly not encountered. I grew up in Southern Baptist Churches and have friends who are fundamentalist/evangelical Christians. Most concentrate on Scripture and have no clue about the history of Christianity.

When I started studying on my own, I tried to talk to some of my Protestant friends about what I was reading. It didn’t go over very well.

A long-time friend of mine came for a one-week visit. She was affiliated with a New Life Church, if I recall correctly. She was absolutely horrified by the books I was reading. She refused to discuss anything, clung to her KJV of the Bible, and treated me like I was the Devil himself—and she was my house guest. It was one of the most disturbing and hurtful experiences I’ve ever had with a close friend.

Maybe Protestants are more educated where you live. I will not question what you claim as your experience. I’m simply saying, my experience has been the very opposite of what you describe.

Peace,
Anna
I grew up in a moderately large SBC church. There was no formal course or study required for church membership, no emphasis on church history, no classes in these things, AFAIK. My father, a book person (who would have thought it?) had considerable Church history around the house, and I knew the origin of the SBC from my own readings in history, but I don’t recall it coming up in any way at the Church.

I was no longer an active Baptist, after around 1965, so my experience reflects …my experience.

GKC
 
I’m sorry that your experience was not a typical Protestant experience. If it had been, I believe you would have found it quite satisfying.
Rag Hanger,
Actually, it was study of both Holy Scripture and the history of Christianity that led me to leave the Baptist Church.

Peace,
Anna
 
I grew up in a moderately large SBC church. There was no formal course or study required for church membership, no emphasis on church history, no classes in these things, AFAIK. My father, a book person (who would have thought it?) had considerable Church history around the house, and I knew the origin of the SBC from my own readings in history, but I don’t recall it coming up in any way at the Church.

I was no longer an active Baptist, after around 1965, so my experience reflects …my experience.

GKC
Hey GKC,

Good to see you on a non-Anglican thread (though I love your participation on those threads.) 😉

Each of us can really only speak from our own experience. 🙂

Peace,
Anna
 
Rag Hanger,
Actually, it was study of both Holy Scripture and the history of Christianity that led me to leave the Baptist Church.

Peace,
Anna
That’s ironic. It was the study of both Holy Scripture and the history of Christianity that led me to leave Catholicism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top