Do some Catholic hospitals perform abortions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Moore11
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In Australia I don’t know of any Catholic hospitals which perform abortions but I know of one in Victoria which refers for abortions. 😦 I can’t tell the arch bishop because I know this from a conversation with a family member who would deny telling me, citing confidentiality issues.😦
 
In Australia I don’t know of any Catholic hospitals which perform abortions but I know of one in Victoria which refers for abortions. 😦 I can’t tell the arch bishop because I know this from a conversation with a family member who would deny telling me, citing confidentiality issues.😦
So its "Catholic" in name only. i dont blame you for being upset.

This is what should be done to any “Catholic” hospital which defies the Church`s infallible teachings on Faith and Morals:
ncregister.com/blog/jimmy-akin/bishop-strips-abortion-hospital-of-catholic-status
 
What I am asking is if there are Hospitals that are Catholic that perform abortions chemical or surgical? It seems pretty strait forward but I cant get a clear answer anywhere?
Either they do or they dont.🤷
 
I would hope not. If they do then they shouldn’t be allowed to call themselves Catholic.
 
What I am asking is if there are Hospitals that are Catholic that perform abortions chemical or surgical? It seems pretty strait forward but I cant get a clear answer anywhere?
Either they do or they dont.🤷
If you can’t get an answer then isn’t that the answer? They don’t!!
 
What I am asking is if there are Hospitals that are Catholic that perform abortions chemical or surgical? It seems pretty strait forward but I cant get a clear answer anywhere?
Either they do or they dont.🤷
Off-hand, I don’t know any that do as a general practice, but like you, I’m ignorant on that topic. But the above mentioned Arizona case shows that they have done them in the past. One way to go about it would be to search hospital by hospital online, I suppose.
 
If you can’t get an answer then isn’t that the answer? They don’t!!
I’n not sure that is true. It would seem odd that a yes or no Question has so little information on it. I personally think it is because sometimes abortions are not called abortions.
We hear about Catholic schools that refer to Planned parenthood and provide Birth Control and Catholic hospitals that do the same, especially in the wake of the HHS debacle but I find it odd that I seem to be the only one asking these questions. My gut would tell me that they dont offer the procedure but that abortions are probably done for “medical reasons”
 
What I am asking is if there are Hospitals that are Catholic that perform abortions chemical or surgical? It seems pretty strait forward but I cant get a clear answer anywhere?
Either they do or they dont.🤷
Moore
Can you clarify a little more what you mean by “abortion”?

e.g. do you mean a procured abortion?
e.g. by “abortion” are you referring to (i) a *medical procedure *that kills/removes the foetus, embryo or blastocyst or (ii) the *human act *as defined by the Catholic Church?
 
Moore
Can you clarify a little more what you mean by “abortion”?

e.g. do you mean a procured abortion?
e.g. by “abortion” are you referring to (i) a *medical procedure *that kills/removes the foetus, embryo or blastocyst or (ii) the *human act *as defined by the Catholic Church?
Abortion. Killing a baby before it is born. Not talking about the principle of double effect but rather abortions that would go against Church teaching.

Amazing that there is not strait answer on this.
Is it the hospitals dirty little secret and something they do by "renaming it’
 
What I am asking is if there are Hospitals that are Catholic that perform abortions chemical or surgical? It seems pretty strait forward but I cant get a clear answer anywhere?
Either they do or they dont.🤷
Of course there are hospitals that perform them, usually in emergency situations, and we know this because they get in trouble when it is found out. For example, the hospital in Phoenix who did an emergency surgery on a woman at risk with pulmonary hypertension. They had to involve their eithics committee and when the ethics committee found the surgery necessary for the woman, they performed it. It was all over the news when it happened. Does that answer your question?

I would think that “abortions” are likely to happen more in any insitution when the situation is ethically questionable, such as when the woman’s health is at risk, and/or in emergency situations. More hospitals are willing to err on the side of the woman due to lawsuits when the woman can acutally die without intervention. When someone dies due to the neglect of physicians or staff, a whole lot of licenses are at risk and malpractice insurance goes up, and it tarnishes the reputation of all involved. Citing ‘religious beliefs’ will only carry one so far when a serious injury and/or death is involved as a result.

In general though, no, they are not supposed to. I can’t imagine a Catholic hospital scheduling a non-emergency, elective abortion though. They may be out there, but I don’t know how you would find out if this happens. They didn’t schedule such procedures in both of the Catholic hospitals I used to work for years ago. And there were never any Phoenix-drama-epsiodes at either of them. But then, there were nearby secular hospitals, at which physicians used to take their procedures that were in conflict with Catholic teachings. If a Catholic hospital was isolated, perhaps their situation would be different. I don’t know.
 
Abortion. Killing a baby before it is born. Not talking about the principle of double effect but rather abortions that would go against Church teaching.

Amazing that there is not strait answer on this.
Is it the hospitals dirty little secret and something they do by "renaming it’
Moore
I find it hard to understand what the difficulty is you are having. You ask for a straight question yet I feel your question is far from straight forward both in content and in the unspoken emotion that surges between the lines. This may explain why you interpret responses as apparantly wishy-washy.

I do not understand why you would think anyone here has access to the statistics you are nominally (but probably not really) requesting? I think you know as well as we do that a Catholic Hospital is hardly likely to keep a register of what you call abortions (I am still not sure you have committed to a clear personal definition of what you mean by “abortion” as your response above is far from straight on this matter).

How about a restart and tell us what is really on your mind?
 
Moore
I find it hard to understand what the difficulty is you are having. You ask for a straight question yet I feel your question is far from straight forward both in content and in the unspoken emotion that surges between the lines. This may explain why you interpret responses as apparantly wishy-washy.

I do not understand why you would think anyone here has access to the statistics you are nominally (but probably not really) requesting? I think you know as well as we do that a Catholic Hospital is hardly likely to keep a register of what you call abortions (I am still not sure you have committed to a clear personal definition of what you mean by “abortion” as your response above is far from straight on this matter).

How about a restart and tell us what is really on your mind?
So another ambiguous response.

Of course I am really requesting this. A freind and I were talking about this in the wake of the HHS mandate and I asserted that I think they do. He said, basically “prove it” and I tried. You would think that with all the stats that are gathered. on all the procedures in all the hospitals there would be stats on this. It is frustrating that there arent. I can look at “Catholic” colleges that refer people to PP and provide BC to faculty and students so one would think there would be some record keeping on something like killing an unborn baby.🤷
Seriously, it is a yes or no question. No fudging on the terminology or circumstances. Do Catholic hospitals kill unborn babies? period.
 
So another ambiguous response.

Of course I am really requesting this. A freind and I were talking about this in the wake of the HHS mandate and I asserted that I think they do. He said, basically “prove it” and I tried. You would think that with all the stats that are gathered. on all the procedures in all the hospitals there would be stats on this. It is frustrating that there arent. I can look at “Catholic” colleges that refer people to PP and provide BC to faculty and students so one would think there would be some record keeping on something like killing an unborn baby.🤷
Seriously, it is a yes or no question. No fudging on the terminology or circumstances. Do Catholic hospitals kill unborn babies? period.
Moore
Can you humour me with a clarification.
I guess you live in the good old USofA where acronyms like HHS, PP and BC are used all the time in the media and national politics? This is an international forum so it may be helpful to other readers (apart from myself) to spell them out. You may not believe this, but we don’t actually get a lot of US national news just as you probably don’t get to hear much about day to day national/political concerns in Australia or other English speaking countries. I guessed that BC means birth control but the others?

I note you haven’t really addressed my question.
If a Catholic Hospital was regularly performing what you call “abortions” (a definition which still appears somewhat inchoate) do you really think it is to the advantage of the adminstrators with Catholic Church oversight to:
(a) call these procedures abortions
(b) put them on their Register of medical procedures
(c) make this available to the public
(d) send these stats off to their local Bishop each year?

So yes, your request does seem to be a little disingenuous at first pass but maybe I do not understand something?

I have no doubt that unborn babies do sometimes get killed in Catholic hospitals.
However such a rare medical procedure, if justified by Catholic principles (I believe there are exceptions other than the principle of double effect), would, correctly, not be recorded “abortion” by the Catholic Ethics committee involved.
(A secular hospital may well call this procedure an abortion because for them abortion is simply a physical/medical definition not a moral one as is the case with the Church).

Your somewhat biased speculation "… is it something they do by “renaming it?” suggests you may have difficulties appreciating the latter point. Perhaps I am mistaken.
 
What I am asking is if there are Hospitals that are Catholic that perform abortions chemical or surgical? It seems pretty strait forward but I cant get a clear answer anywhere?
Either they do or they dont.🤷
Hospitals don’t perform abortions. Doctors perform abortions.

Doctors may have offices at hospitals or have private offices and have privileges to treat or visit their patients in nearby hosptials.

Catholic hospitals will have a public policy of not allowing abortions to be performed on their premises. What goes on in every office behind closed doors is not knowable and some abortions may take place in Catholic hosptials. Some hospital administrators may not care, but if it became publicly known that abortions were being performed in a Catholic hospital a bishop would have to intervene, as in Arizona.

Doctors who perform abortions in their private offices or practices probably do not advertise it and may or may not be welcome to treat their patients at Catholic hospitals.

The places where most abortions occur are in surgical centers, places that do minor surgeries not requiring hospital stays, women’s health clinics, and physicians private practice facilities.

In general things that do not require the use of hospital facilities and equipment are done outside a hospital.

Most ob/gyns, the great majority (at least in my area) peform abortions in their practices.
 
To summarize the responses of the other forum users, “NO”. Any publicly recorded case of direct abortion (NOT a consequence of the double effect principle) by a Catholic hospital will most likely result in, and has historically resulted in, the removal of the hospital’s Catholic status. Thus, there is no public record which can be used to show that Catholic hospitals do procure abortions. For obvious reasons, there is no way to prove that they do not perform abortions off the public record.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top