Do the Marian apparitions conflict with holy scripture?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Thyme
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Thyme

Guest
I saw a video on youtube talking about Marian apparitions in general. They mentioned that we are told to test every spirit, that the devil can appear as an angel of light and that Christ is our only intecessor.

They claim that in apparitions, Mary claims to be an intercessor etc…

Here is the video in case you’re interested: youtube.com/watch?v=AnZIU4g6IHM

This has worried me. I have just started wearing a green scapular and am scared that the apparitions where Mary mentions wearing a scapular aren’t really from Mary.

What are your opinions on this?
 
I saw a video on youtube talking about Marian apparitions in general. They mentioned that we are told to test every spirit, that the devil can appear as an angel of light and that Christ is our only intecessor.

They claim that in apparitions, Mary claims to be an intercessor etc…

Here is the video in case you’re interested: youtube.com/watch?v=AnZIU4g6IHM

This has worried me. I have just started wearing a green scapular and am scared that the apparitions where Mary mentions wearing a scapular aren’t really from Mary.

What are your opinions on this?
As long as the apparitions are approved by the Church, there should be no problem.

Apparitions like Lourdes, Fatima, Guadalupe and others are approved IMO, and their content and purpose have always been to the greater good of the Church, not a harm.
However, apparitions like Medjugorje are NOT approved, and should be avoided at all costs. I have no doubt the apparitions at Medjugorje are the work of Satan.

Some of the arguments made in this video are the used to say that we don’t need priests or saints or angels. Also, most of the (super creepy) voiced over quotes in this video are from apparitions that are not approved AFAIK.

The people in this video seem to speak far more from a protestant perspective than a Catholic perspective. It’s Bible this and Bible that, no mention of what the Church teaches.

No mention of salvation through the Catholic Church either.

Another reason to discount the video is this website: eternal-productions.org/
Seriously, the “Good test” ?
 
As long as the apparitions are approved by the Church, there should be no problem.

Apparitions like Lourdes, Fatima, Guadalupe and others are approved IMO, and their content and purpose have always been to the greater good of the Church, not a harm.
However, apparitions like Medjugorje are NOT approved, and should be avoided at all costs. I have no doubt the apparitions at Medjugorje are the work of Satan.

Some of the arguments made in this video are the used to say that we don’t need priests or saints or angels. Also, most of the (super creepy) voiced over quotes in this video are from apparitions that are not approved AFAIK.

The people in this video seem to speak far more from a protestant perspective than a Catholic perspective. It’s Bible this and Bible that, no mention of what the Church teaches.

No mention of salvation through the Catholic Church either.

Another reason to discount the video is this website: eternal-productions.org/
Seriously, the “Good test” ?
Thank you so much!

I saw the website and I found it funny! They even have a whole page dedicated to Catholicism and seem to be implying that the Eucharist is the antichrist or something.

Yeah, that voice over was really creepy and mentioning of apparitions being from satan scare me.

So none of the approved apparitions of Mary mention that she is an intercessor? Also, what is it about Medjugorje that conflicts with the Church? I haven’t read about Medjurgorje yet and I’m freaked out by that video so don’t want to at the moment! 😛
 
So none of the approved apparitions of Mary mention that she is an intercessor? Also, what is it about Medjugorje that conflicts with the Church? I haven’t read about Medjurgorje yet and I’m freaked out by that video so don’t want to at the moment! 😛
As far as I know, no approved apparitions have Mary saying we must worship or pray to her specifically as if it was necessary for our salvation or anything. Lourdes, Fatima, all these were about how sad she was at the sins mankind was committing against Christ.

When we pray to Mary or the saints, they intercede for us to God. What’s special about Mary, is that she intercedes for us as a Mother to a son. After all, it was Mary who asked Jesus to provide more wine at the wedding of Cana.

As for Medjurgorje, the main issue with it the things like many many scheduled apparitions, no apparent point for existing in the first place, and some weird messages. Look up “Medjugorje problems” or something of that kind. You’ll find some good resources.

Oh, and the Medjugorje messages have been going on since the 80s! It’s not an urgent message from Our Lady, it’s God’s yearly podcast! That alone should be enough to show people the dangers of this supposed apparition.
Also, if you read the messages from Medjugorje, the apparition says stuff like “Thank you” and “Thank you for having responded to my call.” Why should Our Lady thank us?

The apparition also refers to “her plans” in a mysterious way without specifics, which is very unlike actual approved apparitions.

Perhaps the most damning evidence of all, is that I have searched through the ENTIRE file of messages that have been recorded for the past 20+ years, and there is NO mention of the word “pope” at all. Apparently this apparition doesn’t care about the Pope at all.
 
As far as I know, no approved apparitions have Mary saying we must worship or pray to her specifically as if it was necessary for our salvation or anything. Lourdes, Fatima, all these were about how sad she was at the sins mankind was committing against Christ.

When we pray to Mary or the saints, they intercede for us to God. What’s special about Mary, is that she intercedes for us as a Mother to a son. After all, it was Mary who asked Jesus to provide more wine at the wedding of Cana.

As for Medjurgorje, the main issue with it the things like many many scheduled apparitions, no apparent point for existing in the first place, and some weird messages. Look up “Medjugorje problems” or something of that kind. You’ll find some good resources.

Oh, and the Medjugorje messages have been going on since the 80s! It’s not an urgent message from Our Lady, it’s God’s yearly podcast! That alone should be enough to show people the dangers of this supposed apparition.
Also, if you read the messages from Medjugorje, the apparition says stuff like “Thank you” and “Thank you for having responded to my call.” Why should Our Lady thank us?

The apparition also refers to “her plans” in a mysterious way without specifics, which is very unlike actual approved apparitions.
There is also a “message” from Medjugorje where the Blessed Virgin states that all religions are equal before God. :rolleyes::mad: This video: youtube.com/watch?v=3l9faPilhSo shows proof that it is a false apparition. During a “vision”, one of the seers flinches after someone jabs their hand at them. The seer later says that she flinched because “Mary was going to drop Jesus”. :eek:
 
Thank you for confirming this! I searched for ‘problems with Medjurgoje’ and also read about her saying that Mary looked as if she would drop Jesus!

I’m glad the Vatican is picky a bout what apparitions are valid.

Thanks again for telling me this. I have just watched The Exorcism of Emily Rose and it has been playing on my mind 😛
 
Thank you for confirming this! I searched for ‘problems with Medjurgoje’ and also read about her saying that Mary looked as if she would drop Jesus!

I’m glad the Vatican is picky a bout what apparitions are valid.

Thanks again for telling me this. I have just watched The Exorcism of Emily Rose and it has been playing on my mind 😛
That was a scary movie :eek: I was afraid of 3:00 for weeks after watching that!
 
So was I! I would post some information on 3:00 for you, but it will probably play on our minds lol.
Feel free to PM me, if you want… you have made me curious (the kind of curious I will probably regret later :))
 
only when the CAtholic Church determines that they do. Yes the bible calls us to discern, and further records that Jesus gave this authority to discern spirits, and discern the action of the Holy Spirit to his Mystical Body on earth, the Catholic Church. Any other site, source, preacher etc. claiming to have this authority must prove his claim biblically. If his name does not begin with B and end with 16 that will be tough.
 
There is also a “message” from Medjugorje where the Blessed Virgin states that all religions are equal before God. :rolleyes::mad: This video: youtube.com/watch?v=3l9faPilhSo shows proof that it is a false apparition. During a “vision”, one of the seers flinches after someone jabs their hand at them. The seer later says that she flinched because “Mary was going to drop Jesus”. :eek:
Wow! I remember hearing about that one, but I totally forgot about it. Imagine the Blessed Virgin Mary almost dropping the baby Jesus. How absurd!

Thanks for the vid.
Thank you for confirming this! I searched for ‘problems with Medjurgoje’ and also read about her saying that Mary looked as if she would drop Jesus!

I’m glad the Vatican is picky a bout what apparitions are valid.

Thanks again for telling me this. I have just watched The Exorcism of Emily Rose and it has been playing on my mind 😛
I hope you’re feeling settled in your mind now. Don’t worry, the movie fear wears after after a time. 😛
 
Thank you so much!

I saw the website and I found it funny! They even have a whole page dedicated to Catholicism and seem to be implying that the Eucharist is the antichrist or something.

Yeah, that voice over was really creepy and mentioning of apparitions being from satan scare me.
This is a really bad website. Catholic.com has some good articles in is “Library” section, about a number of these articles.

The Song of Songs prophesies about the Marian apparitions, saying, “Return, return, O Shulammite; Return, return, that we may look upon thee” (Song of Songs 7:1).

The Song of Songs has many Marian prophesies. Like Mary, the woman in Song of Songs is raised to queenship (6:12), is a virgin (4:12), is conceived at a tree bringing forth life, as Mary was Immaculately Conceived through the Tree of Life, and she is assumed into Heaven (8:5). She is found superior to all women (6:8-9), even as Elizabeth calls Mary in Luke 1, “the most blessed of women.” She is associated with the sun, moon and stars (6:10) as Mary is in Rev. 12:1. She brings forth the “vine” (6:11), even as Mary brings forth the true Vine, Christ (John 15:5). She is constantly associated in this book with perfection and fertility, the bringing forth of perfect young, even as Mary is constantly associated with the bringing forth of Christ.

This woman also represents Israel, the Church, and an individual soul, but clearly one of the most perfect meanings of this prophesied woman is Mary. And with the Song of Songs, we cry out to her, “Return, return, O Shulammite; Return, return, that we may look upon thee” (Song of Songs 7:1).
So none of the approved apparitions of Mary mention that she is an intercessor?
She is an intercessor. There is nothing wrong with that. The Church has always believed that – only some modern Protestant denominations reject it as Anti-Christ. Truly, though, they are accidentally acting as deceivers themselves, when they try to convince you of this falsehood.

It’s scriptural that the saints, and particularly Mary, pray for us. It was the belief of the Jews before the time of Christ that the saints pray for us and we can ask them for prayers. The Early Christians inherited this belief from them. The practice is also referred to in Scripture.

Here’s a good explanation of this. Read the post made in answer to this question about intercession of saints.

en.allexperts.com/q/Catholics-955/intercession-saints-Mary.htm
 
That was a scary movie :eek: I was afraid of 3:00 for weeks after watching that!
Well, if 3:00 still bothers anyone, I would suggest it as an ideal time to pray the Chaplet of Divine Mercy.
 
QUOTE=Alexander Smith;6981315]As long as the apparitions are approved by the Church, there should be no problem.

Apparitions like Lourdes, Fatima, Guadalupe and others are approved IMO, and their content and purpose have always been to the greater good of the Church, not a harm.
However, apparitions like Medjugorje are NOT approved, and should be avoided at all costs. I have no doubt the apparitions at Medjugorje are the work of Satan.

We are not supposed to discuss Medjugorje, but since the above is thrown into the mix, it is prudent to point out that it is being investigated by the Vatican.

**One who says the above might actually be in disobedience to the Church. ** One who says such a thing is taking the mantle of the Magesterium upon his or her self. The Vatican has taken charge of the Medjugorje investigation, so only the Vatican can determine the authenticity of Medjugorje. So far the Vatican has NOT rejected nor approved it - it is under investigation. And as such, we are allowed to visit there individually or in groups, as many did to Lourdes and Fatima before they were approved. No official Church pilgramage can be organized of course, because it is under investigation.

Those who quickly point out Fr, Gruner’s ‘disobedience’ toward Fatima and the Act of Consecration, but take it upon themselves to condemn an apparition, are acting in the same manner and disregarding the Magesterium of the Church.

It is an act of charity to others to remain silent on Medjugorje until the Church rules.

God bless you.
 
To add perhaps another dimension to the question of whether or not Marian apparitions conflict with scripture, I would offer that, frankly, they all seem to.

Compare the Mary of scripture to the Mary of private revelations. The first is quite demure and sensible. The Mary of apparitions, on the contrary, always speaks in the most melodramatic and saccharin of tones and uses terms and language that seem quite uncharacteristic of the scriptural Mary. Sometimes when I read the texts of private revelations, such as those of Fatima, I am instantly struck by how absurd some of it seems (to me, at any rate).

Things get even worse when Christ features in these apparitions. At Rianjo, for example:

*“Make it known to My ministers, given that they follow the example of the King of France in delaying the execution of My command, they will follow him into misfortune. It is never too late to have recourse to Jesus and Mary.”

“They did not wish to heed My request! … Like the King of France they will repent of it, and they will do it, but it will be late. Russia will have already spread its errors in the world, provoking wars and persecutions against the Church. The Holy Father will have much to suffer.”*

My ministers? The King of France? He speaks like a constitutional monarch. And why does he bring up the King of France (presumably Louis XVI) to a Portuguese nun in the year 1931, as if his beheading were still relevant to 20th century people? Come on. I actually can’t imagine Our Lord uttering the words “King of France” at all, to be honest. Does that sound anything like the Christ of scripture? Anything like Him at all?

I would have to conclude that if you compare Christ’s words in scripture to those spoken in this particular apparition, we’re talking about two completely different persons.
 
Pregustator, those in Heaven can speak in whatever way they want. I find your choice of words, “saccharine” and “melodramatic,” offensive and false. Dramatic, yes. Melodramatic, no.

The discussion of cosmic events or events of national or international import from a heavenly vantage point often does involve the use of a different form of language. The language in apparitions is similar to the language of the Old Testament prophets or Jesus and the angels in the Book of Revelation. It’s not everyday language; these are not everyday events or conversations. They also are not normal human vantage points that are being spoken from. If you expect an angel from Heaven to appear marvelously and say, “hey Bob, how’s it going?”, that would make no sense. The language is more elevated. These apparitions only come for an important reason.

For Jesus to talk about the “King of France,” is simply referring to politics in the manner of normal human custom. He can talk like a constitutional monarch to Europeans or like a Xing Emperor to the Chinese, or like a PM to the British; He can speak however He likes, and He does so to different individuals, people and cultures in different ways.
 
Dear Lief:

I apologize if I offended you; I suppose I imagined we were all free to speak fairly frankly in this forum without ruffling feathers: that seemed to be the pattern I observed around here, at any rate.

While I do sincerely apologize if I offended you, I am afraid I find your “Jesus can do anything he wants to” argument, well, somewhat weak. I don’t think Our Lord really can be someone He isn’t, as a matter of fact, for one thing. He doesn’t suffer from schizophrenia. He is who He is.

The Lord we come to know in scripture is consistently a man with a certain, recognizable personality, with a certain way of communicating, and a certain way of approaching things. He speaks largely in parables, for one thing. His demeanor is tranquil and noble.

The Christ of this apparition (and a number of others) seems to bear no resemblance to the Christ we meet in the Gospels. The same is true of the Virgin. The Christ speaking in the example I used seems nervous, agitated, and threatening. He’s shouting at a little nun because he’s mad at the pope and the bishops (“his ministers”).

Just a thought: if the Lord really wanted the pope to get the message that badly, maybe the one to appear to would have been the pope, himself? If Christ is going to attempt to influence His Church personally, again, just the way He did during his 33 years on earth (despite the scriptural Jesus having delegated that role to His apostles and their successors until His return in glory), is Peter’s successor, the Christ’s own Vicar, so unworthy of a visit?

Because I have to think that if Our Lord had appeared directly to Peter…20th century Peter, that is (Pius X, Benedict XV, Pius XI, Pius XII, John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul I, John Paul II)…any one of them, in fact, and said “consecrate Russia with all the bishops ASAP or you’re going to get your heads chopped off like the King of France,” His request would have been met with swift obedience. As a matter of fact, I think if the Lord appeared to the pope, he wouldn’t have had to threaten him with the fate of the French king; I’m convinced the pope would have just gone ahead and done it even without the threat of beheading.

Well, as it happens, none of the 20th century popes consecrated Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary in union with all the bishops in the world, yet not one of them suffered the “fate of the King of France”. Furthermore, the Soviet Union has collapsed. It’s been dead for 20 years, in fact. And the 20th century ended a decade ago. And the big calamity never came to pass.

I think it’s time to look at Fatima and other similar apparitions in a more critical light, to question more scrupulously their authenticity, and to begin to deprive them of the importance which hysteria and popularity ascribe to them.

I hope not to offend anyone by making such an observation, but…I do not believe in Fatima. I believe in every dogma that the Catholic Church teaches. I am a faithful and sincere Catholic. I love the Virgin Mary. But I do not believe in Fatima. And I don’t believe in the others, either. It’s not that I don’t believe the Lord can interact with his Church in such a way; but rather that I don’t believe that He does.
 
Dear Lief:

I apologize if I offended you; I suppose I imagined we were all free to speak fairly frankly in this forum without ruffling feathers: that seemed to be the pattern I observed around here, at any rate.

While I do sincerely apologize if I offended you, I am afraid I find your “Jesus can do anything he wants to” argument, well, somewhat weak. I don’t think Our Lord really can be someone He isn’t, as a matter of fact, for one thing. He doesn’t suffer from schizophrenia. He is who He is.
The Christ of this apparition (and a number of others) seems to bear no resemblance to the Christ we meet in the Gospels.
Well, as it happens, none of the 20th century popes consecrated Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary in union with all the bishops in the world, yet not one of them suffered the “fate of the King of France”. Furthermore, the Soviet Union has collapsed. It’s been dead for 20 years, in fact. And the 20th century ended a decade ago. And the big calamity never came to pass.

I think it’s time to look at Fatima and other similar apparitions in a more critical light, to question more scrupulously their authenticity, and to begin to deprive them of the importance which hysteria and popularity ascribe to them.

I hope not to offend anyone by making such an observation, but…I do not believe in Fatima. I believe in every dogma that the Catholic Church teaches. I am a faithful and sincere Catholic. I love the Virgin Mary. But I do not believe in Fatima. And I don’t believe in the others, either. It’s not that I don’t believe the Lord can interact with his Church in such a way; but rather that I don’t believe that He does.
From what I understand, it’s not necessary to believe in any apparitions. Fatima has, however been approved by the Church so it’s okay if you do believe in them. I thought that John Paul II was successful in consecrating Russia.
I have to say that the apparitions at Medjugorje had an influence on me for years. I followed along with them and read all I could find on them. Recently, however, I’ve found some things to make me feel differently and to doubt whether these are true apparitions. I’ve learned a lesson in this and will only follow along with what is already approved by the Church.
I have a relative who really believes in the Medjugorje apparitions, along with those at Garabandal, which I’ve never really believed and found to be downright creepy. I try to steer clear of conversations with her on these subjects!
 
Dear Lief:

I apologize if I offended you; I suppose I imagined we were all free to speak fairly frankly in this forum without ruffling feathers: that seemed to be the pattern I observed around here, at any rate.
You have to understand that for someone who believes in the Church approved apparitions, hearing them described as “saccharine” and “melodramatic,” along with other scathing criticisms, is to me a direct attack on my Lord and Lady (even though an unknowing one), and consequently painfully offensive.
While I do sincerely apologize if I offended you, I am afraid I find your “Jesus can do anything he wants to” argument, well, somewhat weak. I don’t think Our Lord really can be someone He isn’t, as a matter of fact, for one thing. He doesn’t suffer from schizophrenia. He is who He is.
Of course He is Who He is. That doesn’t mean He can’t reveal Himself differently to different people, individuals and cultures. I find your argument ridiculously confining on God, and your refusal to accept a shift of mannerisms might occur between when you’re walking around on Earth and when you’re glorified in Heaven.

It is within Jesus’ interest to reveal Himself differently to different people and places, considering the cultural differences in the world. For example, when Mary appeared to the Chinese, she appeared as a Chinese woman, when she appeared to the blacks in Africa, she appeared as a black. In Heaven, you have a lot of room to do what you want in presenting people with images or words meant to reach them where they are. Jesus is not confined to speaking in the same way He did on Earth. He is God. And now He is in Heaven. When He speaks, now, He does so from a highly glorified standpoint, and He often speaks about important events. These facts would make a difference.

Besides, as I mentioned before, the dramatic and elevated language of the apparitions is very similar to the language of Jesus and the angels, and God Almighty, in the Old Testament prophets and the Book of Revelation. When speaking from a heavenly vantage point about very important and sweeping events, a change does seem to often occur. You don’t get regular human conversation, like conversation you and I might have here on Earth, when speaking from a heavenly vantage point about dramatic and extremely important events.
The Christ of this apparition (and a number of others) seems to bear no resemblance to the Christ we meet in the Gospels. The same is true of the Virgin. The Christ speaking in the example I used seems nervous, agitated, and threatening.
If you want “threatening,” just look at the Old Testament prophets or the Book of Revelation. Nervous and agitated are an impression that is completely unnecessary to read into these words.

Very few would hear in these words the petty weakness you’ve placed in them.
He’s shouting at a little nun
No, He’s not.
because he’s mad at the pope and the bishops (“his ministers”).
He never said He’s mad at His ministers. He’s providing a warning. He never comes across as angry in these words; rather, He’s quite calm.
 
Just a thought: if the Lord really wanted the pope to get the message that badly, maybe the one to appear to would have been the pope, himself? If Christ is going to attempt to influence His Church personally, again, just the way He did during his 33 years on earth (despite the scriptural Jesus having delegated that role to His apostles and their successors until His return in glory), is Peter’s successor, the Christ’s own Vicar, so unworthy of a visit?
When Christ Incarnate came into the world, the fact was revealed by angels to shepherds, not to Joseph of Arimathea, Nicodemus, or any of the other worthy Jewish leaders. When God had a message for Israel in the Old Testament, He passed it on to Amos, a lowly shepherd, or to other average people. In the New Testament, He gave the message to Israel through the apostles, who were lowly fishermen, and one of them a tax collector. He prefers to use the weak, because in that way His power is most glorified. He sometimes has spoken directly to the Popes as well, such as Leo XIII’s vision of Satan’s 20th century conquest over much of the world, or Pope Pius XII’s vision of the sun dancing.
Because I have to think that if Our Lord had appeared directly to Peter…20th century Peter, that is (Pius X, Benedict XV, Pius XI, Pius XII, John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul I, John Paul II)…any one of them, in fact, and said “consecrate Russia with all the bishops ASAP or you’re going to get your heads chopped off like the King of France,” His request would have been met with swift obedience. As a matter of fact, I think if the Lord appeared to the pope, he wouldn’t have had to threaten him with the fate of the French king; I’m convinced the pope would have just gone ahead and done it even without the threat of beheading.
Providing a warning of what will happen if you don’t do something is not the same as threatening with it. For example, Jesus, during His time on Earth, warned Jerusalem that it would be destroyed if it did not recognize Him. That isn’t the same as threatening it. And John the Baptist warned the people that the ax is at the root of the tree, and if they don’t accept the message he is offering, they will pay the price. That doesn’t mean he was threatening them, but he was warning them of the consequences of disobedience. It is only right that people should be told what they are setting themselves up for, if indeed they are making destructive choices through disobedience.
Well, as it happens, none of the 20th century popes consecrated Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary in union with all the bishops in the world, yet not one of them suffered the “fate of the King of France”. Furthermore, the Soviet Union has collapsed. It’s been dead for 20 years, in fact. And the 20th century ended a decade ago. And the big calamity never came to pass.
The consecration was successfully performed by Pope John Paul II in 1984.
ewtn.com/expert/answers/FatimaConsecration.htm
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top